Skip to main content
Loading video...

Five words I hate hearing when I play D&D

Transcript 9:31

Hey everyone, me, Undead Viking. I got a quick little video for you today. Well, I think it will be quick cuz I think I got my point that I want to make and I want to make it succinctly. I want to tell you why what the five words I absolutely hate to hear at my role-playing game table. And I don't care if I'm the player or the Dungeon Master or the referee or whatever you want to call it. I hate to hear these words spoken. And I myself used to say these things say this thing cuz this isn't this is a phrase that you will hear this or you you will hear an iteration of this time and time again. And quite simply, it comes down to a situation where uh player decides they're going to do this. And I and I just experienced this actually.

Something kind of off-the-wall or sort of like um not what's expected, right? Like maybe it is a sub-optimal decision. Recently I I was I was hosting a Call of Cthulhu game. You you have most Call of Cthulhu scenarios have the uh moment of like normalcy before the the bad stuff starts to happen. And you it was like a dinner scene type of situation and somebody handed me a note. And I I absolutely hate notes. I I despise it. Um, I mean and that's like one of those things I I I feel like they're childish. And I And I know that's probably too harsh.

Uh uh we used to pass notes around all the time to the DM to like say, "Oh, I want to do something that's that's like X, Y, and Z." Um because we want to keep a secret or whatever. Uh I I I grew out of them uh basically because the people I played with were able to more readily uh divide what their character knows as to what their player knows type of thing. But anyway, uh somebody handed me a note and I was like, "Well, okay, you know, whatever." And I open it up and it was one of those things where they they wanted to play a prank on somebody because there was like a dinner scene where everybody was at the dinner and they wanted to play a prank that would try and make somebody else at the table look silly or look foolish.

And and it was like totally off the wall. Now, that by itself is not a bad thing. It's It's It's like, "Okay, you know, like we we have a fairly serious situation. Uh let's let's go ahead and like, you know, just pull pull a pull fast one." And it was like, "Hey, I'm going to unscrew the guy's salt." And then so when he put salt in his thing, pours out. Ha ha ha ha ha. But, you know, which leads me to believe, why are you sending me a note for that? Why wouldn't you just say that aloud so everybody can just kind of laugh about it? But, regardless, and when somebody said, "Well, why are you doing that?" Um that person inevitably said, "Well, my character would do this." Or my character is like that. Or my character uh backstory says this. But it's it it it's all like kind of a um it's it's it's it's a trend on the phrase of my character Well, my character would do that.

And the reason I have a problem with it are twofold. Um the first one is that it is that's a defense, right? That that's a situation where the player knows they're doing something that isn't going to be well well received. And they haven't earned it. And they want to take their bad behavior at the table and make it well, it's not my fault. It's it's my character. They they're lawful evil or whatever, you know, whatever we don't play with alignments anymore, but you know, you could like that a variation of that theme is well, my character is chaotic neutral. That's why they act like that. My character is lawful evil. That's why they would do that. It removes the ownership of the actual decision-making, the actual action that the player is doing.

And it it it makes it so like well, I I've got this straightjacket that I have to put on. And and old old old readers of Dragon Magazine will remember Gary Gygax once famously said your your alignment is not a straightjacket. It it doesn't it doesn't like make you act in certain ways. The point is is that they'll use that as the reason. And in more evolved areas, it'll be like well, my character's backstory would says that, you know, he just doesn't trust you know, elves. So, that's why he hacked that elf waiter to death with his axe, right? You know, it's one of those things where it's like this is the reason why. And it's so garbage. It is so unearned. And by when When say unearned, that's the second time I said that.

Um, your character's actions should be a understandable situation of of consecutive events where you have laid the groundwork in for your character and how they would act and why they would have acted in a certain way. Uh, even if it is like a one-shot Call of Cthulhu thing, you have a backstory where you like will earn something like that by describing your character, by trying to inhabit that character. I would much rather somebody do something totally off the wall and try and and and mess with the situation, um, whether it's, you know, like hacking that that elf waiter to death for no better reason other than they just want to stir up trouble or you know, pickpocketing another player uh, of their hard-earned gold or treasure uh, from the uh, from a from like the last adventure that you went on. I would I would much rather they just do it and then just be an agent of chaos than also then try to like, you know, have their cake and cake and eat it, too, where um, their their backstory does that or or their alignment makes it okay or this is what my character does. My character's just a dick, you know, and which is the like and I have played that character uh, in my younger days. I absolutely have played like I I I had an entire campaign where myself

and a friend of mine, we concocted this whole plan of the fact that we were both going to be thieves and we were going to rob the rest of the party blind the uh, the entire time. That was going to be our entire goal, which was a lot of fun for us because we drove everybody crazy, but that I was much younger and I realized that my my was at a uh, was was actually like causing everybody else not to have fun. And it was a very poor decision that I that I made at that time. So, it's it's one of those things where if I'm playing the game or if I'm running the game and I have somebody just fall back on that like very very boring dull excuse of well, that's what my character would do.

Um, if you have to say those words, you haven't put your time in as a role player, as a person that you know, creates a foundation for your character to exist in, for your character to react to certain situations the way that they do in order to actually reap those rewards of being able to do that fun thing uh that that you want to pull off. So, so there you go. Uh a relatively quick thing. Uh what do you think? I mean, do you care about that? Does that matter to you? Um, maybe I'm the only one that has that set them off. Um, anyway, this was something actually that uh somebody asked me. Not not in a message or an email or anything like that, but we were talking about uh role-playing games and they said, "Well, what's like the most annoying thing that can happen in a role-playing game?" And then we talked about a lot of things, but this one just sprang to mind as like words that I just ooh, I when I hear them, I just cringe. Uh so, so there you go. Um, thanks for watching this. Uh if I get another wild hair up my butt, I'll make another video. And make sure you watch uh the All Boom Wednesday nights 9:00 p.m. Uh the longest running live uh video cast or whatever on YouTube. So, uh I think so. Anyway, it's like 10 plus years. Anyway, um take care. Talk to you soon.

Progress saved