The Isle of Cats Review I Board Game Overview
Transcript
you might love cats but should you love isle of cats let's review it this is the review for the game the isle of cats the good and bad about it by the end of this review you will know should you love this we have six burning questions that we will answer in this video but before we do that giannis what is this game all about in isle of cats you have polyamino shaped cats that you put on your ship because you're rescuing them from an island each round you get fish that is your currency in this game let me interrupt you here so fish are the currency in the current sea yeah and your turn you get seven cards you draft two and give the rest of them to other people at the table so at the end you get seven back then you can buy them with your currency and then the last thing is you get cats from the island to your ship by paying fish as well as you need these beautiful crates right here you can get them with these tokens as well as on cards the more fish and the more crates you have the more cats you can get you play five rounds and then the game ends by the end of the fifth round who has the most points wins and you get points for how many different families of cats you have on the on the ship how big they are for the treasure some cards give you extra points so there's actually a ton of ways to get points there's also two ways you'll lose points if you leave rats open or if you leave any empty spaces on any room that's minus five points that's the overall rules of this game so we can go to the questions and the first question
is who would you buy it for three two one boom sunday players we recently got this comment under our site video the site actually isn't that light of a game and it's not more sunday players oh which i thought is a cool term to have this is absolutely for sunday players it's light a fun game even the theme gives it like this quirky twist to it and it's totally meant for sunday players as well as i think kids can play it as well as i think it's a perfect intro game to show off drafting games i have cat tetris see what i did there it's a new genre tetris and drafting lovers i feel like this actually has theme which is weird since it's just so very wild but i i do like looking at the cats and putting them on the board and i feel that that also helps like non-gamers engage with this game what is the best player count i have check the box let me check oh it's one to four i feel that that's about right yeah pay you you've you've explicitly stated three is better right three is best in my opinion okay two was absolutely great as well played it with my wife and we both loved it just with two but three was best because it's a bit more interaction a bit more cuts there so it's just more fun so three was the best but it takes nothing away from like two and four players most of the action happens simultaneously time doesn't scale that match from like two to four
what is the best thing about this game here we go i have a lot of text i have more do i have more i mean there's a lot of things to like about this game for me it comes down to like the sense of discovery and accomplishment there's a ton of cards in this game and there's going to be a couple of games before you actually start seeing the same ones all the time and also this feeling of you just putting the cats there you're saving them i don't know it just gives me the sense of accomplishment there's not a ton of original mechanisms in this game but in this combination just works really nice what feels bad is when the round ends if there are cats left on the island they go away so you leave them on the island they may be going to the jungle into hiding and then wait when you play the next game and then come back for them you have to play the next game to save those cats make sense yeah kind of so i have three things one is interaction there's not a lot of interaction but how much interaction would you expect from a thai lane game you don't want to give up good cards the player that absolutely would love them as well as when somebody takes your cat that perfectly fits in that spot that you need ah it hurts the other thing is satisfaction everything you said it's absolutely satisfying to put the right pieces into the right places it's absolutely satisfying to get the right cats to save the cat just makes you feel good and last thing is relaxation as i said a light game for sunday players you feel calm you just put together your pieces it's like solving a puzzle it's just relaxing so this holy trinity
of things is what the best thing about this game i love this combination in this game what is the worst thing about this game three two one i have too many cards you have just i have just cards the thing is i love drafting games i like playing drafting games but for example 7 wonders fantastic drafting game but the first time you play with somebody teaching all the cards and you know telling what they do takes some time but do you think they'll remember it no they'll still keep asking but there's not that many cards in there compared to this where there's a ton of cards and they're very different which is awesome but again it brings up a lot of questions during the first couple of plays and maybe even like third or fourth day and there are some very very specific cards that a lot of people mistake for something else for example there's one that whenever you take a cat you can take another one but nobody reads the small text underneath which says that you still have to pay for them no they're stuck with it because they don't have fish but the biggest deal is that you basically in this game can only do the things that cards let you do you can only get cats when you get cards you can only get treasures when you get cards and all that and sometimes you just don't get the right cards there's the opposite way as well you get the right cards and you suddenly get 50 points this for me it means that you can't take this game very seriously it's not a gamer's game at all it is a family it is absolutely a family game as you always say that
randomness is good thing yeah but for this it's sometimes too much and my other thing is i feel it's one round too long if it would be four rounds it would be easier i mean it's not a long game don't get me wrong it says 60 to 90 minutes in the box i'd say that's about right but i feel it would even gain if it would be only four rounds but it's just my personal feel that i feel this family type of game shouldn't be that long for the heaviness that it has what's the best alternative well you already picked us all for which one projectile yeah but you can it's not a drafting video so yeah allowed i was thinking maybe projectile could be a alternative for this one but actually i think azul is closer than this one project l is really really light compared to both of these games you all have pool of uh very specific pieces in azul's case it's the color in this case it's the form and color that you pick and a lot of times in azul as well somebody picks your pieces and somebody will draft specifically pieces that you need this game reminded me of that only i think a better version of it azul is more calculative is that a word now it is i guess this row will give me that many points that will give me that many points this not so much it's much easier to follow along where and how many points you will get and this is more colorful more interesting i would say but there's a lot of similarities for sure well for me there's two choices one for the drafting and one for the tiling for drafting is some wonders
basically remove all the cats and chips and everything and just leave the cards that's basically some wonders well i'm obviously dumbing down that's not as simple as that but it is pure drafting and for tiling this is a tricky part because most thailand games i have played are really simple and quick ones and the most recent that i have played is new york zoo which is fairly original because it's mostly like a race game you're just racing to fill out your whole board and first one to do it wins it also has animals and they're cute here you have cat meeples there you have the animal meeples if you're looking for a family type of cute game with like these tetris pieces that could be an option final rating i haven't used asterix in a while i think this is that situation where i should break out my emergency asterisks you had emergency like six videos in a row no comment because anything i will say might be edited against me
the arrow didn't hit the mark but it's in the middle it's meant to be in the middle okay i was really debating inside myself which one is it fantastic or really good i was absolutely for sure that it's really good and i was thinking maybe it's even fantastic and for some parts it's absolutely fantastic and if i would look just at thailand games i would for sure put it in a fantastic because i think it's the best thailand game i've played i would absolutely love to play it again and i probably will plus my wife absolutely loves it if i'm usually the one initiating the idea of playing any board games then for this game it's always her name she really really likes it my gamer side would put it in the really good one casual gamer just the casual person would put it in a fantastic for sure because it is awesome i love it well i have fantastic with an asterisk and what it means is i guess i put it really good but depending on when you're watching this video kickstarter might still be going for an expansion for this i think it's called don't forget the kittens i think it's going to be definitely fantastic to be precise i'd put it really good now you know if you're a solo player or if you're playing it with gamers or in a family just works really nice and there's something for everybody if anything that we told you today in this video makes you think like maybe i would like this game try it for sure you're not gonna regret it and also i'm a dog person and if i'm saying this about this game which exclusively has cats well and some fish i mean come on must be good really good
for sure that's it with our reviews so be sure to subscribe like and do all the good stuff that really helps us uh so thank you for that yes and we'll see you next time where we probably would do we'll do like a dog's video right isle dogs all dogs yeah i don't know is there a game with dogs there should be thailand game with dogs i don't think they're in it is there any good dog game that you can name empty niche