Skip to main content
Loading video...

Skulk Hollow Review - Shadow of the Colossus by way of Cardboard & Wood

Transcript 9:06

hey everyone this is jack from the cardboard herald and today we are taking a look at skulk hollow by pencil first game so what is this game this is a two-player head-to-head asymmetric dueler in which one player is taking on the role of the heroic foxin army trying to defend their land from the guardians the big stompy elemental representations of the land itself trying to kick out these inhabitants that have taken over this sacred grounds called skulk hollow and yes i said it's asymmetric in that the foxen player has a very different modus operandi than the guardian player their separate victory conditions based off of which guardian the guardian player is playing and their separate fox and heroes the sort of captain that is your personal representation on the board that gives the fox and player a little special power it's not nearly as defining as what guardian is in play but still adds quite a bit of variety now the basic flow of the game is that players going to take actions driven by the cards that they have in their hand each of the guardians has their own unique set of cards that correspond to that guardian set of actions and then the foxen player has just one deck but they're going to be able to populate the board with more and more little tiny squishy glass cannon fox and meeples that you are going to hopefully be able

to either pelt the guardian with ranged attacks or better yet like in the shadows of colossus video game you send your little foxes to climb up onto the guardians themselves and attack various locations that if you successfully disable a location by dealing enough damage you are preventing certain actions being taken by that guardian themselves and if you deal enough damage that you've covered all of the health spaces on the guardian then you win the game if your fox and leader gets smushed and they run out of health well then you lose the game it's a good thing that the fox and hero meeple cannot be affected by the guardians if it cohabitates a space with other foxens it's good to be king so what makes it cool well first off normally i don't start with theme in discussing the the the highlights of a game but this is so incredibly thematic it is so lovely to see the little foxens climb up this insurmountable guardian represented by the guardian board unique to each of the guardian meeples and then the wooden pieces are so awesome the guardians are big and stompy and moving about the board the tentacle squid one has all his like little cool tentacles coming up the artwork is really charming the guardians look really ferocious and the mechanics reverberate that thematic immersion so well like everything that

you're doing is in facilitation of this great cinematic story that's unfolding in front of you second i really like the guardian asymmetry each of the guardians has their own unique powers and also victory conditions and this adds a lot of replayability to the game you have the really basic bear who just wants to eat tons of little foxens which is helpful that they're like popcorn most of them are glass cannons with one or two health just chasing them around the board and gobbling them up and then you have more complex ones like the eagle who wants to make sure there are no foxen underlings on the ground spaces not only does that create interesting tactical decisions for the guardian player but also it creates cool decisions for the foxen player you don't want to send up all your units onto the guardian which is in general the more protective space if that's going to dwindle your forces that are on the ground spaces on the board making you more vulnerable to immediate victory by the guardian and then there is one that has a sort of digging mechanic that feels a bit capture the flag-ish and then there's also one who wants to get all his little tentacles up onto the board it just gives a bit of variety and a little bit more thematic and mechanical distinction from game to game to game i also like for the simplicity of the game which it is overall pretty simple i'll get into

that in a little bit there are lots of tactical decisions that you're going to have to make both as the foxen and as the guardian player that are based off of not only what your current capabilities are but what you want to line up for future turns this is especially represented in the power cubes that you can allocate the foxen player and some of the guardians can generate these power cubes that allow you to take free bonus actions on future turns but you have to commit actions from current turns in order to create them and allocate them to specific foxes but that's the only way that you're going to be able to take more than your limited action number that is typically three for the foxen or two for the guardians but they make for really substantial turns and so it gives some risk rewards some interesting decisions that you can make i also like that the foxes have different roles on the different underling units and so a card that gives a ranged attack can have a different meaning depending on which foxin is resolving it archers can be in a ground space just surrounding the guardians whereas the sentinel needs to be within the space themselves but on the other hand the sentinel has more health and can also participate in melee attacks as far as what didn't really work for me well one after playing with the guardian some it did feel like a

little bit of a letdown that the foxen player doesn't have the same kind of variety and flavor that the guardians do because the guardians are the ones that define their asymmetric conditions and then the fox and hero changing just kind of gives you a slightly different power that said the change of the guardian does affect how you as the fox player approach the game and certainly try to run interference against them but i would have liked to see more variety and flavor and control on the part of the foxes either through more interesting change-ups between the fox hero or that the fox hero integrated certain new units into their deck giving a different capability also the game does have lots of tactical decisions but it doesn't really feel like there's a lot of long-term strategic decisions ultimately you're going to be reacting to the cards that you have in your hand which is great for simplicity but because your actions are defined by those cards and those cards are drawn from a randomized deck you're not really going to be able to account on what you'll be able to do two three or four turns from now so you don't really get to chain things in sequence outside of feeling like investing in the power cubes or not so lots of tactical decisions which create some immediacy but there is a lot of luck that interferes with overall strategy which makes the game feel more simplistic the flip side of that is that

it is more approachable for younger players and my six-year-old is certainly able to play on a team the box says eight and up which i think is just about accurate so i do like the approachability but as someone who is absolutely in love with this theme and with the the premise of the game i would have liked a little bit more depth and complexity but overall i like this game this is a nice approachable head-to-head game where it's so cinematic that i think people are going to be invested in it to the point that even if you don't like head-to-head games this may still be worth a try because even on the losing end it's so cool to see things unfold and as much as i do wish that there was more depth and and more strategic capability and maybe a little bit more dynamic variety in some situations of the game the simplicity and approachability does work in its favor especially for the audience that it's going for and that's our review thank you so much for watching i've been jack for the cardboard herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald

Progress saved