Crescent Moon - Asymmetrical wargame review, is it better than Root?
Transcript
you can sleep in the sofa you don't help me here yeah there's no no out of game deals five faction fighting negotiating dealing backstabbing what's all about crescent moon stay tuned hi it's turnt and stella here from maple university welcome to our channel and thank you for joining us today we are going to talk about crescent moon so it's an overview and followed by review of this new game that is made by or published by osprey games but actually designed by steve mathes and steve madden is in our gaming group in melbourne yeah melbourne-based designer and this is a game that you know we have seen this come up through the development we've seen a lot of the early early play testing and this is the uh finished version we played the early version of it a few years ago yes and we are going to give you an overview and what's so different about it and um i don't know when i heard about crescent moon i immediately thought oh like five different factions different way of you know getting fixed free points is it like root so let's dwell in yes so uh crescent moon is an asymmetrical war and diplomacy type of game it is a four or five player game so um yeah you're you're not going to buy this one to play with your partner it does
it does fall apart if you don't have that many players so it's specifically a four or five player game yeah if we look down on the board here it we've got a little map there's only 16 tiles here or 14 if you're sorry 13 if you're playing with four players and there are five different factions and it's all about over three or four rounds of play each round has four actions and you're going to try to get as many victory points as you can and each player gains victory points in a completely different way without looking at the individual factions first i'll just sort of show you the board here you've got different sorts of terrains so there's fertile terrain there's some quarries there's a holy site out here which is generally worth points and there are two means of area control out here there's military area control which means your forces are in an area and control it you can you can tax it or you can get the um get money out of it if it is a valuable hex when you control it militarily and military control comes from having your units it comes from having mercenaries with this camel on them which are units that you hired or it comes from having your fortresses or castles so those are all military pieces completely separate to the military control there is also influence control represented by this hexagon here and whoever has influence over an area
has won the hearts and minds of whoever lives there but doesn't actually control it and so you get different benefits by having an influence over an area but fundamentally areas can be have influence control and military control by different players and so you'll see this two two tone part of game come into play the sorts of things that you can do you can you can gain your own military units if you're a faction that has them you can hire mercenaries anyone can hire a mercenary it's represented by the camel side if you're a faction that has none of its own you can hire those mercenaries so it's going to take you a lot more money and effort to get to get these guys but they can move around and do military control you can spend money to construct buildings which are your fortresses and your castles and these towns which i'll come back to in a minute towns and cities can be built as well that's a big use for money um and then you can try to take over areas so you can launch launch assaults and that will um trigger a battle when you go into a battle you can it's a nutritional sort of battle so players will there are cards that you can purchase into your hand and you can play them in the battle and then you'll have a nutritional sort of battle where everyone will lose at least half of who goes into the
battle generally speaking and then whoever's left can take over if you launch an assault on an area with a building you could destroy the building sack it for to gain money out of it or if you go in where there's a castle or a fortress you can take that over with your own units and replace it with one of your own color for example if i'd come in there i can win that the map itself is divided by a river with one crossing point so that that makes things a bit tricky there as well but then there are cards that will let you go across the river so lots of different options going on and there are different maps as well that yes this is not one of the maps from the book i just randomly put these out there but you can organize these in various different ways and and you start with some units and influence some things as well indeed you can also have influence contests so you can try to take over influence from somebody else and then that gets resolved not quite the same way as a combat but it does have a resolution before someone takes it over so what are all the factions and how does this game drive huge amounts of negotiation because it's a heavy negotiation sort of game um probably the simplest uh the simplest character to understand is the caliph which is the blue one really is just looking for area controllers trying to control as many
areas militarily as possible trying to get influence down which gives them an easier way to get more units as well and gains points by spreading out everywhere and kind of is the most basic and easy to understand in that way the warlord which is the black one the warlord likes to have influence because that's an easier way of gaining units warlord has an action to gain units everywhere it has influence or even lose influence to get two units so there's a much easier way of getting units on the board and then just marches around destroying stuff and gets more points for taking over and destroying things and killing other players units than for area control there's some points for area control you get benefit from from having a sprawl but really you get the most points by going somewhere say say there was somewhere that had a castle and a town and a bunch of units and just going in there and destroying it all is worth points yeah and the warlord can't actually build fortresses they can take over fortresses if they don't want to destroy it but they can't construct them so that's the warlord um the caliph and the warlord are both sort of fighting and they have their own units but they have different objectives out of that the sultan who is the green character the sultan is all about building the sultan um being the ruler of the land has the
ability to to build towns and cities all over the map and to a lot of money to convert them into cities and to tax them as well so every town and city on the board if you have military control of a town you'll get some taxes out of that but the sultan always get tax gets taxes as well and if the sultan controls a town then we'll get double money so the sultan has twice as much money as anyone else in the game makes it easier to buy cards easier to build more buildings and if you let the sultan get too many buildings on the map without destroying it all then the sultan's going to get a lot of points including this one this is the sultan's market a different way of gaining the cards this is actually they can get it for free but they can sell it through other sections for whatever price they set negotiation yes so normally normally there are cards out here and you'd have to pay the co either the cost shown to the player whose card color it is because these cards even though they're in a joint market they're owned by the the player that is that color essentially the sultan owns no cards but sets the price and takes the money for the sultan's market yeah so yeah if the sultan builds lots of buildings it can be good to you know you get money if you control one of these towns cities but the sultan keeps generating and so that's that you've got to balance that out the nomads are an interesting breed they're the yellow ones they can they sort of pop up in the desert they control the market on mercenaries that's
their major part of the game so the sultan has no units of his own the merchant has no units of his own they have to buy mercenaries if they wish to have units to do military stuff and the other two can as well they've got easier ways of getting it so the nomads set the price for mercenaries and they gain their money that way through a negotiation and you know once someone has become a mercenary um they the nomads can also make them dessert as well so it's this careful negotiation where the nomads can give you mercenaries and then take them back at an opportune moment but if the nomad is doing that then no one's going to come and shop with them anymore yeah so it's got to they've got to carefully balance when they do that for the greater overall good and ultimately gaining money and doing all this negotiation stuff is how the the nomad gets the points then the last one is the merchant and the merchant is uh much more into influence and gets points through influence and can swing a lot of battles so if there were a battle on a space containing or adjacent to merchant influence then the merchant gets to play cards uh in favor of one of the two sides the merchant's always negotiating with the other players to say all right uh if
you the merchant trades in victory points so it can be like if you give me a couple of victory points i'll play the cards that will help you tick over to victory in this battle and the merchant can lie and cheat as well and backstab but the merchant only gets the victory points out of it if the player was that they sided with wins the battle and the merchant in particular doesn't have the base victory point gaining tends to be more slow so as long as the merchant's influencing nobody to have a runaway victory then they're still in the running essentially you kind of like want to normalize everything make sure there's no as you say yeah runaway winner yeah and they have a lot more cards in the deck as well so they tend to get their money through these cards because they've got so many they've got so many more of them in the deck they tend to earn more through that and so that's that's really how it works you can see the negotiation element is huge because you're constantly negotiating with the merchant to influence battles you're negotiating with them yep you're negotiating with the nomads for mercenaries when you need them there's a bit with the sultan here as well and then you're just generally talking to other players to try to stop runaway victories and for the four player game it is the merchants that actually got dropped off the nomads sorry the nomad noise yeah there's no nomads with the four player game and you just buy your mercenaries
from the market from the uh from the common supply all right many more different things and and other players have specific actions and sultan can build more times than other players on a turn and the warlord can move more times and there's there's all sorts of different things that uh that come into play but it is critically a negotiation game because some of these roles they require negotiation they thrive on it and you're going to have a bad time if players aren't doing that so yeah that's uh that's the nature of the game and usually this is what from the designer because we play uh we do a playthrough video and i don't think it will be released by the time this video release will be the other way on the dice tower it's a it's a four-player play through with the designer steve matthes and our friend henry and we play you know i play the warlords and steve's played assault and it was a it's very fun
it's one of gameplay games that you need to negotiate and you can backstab and no hard feelings after that um so what do you think yeah i enjoy it it's not um it's not instinctively the sort of game i'll generally try to play but it's got um because it's really tight and it's short on actions and you can sort of um you know the way you can influence things in a way you can try to uh everyone's stop runaway leaders it has some really interesting elements to it um so yeah i do and i do very much enjoy it in that way yeah um yeah so one game came to mind when i know about this it's rude i think it's a it might be a natural question root or always might be more rude certainly i mean certainly the the highly asymmetric tight semi-euro e war style obviously brute was very successful on that um a couple of years ago and it had negotiation and there were i remember playing the beavers in a game where nobody negotiated negotiates um what are they called the water no i played there was a game where i played the beavers okay um who are the the ones that run up and down the river and their game is completely based on negotiation and nobody everyone was novices and nobody felt like negotiating with me
for me this one you've forced a lot more to negotiate i feel it's more natural here than it is in route where you've got some of that in those negotiation things yes i play anything guess what the vagabond yeah it's not like quite the vanguard boys but the second one so always have that song in my i mean come on i'm sure some some people that have played rooted play flingerborn fingerboard we've gone like we've gone off but it's a little bit like that and it is five player well this is five player xmas it is also a symmetric game where you need to focus like each winning condition is different and you need to watch out other people if they are going to win otherwise you can't really sort of like strategize try to block them but you need to know how they win to block them i think yes for sure i think if you're comparing degree of asymmetry um because root i think is probably about 60 40 um maybe 70 30 somewhere between that in terms of 30 to 40 the same actions and then the rest is asymmetrical uh this one is probably closer to um 60 40 the other way i think so i think it's 60 percent 50 to 60 symmetrical because everyone's got the same sorts of actions mostly some have slightly different flavors or different costs and then each player has a handful of actions and
effects that are completely asymmetrical so i think that makes it a slightly easier entry point than root as well and i think some of the the mechanics and things about where where you could i was found with the route it was difficult understanding which uh areas you could move from and where you ruled and where you didn't know i think some of that's a little bit more intuitive this is a bit easier here yeah that you were playing the merchant which is the bags they have no negotiated the backstabber that like to influence boys yeah yeah i enjoyed playing the mission in that last stop i want to play them that anyway that last play through yeah i didn't go hard i was a very bad nurse and i think everything i tried to influence i just wasted my own cards and failed on i didn't go hard enough you got baited by henry the caliph got baited a couple of times yeah um so but it yeah it was um i enjoyed uh just playing that i played i play the warlords it's i think probably the most straightforward faction where you just basically just build your army and then attack um it might be other people might say oh my god there's a lot of a lot of armies is gonna not necessarily going to win as i found it especially if i have the card that sacrificed my own armies but um yeah we should probably play a little bit more cooperatively at least at the start and natural natural ally and the kali venus sultan apparently is also natural this is tips from the designer steve himself i enjoy it i
enjoy the um i do enjoy being the warlords just being just like oh just like attack and then trying to get frequent points that was pretty straightforward as i say um probably probably the easiest one um but i do want to try to play your role made the merchant it's just quite fun trying to get people to oh yeah just just buy me that and give me some points how about you you you get how much how much support how many picture points you can't give money but you can kind of like offer victory points and you get figure points if that person that offer future points win and at some point you backstab somebody so that was fun yep the card play is a huge part of the game as well um it'll look overwhelming at first but there's not that many different cards yeah um and they all do sorts of things like add extra influence to a combat some of them are single-use some of them are multiple use some of them have to be activated with units so that you can't like march one unit in and then win a whole battle on cards alone um and yeah so there's a nice nice sort of range there there's ships i think i saw that gives you a surprise attack over the river um i messed up on that i should have got that one so i have you all and um helpful books of course um you need for anything asymmetrical like this is uh booklets for everyone yeah pretty straightforward it's not that hard to all we have steve as well so it helps as well yeah i quite enjoyed this one this
little game of you know there's a lot to probably learn a little bit at the start but it's just fun when you negotiate and it's true it probably does make a the fact that we've been taught by the designer every time we played does mean that we've got an inside line into the sort of gameplay and the sorts of yeah so he kind of you know learning learning from steve meant we could shop the first two learning games off the front where no one has any idea what's going on which is pretty helpful yeah he's really fun so hopefully this review and the way i just described the uh the characters there will help you to uh to learn to get past the first uh learning game as well and um and just what does what sort of game it actually is like what like is that like it's not the like totally serious i mean we the way we play we didn't really play seriously obviously we think of the strategy seriously but how how do you say i think it's a lot of talk and interaction between players yeah i think because you have to rely on other players to do things and sometimes if someone's getting a runaway leader a runaway lead you need someone to help and maybe that doesn't give them any points maybe you've got to work together to say all right now should you go and destroy his influence there and then i'll go and destroy his castle there because that's what points to me and that's worth points to you um
it means it means the conversation can go in a lot of directions and it means that you can throw the victory points around a little bit liberally and kind of see where it pans out um which is good i even like at one stage i'm pretty sure i've threatened you to you can sleep on the sofa you don't help me here yeah there's no no out of game deals oh well yeah that's absolutely fair that's true that's true um so yes um overall it's enjoyable it's a bit of a learning curve enjoyable experience playing chris and crescent moon um good to see that we've you know we've seen it developed from many years ago from the first time we played with steve um it was pretty close to its finish um yeah this was a few years ago but it was it was pretty close to this at that point it's been tweaks of um of balance thereafter i'm glad that osprey games picked up this game now i'm telling that steve is in our game group we try to be as non-biased as possible yeah thank you yeah yeah we've been playing the game there we we do enjoy it we have had fun with it but we do we do know the designers if you want to take that with the pinch of salt that's uh that's fine by us as well yes um so have you played root have you do you enjoy games like root i think although you explain how similar or how
different from brewed is it might actually be attract um the attractive game for people who like games like that i think it's certainly i mean there's definitely a lot of there's a lot of overlap in them in the mechanisms and the style of games so uh if you like one you should like the other note out and i think um root was actually published that's before steve has the game so the game is already out there and it's got the idea already before root came out halfway during the development of this yeah yeah so it's not like you know oh they're like root notes it's like it's different completely already existed before anything else aaron um no i think that um yeah that covers it all for me as well i got these nice little i think i showed these before the little crescent moon points yeah you can just hide scoring things like your victory points yeah semi-hidden because you always announce them but then uh oh yeah then hide them towards the end um yeah and get a little business as well yeah some nice little pieces i forgot to bring a city out let me grab a city yeah in the meantime while you bring a city out i love this box like i do love the artwork and stick was impressed about the artwork as well yeah it's a really nice uh really nice really nice image here really nice image with you know this bit of a girl like gloss well it's um uv not even uv yeah i'm in boss yeah well done osprey games and steve so this one is the advanced copy that we
have here um and um yeah let us know what do you think of it have you heard of it you might have already played tested crescent moon as well let us know what you think if you've been around the melbourne play testing circuit i'm sure you've uh played a game once yeah it was like in pax australia as well at some point and that's interesting i guess yeah um just you know a lot of way to to play a lot of replayabilities here because each player will bring different value different cards different faction that you can play different maps in particular as well because i mean each faction is instinctively going to play a similar way which is the other thing about this sort of game i guess if if you didn't negotiate if there were no negotiation and no map variability you would do the same thing every time okay so the fact that you've always got the same flavor of what you're going to do but you can respond to a new map and what other players are doing that's that's what gives it the replayability there you go he said it uh and thank you so much everybody for joining us and watching this review hopefully you enjoy that and if you do or if you want to help us it'll be really grateful if you can how do you know that you just read the script there's no script hit that like button for us and subscribe if you haven't already done so i'm also on instagram uh so find me there we do a lot of fun videos as well like life play through on
the weekends play through how to play in middle university and the daiso and hopefully we will see you again next time as usual if any comments right below and i'm happy to reply back to you that's it see you next time bye everyone