Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 136: Rodney Smith on Wargaming

Transcript 1:01:22

it's ad break time I'm pleased to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast remains proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations this week I have a very special announcement which is that I will once again be teaching a class for their certificate in applied game design come take using games to teach what you can convey through play with yours truly the class runs from January 22nd to February 29th and I would love to see you there a link to the registration page is in the show notes cgs's latest game 500-year-old vampire just finished a very successful campaign but if you forgot to back it you can now pre-order through backer kit the link is also in the show notes I also want to plug my own patreon your support means a lot to me both emotionally and finan financially patreon money is what makes it possible to keep improving my channel by upgrading the equipment and I'm also hoping to increase the amount of videos I can publish over the course of the next year if you want to help out head over to patreon.com beond soliter for now though let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from beond solitier and this week on the Pod I have a special guest this is Rody Smith a man who needs no introduction but if you didn't know who he was he's from watch it played how you doing Rony hey I'm doing good Liz I feel we've already been chatting so much before we started looks like we're right in the middle we're we're bringing everyone in in the middle yes the chat it's appropriate for a classical Epic no start in the middle um but uh first off um thank you so much for coming on the show I know you're a busy man I'm very appreciative uh oh I'm so glad you invited me Liz I as I was saying to you earlier I've been I've been enjoying your work from afar and it's kind of a

neat privilege to be able to like join you and get to know you a little better here and also spend some time with your audience in chat and and dive into some hopefully interesting topics for everybody yes so I invited you on the podcast because I have a feeling that you have a continually growing war game habit and I think talk about it has it been showing has it been noticeable yeah you're right just a little bit a little bit um so tell us about that like if I recall correctly you did war game when you were younger that's it's something that's kind of come back into your life and so how has that I guess rekindling of an old Romance gone oh it's been going great uh but yeah you're right when I was when I was young my first sort of uh game outside of the traditional Mass Market games was Empires and arms you familiar with that older title okay um I just I had an Avalon Hill catalog and it was listing all these games I I picked it up at like uh I remember the the shop sold pool tables I don't think it was a game store but it had this Avalon Hill catalog and I was fascinated because the description for this Empires and arms game was that it had an 80-page rule book and took 12,000 hours to play up to 12,000 hours you know and it just sort of no 12,000 minutes well it doesn't matter a long time it just sort of like blew the top off my brain as a young person I was like what could this possibly be like how what would require 80 pages of rules what is this simulating and I suppose it's maybe

telling that my reaction to that wasn't to run screaming in the other direction but to beg my parents help me pay for this I'll pay you back type of thing right um it was Destiny it was Destiny kind of but but the thing is it was like you know a really really complicated game that shines with seven players and I wasn't going to be able to find one other person who was going to play that game with me I I then later found Ambush which was a solo uh war game from back then and that was really like an incredible kind of magical thing for young Rodney but then um I I don't think I really pursued much in the way of wargaming after that and I stayed with gaming you know I I play mag gathering in a variety of other games um but it was yeah in the last well I don't know when I don't know when I circled back around to Koopa Libra but that was really where the love happened but it started kind of with Andy and Abyss because uh my buddy Joel Edie from drive-through games had reviewed Andy and Abyss back when it came out and I thought it sounded fascinating then and I bought a copy of the game and I unpacked it it was kind of like Empires and arms all over again where I'm like oh I'm never going to find anyone who's going to play this with me and I hadn't sort of figured out how to play it but I was like if I'm struggling who am I going to even if I figure this out who's going to play with me and so I packed it away and I sold it but it just noded at the back of my brain about what was in that box and what could that experience be so long story longer uh I did do a couple of video projects with

GMT and they had sent me kubba Libra I think they were interested in me maybe doing something with it but we hadn't formally discussed anything so it's sat on my shelf there just taunting me and Matthew Jude who's also on the watch of play team had a copy and we just sort of like should we just try to learn this together can we just do that maybe because maybe with somebody else you know to kind of like help you to sort of soften the fall of like I don't know what's going on here and you can just sort of commiserate with somebody else maybe it just was sort of like the uh a bit of encouragement I needed and we live streamed reading the rules out loud to each other it was a six-hour art performance piece like survival mode can we get through this um and we did and that gave a pretty good Baseline of like what the game was it started to come together and then I sat down one day I just had kind of like an open free day and I said I'm going to sit with this game I'm going to play every faction myself and I'm going to figure this out and Liz it was love at 12th site or whatever we' call it at that point cuz like you know I've been circling these games for a while but that experience was I mean I was just floored as I took turns I was like oh my goodness and now this faction is going to do this which is going to pull this lever and cause this effect and then this faction what are they going to do they're jammed in the corner oh they can do this unique thing because all the factions are unique and so it really um yeah it was uh it was like oh this is what war games are doing nowadays interesting and it made want to know more I do feel like we have to hit on something important before we get back

to the actual serious things which is it sounds to me like you need to unpack some solo gaming related trauma Rodney look at think about all the people you've left to discover that for themselves wait you cut you cut your teeth on ambush you chickened out a k solo the first time and you helped no one and you need you're not you play all the factions by yourself it's if anyone's not familiar yeah when I do tutorial videos on my channel if there's solo rules I will often leave those for the viewer to discover on their own own and uh yet I have certainly found lots of enjoyment in Solo play all the more so since really kind of diving into the war game World a little bit you know and it was from like learning the mechanisms of the game that got me intrigued about the historical backdrop of kubal Libra and that led me down a few Rabbid Trails of documentaries and books and and then that sort of made me realize the richness that comes from pairing the historical real you there's a historical reality that's not going to be able to be reflected in cardboard and plastic and whatever like not not truly but it it gives you a perspective that I don't think I I would not have otherwise had if I hadn't had the experience with the game and I don't think I would have independently pursued the historical knowledge with the game frankly so they were kind of like a married thing in a way yeah I actually

have that same experience of my games and my historical interest reinforcing each other um I think that did you start though Liv with a historical interest did you have that before you found games so it's kind of a mixed bag um if you look all the way back you know my family is always like games you know playing card games and stuff like that but right my first interest in games that was like wow this is something really special um was actually in a high school history class I actually interviewed my former teacher Kirby Whitehead on this podcast because he had access and allies and I learned he has some GMT games in his room and he's become much more advanced like he's actually got his modelu wi kids using things like kubba Libra as like part of a modelu tournament where like some of the things in the game come out into the world of modelu like into their role playing aspect right um and you know he's he teaches here I stand to European history Gams yeah so it's pretty intense yeah I didn't get that but I wonder if a seed was planted right because I always thought of myself as kind of a video game person mostly right until I got to graduate school and it was my way of blowing off steam with my friends so I had a historical interest because I was pursuing a degree in ancient Christianity but you have to do something else and so you know I was playing Magic the Gathering and then you know I needed to do something cheaper so of course I got Lord of the Rings living card game which wasn't really cheaper because now I'm this um yeah yeah but actually when I quit when I when I quit my uh academic path like I finished my PhD I became a high school teacher um leaving Academia is like a traumatic

experience it's like getting a divorce um you know quit the academic path now I'm sorry some of your viewers may already be familiar with this but what what do you mean by that so basically when you go to graduate school and you get a PhD the expectation is that you want to be a professor and that's really what I thought it was going to be and you know it's more and more common to leave Academia in that pathway now because the job market is so terrible okay but back then but back then I had to make it was not it was not cool to do it at the time but I made a decision to not put myself through that and to instead have more control over where I lived and you know be a high school teacher um and so I was you know it makes you question who you are like so much of your identity gets wrapped up in in Academia and so I kind of saw gaming as separate for a long time right but it turns out that you can't take the Ivory Tower out of a person because um I started developing interest in historical games later and then I saw somebody at like a Latin convention with the kids that I took my students to who talked about um ancient games they brought him like he was like a local person who gave a lecture and it was uh the first episode of my podcast I kept this guy in my back pocket for like a couple years and i' asked somebody else if hey let's interview him on this podcast like let's just have him on as a guest no no no and I was like you know what GNA start my own podcast and once I started podcasting it just blew everything up so what what compelled you to sorry I'm making this about you now um what what compelled you to say I'm going to

podcast about this I think that it kind of ties back to what interests you about war games right it's like oh a game can be something more than just a game this can be an entire experience and I can share that experience with other people solo gamers are probably the chattiest gamers too like you wouldn't think so because we play by ourselves but then we go online we talk about it and so well there's also like let's not forget when you're playing solo there's still very much of dialogue happening oh yeah even when you're alone at that table like I'm having a lot of conversations with myself solo and with a designer in really abstract way um but this actually leads to you know it sounds like I sort of made my internal life into my content I I hate the word my media let's go with that but you on the other hand I sort of feel like there's the Rodney who makes these like really nice slick videos that you know maybe I don't know how much control you actually have over like what your schedule looks like I actually would be really curious to know like I'd be happy to tell you the orders that come in right versus what you seem to be playing when you have your own time right okay well and so yeah yeah um in terms of like my schedule for watch it played um so I do it mostly now almost exclusively tutorials when when the Channel first started it was just me I did tutorials and game plays and and it was never just me I did with with the kids or I had other other people but I I did a variety of things I also did a series called table talk that was very conversation with different different

topics of discussion in the hobby but the reality is really have a strong passion for T making tutorials for board games I just love doing it and um that's where I threw myself fully in so I am I set a goal the very beginning of the channel 12 years ago that I will never cover a game I don't want to cover um tutorial videos are just a very um it's a very involved process and then I also make a commitment to answer every comment on every video that I've ever done so if I was doing that for games you know if I was doing that for games I did not like on some level I would have I don't think I'd be here talking to you right now I would have like thrown myself out a window a while ago uh it's so I don't have to love every game I feature but I have to like something about it you know um yeah now when it comes to uh what I've been playing off off the channel um yeah it's been a lot of War games of late but it's not exclusively war games I think it's discovering for myself I shouldn't it's not like I discovered kubal bre lots of people were enjoying this before but discovering it for myself and falling down that rabbit hole I've been excited to talk about it more publicly and share that because I feel like there's a lot of people who maybe see wargaming as something that's maybe not for them or it's an audit or there's too high of a barrier to entry which I think sometimes there is more so than there needs to be that's maybe a separate thing to talk about but and so I is maybe somebody

that people might think well I've seen Rodney play just one and any other number of games if he's into war games maybe I can too kind of like that's maybe my hope a little bit I don't really need anyone playing a game they don't want to be playing but if I might Inspire some curiosity in someone who could enjoy war games um I'm kind of excited to be able to do it because I've gotten so much enjoyment and so much fulfillment out of it I've always enjoyed the hobby I've never in the course of doing this burnt out on games I love that's what I want to do when I'm not working I think hm I wonder what game I can pull off the shelf uh but discovering war games has been like discovering this whole new thing and that's been really exciting and fun so I don't know if I answered the question uh I'm playing a lot of War games but I'm also playing a lot of not war games still too but yeah I me I also have a mixed diet so yeah yeah like a lot of my gaming right now is remote and War games work really well for remote gaming by remote I should clarify I don't mean um through BGA or tabletop simulator those things which are also great but I set the game physically up in my basement and then I take turns using my phone and like recording what I'm doing sending that to a friend who also has their copy set up and then they update their board then they send me a turn back and War Games just work quite nicely for that because especially with like Koopa Libra and that it's a shared deck there's no hidden information so it it just works really cleanly and these are games that you could spend a little bit of time thinking about your turn well now you can spend as long as you want because no

one's sitting around waiting for you to take your turn your turn comes in when I get an update ping on my phone I come back to the table and I'll take my turn when I get a chance kind of thing right so it's been a really kind of relaxed cool way to experience those games that's so funny that's it's like an update on the traditional play by mail of like the very earliest Avalon Hill General like personal as no I really think it is it is just an evolution of that which kind of charms me a little bit because my brother used to play by male war games right so I'm doing my brother was 16 years older than I am but I'm now doing effectively an evolved version of that but the the kind of the nice thing is it's still very it allows for that kind of conversational at the table experience even though I'm not at the table with my uh with the other players we're talking they can see me we're having Expressions we're reacting to things you know and it still gives you that kind of at the table feel and I'm still interacting with the game which I love board games is for me such a tacticle experience that I like that I can still do that even in that format do you feel like you have a different relationship with the games that you I guess engage with for business versus the games that you play purely for pleasure no but that kind of maybe goes back a little bit to what I said earlier about how like I just don't do games I don't want to do so in that sense I'm not like oh I've got to do this game this this week I got to work on this game G you know I don't have to think that way because if I pick the game to feature it's because I want to do it I'm I'm in a fortunate position that way right because I've been I've been doing this for a long enough time that now

because it wasn't always this way obviously right but I've carved out enough of a little space for myself that I I have options like Publishers want games covered and what a thousand Games come out in a year now over a thousand I can cover if I go flat out 55 so I I'm able to be a little bit Choy in that in that way and I have broad tastes which is kind of nice too I think like I really like everything from your just one to your you know thinkest Euro or whatever yeah I guess I mean I just this is a personal thing for me probably then I am crank where if I have to do something I immediately don't want to do it as much okay yeah I don't when I want to do it yeah I understand that you're a little more of a is that I don't know what I would call that is that being a contrarian a little bit like oh you want me to do that now I don't want to do it anymore oh it's on a deadline I have to play it now oh no and like that doesn't actually change whether I really love a game like for example um you know I did all those gearlock guides for chip Theory this past year I loved it as a process I actually still really love to bones which I think is saying something after all the time I Spit with that game that does yeah um but also there were times when I was like but it's it's purely just like a contrarian thing like it'd be like but look at this thing that I don't I'm not getting I'm I'm not I'm not under contract to do it but right it's over there well listen I definitely I can certainly share that feeling of the work obligation is keeping me from something I'd like to be doing for sure because the work obligation has to

take priority so I definitely encounter that like I've had sitting over in the other room where I have all my remote games I've had um the British way set up for four months now and I'm three pages into the rules uh and that's where I stalled out just because the video production schedule has just gotten a little too busy for me to be like partitioning out time to do that so yeah I mean I want to be playing that but the thing is again I I I guess I really feel fortunate I love what I do so it helps in that regard doesn't mean it's not work though like um when I'm staring down the barrel of you know 13 hours of shooting a video I'm not like Yay but I certainly at the end of it you know I I I feel a certain uh level of yeah fulfillment and satisfaction that I get out of that I'm sure you experience the same thing right it's like recording this podcast with me is complete sure but when you're done you'll feel fulfilled hope no actually um I really strictly the way I do my podcast specifically to keep myself happy so I limit myself to a 20 episode season and then I force a break even if I'm still feeling it um I make myself take a break it's actually how I made myself write my dissertation as well I wrote two pages a day flat no more than two pages I woke up in the morning the first thing it is write two pages and I stopped no matter how on fire I felt I would just stop and I would do some research and like outlining for the next day and I get up the next day and write two pages but I always had two pages in the chamber so I never went for a long time with without

having anything to say yeah yeah and so I felt like I I instead of just letting myself go where the spirit took me right it was like okay I'm gonna regiment this in a way that keeps me hungry that's interesting too because I would imagine Liz like if you let's say you finish your two pages and you're like I know I have more in me the upside of pausing is that when you sit down the next time you like you said you've got something to work with as opposed to well I went FL out did six pages and now I'm showing up the next day and I have no idea what to say next exactly like I've emptied the tank type of thing and that can be demoralizing and almost maybe make a bigger speed bump than if you had it like kind of pasted yourself that's interesting Liz that's H yeah and also I just I never want my podcast to be a chore for me ever right ever it's my favorite thing that I do um except for maybe game design which I've started to do which I really really enjoy right uh but I it's almost like I the other thing is I'm very picky congratulations about who gets to come on the podcast so I yes I I don't record episodes with people I don't want to talk to you for an hour sort of like you would never cover a game that you don't want to cover I'm not gonna have a conversation that I think is a drudge um because there's only 20 episodes per season that's like Precious right so you have you know what I mean it just kind of builds and I could see somebody I could see somebody listening to this and going oh how nice for you you only do what you want to do kind of thing right but it the reason for that and maybe this is similar for you is

if I can't do it the way I want to do it I'll just do something else like this this thing when I started was uh yes I had a real interest in seeing if I could do this full-time I knew that I felt making tutorial videos for board games was something that maybe I had an aptitude for and there was maybe a need for it yeah and so I decided if I'm going to do this I want to do this a way that I can do in the long run like that I'll be able to do it in a sustained way so if I make a bunch of compromises I won't you know I'll burn out I won't be able to keep doing this forever but if it doesn't work the way I want it to work then I tried let's fail fast and then go get a job where you know I have to do what the boss wants me to do or whatever right like it was you know it the only reason I'm able to sort of stick to that is because it worked if it hadn't worked I would have bailed and done something different you know yeah no I think that doing what works for you there there is something to that if you have to Be Your Own Boss in any regard if it's your project yeah so I want to go back to something you said earlier which is that first of all you admitted you oh rules Lord to being confused by could really WR no op but no actually I wanted to tie that back in so you mentioned that there's some accessibility concerns for war games and I guess I wanted to talk about that a bit because if who who would be better able to discuss that than like rules master so well yeah I mean listen I'll tell you something War Games sometimes make me wonder how much of a rules master I am because I look at the war game as side of the Hobby and I see a

lot of barriers in in the way the rule books are presented and yet I cannot deny there are lots of War Gamers so somehow you're all figuring this stuff out but I look at it sometimes and I think you're figuring out in spite of not because war game rule books are actually presented well now this is Broad strr for all of you major war game fans I apologize if you're sitting there going like I these war game role books are great for me wonderful I have found there to be some some distinct differences in the way war game rule books present themselves compared to other rule books that I've spent a lot of time you know reading and learning from and um this isn't always true but I find here's here's how I would summarize it I find that war game rule books often tell you the rules but they do not teach you the rules and I think there's a weird subtle difference there that's very difficult to Define but it's a lot of listing information as opposed to explaining that information that's being listed now it's technically maybe all there but the rule book is not doing a lot of the heavy lifting of the teaching part uh for you now I think war games have tried to complement this by having their rule book be very like a perfect rules reference and then they include some other book that's sort of like here's four people playing the game Let's watch over their shoulder as they play and then you'll sort of see it all in action I'm not convinced that's really like the best way to to learn rules per personally like for example when I'm teaching games I don't say hey sit down here watch me play the game I actually

teach the game I teach the rules and then say here you go off and play it type of thing right and I think there's a lot of examples of lots of rule books that teach you the rules as they're explaining the rules like explain the rules as they're teaching them to you right um it's I I it's a funny thing like I I've got Star Wars rebellion here uh off screen and this is like you know this is not an insignificant game I don't know War Gamers might say okay well okay there's a game that maybe is in the weight of some of the war games that are out there right and when I look at the rules here um what's a good example well here's here's something so here's here's here's a little paragraph if you'll indulge me uh assignment phase during this phase players assign their leaders to missions missions represent pivotal moments from the Star Wars saga such as stealing the Death Star plans each player has a hand of mission cards that represent the different missions his leader can attempt his of course his or her OB um so the the way I think a rule book would have written that whole paragraph would have been during this phase players assign their leaders to missions period moving on there wouldn't have been any kind of like missions come from cards that you're holding in your hand and you'll be playing these and they represent X you know what I mean like there's like the rule book is being a little this rule book is being a little more narrative it's giving you some context and giving you a sense of place as it's telling you about the rule if it had just said during this mission players assign their leaders to missions that would have been technically correct that is technically the rule that's what

happens you know but in war game rule books like solerno 43 which is just been I love you GMT but this is murdering me trying to learn this game um it is just one sentence after the other of contextless sentences one after the other after the other after the other now I am confident that if I could hold all of those context list ideas in my brain all at once this would be no problem and of course I know people are playing this game so obviously it can be done if if you allow me just one more thing I know I've been going I think another thing that maybe happens in war game rule books is there a is a presumption of knowledge so there are multiple games in this uh series I don't know what the rule book looks like for the very first one that was released but when I'm reading this I feel like there's a lot of presumption of knowledge here you've played five of these games already so we're just going to kind of you know uh bounce you through some of the differences and changes here you'll figure it out um that's a weird thing Liz if you got time for me to rant a little bit longer go for it one more thing one more thing solo 43 and I do I I am really curious about you I really want to play you someday I really want to understand you but like when you open up the rule book it gives you very nicely at the beginning very nicely a sequence of play out line just to let you know here's what round looks like okay and it tells you where to find all the rules related to these items so the very first thing is the role for weather this

is the very first thing you do now just so you understand this rule book is and I know you know this Liz but this rule book has all kinds of numbered sections that go from 1 to 25 okay 1 to 25 2.3 right exactly so 25 is at the back of the rule book one is at the beginning so the very first thing you do in the game the very first thing is roll for weather do you want to guess where that's explained in the rule book 20 20 22.1 so the very first thing you have to know how to do is actually rate the back of the rule book let's let's listen maybe there's something that's just a random thing let's go to the next thing ready air and Naval support markers 22 as well adjust Supply points 22.3 okay so maybe there's some weather phase stuff that's for later fine fine fine let's move on to the next thing the German player turn okay getting into player turns cool great use Supply points to flip Asus to the ready side 17.5 so I got to read all the way to 17.5 before I get to the first thing a player actually does in the game well second or third I find that a little peculiar interesting approach I am absolutely certain this is an amazing rules reference though like once you know how to play the game and you're like I need to know how weather works I'm going to be able to find that rule in a heartbeat it's going to be just nice and precise and it's going to be awesome but learning Liz it's killing me it's killing me so anyway so I think I think if if the average person was to pick up this small little boxed game and go oh look a NE intro level because it's also kind of like advertis as one of the easier ones to get into from the series I think it would be very much like oh

none of this is for me like no one's no one's trying to help me get into this system this is what is this I think that's the messaging I would feel and I do feel a yeah I think that's part of so I am a teacher by trade and I I also love to make tutorials um mine are much chattier because I spend a lot of time giving context for why things are happening because learn and so had more time to more of them I doing for war games but the act of learning a war game the first time is horrible unless there's someone else to teach you it has it's it's much easier when it's transmitted person to person yeah and I I think that's something else that maybe War Games rely on a lot of I mean I think that's a a lot of War Games rely on that generally speaking people like to be taught by somebody else that's actually part of the reason why I started watching played was back in the day before I started the channel and I knew I wanted to create some kind of media for board games I said this like I want to share my passion for it you know and there was a great thread on BGG where someone just said like how do you like to learn war games and I assumed because I was on BGG I knew what the answer was going to be we all love reading Rule books right no it turns out the majority of that thread was people saying I hate reading Rule books I want someone to teach me and that's when a little light bulb went on over my head like oh I love teaching board games so if that's what you is that what people are looking for I'll do that like that will be something I can be the person who you're looking for to maybe be the friend of the table who can help teach you know um yeah so so yeah like you I like to teach I like to help and I think sometimes maybe War Games kind of presume well someone's going to teach you or someone make a video or whatever

and I like making videos but I like to think that my vide is a compliment to the rule book you know um as well that you could get by just on the rule book alone I'm not there's not always going to be a video for a game nope especially not if you're a solo player like especially especially if one of the guys who makes I had to go find out on my own rodne sign up oh I'm sorry I'm sorry so the so this conversation is a delight for me in part because you went on a rant because I feel like you present a very smooth Persona on your channel very you're very polite you're very measured I don't know what you're like when you're angry or if you get angry I'm assuming you do but perhaps you just go I'm fine no I can I can get pretty work up that was a that was a sense of it but it's it's really nice actually to like get to talk to you about this and it it made me want to lead into another part of discussion I want to have which is that I I wanted to kind of know when you think it's important to editorialize versus not because I feel like that's something you steadfastly do not do about games like even um you know I had to probe you to get you to talk about feeling obligated to play game because you like all the games you would never play game you don't like um because partially I believe that's true partially I think that you don't want to say anything bad about anything but I just got you but you know that makes sense for you in a professional capacity at the same time um I on Twitter you're a different man Rodney but you know you occasionally did did you not know someone else manages

the Twitter account it's not me I saw this what they it's the AI videos of Rodney everyone giving opinions it's just the Rodney voice no uh but it's really interesting to see your Twitter Persona well I think it's it's still you it's just a different facet but um right you know um you do like to weigh in on certain issues that are like communal board game issues so what is it that makes you feel like it's time to speak up and how do you make those decisions as a professional and also a person in our hobby okay I'll answer the easier part first but don't let me get away with just answering the easy part uh the easy part is I don't do that edit editorializing in the tutorials because I feel this real strong desire to get you in and get you out as quickly as humanly possible my feeling is you don't really want to hang out with the Canadian guy you actually want to just go play this game so how quickly can I teach you this I want to give you enough context enough conversation so that it doesn't feel like it's just rapid fire but I'm trying to get you in a note and also I'm not interested in convincing you to like the game or not like the game so I don't offer my opinions on games I just feel this real I think it's very difficult to tell somebody else whether or not they'll have a good experience with the game no matter what my experience was cuz I just find games such personal experience just like mu music movies art we can both look at the same thing and have a wildly different experience of it so I'm very and anytime I say this I always feel self-conscious because there's lots of

people who offer their opinions on games and I'm so thankful that they do I'm so thankful that there's people who are confident in that space I've just never felt confident in that space doing that um so so that's why I don't editorialize as much for example in a tutorial video also I'm trying to keep it somewhat milk and toast in a way I want it to feel kind of relaxed learning getting hit with 20 pages of rules someone talking to you you know it's a lot of it's a big info dump right so I want it to be kind of just calming and relaxing and let's get through this together you know and go have your fun but uh so this that that's maybe the easy answer on that part um for a long time I don't think I really did editorialize too much on social media either or outside sometimes I would weigh on a gaming related topic even on my own channel in a separate video um whether that was like you know paid reviews or other things like that that struck me or maybe I felt like I had something to say about or or the effective hype and things like that but I don't know I don't know what I would credit I would probably have to credit gosh this is uh how do I talk about this I think there were times in the board game media space where where people were trying to talk about serious issues that were affecting them that honestly were not infecting not affecting me at all in the slightest and as a friend to some of these people I

didn't understand why they were frustrated or bothered by something in the in the board game Hobby and didn't weigh in didn't offer uh support didn't know how to uh and some of that comes from ignorance and I think thankfully through the patience of my friends and listening a little bit to some of the frustrations that have been expressed it penetrated kind of whatever shell I had to go oh right I'm not experiencing these things that the people are talking about but this is being experienced on mass I'm hearing it too many times this is not fluke this is a shared experience of whether it's women in the hobby or marginalized look we were just reading earlier out of the uh Star Wars rebellion learn to play rule book I read this rule book out loud as a joke uh on my channel cover to cover every second word in here is he and when I was reading it I had convert all those in my head to they and it was really simple I don't know why the rubble couldn't do that now people will say who cares pronouns whatever it I think that what health me start to just understand a little bit is when plat Hat games started putting she pronouns in their Rule books and when I was reading them I went oh I don't feel like I'm being talked to anymore and then a little light bulb went on over my head I was like oh this is what someone else could feel like when it's framing it all towards a pronoun that you don't relate to or you don't connect to and it was just that little chisel that went oh how effortless would it be to just make it much more inclusive in the language

right that's a small small little thing but but not a small thing to a lot of people right who have tried to talk about it and express that and here's the thing whether you care about these issues or not historically what I found was when someone did care and would talk about it in a calm and rational reasoned way they were often mocked derided told to be quiet it's just about the games what's your problem why you yelling at us there was a lot of like this very strong dismissive pushback and yeah at some point in time I couldn't I couldn't not see that anymore I guess and maybe that's part of the editorializing a bit maybe it's trying to make up a little bit for some lost time um and seeing some of my colleagues who dealt with some of that stuff um and realizing if some of us who could have had said some things earlier on maybe we'd be in a slightly different place now uh maybe I don't know I don't know I don't know the other thing too is like it's some of the editorializing you you put yourself in this position where people will you know uh then dismiss you as trying to be a white knight or uh virtue signaling or whatever and I I think I can't help but see some of that commentary that is just a way of like so so I should shut up then like that doesn't feel right either like I

guess I don't want to I don't want to be accused of that so therefore I guess I won't say anything and that feels to me like how one side of the conversation gets to keep having their side of the conversation um so I just have told myself or I try to think about what's my motivation for saying this do I have something to contribute generally speaking when I if I do weigh in on something I try to present it from well here's what I've learned here's what I think I've been guilty of in the past and maybe I've seen how this could be different for me so maybe this is Meaningful to you you know I try not to make it an accusatory thing as much as a maybe sharing some of my own experience I don't know Liz does any of that make sense no it does make sense um and I I find it interesting that you know you are pretty much a stone cold professional about the games but I think you're I mean I'm not saying it's not professional give an opinion because I think it is um it's I think it's important I mean do you feel a sense of responsibility from the position that you're in as one of the largest gaming channels um to weigh in like do you think you have a responsibility to do it and by that you don't mean on opinions on games as much as yeah no like on issues in our community yeah um yeah um and I feel a little funny about saying that because at the end of the day I when I started making videos about board games I was a guy in my basement talking to a camera and these 12 years later I'm a guy in my basement talking to a camera so something changed right like but but it also didn't you know

what I mean and uh but it's difficult it's difficult not to see it's hard not to talk the talk about AI Andor AI art and Borg games right yeah that's a conversation that that flared up recently and I have to admit like I I wrestle with that in my brain and because I have a slightly larger platform I'm also like hearing a lot of things right because people are interacting and talking there's things in the comments I'm feeling like oh there's like a a tide going a certain way and I wonder if that Tide's going the right way and I wonder if we could all just pause and just think about a couple of other things before we all jump on like the AI art bandwagon like yeah but but is are my concerns really does does anyone need to pay attention to me I don't know like so I actually I I wondered to myself at the start like as people started to weigh in I was like I wonder if Rodney's gonna say anything or not and I'll tell you the reason that I wondered is because you love board games and you teach them because you love them right but you also have a business where Publishers come to you and commission work from you and so if our industry swings in a direction where AI takeover does happen and there's a limit on the number of games that you can take that don't have that kind of Art in them I mean I'm a public school teacher like I don't make any money but I certainly don't make any money off of YouTube right so like you know for me I can pretty much say what I want because screw it like what's gonna happen that

the same people who weren't hiring me continue to not hire me like oh no uh but in your no I I see what you're saying it's not but you're you have more to lose you're saying the stakes might be a little different potentially for me yeah yeah yeah um yeah that's that's a tricky thing Liz uh I don't I don't want to burn bridges for no reason but I also don't want to keep Bridges up for the wrong reasons either like and that's a tricky thing because at the end of the day I need to also like I I would love to be able to keep doing this for the rest of my life this is what I want to do um and there is a financial reality to that I can't do it unless I'm getting paid and publishers want to they see value in what I'm doing to hire me to be able to do tutorial videos and things but um yeah I don't know I I don't know Liz like I don't know at what point I will compromise I'm not I'm Still Human at some point time maybe maybe I'll com maybe once everything becomes AI artwork I'll be like well I've lost this battle um so I I'm not going to stop teaching board games so I guess I got to Now teach these goofy looking AI board games I I got I got an email today from somebody and it was like Hey we're we have this game it's going to be awesome we'd love for you to do a tutorial video for it here's a link to our little video and the whole video was it was clearly all done in ai ai voice over AI uh uh

artwork on all the cards AI I'm pretty sure the video itself was put together just by AI you know animations in Ai and everything and it was like just the the you know the most horribl looking thing right now ai is the worst it's ever going to be it's only to get better from here and I don't actually have just for those who maybe don't know some of the things I've said I don't have something against necessarily AI my main concern is are we skipping a step if if the AI models are taking copyright materials things created by other artists and that's being used to teach or to fuel the database without compensating the art artists that makes me feel uncomfortable um you know and I feel like that's the part I have an issue with if the artists had the option to opt in and say yes you can use my artwork to teach your model uh I'd feel differently now listen there's going to be counterarguments to that what's the difference between a computer looking at a a piece of artwork and an artist looking at a piece of artwork and copying it um this is probably not the conversation we need to dig in right now but I think there are distinct differences distinct differences between what a machine is doing and what a human is doing I think sometimes we romanticize a little bit what the machine is doing because we're wowed by it because it's kind of impressive like that the machine can do that and so it starts to feel like this almost sentient robot like thing and I don't think that's what we have right now I think we have something closer to a photocopier a more sophisticated photocopier but if I ran a picture

through a photocopier and I got my photocopy I wouldn't say look what the machine was inspired to create um now again that's a silly example and I know AI art is more complicated than that but I think right now on the spectrum of AI being truly inspired the way humans are and a photocopier I think we're closer to this right now and we might get somewhere else later but I think we're more like here but we're kind of treating it like we're here and I anyway like I said so so sometimes when those things come up yeah when these topics come up it's not that I feel I'm right I don't know especially on this topic I don't know exactly but I have a leaning and so I I kind of like think well maybe I have a way of expressing that perhaps would make someone think and wonder about those things and then ask themselves those questions and be challenged by it and then pause and think about it before going hey cool look AI art let's put it in everything I don't know um I think also and I want to poke here just because I like to this is this is what I always do my podcast you know you the AI art I I think that part of what you're saying and this something we have in common is that part of what bothers you is missing that human element in a game making contact with another person you know you like to teach games because you like to game with people you like to respond to every comment you're really interested in communicating with people um so you know I mean this also actually makes me wonder about you know your teaching style too like you talk about kind of getting people in and out because they want to go play their game right uh but

how much of a personal touch do you think you need as a teacher to to kind of make the teach work because I my classroom operates solely on my willpower powering that classroom at this point how I choose to express it you know but that's live with a bunch of teachers who don't necessarily want to be there no no that's very difficult that's a very different in challenging environment to be in I can't see what my quote unquote students how they're reacting to anything I'm saying I have a shield that way you know what I mean like when you're teaching to someone live and someone's like snoring or on their phone or whatever that that really can sort of change your whole flow and your own psychological well-being I'm sure you know um as a teacher do yeah well I mean you've taught live before like how does having that experience impact what you choose to do in your videos I I try I try not to bake too much again kind of conversational stuff into the tutorial I mean I tried it I hope it's friendly people I'll get the comment every now and then from somebody who's like you smiled too much in your tutorial videos you're you seem too happy uh could you knock it off kind of thing right and I understand um it's especially kind of probably jarring when I'm explaining the theme to a game and I'm like in this game you're going to be playing as aliens ripping the heads off of whatever and I'm smiling you're to here but I am I think part of the impetus for that for me is I again I know that rules are intimidating and for some people especially people who are

not initiated into the hobby yet and I always believe whatever video I'm making could be the first first encounter somebody is having with let's say a modern style board game right and I just want them to be met with a cheerful face of somebody who doesn't seem in in too much of a rush but is excited to have them there and don't worry we're going to get through this together and everything's going to be fine like that's kind of the feeling I want everyone to have and I want that for this the person who's a seasoned player who's just like I need help with this or I just want help with this or whatever the case may be right um so that's I guess that's where that piece of it comes from but the if if there's anything that maybe I'm half decent at when it comes to the like the format of how I try to think about approaching a tutorial and watch a played um and I've shared this in other places so I apologize for anyone heard me say this before but I think there's something really important you have to do if you want to teach a board game well and that is forget what you know which of course you can't do because you have to know it to be able to teach it but you have to remember what it was like before before you knew it so that when you're teaching it you're remembering what the person you're talking to has in their head because they don't have in their head all the things you have in your head right and the thing I notice all the time is someone's teaching a mechanism or whatever and they've just rambled off five words in that sentence and five of those words they haven't defined any of them anywhere because in their mind they're like I don't know what these words are so this is not like a weird confusing thing but it is to the person

who hasn't read the rule book yet they don't know what those words meant yet so you got to like remember oh this person doesn't know that word so I got to start there got to Define these terms then we can graduate to putting those terms together to explain you know the mechanism or what have you right and then there's the order in which you explain the mechanisms are you building Concepts on top of each other or as in the case of solerno are you starting with something that's at actually at the back end that you're going to do last in the game and the thing you're going to do first in the game we're going to put at the back of the rule book so that as you're learning you don't actually have a growing picture of the game it's just all these disperate parts you know yes I have one more little rant I think that rulebook writers sometimes do this little shortcut for themselves not considering the rule book reader which is sometimes you'll get a rule book where they'll outline a whole bunch of Concepts disperate Concepts like uh here's what discarding is here's what drawing cards is here's what these icons mean here's what uh this type of combat is here's what the and then they get into and here's how the game goes right then they start teaching the rules and what they're expecting you to do is take these indiv idual items and then plug them in like read all these disperate things hold them all in your brain and then when I use that term later just insert that here I think that's like a rules writing shortcut thing because the the rule book writer doesn't want they want to just sort of get all the complicated stuff out of the way so they can then just teach you how to play the game over here right but when I'm learning I I don't want to have to memorize 15 different

abstract Concepts that don't plug into anything yet and then now I'm like five pages in reading the next 10 pages have to remember those first five pages then plug them in here I'd rather just start me with how the game starts and then as those items come up yeah tell me at then and now it's sort of fitting into this sort of uh story as opposed to just a whole bunch of separate things so um I don't know what why I was saying that but that's another thing I feel about rule books but it actually leads me to another question for you so I think that I mean one of the reason I had you on here is I think that one of the things we do also have in common is that we both are I guess I'll just use the term evangelist war game evangelist like we want other people to experience the joys of war and historical gaming because it really is wonderful um but you know there's still much that people are left to find out about on their own yes and so not just the solo rules all the rules good luck as as somebody who is an expert on rules and who has really thought about how people approach rule books and who remember is what it's like not to know something yeah what advice do you have for people who want to explore this but don't know how to get going because sometimes they will be on their own Define the this who want oh want to expl You're Gonna Do war games yeah okay you know what you know what I would recommend honestly um everything I just said in this how long we've been talking about war games and some of my negative feelings about them again I feel like that's a trend

but it's not not all of them and David Thompson for example has written the rules in his uh postman's in uniform and what's that whole series called do you remember oh the value Defense series viant Defense series yes David Thompson doesn't always write the rules to his own rule game his own war game sometimes the publisher does it sometimes you know they there's variet different ways it can be done my understanding is for that series he wrote them himself and I feel like it shows and he is a master he will uh not only not just tell you the rule but teach you the rule but then immediately follow that with three examples with illustrations and those examples will include those weird Edge case situations so that when you're done you're like I have a comprehensive complete understanding of this one action I'm now ready to hear about action number two and just keeps building on top of it it's just some of the best war game rulebooks I have ever read just in terms of their comprehensiveness now the the downside and some Publishers would see this as a downside side is the rule book is like maybe 20 30 pages right there's a marketing element which is if my if my rule book is five pages it looks like an easier game it looks more approachable it's less intimidating I just really don't like that at all because I feel like it's a lie uh the reality is if you if you want to make a five-page rulebook for marketing reason reasons design a five page rulebook game if you've

designed a 30 page rulebook game then please give me all 30 pages don't artificially trim out a bunch of stuff leave out examples or make the print really really tiny you know yeah I just again like uh David Thompson maybe goes almost I don't I don't think you can go too far honestly but he he goes right on the Other Extreme I'd love to see more people aiming for that honestly so there's there are war games I think that are approachable that way and he's made a series of them and those are solo ones you can just jump into on your own yes well I mean we all know I'm bias David Thompson because he now doing nine witches but I have bad news for everybody which is that I'm the primary writer on the rule book for that so if anything's wrong with it in the future it's my fault well have you have you written rule books before no it's my first one okay well then we'll we will be judging harshly go for it well listen listen I I mean again you you you you know you certainly got a partner there who can maybe help offer some advice as you figured out I I also think Liz for all my criticism here I hope people will take it in stride because the reality is it's much easier to criticize something than to start from a blank page and create something okay it's much easier for me to come in here and go here's what's wrong with this rule book but if you'd given me the blank pages and told me all the rules of cero 43 and now I had to write the rule book I can assure you I'd do it differently but it doesn't mean that I wouldn't have had some made some is errors too and and had people scratching their head Etc right absolutely and then I guess you know we've touched on it a bit like talking about history and historical influence but and in interest but what is it about

war games that makes them worth the trouble huh H well this is very subjective um but I have found like for example when I learned Kua Libra and played it I found the experience and the way it made my brain sweat and the mechanisms and all of that really fascinating to me I was just wildly fascinated by it and have played the game I don't know like 20 times now and I don't I'm Still Loving playing it all the different coin games they all like pull me in so there's definitely like that part of it which is I don't know how you sort of pin that down cuz someone else could play that game and mechanically not enjoy it at all like someone else would might not have that fun moving those pieces around and having that experience uh there's that I think there is the there is something about it being grounded in a historical setting that uh I think adds layers to it um you know I found after playing Koopa Libra you know being curious about what was going on here CU a lot of the cards you know in the deck they show illustrations they talk about historical events the rule book itself and the Playbook provide additional details about the history so I read through all that then I watch some documentaries start reading books and it gives you a level of appreciation I suppose about not just the game but what it's modeling and what it represents and maybe kind of expands your mind even a little bit as a human on the planet you know I feel like there's things I've learned about war

and conflict that are not necessarily uh great but they're true you know just in terms of like tensions between different factions and human casualty and Terror and its place in conflict and all the rest of it you and you I don't know it's it's uh there's something in that that makes the game more than just a game anymore cuz like when I'm playing a trick to taking game I'm not having a bigger experience like the experience is the trick taking game and that's fun and and that's great and games don't have to be more than that if you don't want it to be right but I think historical war games do invite you to consider something Beyond just the game itself and I think that is a perfect spot to ask you other than kubba Libra what have you been playing recently that brings you some Joy well it's another coin came I'll give you two answers I'll give you two answers one that's a one that's bringing me joy and one that's not bringing me joy and I will stop picking on CA 43 so it's not going to be that which CA 43 I will eventually Master have me back on sometime in the future we'll talk about how I did with it um people power have you played people power you know it's on my to-do list and I'm very excited about it this is a three-player coin game and for the longest time I would have said kubba Libra was like the ideal starting coin game uh it might still be for a little while there was like oh I think it might be people power there are certain things about people power that are a little I think a little easier but there's a

fragility to the balance in that game and I could see first timers feeling like one faction's way more power than the other and I don't think that's what's going on it just takes a while to understand what you have to do to kind of like counteract what they can do I think it's one of those situations where there's a faction that might be quote unquote a little easier to play and so it might take a little while for the other players to kind of catch on to what they have to be doing but I have found that one just really really interesting really tickles my brain I'm mystified still by like you know what the right thing is to do in any given situation but I'm really enjoying it the one that's causing me a little more like gritting my teeth kind of feeling um is Inferno my first levian campaign attempt o um and that's not me disparaging the game it's just this is another one of situations where the rule book is very dense it's a lot of telling you not necessarily teaching you and there's a lot a lot of moving parts and I feel like it's a it's a slightly higher Hill to climb Than People Power was so I I'm in that more like sweaty part of trying to just figure out what the heck's going on in it stage so I'm not having fun yet exactly but there might be fun on the other side of that effort we'll see I believe I believe uh and um what I always ask people not that anybody actually needs to ask us about you but where can you be found online sure no no I so if if you're interested in watching any of our videos we have tutorial videos Gameplay videos um and a variety of other types of content on the channel

includes including news and everything else and some solo we have a solo series called table for one where we teach and play the solo rules for some of the games too um that you can find us over at youtube.com/watch it played and then like on social media if you just look up watch it played that's probably us um on there under that whether it's face Facebook or Twitter or any the other number of social media places that are popping up these days fantastic and uh I of course am beyond soliter everywhere online and every time Rodney tells you to go discover that on your own just just come to me I got you that's right to Liz it's a partnership Liz we're working together Liz thank you so much for having me on this was such a delight I hope people enjoyed some parts of this conversation I I really enjoyed talking to you and and and talking about these these subjects that are not something that I because you're right on the channel I don't really have an Avenue where I would talk about this this way so it's nice to be able to do it thank you yeah it's so nice to get to know you better like you know it's now I can be like oh hey it's Ronnie yeah we're bu you know I've been I've been watching your stuff for years but you know it's fun to actually make contact we've like exchanged a couple Twitter messages and like that's it so this is really cool for me too I really appreciate your time a pleasure so everybody out there please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy ging bye everybody

Progress saved