Skip to main content
Loading video...

In Magnificent Style | Review

Transcript 11:51

thank you hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson to be on Solitaire and today I'm going to be reviewing in magnificent style pickets charge this is designed by Herman Lipman and this is the nice Deluxe Edition from Worthington games alright so here we are all set up with in magnificent style pickets charge this is a solo only game and it's a bit of a push or luck game about picket's charge where we are the Confederate units and we are trying to make it all the way across this field and charge into the Union line up here and of course they are going to be determined not to let us do that so there are a lot of smaller complexities to this game such as making sure that you notice where there are obstacles which affect your movement looking at areas that provide a little bit of cover and reduce hits you have to watch out for the angle where your odds of getting hit go up and you're going to have to do some bayonet combat if and when you reach the other end there's also a lot of card play in this game so what you're going to run into is moments where you're going to draw a card and when you pull the card there is a Confederate event on the top in Gray and a union event on the bottom in blue and so there are a whole lot of different things that can happen in the course of play but at its heart this is a super simple push your luck game with your rolling Dice and you're trying to move up as far as you possibly can one of the things that's kind of nice about this game is that everything is printed on the board which means that yeah you do need to

read the rules but you actually will have a whole lot of shorthand to help you out so you're going to have a union activity phase where you draw a blue event you're gonna have a follow me phase where you assign your generals to whatever unit you want them to be with for the turn and then you're going to have a Confederate unit activation phase so all of these units are going to have to activate at some point on any given turn and you have five turns total in the game to get them from here to there so as you can see things get a little bit tougher as you go along that turn track and there are even little times printed up there to indicate where like in the timing of pickets charge you are but everyone's going to activate and then basically you're going to choose whether you're going to move or regroup and basically what that'll mean is you're going to keep rolling these dice so this wasn't the best role but it wasn't the worst either if you look at a six in one combo it's against the wind and let's say if I begin with this unit down here this unit would take one hit and move one space or the unit would take two hits and move one space and enter an obstacle then I would get to draw one blue card and one gray card so basically some of the results are good for me I get to move some of them are bad for me I get hurt and have to draw a union event but basically I can roll these dice as many times as I want and just keep trying to advance my units up the board but I'm gonna have to decide when I want to stop because one thing that's also very interesting is that as you move up with your unit your Rally Point does not move up with you let's say that I managed to move up a few of these squares if I

don't stop and regroup soon my Rally Point is going to stay back here so for example if I take some heavy fire and it forces me to move back to my Rally Point and my Rally Point is back here even all those good rolls that got me a little bit further the board are going to be as nothing because I didn't stop and regroup so at the end of your movement you get to regroup and move your Rally Point up and Mark it done and you're going to do that for everybody along the row in whatever order you want but essentially the the real heart of the game is trying to roll the dice to advance these units and trying to choose the right moments to regroup and stop trying to push your luck so that you can move your Rally Point up and not get forced all the way back to the beginning because you thought you were getting lucky and then you had a problem there are also lots of little things going on so for example you have some artillery fire and we don't actually know what's under these tokens at the beginning of the game there's a lot of Misses in here but there's also things that will help to suppress the Union Soldiers and there are also a few ways to mitigate your rules in this game so every division is going to have a general with them who can flip and take special General actions one of which is a re-roll which you're going to want to use a lot you've also got two of these Long Street tokens they're one and done once you use them they're gone but they're very very handy in a pinch and there will also be various helps and hindrances that come from the cards that force you to put some of these tokens out so you might get Rebel Yell that helps you advance you might get some smoke that helps to disguise you but something bad could happen too you also might need to make some strategic choices in terms of how close you want your units to be together

because whenever they're three in a row who are that are adjacent to each other you can form a battle line and move them up in a group because they draw some Confidence from each other and so the other thing is if you've got one unit that's getting out too far ahead they can't help their neighbors as they all Advance together so overall it's a fairly simple game and you really are just pushing your luck rolling the dice trying to get where you need to go at the same time there are quite a few decisions to be made when do I stop who do I activate in what order where do I put my generals how do I use some of the benefits I might get from the cards how do I handle bad choices that come from the blue events there is plenty to think about in this game even if you are basically just rolling Dice and trying to move forward so with that said let's go ahead and have some final thoughts all right so now for some final thoughts I will say I have deeply mixed feelings about in magnificent style because of its topic so I'm going to start by talking about it as a game first and then we're going to talk about my misgivings on the subject matter so first things first I think that this game is overall an excellent Pusher luck game it's very fun it is surprisingly engaging and that feeling that maybe you want to roll the dice one more time to see if you can advance one more space is very very strong in this one I would say that as a game system a solo game system it's super fun um it's really the nice weeknight kind of solo game vibe that I'm often looking for and I generally think very highly of it as a game I will say that there are

maybe a few too many little rules and what I mean by that is it's very easy to do things like forget to draw card or forget an effect that there was from a card or be a little bit confused about what you're actually supposed to do with a token because the base structure of the game is just so intuitive and so strong and then there are like little things to track that almost feel like an intrusion rather than you know something that belongs like inherently intuitively in the game that said this didn't really bother me too much um I loved that a lot of the rules and steps were printed on the board it was super easy to get playing it was super easy to you know find little reminders of the basic stuff on the actual board which I personally like and I thought the graphic design for this was really really nice you know the field is detailed enough to look like somebody put some research into it which I know that Litman did and I know that his artist would also have done the same um uh but then but then it's also clear enough to really see where you're moving and you know things like the different colors outlining the areas that get closer and closer to the Union Soldiers are really nice and overall I just thought that it was a clean visual presentation that I really enjoyed and I did like a lot of the attention to detail you can tell that a lot of research has gone into Pickett's Charge so even though this is like a simple little die rolling game the details and the things that you could do in the game are very deeply rooted in history and that is something that I typically really enjoy in my historical games this one manages to be light and fun while

also packing quite a bit of information about Pickett's Charge in the cards in the flavor text in the rule book you know I felt like it came away knowing quite a bit about something in history that I typically avoid so I think that that is where I need to uh transition in terms of my final thoughts you know overall I really like this game I think highly of it is a game I think it's a nice design and I'm not gonna be able to keep it and the reason I can't keep it is because I just can't stand Civil War stuff um that's a personal preference I have no personal issue with you if you like to play Civil War games so you know don't take it wrong but you know I grew up in the America I grew up in the American South my grandparents went through a big genealogy phase and I found out that a lot of people in my family tree are Confederate soldiers like I've been told as if it was an exciting thing by my grandparents that oh you can join the daughters of the Confederacy if you wanted to and frankly I'd rather do just about anything enjoy the daughters of the Confederacy um I am kind of grossed out by my own family history and like what my ancestors did I don't feel comfortable with that Legacy at all I do not particularly enjoy Lost Cause narratives or touting The Bravery of Confederate soldiers because I don't think that their cause was a noble one and you know you can talk about states rights but until you go and read those documents and see what they were actually fighting about I don't really think that's a great argument so you know I don't want to get too far down that road in this video but suffice to

say I personally do not like Pickett's Charge as a game topic because I think that there is a whole lot of just romanticizing of this narrative when if you look at modern historians they say the pick a charge was actually strategically pretty stupid um it's just that the Faulkner of like oh every Southern boy can imagine it's 3 P.M the day of Gettysburg like no like I just can't stand it I absolutely cannot um so if the topic doesn't bother you I think this game is awesome if the topic bothers you like it bothers me then it's hard to just relax and have fun with it even though it is a very well designed game and it's a lovely production uh I do think that you know you can also talk to yourself depending on what your internal narrative is about you know the charge like maybe for you you can interpret the game as you know an illustration of how silly this charge was and how dangerous it was for the people who went through it um not even all the Confederate generals thought it was a good idea at the time on the day so you know that's not a crazy interpretation but for me it just felt too much like valorizing something that I would prefer to never see valorized so again like if this topic doesn't bother you or if you enjoy Civil War stuff it means a great game I really can't um I really can't fault it for anything other than maybe there's a few too many little things going on and what is otherwise just this really Sleek design but when you're gaming history you have to think about what history you're commuting with and the way in which you do it and that is going to be something that because the topic isn't gonna work for everybody that said I do know

there's another game that uses a similar system called crowbar that's about D-Day from Litman and so I would actually really like to play that one I think that I might really enjoy seeing this system re-implemented with a theme that I find more noble and palatable than this so that's where I met on in magnificent style I think it's solid gameplay I think that it is a very enjoyable solo game uh as long as you can stomach the topic which I personally cannot so that's where I'm at thank you so much for watching please like subscribe comment and most of all happy gaming

thank you

Progress saved