Skip to main content
Loading video...

The making of Posthuman Saga, Episode 2

Transcript 16:02

yeah the next thing was the board how did you feel this is the first time we was in the world who have 20 spaces Beijing we need completed exactly we need 10 to 11 of 13 backgrounds and from the best groups on average so like base way that's enough the constraint of the because okay you have 20 boxes but you may not be able to but I'd like the fact that everything is identified here I think that gives the game more presence in something I mentioned yes I'd like to actually using the board yeah I like boards I think that both engines are posting aware but it was almost like yeah everything you have I think you want direct people to the central bit yeah how to organize your stuff just over there so you want to have the board I thought that was constrained I don't wanna bump into since these are this is abstract space and it's not really topographic let's face then I don't think that bugs me I think that would be just me I don't used to the different thing I'm worried that you know if I go do one two three if I start my mind mission go one two three start to you don't don't take my objective and go one two three and here it's like oh I

hit right at the perimeter right where I started when when I put the tile as the fortress oh it was the issue yeah but it's different when it's somebody's face versus here we are at eyes next to a fortress problem is that it's next to the fortress not yeah

if this wasn't but I feel you think that's going to give away from me that's fine there's a this is like this

so I have come to understand that game design is really not as easy as as we think what is for you the hardest part of game design yeah you're right the game design can be quite challenging or at least as challenging as it is rewarding and that really depends on the kind of game that you're making or your approach your process to making games from my part my passion is to create experiences or explore stories worlds or situations or themes of particular emotions and and translate those into root systems the idea is that you create those root systems that that create emotions and images in the players mind that is beautiful when it comes together was just very hard to get there especially to do so without having too many rules they trap when creating a story or experience is to simulate is to have lots of little rules that try to create that little part of the experience that you want so the hardest part for me is creating a streamlined system a good set of mechanics that without too much blood it creates that experience in the players Minds ideally without too many rules and I'm still thinking about it comes through to that process and my games I'm trying to make them like more

and more streamlined as as I go along but I think definitely that's one of the hardest parts and the second part is related to it is to have rules and story rules and experience fit as tightly as they can so that every rule has a story explanation or every story or experiential bit has got a rule to support it and that can be also quite tricky to do and finally I mean I think the hardest thing with designing for board games even more than for video games which I've done quite a bit of both is that you don't quite know how players will understand the system that you don't quite know how the experience will actually come about you can encourage a certain form of gameplay you can encourage a certain form of experience but ultimately you're giving this object the set of props and these and this rule set and then players will do very different things with them and it also depends on the specific group and the society and culture and that's super fascinating it's really interesting to see what players do with it but it's also really scary because you never quite know what's what's going to come up of course we test a lot and that's why we do testing and do testing in different countries but still that's a very small subset of people compared to the you know whatever tens of thousands that actually play the game

eventually what are your design goals for posthuman saga the main design goal for posthuman saga is to create a adventure game with strong emergent story and scripted narrative that has you know good writing in it that's backed by a solid streamlined set of mechanics you could call them a sort of Euro style mechanics I guess and and I want those two to be integrated at every level so as much as possible every rule leads to an interesting decision leads to an opportunity cost and also has a story reason for it or a story hooked on to it so I think that would be the main goal of the there's also an element of wanting to evolve previous design where posthuman was the gold there was hold the emergent story and site switching this experimenting with a side switching mechanic that comes in randomly in the game and it's kind of sandbox world that has a lot of simulation of the potential emergence in it and I wanted to narrow that and into a more streamlined experience with its pluses and minuses as I understand and I wanted to experiment with having that kind of experience more than emotion in my

passion when do you say okay now what I made is good and you stop either anything when do I say well I made us good I I don't think I'd ever say I never say that and when would I want to stop by to rating when I'm forced to I guess I would keep going at it probably I don't I can't think of I mean I can't think of a game which I felt was you know perfectly ready but that's I think a process of learning as well to to understand that you can always keep fixing and fixing does not always move a game forward because you might fix one element and that addresses you know two or three issues and then that might have a domino effect that creates a problem somewhere else and that's you know that's at one of the challenging parts really challenging parts of game design which I should have included in my previous answer I guess so I think realistically when I think that it's done is when I'm when I'm watching play tests and when I'm playing the game myself and the notes that I keep for every test end up being really trivial or just more considerations of balance or something like that that's when I know it's done when I'm not thinking of

making any changes to either the content or the system and that are necessary but that could be maybe slight tweaks or improvements so what metric do you use to decide whether your game is good or not oh okay that's something that I might have to wrestle with on a daily basis I guess I started off writing publishing fiction short story poetry first and short stories then making video games and now board games and board games are probably the most mass marketing thing I've done so I'm still adjusting to the fact that there's thousands and thousands of people experiencing the things I do and I'm still wrestling with how to validate my own work and it's and it's really tough now there's you know a lot of there's a scoring BoardGameGeek which none of my poetry or short stories ever had a score for anyway and and of course I I want to see you know a good or a decent rating on board game VI I want to see good reviews especially from reviewers and critics whose work I respect and whose analysis I I learn from but I I keep

wrestling between or juggling between meeting my design goals and developing myself as a designer and doing what I intended to the game with having you know popular and mass appeal and I'd like to think that those two are easily balanced but they're not I mean that they you know there are great designers that manage those two but so far a lot of my games have had a very you know very specific goals which I am happy to have met they do what I wanted them to do but then once you start seeing all the you know reading negative comments or when the scores aren't as much as you want them to be then obviously start getting upset about it and then start really undermining your own sense of your design work or maybe even self-worth but I'm keep trying to tell myself to stay on track and and you know have a set of good goals and meet those goals and use that as my metric essentially and because I still feel like I'm in development essentially I'm still feel like I am my main goal is to to improve myself essentially I guess if I had to give a short answer which that one wasn't it would be that the game I make meet my design goals that I enjoy playing it and I enjoy playing it after I release it and it doesn't mean there

won't be things I won't be you know I'll just like after bother generally I enjoy playing the game and that people I care about and whose opinions I care about like the game I don't need necessarily for you know tens of thousands of people to think that that's the best game ever made there they're meant to deliver particular sort of experiences and as long as they do those and do those well for at least the majority of people that play them I think that that makes it a a good game

Progress saved