Emberleaf is an Excellent Board Game
Transcript
Here's the problem. On one hand, over many, many years of work on this channel, we have carefully cultivated a sort of a semi-journalistic, some might even use the dreaded word ethical approach to reviewing board games. You know, deals with publishers, avoid buyers as much as possible. We don't even accept review copies anymore. On the other hand, the reason I personally wanted to talk about board games to begin with is because often I get to put a spotlight on games that are, for the lack of a better word, cool. They're good games. They need to be known, touched, felt inside my loins, your loins. And up until now, this was not a problem. But this year, one of my friends, Frank West, decided to make a game that speaks louder than loins. It is precisely cool and I want you to know about it. But this is what the industry wizards call a conflict of interest. The sensible thing to do would be to just let other people cover Amber Leaf. Leave it to the pros. But gosh, I I just can't help myself. I want to have my board game and eat it. So, here's the deal. If you don't know who I am, hi, I'm Etha and this video does not represent our channel. If you do know us, whatever you think of me or whatever mind frame you watch our videos in, abandon that. This
isn't a no pun included video. It's just me using this platform to gab about a thing my friend made because I can't be unbiased here. No matter what critical faculties I have developed or whatever trust you have in me, forget it in this video. It's impossible to not feel better about a game that is made by a friend. And anyone who tells you otherwise is lying either to you or themselves or both. There is no impartiality, no critical thought, just me platforming things. Doing a favor. No one's asked for this favor. I didn't tell Frank I'm doing this. I'm just doing this. And belief is what you call a tableau builder or if you're not nutty for nardboard game where you play cards in front of you and then hope that amongst the cards that you played there's cool combos that catapult you ahead of other players. It's fun and belief however is not satisfied with quote unquote fun. It wants to make your lovely time playing anthropomorphic woodland critters an agonizing headache of impossible optimization. And if you know me by now, oof, it's my jam. Also, despite the art dawning the robe of cottage core, good vibes only, and belief is a surprisingly sharp and competitive game where slip-ups are easy to make and punishment is quite severe in a way that reminded me of one of my
favorite games, Dune Imperium. Ah, now I got your attention. Let me show you some mechanisms. On your turn, you'll do one or two things. Thing number one, just play a card. What could be simpler? Wow. Cards usually have when played effects. For example, if you play Ripple, you will gather one wood per every wood symbol visible on your playerboard or the top left corner of already played cards. A very familiar board game thing. Have more symbol. Collect more resource. Which means before we play ripple, we want to play other cards that have wood symbols. Amara has a wood symbol, but it's when played action lets us build a building at the extra cost of one food.
Okay, building buildings is cool because amongst other effects, it could uncover two more wood symbols on our playerboard value, but that costs four food and one honeycomb plus the one extra food that Amara is asking for. Okay, then we need to play cards that gather food out of the cards that we start the game with. Ripple is the card to do that. In case you missed it, to get value out of Ripple, I first need to play wood symbols, which I get by having food, which I get from playing Ripple. Please make it make sense. No, really, this is what the game is asking you to do. Figure this and many other impossible puzzles out. And I haven't even explained the main mechanism. Frank, you're probably watching this, so I'm sorry. I talked to you about it. I know it means a lot to you, but you decided to call this mechanism card dancing. And it's just I mean, I get it, but card dancing really. Anyway, what Frank means is card sliding? because instead of playing a card on your turn, you have the option to slide all of the cards one space to the left. And there are a myriad of reasons why you would want to do this. You might have noticed that the food gathering effect on Ripple does not look like the wood gathering effect.
That's because you don't activate it when you play it. You activate it each time the card slides or dances. I guess the rule book says when it slides though, it's almost like the mechanism is called card sliding. Aha. So, what we actually want to do is jam as many of these sliding cards onto our playerboard to get as many slide effects as possible. Obviously, if I play them further to the edge, then they'll trigger more times each time they slide. But then the other effects on the cards. No, no, no. Don't get distracted. This is just ADHD bait. You only start the game with six cards in your hand. Each deck is asymmetric with a unique composition of cards. So there's five different sets of cards to master. But what's important here is that no matter what you play, whether cards with when played effects or dancing effects or activatable effects or persistent abilities or when they dance off the board abilities, they all get lock jammed onto this playerboard and you can't get them back. Which means that if you played a card to this space at some point, you will need to take the slide action three times before you can reclaim it and then play it again. And each of those slide actions will trigger a whole bunch of other effects. And that's like a constant cascade of claxons declaring, "Hey, remember that time you around? Now you're finding out fries." I love this kind of design
because it's not sparing my feelings. It is a persistent notification that I can figure this stuff out, exercise through repeated attempts, hone my craft, practice my moves. Oh my god. It is like car dancing. Do you think Do you think sometimes I'm too harsh on board games?
Nah. There is an unachievable ideal in baked into Emberleaf. A Cifian pedestal that you can't quite place yourself onto. And that sort of thing can seem like a frustrating experience. But Emberleaf is also clever enough to leave plenty of room for you to do fun things. It's a design that blends new ideas with tried and trueue satisfaction delivery mechanisms. Abilities flow and blend into powerful combos, and there's plenty to do to constantly reward your efforts. I mentioned that you use resources to build buildings. Each time you do, you'll get points if you build different types of buildings in clumps, but also you home these animal villages on them. Each one you place unlocks a bonus. It could be some resources, a gamechanging effect, a scoring ability, or even a new card to add into your deck. And one of them is And one of them is legally distinct from Howard the Dark. What a hottie. I should have printed a giant version of that one rather than an otter with some crabs. I don't know what I was thinking. And then there's favor cards. You can pick up a few from building bonuses, but most of these cards you simply get when you move your character to a different location.
You want these cards because they basically say if you do this, you get points. A favor might ask you to home two frogs, two rats, and two rabbits in the same location. Mega points if you succeed, or have one boat house in exactly three locations. Easy. The problem you quickly run into as you keep gorging on these favor cards is that as you get more and more, you realize that they start generating friction between themselves. Take the card that asks you to have two frogs, rabbits, and rats in the same clearing. If you then take a card that says home exactly free rats, they sound sort of compatible. They want you to do the same thing, but you collect these as you play. Meaning that if I already homeed a rat here and here, and now I suddenly have these objectives, I can no longer place rats in any other clearings to succeed at both. And that's just two cards, which means you want to time when you travel to and out of locations when the right card appears in the favor row. But the ability to travel is dictated by cards you play. And what if the card that lets you move is stuck in your tableau? How many turns till you get it back? How many turns till things change and the card disappears? I left the Dallas mechanism for last because underneath it, there's a nasty little surprise.
Scattered across the map, there's these banners. They represent pesky N du wells you have to dispose of. If you play a card with an action that lets you fight, you'll usually count the swords on your board, see if the total matches the health, and remove them. This will score you however many points the banner had and make travel cost less for everyone. But also, you advance on this track to get a little bonus. Maybe a few bits of wood or sometimes a honeycomb. That's a rarer resource. Nice. But wait, what is this here at the bottom? It's a trophy. Whoever reaches that space gets a massive point bonus and also a truckload of resources of their choice. That doesn't seem very fair. One person gets a pittance and another is riding away with a bathtub full of cash and they both did the same work. I think someone introduced a touch of capitalism into this happy critter world. Another way to get a trophy is to build the last building in the clearing. Again, same work as building any other building except this time massive bonus. What gives? The ability to do all these things is tied to cards. Want to fight?
Make sure your cards not stuck here. Want to build? You need a card for that, too. On and on they walts in and out of your life. A sigh of relief each time they go and heartbreak when they don't come back. There is a right moment to do everything in Amber Leaf and plenty of wrong ones. And to pin the ass on the dunkey, you just want it to sit still for a second, but the dunkey is on a trampoline, and the ass is a mirage running away, just like this analogy. So, that's Frank's game, and I really do like it a lot. I do, of course, have some gripes. It does play a bit long, especially when there's so many changing factors, decisions can spiral out. So, not really ideal for larger groups. And I think its odd belies a much more crunchy and sinister game potentially giving less experienced ball gamers a false impression into what they're about to embark upon. Bonus points to myself for using belies correctly which I somehow bodgeged in our arcs video. But now we come to the tough part. I don't want you to buy this game. Well, that's not quite true. I don't want you to buy this game because of me. Like I said, I consider Frank a friend and also a really lovely person. We've had some adventures staying in a nightmare hotel in Djang, watching Naked and Afraid, and eating the world's greasiest pizza.
Those were good times, which is why I wanted to make you aware of Embelief. But to encourage you to make purchasing decisions based on whatever kind of trust you've built up with us by watching this channel in a very compromised review, that'd be a step too far. So, as a parting bit in this video, I want to sincerely ask you, don't buy this game, at least yet. Do more research. Explore less compromised reviewers. Dan Theorough wrote a review on Space Biv. Who knows, maybe SCSD will put this in a podcast at some point. Listen to some other verdicts. Watch some playthroughs before you play did one. I can't believe I'm about to say this. Do your own research. Uh, as for me, uh, I'll see you soon in a better, more, no pun included, review.