Skip to main content
Loading video...

Thoughts on Generative AI in Board Games

Transcript 15:36

hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond solitier and I felt this was a good time to just record a quick video um discussing why I have said on social media recently that I do not want to cover games that incorporate generative AI art um into their product and there are a lot of reasons you could give for this a lot of them have been spilling across Twitter and blue sky and Facebook um and Board Game Geek because terraforming Mars's new expansion from stronghold uh blatantly incorporates art that has been um generated via AI so I felt this was a good time to clarify some of my positions that are deeper than just it's stealing although it is it is stealing um Mid Journey especially which stronghold has admitted that they used is based on trained on images that are scraped from the internet without attribution and without compensation for the artist that they scraped from so when you put a a search query and something like midy and you get a response back um you're getting responses that are Amalgamated from artists who may not have consented to having their art used and that's just a base problem for me and it's a very big one with AI right now but I think that Beyond sort of legal technicalities copyright stuff there are a couple really important reasons why we should hesitate to embrace AI generative AI specifically uh in games and I wanted to kind of talk through where I'm at right now on this because I've been thinking

about it a lot and I think that if we don't speak up now then you know when is a good time to speak up because this is the moment where if anything is going to be culturally set for board games it's now and you know maybe what I say won't mean anything and I can't fix anything but I have to try and I also want to get my position out there because uh because speaking up is is the right thing to do in a situation like this so there are three really big overall Concepts I want to talk about um as we go through this little ramble all right so the the first aspect of this I want to talk about is basically just the issue of doing your own work um I as somebody who spent six years getting a PhD um and who learn how to write historical papers and who actually learned the dead languages that I worked in have I would say probably a very intense set of feelings about doing things the long way but the right way and like actually cheating Mastery over your subject area and I can't help but feel the way that I feel and then look at artists and feel a lot of sympathy for them it takes a lifetime to become a very very good artist even if you don't really consider yourself an artist you're like I'm just an illustrator I'm just a graphic designer it takes a lot of practice and a lot of expertise building to become good at that and I think that one of the discussions of AI that grosses me out the most is the idea that you can alide over all of that work and all of that Mastery and create something that's just as good my my my biggest pressure point is when somebody says something like oh you know AI it's

the democratization of art like what no the democratization of art would be giving everybody enough Leisure Time and access to learn how to do art themselves and take pleasure in the process it's not giving everybody an outcome that they couldn't otherwise achieve in like two seconds because that would be easy that's skipping the entire process of what makes art valuable all of the practice all the thinking all the drafting all the intentionality that goes into a really really good piece of art that's something that you're willing to throw away for the sake of convenience and I think that's gross I think that's gross on a human level just taking credit for something you clearly can't do um but I also think it's gross as a teacher um it really upsets me because my students are also starting to think this way because Society is making them comfortable thinking this way and it bugs me when I have a very transactional relationship with my students um you know very often they're very focused on the end product of what they make but what they don't understand is what I'm watching is the process when I ask students to write a paper I don't necessarily care about the end product as much as I care about being able to see the research the building of the argument helping the student decide what they really want to say helping my student pick uh really good backup for the arguments that they want to make all of that is a process that you cheat yourself of going through when you use AI to generate something in like 5 minutes and not being able to that process yourself both makes what you

create more Hollow I think that that's both aesthetically true and morally ethically internally true but it also means that you're essentially taking credit for an end product that you really yourself were not able to create and so if I'm grading what you learned as a teacher I can't take something from Ai and see it as an expression of what was learned I can only see it as an expression of what was produced and I think that being obsessed with production and that particular way is a problem it's a problem for the soul of humanity it's also a problem for the kinds of products and art and experiences that we consume in our lives and so to me AI feels a lot like cheating it feels a whole lot like taking somebody else's work you know maybe I put something into a search engine that doesn't make me an artist and it doesn't make anybody an artist uh you have to actually make art to be an artist just like you have to actually write to be a writer and just like you actually have to to play games to be a game reviewer and I think that leads in the next part which is that this AI discussion pains me in part because I'm somebody who takes games seriously games actually mean something to me they are meaningful they are not just throwaway they are not just product um they are expressions of a human mind several Minds by the time somebody's done working on a game but I'm always really interested in what was the designer's intention behind this game um and you know a publisher can also put some intentionality on things but the real idea right is that a

designer designs a game they go through the publication process and ideally the game emerges as an expression of something that they really wanted to put into the world that was their intention that the players have an experience the designer intended um and that everything in the game including the illustrations the art uh lends itself to that process and so when I'm assessing games especially because I prefer historical games I like games that I can take very seriously and I can get really into the subject matter so one thing that really bothers me about this is that I don't want to live in a world where I can't tell whether something that is in a game was the author's actual intention for the game or whether somebody was being lazy and it's just a computer mockup but it adds to the overall Impressions that I'm getting from the game like how can I interpret what you're saying if I'm not even sure that you said it um and I feel like this is going to lead to to partially things like oh well you just misunderstand me who the AI said that well I mean you you published it um but I think that it also means that when I'm say looking at a detail of art on a card you know can I understand this as something that a designer and an artist talked about and created together or is this a detail that just appeared in whatever the computer crapped out and they kept it because it looked okay and nobody really really thought about it and because art is communication because games are communication I think that letting somebody else do the saying for

you um is a bad idea I think that you should buck up and say what you mean clear as Bell and that you should say yourself uh and I think that working with an artist is part of that so for night witches I don't want to disclose who we've been talking to because it's not official out there in the world yet but you know David Thompson and I have been talking to an artist about night witches we had a really good conversation about um you know what vibe do we want our game to give off what do we want these women to to convey uh in images of them and how are we going to make that happen and we've also been talking about graphic design you know what can we do to communicate really clearly about this game so that people know what to do with a minimum amount of frustration but that's a human process everything in night witches is David's and my intentions even if they go through somebody else and I think that there's something that's really important about that like every detail of this game is intentional and if it wasn't how could you assess me as a designer through my game I I feel like the real issue with AI art is that it's not really intentional like even if you put Aquarian the AI doesn't really understand the things that you're asking for as real emotions or as real objects it's just using keywords that's been trained on to create kind of a um a collage of ideas that it has that then then puts into the art that you get it doesn't have intention it doesn't have feelings it doesn't know how to convey only a person really knows how to do that so maybe AI can approximate something like that but it's never going to be a true human expression and that's

what I want to critique I don't really care what a computer's able to do I want to know what you have to say and I think the last thing I want to talk about and this is kind of like a weirder discussion because I don't think there's like a onetoone correspondence between these things but there is kind of a connection for me I think of somebody who does board game media so I also think there's a connection between treating art and illustration as a product and not art um and also our current complaints about content and content creators Etc so you know the big quackalope explosion happened over the summer um but you know I see all kinds of discussions periodically about oh well you can't trust content creators and oh you know nobody ever really talks about games anymore nobody ever gets really deep into games anymore like when am I going to get some real critique of a game and like we talk a lot about what is real critique does it mean you have to be negative about games games like what kind of depth are we supposed to go to um you know I routinely see people say well how many times did you play this game it it's weird because we we verbally hold media people in board games to a high standard but then in practice if you look at what we're consuming that's not necessarily true and I worry that with art we're just going to go wholesale down the content route like I actually really despise having my work referred to as content even though I because of our vernacular like I slip and refer to my own stuff as content sometimes and then I really bad and angry at myself after I do it because in my opinion what I do isn't content um what I do maybe you can call it media maybe you can call criticism I

think my podcast is something else but everything that I make is something that I really did make in interaction with a board game but I have real intentions behind my work and those intentions sharpen over time um I don't view what I do as just filler I do not view my work as the intellectual equivalent of cheese food and I also don't don't want to treat games that way at all in fact you might have noticed that a lot of the game reviews that I'm choosing have changed over time cuz I no longer want to just review any old thing I want to review something that means something and I feel the exact same way about art that I consume I want to look at something that means something and I think that you can't I think that you can't sit there and just gulp down a bunch of AI art uh and then complain also about the boringness of content because you're basically trying to make your art the same way and one day you are going to look at a game and you're going to realize that your connection isn't really there maybe you really like the people across the table but the game itself isn't doing much for you and you're going to wonder why just like when you watch yet another Sy board game video you're going to wonder why why am I watching another unboxing that's just like all the other unboxings it's because we through our Behavior have accidentally put ourselves on an eternal diet like mental hospital food where games don't mean anything anymore and where the human connection is gone

because it's completely left the game the game has no spark of the life of the designer left in it and we also don't either I think there's a lot of things that have like I've touched on this video like I'm not even sure this is a coherent argument I'm just talking at this point so I'll I'll kind of draw it down but basically what this boils down to is I don't believe that AI can make things that resonate sufficiently with humans because it lacks Humanity even if it looks like a good illustration um you're still going to limit yourself in terms of seeing new things that are actually creative or fresh seeing things that you're connect with quite as heavily like right now even really good pieces of AI quote art like I noticed my eyes kind of slide off them like even if they look Lush they're just not that interesting and it's because they're not really saying anything they don't have anything to say and I'm interested in engaging with art including board games that has something to say so I guess the conclusion of all of this is you know I say this to myself and everybody else like we're living in a world where people want us to keep accepting good enough as something that we should be satisfied with and I do believe that AI can create something that's quote good enough but is that really what you just want for yourselves in every board game you play in every bit of visual media you try to engage with and every text you read nobody actually wants to look at that stuff nobody actually wants to read it why do you think you skim over so many work emails I mean nobody wants to read stuff that doesn't really have anything

to say uh and I think that that's true both in terms of reading literally and also reading in images and board games so if you've got something to say you should be saying it yourself you should know how to say it yourself and if you can't do the art yourself you should know how to communicate with an artist a human artist who can actually understand interpret and breathe life into the vision that you have because everything else is just kind of like the whitewashed tomb of biblical literature um you know there are also people who think that teachers can be replaced by a computer or by Script and uh I can tell you that basically by the uh you know interactions I have with students that's definitely not the case I taught through coid kids don't want to learn on a computer uh but also you know you can't teach somebody from a script even if all the information is there uh it's the connection and the Art of teaching that that brings out real learning and that brings out a real Connection in the classroom and I think that's also true with board games you know if you if you want the board game to be something special and not just an activity not just content to fill up your days then you need to have intentionality about it and to have intentionality about it you need a person so that's where I'm at with this um unless something drastically changes in the future I will not be covering any games with generative AI I think they're theft and I also find that and and I also think that it's creatively bankrupt and I won't have it so thank you so much for watching please like subscribe comment and most of all happy

gaming

Progress saved