Lockup Review - The Broken Meeple
Transcript
hi everyone welcome to another broken meatball review and today it's lock up lock up was getting quite a bit of buzz from Kickstarter lately when it started arriving and people were opening up their copies and going oh yeah lock up yeah we really like this one or I've been waiting to get this one for a long time surprising considering as I looked at it I thought okay Sam's cool but why was again a lot of hype it seemed that a lot of people were just really excited to get this one in the post maybe because it's got the words a role player tail on the front of it and if you don't know in funder works is line up they've got the brought out role player which is a really cool dice game about building up a D&D character which is on my shelf in the other room and it killed sagrada for me and i know i really love the game this one is effectively you're saying it's in this role player universe everything's got to have a universe these days but really it just basically means you can use the same fantasy monsters and the art style can be the same apart from that this is not really a sequel to role play or anything like that it's just using the same artwork the same theming of that fantasy world cartographers doing a similar thing with that as well so lock up is what I would call kind of like a simple sort of worker placement game in the census it's this worker placement area control is kind of hard to describe the idea with this is that you have a fantasy prison that's filled with all sorts of like dodgy monsters and everything like that and you are effectively like rival kingpins or like what do they call them I call them kingpins but you know
essentially those one thing you see in films and TV series whereas I as much as the prison is as much as they're in prison they kind of run the prison you know there they are running the show they're like the feared boss of the prison that kind of thing your rivals and you're trying to be the best one and the idea is is that you've got all these different rooms in the prison with different effects that trigger you're trying to have the most reputation stars as there's always stars at this one at the end of the game and to do so you're hiring goons it'll go in front of you and essentially be your posse you're crafting items that get you like status symbol effectively for reputation and of course you're all trying to do this while also avoiding the gaze of the guards if you're aroused too much suspicion the guards come in rage and you'll lose some reputation as a result but the game itself is actually marketed as quite an easy game to get into and play and it actually does feel that way this is a very simple game not crazy simple I don't know if I would go as far as to call it gateway level maybe next step but it's definitely a light game there's not a lot of fiddly rules here two of those by the ways that you get stars a similar that's just like you get these by one method to get these by another and everybody understands the whole getting victory points and that where the crux of this game comes in though is that these locations you only win and trigger their effects if you have the highest strength in them each of you has a effectively get out of bag
here you effectively have like a a prison it's quite night that you put this cardboard thing in there and it looks like the rule behind bars it's quite kind of neat but you effectively have markers hidden from other players in front of you number two to five with a couple of special ones with different rules and the idea is is that you take it in turns to place one or more of these markers onto the various rooms highest strength is what triggers a location for the best effect and then second and third place and so on but two of them out of the ones that you put down are allowed to be put facedown the rest must be face-up so you have some information from what other players are doing but they might also put a couple facedown it's like hmm has he put that level five one there's that only at level two and he's just goading me but as the game as the round goes on and more markers start coming out it's like oh hang on you already put his high ones over there so that can't be that high can it you know it you start piecing together a little bit you're getting each other's heads but it's quite mean and direct you know you are actively shoving your guys into these locations trying to get the highest strength if that means that you've got to screw somebody else over by you know opposing their strength by putting higher one in there then world tough to that other person the biggest consolation prize you'll get is a few little special tones as they're called which are kind of like one use effects they're pretty cool effects is a good con and price at the end of the day but it means they're not picking up the cube resources which are basically the same as each other they're just generic cubes and various other bonuses as well
however the problem is is that if you start to go into certain locations that I've got these black suspicion cubes around the place if you collect them and eventually there's not enough black cubes in the supply to refill certain locations the guards come in raid and whoever has the most suspicions loses a bucketload of points and so the second place for a bit less so you're trying to win the locations but you gotta be careful not to win too many of these black cubes there's ways to mitigate it with one of your markers by negating the effect but for the most part it's like okay I better watch exactly what I'm doing but oh you're kind of doing for a pasta victory and this is where I have a slight flaw with the game is the main way you get stars in this game is a by crafting items or hiring goons goons are essentially several different people like cultists and Dwarfs and demons and they score you endgame points in various ways like dwarf imrat skin men you need and sets you know like more of them get you more points koltes gives you points for items the cult the demon wants points for certain types of items the Hobgoblin wants your your enforcer marker which is built up by red power cubes to be as strong as possible and you get points for that but that's pretty much what they are they don't get they don't have cool special abilities unfortunately aside from a little bonus that they give you which might involve getting rid of a suspicion cube or just gaining another resource cube butter than that they're just generic in game scoring points the items are even less interesting in that I like terms I literally just instant points they don't
do anything else they're pretty much just symbols for you know occasionally they might have a like a bonus that they give you but for the most part it is literally just pay the cubes crap the item and get the points you know nothing much that different between them and the goons to be perfectly honest and you get both in them very much the same way to get goons you have to just give in a certain amount of any resource you feel like whereas the items have specific requirements you know so you might have to get a blue grain of gold for a particular item but both working very much the same way a kind of wish that you were bit more differentiated to be perfectly honest a couple of other ways of getting points in the game are some very interesting objective market objectives that you can get you've got an instant one which the first person to get it you get the points you've got leader one which is whoever has the most at a particular time takes the card and then at the end they score and then there's a game end one which everybody can score for it's quite neat that there's a good amount of variety with those as well and on the subject of variety I wish there was more goons there's not a lot of different types of goons the items there's a lot of different items are all unique but they're so generic the fact that they're all different doesn't make a huge amount of difference really but you do have some cool trait cards which effectively I like an advanced setup you've got your player boards but the generic and you know side a makes no difference it's crap that out of the way and just look at advanced setup because frankly it's not difficult to get advanced set up but
with that you flip it over the site B and then you have starting you know different starting resources and points you might have a special ability that goes off you might have different storage limits for how many cubes you're allowed to keep but on top of that if you use advanced setup you deal out these trait cards and you pick one of them to start a game with and it gives you a different amount of points and starting resources and there's quite a few in there yeah you you're only gonna get dealt two and pick one but you know are you gonna be the reckless bugbears are you're gonna be the proud goblins are you gonna be the ferocious insect awaits you know it's kind of one but yeah it's nice to have a bit of starting variety with the game they're not drastic they're not game-changing they're just like oh I get to have something a little bit different this time and it's mostly just what cubes do you want to start with really more than anything else maybe a tone card maybe like a free goon when you start the game that kind of thing but they're not there's nothing like too drastic in this but then it is a like game so what do you expect it's trying to keep itself relatively simple and if it tried to give you like tons of weird player powers and tons of different goon abilities and items with special powers then it would take it up to the next level like Midway and that's kind of not what this game is aiming for a component wide pretty solid the cards are decent quality our work is just like it isn't role-player so it looks cool it's got that fancy s almost like cartoony fantasy style the these little bars you know they're adequate but I do like the fact that they put in the extra effort with having the bars that you slide the strip into the seats yours I just
thought that was a neat little twist being a simple thing cubes yeah why does it have to be cubes I keep them in the box like this and like I say they are big and chunky cubes I'll give them that but they're cubes you know don't expect funky resource tokens or anything like that I know this was on Kickstarter I don't think they upgraded the cosmetics for Kickstarter but as again I am reviewing a retail copy of the game so this is the one that you will pick up in the shops so with all that said and done is the game fun to play yeah it is generally it's a pretty sweet game you've gotta be willing to take some direct interaction though because this is not a friendly game you know you'll put some guys at and locations and other people are trying to block you one will get higher strength some of you might have some you know way of oh I got this item which allows me to give a suspicion cube to someone else or while you take it haha a little bit of take that in there but of course you are going at each other's throats for these locations and you don't necessarily know what some of the facedown ones are so everybody's in each other's faces and that has a profound effect if you start going to the higher play account the board is double sided so it works for different player accounts I believe - and free work on one side and free and sorry and four and five work on the other side but and there's also a solo mode in here if you really want which herb it's okay it's nothing amazing but I mean I like it fine I play it every now and again you're essentially trying to get the reputation stars and avoid the guards but it definitely it scales well enough
that the board is not too open with less players because you have an extra marker to use you know an extra minion to put out but definitely this does feel like a game you want to play with four or five more often two and three is fine I've played this with free player I had a good time there was definitely some times you had the room all to yourself sometimes you were like really in each other's faces the definite way I would say I would want to play this often though is four and five it does take it a little bit of that kind of decent time length room in the time on the box is nineteen minutes flat that's kind of accurate even a free player game could take you ninety minutes if people are new ish to the game sixty if they really know what they're doing and they're super quick but typically you're going to be looking at a 90 minute game here and what the flag did to have been a bit shorter for how light it is but you know ninety minutes is not too bad it's kind of like my ideal length for a game that involves me having to think and plan ahead cuz you gotta be careful you can't just check out markers willy nearly you've got to think about where you're putting them but four and five gets very crowded yeah you don't get extra locations you just have first second and third place for the various things so that you know third place gets a bonus rather than just the top two oh wait that's all well and good but there's no more locations so you're gonna be crowded into these areas and even when you get rid of the lowest marker in a 5 player game you get rid of the 2 value mininum doesn't matter there's a lot of players there's a lot of markers it's going to get pretty heated but then that's what the theme in the game is and the theme comes out sort
of I mean Dorf you know it's good to collect a lot of dwarfs and cultures like items and that but you know the theme is more kind of it's a nice dressing it works the theme is fine and I like the idea that you are basically or the prison and trying to avoid the guards I mean the theme works but we can call it like completely dripping with it you know you're basically grabbing cubes from various areas and turning the cubes into goons or items pick one pick both doesn't really matter so you know theme is there but not like crazily there if that makes sense more of the theme comes out with just the fact that if there's four or five of you you are actively in each other's faces screw each other over because nobody in the prison is anybody's friend as we know from pretty much every TV show or film that ever has this sort of thing so oh you know I enjoy it I wasn't as blown away by it as I thought I was gonna be I mean I was expecting a bit more from the buzz it got but I feel like I would bring this out every now and again if somebody just wanted a light like again I don't know whether the call that worker placement or action set I suppose it is a worker placement I mean you're putting workers out into the locations but whether they actually do anything is another thing you know so it's hard to describe but it's a it's a decent light game you know what to call it category wise but it's a light game won't take too long 19 minutes tops probably I wish it was a little bit shorter though which is why I probably wouldn't bring out as often as all that but it will make you think you have got to decide you know do I want to put that
my free first maybe the five I definitely want that location but should I go there now or should I can deserts my dominance or shall I you know maybe wait see what happens and go to this one first you can put out more than one marker at a time but I don't see much point in doing more than one marker at a time because if you put them all out you've basically played all your cards and everybody else can react to what you've done why not just simply put one out of time in I don't know occasionally there's a kid but there's times when I put out too but the idea that you can put that as many as you like I think if you put out three or more in a particular location then you're kind of playing your cards too soon and it's gonna hurt you more than it's gonna help you but I don't know maybe it's a way to say look I'm having this location whether you like or not but then if somebody wants to get in on your location they know exactly how to beat you so again not sure why you would do more than one at a time for the most part and that tends to be what happens so it's mostly one mark and one mark on one Michael one marker the terms can take a little while if someone AP's so ninety minutes is kind of more common but I enjoy the game it's well produced it's neat draws a few laughs you know you get a few references made from like fantasy races and that but although I'd probably give it about seven it's decent I don't think it's mind blowing it's good I will occasionally bring it you know if somebody suggests it on a game night I'll be like yeah cool la cops a bit of fun but I have played better games this year I have certainly you know that the meanness of this is not
super mean I mean I think if you're worried that I yes it's gonna be too direct interaction or too mean for me I don't think it's quite that bad giving a suspicion cube to another player hurts though that is the one bit of take that which you might not agree with but it's not like you have a hand of cards and one says oh yeah you miss a turn or you your five marker for the round it's not quite that bad but it's decent it's fine I just wasn't blown away by it a decent respectable seventh so that's it for me I'll see you on the next broken meatball review and whether you've locked me up in prison with the bugbears or the insectoids or please don't knock me up at the goblins for there's no they smell yeah it's still only a game take care and I'll see you on the next review
you