Skip to main content
Loading video...

Majesty Review - JonGetsGames

Transcript 19:57

welcome to Jong its games today I'll be reviewing at majesty this is a light tableau building game designed by mark Andre and in it players are vying to build up the most wealth in their town by recruiting the correct citizens and in general citizens do better when they are with people that they know and like but they'll also oftentimes get points for synergizing off of each other first I'll explain how the game plays and then I'll jump it in my review before we start playing majesty each player is going to give their own tableau of city cards as well as a card over here with five people's on it and then we are going to remove some of these one value cards depending on the player count shuffle these up shuffle the twos up and then stack them just like this then deal out six cards and we're ready to play the game for each player's turn all they have to do is select and pay for one of the cards from this row and then put it down into the associated building in their tableau now the first card in the row is always free and if you want to grab any of the cards that are deeper down then you'll have to spend some of these workers so if they learned this Knight right here they would have to take it two of their workers and plug them down just like that but for our first example we'll go ahead and take the free card which is the Miller and now we're going to put it down here because it is associated with the same symbol and now we can activate this region next we look to the bottom of the card to see the specifics of its activation for this one we see that we will get two points per a wheat symbol so for the first card we put down we would get two points but if we already had a card down and we put another one of these down then that would be two plus two or for victory points total so for this first card right here we would simply take this two point chip put it

in front of us and our turn is over at this point the next player gets to take their turn by sliding this card road down and drawing in the next card so that they have six available to themselves and they play will keep going around the table until everybody has done this 12 times it is worth noting that on your turn there might be some of these workers already placed on the cards and if you go ahead and take a card that has a worker on it then you get to activate the card and take all the workers and put them back on to your little card right here but you're never allowed to have more than five workers so if you ever take more workers then can fit on this card then you simply get one extra victory point for each worker that you're not able to fit it's worth noting that some of these cards are double-sided and when you grab them from the middle you can choose which of the area's you will activate with that given card and now I'd like to talk about some more of these activatable spots specifically I want to talk about the barracks which is where you put your nights down into now this is pretty simple you get three points per night Sybil that you have in your area but before you evaluate that you have an attack and the way this works is you add up all of the night symbols in your area and that is the value of your attack and you hit everyone else around the table they will then check to see the number of the guards that they have in their guardhouse and that number of the guards will equal their defense value and every player who has less defense than the value of the attack will then lose one of their citizens into their infirmary and it's always going to be the left hand of most of their citizens so for instance if the guards right here were the left hand most one you would flip it over and put it just like that and at

the end of the game we will lose one point for every person in the infirmary but there is fortunately a way to pull them out when we come over here to the cottage we see that when we activate a witch over here we will heal the top card from our infirmary so it does not matter how many witches we have over here just when we activate this we will take that card right off and it goes back into the area that it is associated with but we don't reactivate that area also we can now talk about some of the other bonuses over here we see that the witch is going to get us two points per witch Brewer and a Miller we have in our area so each one of these activations that scales very well for all three of these spots and then the brewer over here is going to actually generate points and more of the worker maples equal to the number of brewers you have and this down here is actually a way that people can get points when it's not their turn because it's this symbol shows everybody else around the table including the person who is uh playing is going to get two points if they have a minimum of at least one of the Miller's so essentially the Millers are going to be making the wheat and barley that the brewers need to actually make the beer so you can make points when other people activate their spots at this point the remaining three buildings should be pretty self-explanatory the guardhouse gets points for guards nights and innkeepers the inn gets points for innkeepers as well as gives points out for everybody who helps supply it with beer with the brewers and the castle over here it gives you points for the nobles and can give you extra workers as well so as I mentioned or you will keep playing around the table until everybody has taken 12 cards and then the game is over and you can score up the endgame points the first

thing you want to do is evaluate each one of the individual spots and you are gonna check to see who has the most of those given types of people so we start with the Miller whoever has the most Miller's gets 10 points then the Brewer whoever has the most of those gets 11 etc all the way down over to the castle where whoever has the most of these Nobles gets 16 points which is the most and then of course you have to evaluate the infirmary and everybody's going to lose one point per person in the infirmary next you will score points for the diversity of different people that you have in your tableau so you count up the number and it's 1 2 3 4 5 6 in this instance and then you square that number so 6 times 6 or 36 points total and you add that up to all of the other points that you have so obviously if we had had a seventh person here that would be 49 points which is a much better way to do it but that's not always going to be possible based off the decisions you have so once you add up all of those victory points from the ones that you gathered in the middle of the game and these endgame points you will see who has the most and that that person is going to be the winner it is worth noting that each one of these city cards has an a side and AV side and if you look down here the B sides are rather different and they offer different synergies between the cards and the game offers that you can play with all a sides or all B sides and it does say if you want you can alternate between the two but you have to make sure that everybody using the same set of A's and B's although it does seem like it's been designed to stick with the B's and the A's alright let's now begin the review for Majesty off by starting with a couple positive points and the first of these

has to do with the central tension point that you have every single turn of the game and that is what citizen do I am list and that seems like every basic thing because that really is a game you just do 12 selections of citizens and then you end the game and see who won but it's specifically what I'm talking about here is you are restricted by the number of the little-people workers that you have in front of you so right off the bat you might not have access to the entire line so you need to just process the people that you do have access to but then there are a wide variety of other things that you need to consider while you're trying to figure out which person to grab because for of all you know at the end of the game there is that squared at scoring for how wide you go so it is important to try and not to go really hard on just a specific couple of these citizens but then you have a counter pull away from that because there is the area majority scoring for each one of the citizens and in general the citizens they score off of each other so if you already have it three of it that one type then getting the fourth one is probably gonna be very lucrative for you because it just scales off of that number that you've had already so I just love it the push and pull within the decision structure I found that it creates for pretty satisfying decisions because it is not necessarily always straightforward as support has which citizen you should grab now I'm not gonna say that every single one of your 12 turns is gonna be fraught with like tough decision making but I will say that for a light quick game I was surprised at how solo the decisions were for positive point number two I just want to briefly mention how quick and easy this game is to both

learn and play I feel like this is a learn while playing style game because once you just get everything set up around the table as long as the person who is teaching is a star player they can just go they just take their first turn and explain the restrictions for the people as far as which of the citizens they can grab then they put it down in front of themselves and explain how that iconography works and then if they want to they can explain all the rest of the iconography or they could just pass and have it go to the next person and you know they'll have specific restrictions and maybe they have questions about some of the icons but from what I found that people have found that the way all of the citizens process to be very straightforward and I think that's definitely a plus for the game next up let's move into a couple neutral points and the first of these has to do with the night card now this is probably the most controversial sticking point for this entire game and of course these are the ones where when you play them into your tableau you then attack everybody else around the table and they essentially check their number of guards versus the attack power of your night and if that is not adequate for themselves then and they're gonna have to injure their leftmost person and put them into their infirmary and I think this is a bit of a polarizing mechanic in the game I personally not only don't have a problem with it I like it in the game because I think that it is another piece of player interaction or the table and it's also another piece of tension because when you have the decision to make of which of the citizens do you grab you will oftentimes be presented with the option of taking one of those nights and if you take the night then that means that somebody else can't take it later on and attack you

back which is kind of a strange situation where it's almost like your best defense is a good offense sometimes and of course if you find yourself taking too many of those than maybe you're not going wide enough to get that really great square bonus scoring at the end of the game but also on the other side of the coin this is pretty interactive like you are drafting cards and trying to build a little thing in front of you and then the game allows people to just pick up a stick and hit you over the head with it and it's not great when you have to like burn a person over to the side especially if it's one of your kind of middle of the round middle of the range people if you have one of your Miller's get injured it doesn't feel anywhere near as punishing as if you maybe get one of your guards injured or something like that if you have not drafted the citizens enough to actually protect from the left hand side so I like the interaction I like how it works I think in general you can set yourself up to protect yourself if you see things coming and like I said if you don't have the option of grabbing a guard but there is a night out there maybe you take it yourself and if none of these things work you just don't have them evils to grab that night then do something else I mean pick something that's gonna get you points and just be comfortable with the fact that as you're playing this game odds are good you're gonna have some people get injured and there is an entire citizen that is able to heal those injured people back up and bring them back out also having some injured people is really not the end of the world I've seen people win by having a big pile of people in that injured part of their board so it's definitely not something where you're just going to lose if you keep getting hit by the night over and over again as long as you are out valuing those losses with some

bigger gains elsewhere on your board for neutral point number two let's now discuss the role of luck and majesty and you know from a broad sense you can look down and see that the engine of this game is a shuffled up deck of cards so obviously there will be randomness that comes into play but it is definitely mitigated by the initial setup because you are controlling that shuffle buying shuffling to separate decks of cards independently and then putting the twos on the bottom and the ones on top of that so that you will have more even distribution of citizens that come out over the course of the entire game and so that definitely helps things out and another thing to keep in mind is that at lower player accounts that row is going to move even slower than it would potentially at a 4 player account so any perceived luck problems will be a lot smaller at a two-player game versus a 4 player game but I can tell you right now that even at 4 with 3 of the cards going away before it's your next turn it seems like I've just never had a problem with luck I mean sure occasionally there are times where I'm just like oh the card I needed came out at exactly the wrong time and they happened three turns in a row but that really does seem to be kind of a rare type of thing and honestly this is a tactical game you it really wants you to not always have amazing options it might be like here's some okay options or bad options but trying to pick the best ones from those and just move on I think that's kind of baked into the design of the game so I personally don't have an issue with luck here ok let's now move into the negative section and I only have one point to talk about and it relates to the b-side version of the game that you can play so

you build your little tableau of all the little buildings and they have an a side and a B side and the way the game is designed you have on you all of the a signs are meant to be played together as kind of like an easier way to play the game and then you have all the B sides that are meant to play together as a more advanced way to play the game and I have a couple of problems with it honestly on the first problem that I have is that it seems like the innkeeper in particular on the B side is way overly incentivize for people to go hard on them because they are the most complicated of the citizens on that side and the way they work is that whenever you put an innkeeper down you then find it the column with the most citizens and then you get two points per citizen in that column but it does not exclude the inn so what that means is if you have a game or somebody takes anything innkeeper and they maybe get a couple points that's fine and the next time it comes around to them there's another innkeeper either like yeah I'll take that and then what's going to score off the innkeeper's so each innkeeper is gonna score each other a couple times and if they have an opportunity to take a third and keeper suddenly they are making massive points and you have the situation that isn't fun for anybody because you have the person who's grabbing the inn keepers who suddenly their sole focus is just grabbing innkeepers and if it's an option out there on the table then they have a non-decision turn like they just do it they take the innkeeper and they keep moving on and then everybody else on the table is gonna feel this solid pressure to try and counter draft those innkeepers away from somebody who's already been building up the strategy it just it's just unfun for everybody and I feel like I'm gonna be house ruling the B side innkeeper from now on and just say that it can't target

itself because somatically that makes no sense and there are several there are a couple other places on the advanced side that actually incentivize having innkeepers anyway so it's not like the game needed more reason to force you into taking these things the other issue that I have with the B side just from a general design aesthetic is that it was designed to be played all together and specifically it is a much more aggressive side like you can see the way the Knights are incentivized to work with several of the other rules and then also the with the way that the noble gives you extra points for people in the infirmary it's just a meaner side to the game and I wish that they had scrapped that entire design ethos and instead said that the B sides are a little bit more complicated but built to be randomly shuffled up with all of the a sides every single time you played the game because the way it is as shipped you can play it as an a side or as a B side and officially the rules do say you can flip the cards around if you'd like to play it that way but it does not seem to be an toning that that'll work very well and I just wish that the game had been designed so that the first time you play it says play with a sides and the second time you play until infinity you just randomize are the A's and B's that you have a different setup and I think if it had been designed from that angle it would be a much more solid advanced way to play the game and it would add a lot more depth to the overall experience so just in general I feel like there are several misses to me with the advanced side of the game it's now time to discuss the variability for majesty and

if you just listen to my one negative points some of this is gonna sound a little familiar because I feel like it is in general a little bit less variable then I expected going in and that's because there's essentially two ways to play the game you play with all of the a signs to your buildings or all the B sides to your buildings and sure there are seven different types of citizens in the game and every time you sit down to play the game you'll shuffle up that deck of cards and it may be one game you go hard on at the guards in another game you're going really hard on the nobles but I feel like from a variability perspective there was a really big miss in trying to actually design the game so that you randomized the a and B sides and have that be a really good way to play the game as opposed to it being a or b and the rules do specifically say that you can randomize them up if you like to but it does not seem to be in toning that that is the way the game was designed to play and I haven't tried that but I am NOT confident that that will work super well and I might at some point in the future but in general it leaves me feeling like the variability is a little less than I expected going in when it comes to player account Majesty supports two to four players and I've played at several three and four player games I've never had an opportunity to play it at two but I do think that three player is probably the sweet spot for a couple reasons the first one being the classic two-on-one maneuver where if you think one person is running away with the game you can have both of their opponents kind of try to slow them down by counter drafting based off of the cards in that card row and another thing to consider is that with more people around the table you're gonna have those cards

disappear and a quicker rate in a two-player game only one card is going to disappear between turns and in a four player game you're gonna have three cards disappear out of these six so it's gonna be a much more tactical affair at four but the reason I'm saying that three is probably best again is because you can have that two-on-one gang-up because well this is a game where you have a scaling amount of points that happen it's essentially little engines that you're building in front of you and so slowing someone down who maybe is getting a little bit too many of these really good cards is probably a good thing but all that being said I imagine the two-player game plays very well as well in conclusion I've played Majesty five times at this point and I have been impressed with it overall I've had a good amount of fun playing it I was not expecting the decisions that you make on every one of your turns it to be as satisfying as they ended up being and I don't want to oversell it it's not like this is a an incredibly deep game but it is so quick to learn and to teach and to play and for each one of those twelve decisions you make you have a variety of good things to think about first of all you are trying to take a citizen that's gonna work well with the citizens that you've already grabbed maybe getting some synergies with that same exact citizen or sometimes they kind of play really well off of each other but then also you're trying to win as many of these area majorities on these columns as you can while at the same time trying to have a nice variety of all of these citizens because you will square that variety at the end of the game and that could be a lot of your points a winning score is often times in the like 150 160 s and if you have it 7 people that's 7 times 7 or 49 points

which is almost a third of your probable endgame score and that's a big deal that think that you have to consider it is definitely unfortunate then I've been so unimpressed by the advanced b-side for a couple reasons one because I like the engine of this game and the a sign is fine but I would like to enjoy the a version of these buildings that interact a little bit more with each other that works better but also from a variability perspective it seems like shipping the game with just two modes of play is a bit of a misstep when they could have just had a beginner first-time game and then just randomize the A's and B's every single time you play the game from that point on and as I mentioned before you can do that and the rules say that's fine to do but it's obvious events a variant and not something that was designed around and that was that's something that I was hoping the game would have honestly looking to the future I enjoy the overall engine and the simplicity of it so much that if they come out with an expansion for this one that has new buildings to be activated in your player tableau area I would be quite interested in grabbing that to get extra variety into this game because that is again one of the main catching points for it but in general I've really enjoyed the game I've had a lot of fun with the decisions I made and I advise you give this one a shot if it sounds even remotely interesting to you as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel through patreon including all of these producers level pledges if you two would like to directly support the channel you could do so at patreon.com slash John gets games and I'd really appreciate it

also if you'd like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and monthly vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved