Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 9:09

Hello, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, my wife thinks I don't give her enough privacy. I wish he'd just come out and tell me instead of just writing it in her diary. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Puna, Rome versus Carthage from Fallings.

I don't think In Punica, Rome versus Carthage from Fallon, two players take on the roles of either the Romans or the Carthaginians during the Punic Wars of antiquity. Now, this is a very light area control war game. One player will play the Romans, one player will play the Carthaginians. You'll each get a deck of cards, and these are numbered 0 to six for a total of seven cards. You'll also have soldiers on the board, land forces that you will place according to where it tells you on the board itself. Uh you'll also have fleets on the seas, and the Carthaginians will also have their elephant, Hannibal. Now, the Romans will take the first turn, and what you will do on your turn is you will play a card.

Now, the card is going to tell you what specific actions you can do on that turn. For instance, most of the cards are going to let you move and it will tell you how many movement you get for fleets or how many movement you get for land forces. Now, land forces can move to adjacent areas or through a chain of unbroken sea zones that you have fleets in. Now, the fleets themselves, they can move anywhere on the board. They don't have to move adjacent. They can just essentially teleport to any region on the any C region on the board. Now, there are a few other card effects as well that will trigger when you play the cards, different things that you can do, but critically what's going to happen is if ever you end your turn with units in the same location as that of your enemy, a battle is going to ensue. Now, how a battle works is that both you, the attacker, and the defender will go ahead and play another card from your hand.

Now that card uh will have a number value on it, but critically you may also have a battle effect. These are cross swords. If you get the battle effect, then starting with the attacker, you can do that. Essentially, you can do the movement there. So potentially, you could bring more troops into that battle if that's what you wanted to do. Now, you're going to add up all of the strength points you have. Now, all of your soldiers have one strength points. All of your fleets have one strength points. Uh Hannibal actually has two strength points. Now, you're going to add that to whatever card value you played. So, if you had, you know, two soldiers there and you played a three, your strength value would be five. Now, whoever loses the battle, they will lose one of their units and they will retreat. If ever the score is tied, then both units will lose uh a person and the attacker will retreat. Now, over the course of the game, uh you will be losing your soldiers, your your land units. they will be uh dead. They will be taken off the board and they can never come back.

Now, if you lose a fleet, you can at any time on your turn remove one of your land units and then put a fleet back on the board in kind of your spawn zone or your capital. But your soldiers, as I say, do not come back. Now, there are essentially three ways you can win this game. If ever you control the opposing players capital, either Carthage or Rome, you win the game. If ever you control three of your enemy's influence areas, these are spaces on the board that are marked with kind of their symbol, you win the game. And if ever you succeed in destroying all of your enemies land forces, then you win. Puna, Rome versus Carthage. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now back to the review.

Okay, ladies and gentlemen. So, Puna Rome versus Carthage. This is a very light game and it's a it's it's an area control light light light war game where you are trying to v for control of the Mediterranean and win the Punic Wars here. [snorts] Now, this is, as I say, it's a very interesting game because it is so simple and yet it kind of packs a punch. Uh, this is one of those games that I think is just deep enough for the time it gives you. If this had been an hour-long game, I probably wouldn't enjoy it that much, but being as light as it is, it's a game that I think you can get into and have a lot of fun with. Again, you're looking at 20 to 30 minutes here, but it's it's it's it presents some real fun and challenging moments. For instance, there are those moments where you the battles where you're playing your cards. And what I what I should point out too is as you're playing the cards, you lay all the cards down and they're kind of out on your board where the your opponent can see them. And you don't reclaim those until you play your last card, in which case you can grab all of those cards except for the last card which remains out. So over the course of the game as you're doing these battles, you can kind of see what cards your opponent has already played and you can kind of deduce what cards he's got left in his hand and what he can and what he can bring to it. Now there's also, as I say, some some bells and whistles, some surprises. The Romans, for instance, uh they're much more limited on how they can move their navies, but at the same time, they can retreat if ever they're in a disadvantageous position. They can play one of the retreat cards and essentially

get out of the clutches of the Carthaginians. So, the Carthaginians kind of have to be aware of that. Do they want to play their most powerful card if it's fairly obvious their enemy is going to retreat? And indeed, do you want to play do you want to hang on to that most powerful card when you need it? Because when you finally do play it, it's going to be a while before it kind of cycles back into your hand. So, there's a lot of issues here uh like that. A lot of things that are going on uh that you have to pay attention to uh with with the card play and the battles. And it's fun too when you're in the battles and some of those kind of battle, you know, you get some of those cross swords that let you actually play the card um the actions on the card and not all your cards have that. So, that's something else you have to consider when going into battle. There's there's a little bit of bluff and counter bluff there with regard to your enemies, but fundamentally it is a solid two-player quick game. It's a game that really, as I say, packs a punch for the time that it gives you. Uh Ray and I played this. We we had a lot of fun with it. It's again a simple game, a light game, but if you're looking for something at the beginning of game night or just some filler for two players, this is something that could pack a punch or even something you could take to lunch, you know, take to work and and play it on your lunch hour. This game, like I say, is a lot of fun. So, uh, I'm going to go ahead. I'm going to give the, uh, Puna Rome versus Carthage a seven on the Cody scale for one of these lighter, quicker games. I think it, as I say, it really packs a punch. Thank you once again for joining us today on the Discriminating Gamer. As always, we ask you to please leave a comment for us on YouTube, on Board Gamegeeek, on our Facebook page, on X. We really love to

hear back from you. We really love to hear what you have to say. Please, please, please subscribe to our channel, like this video. that really helps us out. And if you do like what you see here on this channel, I would humbly ask you to uh check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, military history, fun things like that. It would mean the world to me if you'd subscribe to that channel as well. And if you do really like what you see here on the discriminating gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. You know, I have successfully grown human vocal cords from stem cells in my laboratory. The results speak for themselves. Please somebody on my feet again. And I DON'T KNOW WHERE I'M GOING. And I don't know where I've been. Please somebody ground. It's a long time.

I wind up feelless.

Progress saved