The Problem of A.I in Board Gaming
Transcript
hello and welcome to boy stupid my name is Wayne and I'm Matt still with have voice still Matt it's okay Matt are you a robot I don't know I don't know maybe I don't think I'm a robot but I don't know if I'd really know but we're living in a simulation I don't know we might be because this is the subject of today's spicy topic where we're talking about the problem of AI in board games AI in board games and it can be used for in a number of ways but specifically around artwork and with that jazz and there's been plenty of debate and conversation on various games a lot oh my gosh there has been well there's been a lot of AI conversation in the general world and of course as well in our little so yeah absolutely so yeah turns out AI can be used for more than just ball game up yeah and if you'd like to to hear us talk about how it's being utilized in b games uh then maybe you should consider uh hit the Subscribe button yeah do that I mean you don't need to be an AI even if you're a robot even if you are no probably don't do no Bots no Bots no paid no paid Subs no just organic humanoids only humanoids yeah carbon fiber creature carbon people hit the Subscribe button do that yeah and let's dive in to why AI might be an issue to talk about oh maybe not dice feeling nice cboard dreams and G GS click subscribe it's a
two all we need for you and me what you so M first things first we should probably say this is just a point of conversation us really we want to engage with you the community yeah so we uh we discussed about these things about AI like a million times now it's one of the things that conly comes up because we all down on Reddit or BGG and seeing a lot of this conversation going so I was say you know what let's talk about it a little bit but mostly just like we want to hear from mute so comment below let's let's I I want to see a little bit of Buzz and um in the comments because like yeah it's it's really nice to hear different opinion from different people mostly I always blah blah blah to Wayne about this things yeah and we know we know some of you some of you friends of us and Friends of the channel are designers some of you are Publishers some of you are artists exact some of you are just like super board game nerds like us and so we want to hear all of your views on uh Ai and board game art um so the mat let's start with in principle how it's being used or how as far as we know it's being used in games um so far a few things have been have been used the AI has been used the the one that is has been up front in like
front pages of all these scandle things it's been about the the actual artworks so we're talking about the art in The Bard game um as been the assets all of the art assets been done by nii with um uh meat Journey or whatever whatever or some tools in Photoshop AI tools or whatever it is so it's been someone creating a game uh completely removing the the art side to it so removing the the art directors or the um the graphic designer the illustrators and all that the nice people that create those beautiful beautiful um artwork that you see in the board game that is they're very part of a board game cuz uh it's a physical product yeah it's a physical product and I think a lot of times games they need to look beautiful sometimes they could be a little bit just an Excel spreadsheets otherwise like C example yes but but yeah that that is is been the ones that it's been pointed out immediately because um people find out that they can kind of achieve more or less the same quality not really or at least not at that point uh without having to spend money to get the the art made and that is bad yeah but however someone else has been using AI tools to refine that art so artists themselves
that's been using the AI using tools within platforms like Photoshop exactly CU at the end of the day even Photoshop even the video that you're watching right now there is some AI magic that makes the video looks looks better I don't really look like this no but it's got a lot of air worky that's not true are you said a um but yeah let's let's start with with with a very with what we think is well I think it's bad you think it's bad I think everybody thinks there's elements that is bad and there is a line that I think everyone needs to kind of decide on is where it becomes bad because we are having a conversation just now Matt about okay there is a tool that I use on canva to make thumbnails which if you click a button it automatically detects the background and the background is that too much is is that automatic color correction on your phone is is that too much should I be paying someone to do this stuff for me I mean where where is it I mean because AI tools are so Advanced now and they're getting more advanced every single day they can do so much I mean I'd probably say I mean I think a quite obvious sign is yeah for trying to generate all of your art assets via AI is probably a step too far but who am I to say because sometimes cost might be the
factor and and I'm fine and I'm fine with that however I want to see that reflected in the cost of the product and I want to know that it's being created by with with you need full transparency I want a full transpar it's kind of like the food that you buy yeah I want to know if something is B if something is being mass-produced I want to know it then I I can make the choice of of having it or not having it depending on the price depending on on a million other things but I do I do want to know that that it's been used and then I can always make my my own researches to how it's been used and I'm thinking about how it's been used because this even for for the art um there's been a campaign that went up on a lot of threads a few a few months ago and it's a game that we actually touch with our hands and we SP with the designer we play and we really like it that is draon is eight fantastic by the way very good game um it it it spiked up on this AI um witch hand uh for for for games I think there was a bit of a a Witch Hunt at that point uh because um apparently they use AI in the um in the artwork actually not uh actually what has been using the the artist himself that is draw every single character every single card in the game has been using some AI
tools to generate some vency on those million cards million design that he did and then took that variances and redraw them himself but people were mad about it so this artist who's created the own his own prompts to create variants is being paid to create art and he's creating art and then using inbuilt Tools in photos shop and I think other tools to help Define and create yeah even on AI things repainted over in this sort of iterative process that was really beautifully transparently put out uh by wise wi games they were like here's the exact process in in excruciating detail and I was like that seems fine to me yeah exactly that seemed fine to me I mean like I was like but some people like we saw with that that e went like people hat it like forks and Tores and um um just like bit that's not that's not where you where you should go the the my problem the big problems is looking at some of the games that are now on Kickstarter on game found and be like that looks a little bit suspicious and and there is no mention at all about AI art or or any of those things I think that is where we need to kind of like keep an eye and um definitely transparency is absolutely key so let's talk about the in the Indie publisher there could be a case to be made where actually some games couldn't be created without utilizing AI to yeah to bring the vision
to life yeah at that point if you say well basically hard luck mate you need to try and make the you know make the game good enough until people can you believe in it enough to give you funding to maybe pay some artists or do you utilize the AI and and just go for it I I'll say go for it uh but with full transparency with full transparency and again I want to see that reflected into the into the cost of the game because if a game cost 4050 it's not just to pay the physical assets of the inside the game you pay the people that been working on it and including the artist so if you got a if you're a oneman band that he's got this great games in his head and he wants to put it out on the market but it doesn't know if if I was doing it a game I will draw like sticks man and that's that's all I can do cuz I I'm not great there but AI could actually help me bringing more to my vision to to reality but again if you if you are straight with it and I don't see where the where the problem lies but if we then don't pay for it cuz I know the US haven't paid for that yeah you haven't paid for that artwork I guess um I suppose you could also utilize it as like a brainstorming type tool where you're utilizing the prompts to give you ideas and then the artist could then
base the artwork off of those ideas is that is that the safe side of the line I don't know it's so hard right because you got you've generated AI artwork utiliz right interation of it um the guys uh um that did Cil exactly this this kind of thing so they generated this AI images and then they took the inspiration of that AI generated images to create own their own their own um their own cards for the that tarot games um yes I think I think that's a yes even because now it's everything is an experiment I guess um yeah especially at the moment yeah um the the next thing I really want to touch on is even utilizing all of these tools you've got the ethical consideration where AI harvests right loads of information it basically scrapes data from millions of images all over the Internet and then utilizes that in order to generate its uh its its work based on the prompts given and you have this kind of ethical thought where those original artists will never see a penny for the ReUse of the work in a new format in a remix in a remix in a remix yeah but how do you stop it how do you stop you close internet that means that you go back to the the Dark Ages
I I don't know yeah um it's hard because the door's open right now right it's it's it's hard we were talk about this like all of these amazing tools that you can utilize now um they've it's constantly changing and and we're in the middle of a bit of a revolution with AI not just in board gaming obviously in The Wider World um where you liken this going back to the Industrial Revolution where you had factories and machinery and people were up in arms because you know that was the destroying drops destroying trades but actually that's just normal now yeah and a little bit even closer to us it was the Napster the Metallica Napster where music Napster is killing the music and now after 25 years 30 years you only listen music on Spotify you watch your stuff on uh on Netflix everything is on is streamed you don't buy anything physical anymore and all those things so um I I think I think a lot of of the AI things is again it's very much happening while we speak yeah um there's stuff that is going to go busted something that is going to be utilizing in in everyday life and I think at certain point even in board game we all have to kind of like accept that is a thing yeah potentially we will even in our little bubble although as that happens and we see other games that
we've S as well that utilize it like foxport which almost an entirety AI um generated art yeah um of of similar what we call that um legally distinct legally distinct from Hogwarts Harry Potter legally the thing utilizing enti yeah they already were like very borderline with the theme and then I think I think we didn't know about that either but again everything went down because um to if we don't know basically um people find out that most of the art created for the game all the all of the art was AI generated but that was non non-disclosed in in any shape or form up to um until recently yeah until very recently and that's like that's not that's not okay even because as a publish share as a design or whatever or whatever you are you're then getting the things are not being clear with your with your audience and you not just going to lose them okay if if I say all right this game I made the the art with AI half of the people is going to back it it's going to be bad for me but maybe the next game I'll be like all right did something wrong it Rel is the new things yeah now you're losing people not just for that game you're losing the people forever because you you're hiding stuff from from the people just like a St and also I think there is a little bit of in there's a lack of Integrity there right
and then more more than just the Integrity of of of transparency you've got Artistic integrity because you've got some amazing games that are iconic because hand painted absolutely hands painted Dixit for example is a great example useful cards all hand painted just stunning artwork all of the great artwork by iano tool for example or the M all of these unique artists that have a style um Vincent D TR it's just stunning you can spot it a mile away and it's a wonderful thing it's a beautiful thing and the and the art is part of the game is is board gaming is uh tatical tactile tactile not tactical strategic it's a tactile um visual experience it's not just the game it's it's not just the mechanic the pieces and the what they look like the colors and all that stuff makes the the game great CU again a great game that looks horrible is never going to be that great yeah there's going to be a line where it gets to we just P people off we've got and especially these days are all games you like yeah all the games I like except you you B fair enough but but I know what you mean like there is there is a definitely at least now the production and design is so so good and the artwork is so so great that it really adds a level of Brilliance to the Hobby right and I think it's a real shame it loses that when you start having generative a
yeah yeah yeah but at the same time not everybody can afford to pay you know all for for their new game um so I'm I'm I'm kind of like you're an indie publisher you're a Onan band with your game and you need AI to make a dream reality go for it when it's someone like without making any names but big publisher and you start going down the the the I need to save money cut here cut there let's do AI that I think is uh you need to go to hell that's that's that's the reality fair enough but again if you're a small publisher you need to say please tell me that I did no no hey I did not have much experience and money to pay an artist to do this I'm making it AI but that's why these games cost you $20 instead of4 yeah fair enough and we already touched on it that the one of the other major problems is that player backlash reputational damage if when people find out because people are still up in arms about the whole thing and to and and understandably understandably with all the things that we've talked about even if you are fully transparent people still get angry about it and and that is again that is our as um our foring and us um as customers yeah uh so as soon as there's been this trend
now they see that as soon as you read AI people goes like forks and torches and pipes vot one down vote exactly without without actually maybe finish read everything that publisher all the artists itself started started doing or saying about it because they they might have use some AI tool like everybody do right now or you do whenever you take your stories on Instagram and uh make more beautiful than what you are that is because AI so it goes back to that question Where's the Line we don't know where it is uh but I think we'll find eventually the line will be be more Mar at the moment it's still it's blur because it's it's so new we are in in in the revolution it's currently happening but um but there are so many things that I think is going to be great for example As a Dungeon Crawler lava uh unlike Ani that from my favorite games keep producing um new map new maps or new or new things that I I don't need to pay for cuz it's it's just like it's going to keep creating things like that's that is going we're going to get there and that's going to be amazing I mean we haven't even touched on things like utilizing uh AI in mechanical design and Mathematics I haven't seen anything of that yet but I think it's probably a matter of time and I'm sure uh viewers
you'll let us know in the comments if everyone's been utilizing AI to generate the game mechanisms helping with the you know the I suppose the the logic of a game I think and there is one example I can think of I think it was half no moos actually Sak stat where they ran the game rules through an AI to try and see if it would break but that like utilizes play millions of times but it's not it's not a good thing great things because using AI to make your product better if we because you would not have the physical time to get a game like a car game got through like a million play test that thingss we do it in an hour and it's going to tell you like if broke this this this and this yeah and you can work it out way faster than than before yeah know absolutely yeah that was that's that's a great Point that's very interesting so I'm Bean to see what more games have used that in creating you know make defining the logic of a game's boundaries that'd be very interesting to knowe Matt is there anything else you want to talk about or should we take it to the outro take it to the outro because um my te is finish and my voice as well okay M let's go so that was our discussion on the use of AI in board games and I think it's only just begun yeah and again what we discussing like very we touched a few a few argument very very uh quickly we could we could talk about this stuff for like for days but what we wanted to do rather than um you heard more or less
our ideas where we sitting on this on there uh but what we want to hear is actually you guys down in the comments below let us know what what's your point of view cuz I'm I'm I'm really interested to to the wider audience or to to our audience the B family to to understand what you guys think and um especially if you're an artist or if you're a designer do you use those tools y where's the line for you are you okay with it or not and then for the rest of our fan uh those board game enjoyers what do you feel about it is is it is knowing that a game used AI in anyway an absolute no no you're not going to spend your money or do you not mind or are you somewhere in the middle um we'd love to know but what something else I'd love to know if you're not um an ala if you're not a machine you're not a machine and you want to you want to hear more about board games well on our patreon you can find a lot of like exclusive non AI cont content like human gener pure organic pure organic way is me organically um recording more exclusive content of just um yeah it's um and it cost like a coup P it's like a coffee it's a coffee what what's a coffee in AI I don't know I know an AI I can't make coffee I can't make coffee but you they will Evista coming soon you
heard it first um yeah you can go check check that out and otherwise hit the Subscribe button that is free and requ no Bots no BS please just organic growth no no paid subscribers no no paid views no no another episode about all that stuff but we're not going to just just subscribe uh and if you like that you should check out the rest of our videos and we'll catch you again at the next one news for you and me what what what you Qui see