Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 12:40

hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond soliter and this week I'm going to be having a look at myth wind this was a review copy sent to me by open owl Studios of a CO game so let's see what it looks like all right so now for a very quick tour of myth wind I mentioned in the little BLB this is a cozy game so basically this is a game that doesn't actually have a wi Condition it's just a game where you play one of four asymmetrical characters there's a fifth character if you have the expansion which I do not and you basically try to meet a goal each game there's like little mild consequences or nice little bonuses if you do manage to success to the goal you build up your town and you just try to become a more profitable and successful version of whichever character you're playing but this game has rotating Seasons you just can play through as many seasons as you want this board will grow and change with time and you're going to be pulling event and Adventure cards that help with that so basically just in general each day is divided into Dawn daytime and then dusk at dawn you do things like draw weather cards see what the weather's going to mean for you today if the weather shows up in particular patterns then different effects might occur but basically you do some Dawn setup then in the daytime each of your characters or just one if you're playing solo you can play this true solo and you can play this any character you can swap them in and out which is pretty nice you spend part of your daytime in town so you do a town action so these different spaces are different actions that you're

able to do so you can do things like go adventuring and pull an adventure card you can decide to construct one of these building if you're able to pay the cost and you're able to clear the land so that there's room for those buildings when they hit the top of the construction queue there are also individual actions that you're going to do on each of your player boards I'm going to talk really briefly about each of the characters uh but you essentially have totally different personal actions that you can perform and you can get Workers as one of your town actions to help you do more of those so there's stuff that you do in the town and then there's stuff that you do individually so the crafter is going to basically take requests and get raw materials to attempt to build refine and sell crafts the ranger spends a lot of his time not even in town he goes on these little adventures uh that sometimes lead to interesting results youve got the merchant who is trying to stockpile goods and then buy and sell them at good prices so the market will fluctuate there are also some rival cards that mess with you when you try to be the merchant so you have to be careful because it's not just you out there trying to sell and get your profits and then you also have the farmer who's pretty fun they they've got this polyomino board essentially here where you are planting crops and you're trying to do it in really efficient ways out on this board so you can sell also I don't want to break into everything but all the pieces for all these are stored basically in these trays which is really nice uh and then you actually have some dice slots over here so depending on whether you're allied with these Sprites one of the premises of this game is that the town you're building is surrounded by them or with the PE the town's people

um that kind of impacts what kind of actions you're able to take so you've got like a little array of things that you can do each turn and then there's kind of like a dusk phase where you clean everything up and that's really it the game is super simple uh it's a mixture between playing your own little small game on your own board growing your town and also kind of hitting story beats so as I just mentioned the town is being built in a place where there are little fairy creatures called Sprites who have different feelings about you kind of depending on things that happen throughout the story honestly everything is pretty low stakes but different action you take are going to align you with either the Sprites or with the talent people like at various turns you can switch back and forth very easily and there's just like little things that happen to kind of get you deeper into the story of the town and of its relationship with the Sprites and the surrounding woods and without going into too much further detail that is that this is a game that again there's no win or loss condition there's no end game so basically whatever condition your Town's in you can just show up set it up play a couple Seasons play as any character that you want and you can continue to revisit this world that you've been working on and keep working at it as often as you like with no actual conclusion so if you find this game experience cozy you can just kind of keep building in and building up so with that said let's go ahead and have some final thoughts all right so now for some final thoughts I was not totally sure how I was going to respond to myth wind when it was sent to me because on the one hand um I really really love cozy games I love cozy video games uh and on

the other hand I have St I've struggled with kind of story driven board games in the past so I wanted to know if this one would be different um uh tldr it's really not but let's talk a little bit more about why that is so for cozy games I really do like cozy games on my switch and on my PC so I love things like Animal Crossing I love things like uh I really liked wild flowers in the last couple of years and I I generally love visual novels games that are very much about story games that are low stakes I also love to read cozy fantasy so Legends lattes and bookshops and bone dust by Travis baldry were among some of my favorite couple books of the last year so when I took myth wind uh there was definitely a chance that I was really going to like it uh but as a board game I just don't really think it's that exciting I there are also going to be people who really disagree with me so the first thing so first things first the good it is very clear that myth wind is a wellth thought out beloved just carefully crafted and packaged game everything from the character trays and how they all fit together to the art and the different little Rule books and the way that everything's organized this is a game that was made by people who really did want you to play it and get it out again and again and again play it again and again and again and feel cozy while you play it however it just didn't quite work for me part of it is that I liked the the different characters play very differently however I didn't actually

find any single characters gameplay compelling enough to make me want to keep playing and playing and playing this game with no end in sight I didn't get enough satisfaction out of for example being a successful farmer even though the polyomino are fun to want to be the farmer for season after season I was interested in the markets as the merchant for the first couple of times and then I stopped caring about the market uh as my town grew I didn't really feel more invested in the town I was just kind of like oh this is interesting but when's it going to get like really interesting and I felt like my character arcs never crossed it's very much like everybody's in their own corner of the Town doing their own thing and I can see why it would be that way because you wanted to offer these different playing experiences but I kind of feel like it would have been more exciting to be able to do something like run two characters as a solo player but have those characters do things that actually impacted each other on the board and so that attempt to kind of create a cozy environment to be in I really respect and I can see where this game was going as it tried to create that I also think that it missed missed some opportunities that might have been more difficult I think to create design wise uh but that would have really made the game pop which would have been things like make it feel like stuff that you did left more of a unique mark on the town um make it so that playing as one character you're really picking up from something that another character did other than like a building that got built and so I really feel like there were some missed opportunities to have more of a

storyline that was actually interesting and more so something to work towards that didn't just feel like you kind of sat down and did the same thing every time with some minor variations and you know it's also fair to say like I generally have a hard time with like story board games didn't like sleeping Gods um I thought that lands of Galer was okay but it didn't quite do it for me that said I will say I think that if you're looking for a relaxing experience where you go around and things happen I actually think that lands of Galer is still tops of this genre for me personally somebody who's not a devot and I just I guess I'm always hoping for the one that's going to be different and I thought that myth wi might be but then it wasn't it's just another one of those games where if you like that kind of emergent storyline you can get really into it then I can see you really enjoying it but I just kind of felt like it was working real hard to give me not a whole lot of story on drip like the the setup where humans are working with Sprites potentially interesting ultimately pretty predictable and not that interesting so if you really like the mini games for this and you just want to try all the different characters out I can see you having fun with this game for a while but this idea of a town that's like almost a living breathing them that you leave and then you come back and you leave and then you come back and you can just keep it going forever and ever and ever um that would be more compelling if the game were more compelling I do like that so many games now including one that's as well produced and as mainstream as this are playing with the idea of no real Victory or loss condition I mean there are goals in this game but you know there's just a consequence if you don't meet the goal

for your play session doesn't end the session so I I like that we're playing with that a bit more you know amabelle Holland uh from Holland Spiel has been really messing around with what is the importance of a victory condition and what does a game without victory conditions look like and how can games exist as feelings or experiences or um you know immersive events as opposed to something that has just a set win loss I am really good with games experimenting with that um I don't have a problem with myth when not having a wi condition I actually think that's potentially very interesting but even without a wi condition I need to feel like I'm going somewhere and I think that that's sort of the problem with this game like I never really felt like the things that I was doing were going anywhere interesting it was like a little Cruise like a pretty Pastor um and then I was done and I wanted to go home and I didn't want to go back and so I think that a lot of love went into this game there's a lot of thought that went in this game there going to be people who absolutely love this gaming experience but it wasn't for me and it wasn't for me because not because it doesn't have combat cuz I actually think that's cool I think there should be more games without combat um not because it doesn't have a wi condition I'm fully willing to experiment with that um and not because it has asymmetrical play because I think it has a lot of potential I think it's because things didn't like fully come together in a way that made me feel committed to this world enough to keep coming back and because the sense of progression in this

game wasn't wasn't really satisfying to a point where I felt like I was actually building anything I needed more attachment and more investment for this premise to work and instead I felt like I had some relatively amusing mini gamess um and you know I checked out to the different characters it was fine uh but it was fine and if you want me to keep coming back and back and back with no wind condition and with you know the idea that I'm going to come back and be cozy and have a relax ing time and want to revisit this world I just need a bit more than that so that's how I feel about myth wind um I know it's hot right now everybody's covering it they s they must sent review copies to a lot of people CU these videos are everywhere uh but that's where I'm at on it um it's probably not a huge surprise but you know I'm just going to keep trying these and hope that somebody's going to get a story game right for me at some point because I just I believe that it'll happen it's just not this one that said it's lovingly made um you know it's it's a beautiful product I'm sure that there will be people who really get a lot out of it but if your taste align with mine that's probably not you thank you so much for watching uh please like subscribe comment support me on patreon help the channel uh and most of all happy

giving

Progress saved