Seeland Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm taking a look at Sealand which is a board game dating all the way back to 2010. this one accommodates two to four players and takes 45 to 60 Minutes to play and the designers of this game are Gunter Burkhart and the legendary Wolfgang Kramer before I get into my thoughts on Sealand I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so the main board for sealant is gonna look like this where you have this rather large map made up of all these individual hexes and you can see that these blue tiles have been randomly distributed face down on these pre-allocated spaces there's quite a lot of those but we do not know what's on the reverse side and we've set up for a two-player game here so therefore each player is going to have a starting windmill on one of these starting spots and to the top left hand side of the board you have where most of the gameplay takes place through these rondelles and through this coin um kind of this cool coin mechanism that manages each player's money at any given time so in this game you have two different types of tiles you have these windmills and you have these three different types of crops and you can see that these all have unique numbers on them or different types of numbers ranging from zero all the way up to seven I believe and you have the two stacks of tiles here we've got the windmill stacks and we have the crop stacks and this is going to be one of the counters or one of the um end
game triggers once one of these Stacks have been depleted and of course when that happens the player with the most victory points um when that happens is going to be the Victor there's going to be a few additional resources such as these Governors which may come into play when some of these tiles are revealed each player is going to have an additional three windmills which they can put on the board so you have a maximum of four you've got some of these coins and you have some of these Point markers so how does the game actually work and what are we trying to achieve so on any player's turn they are going to move their player marker on um which is going to be sat on one of these coins and move it a number of spaces depending on the tile you wish to draft and you're going to draft these tiles based on where this Governor piece is here or where this Guild Master is um and the first spot you go to is going to be free the second one is going to cost one this is going to cost two this is going to cost three and so on but let's just say for an example on my turn I wanted to move um one two three spaces like so and pick up this windmill now again because the first spot is free this means it's going to cost me two coins now when I spend these coins I'm going to move my player piece two spots on the coin track because I spent two coins and then I'm gonna take the tile that I've just drafted and I'm going to place it somewhere on the board now when you place a windmill you have to place it next to what we call a developed spot so at the start of the game there's not very many um developed spots but um as you can probably imagine as you start pushing kind of um these crop tiles down that would then be a developed spot that we which means you could then sneak a new um windmill
tile in there but let's just say I wanted to put my windmill tile here like so and then I would voluntarily choose to put my windmill on it bearing in mind I only ever have three of those or sorry four of those to play with so that would technically conclude the orange players turn but then it'll go on to the wood player here um and let's just say he wanted to get on this tile here again this one's going to be free this is going to cost one this is going to cost two so therefore they're going to move two spaces like so in order to take this tile here which is quite a nice one and then they're going to take that and again place it somewhere on the board now when you take one of these crop tiles you have to place it next to one of your windmills so let's just say they placed it here like this and because now there are two coins exposed to the back of this coin track they're going to now move to the front of the row like so meaning that we both now have five coins to play with again and you can probably tell that if um say for example uh this player had ended up spinning four like this then this player ended up spending one this will go to the front like this and you can see in the future round that this player now only has two coins to play with whereas this one has one two three four coins to play with so how do we actually score points so whenever you completely surround a windmill with any other tile um let's say for example this uh the wood player played this um red tile here like so thus completely surrounding this windmill you've got to calculate your total value of points based on not only
the windmill value you're on but also all the other ones around it so this is going to be five it's going to be 12. it's going to be 16 it's going to be 21 points now you're also going to get additional points if you have all three different types of crops so this is going to be now 26 points um because you get the bonus Five Points now if you ever only have one type of crop so let's say for example um this one was surrounded only by these or this particular type when it comes to scoring like so um because there's only ever one type you are not going to score any points whatsoever so you want to have at least two different types of crops before you um you know before you decide to cash out essentially now once you've taken those points of course you're going to change your um your point tally to reflect how many points you've gotten like so what the fact it was this color and then you're going to remove the windmill that's just being completed and put it back into your personal Reserve so you've always got those four to play with meaning that you want to have a kind of cash flow of um you know once you have in your reserve ready to deploy into the board as well as having some on the board gaining points as you go now whenever you build a mill next to one of these blue tiles so let's just say the um the wood player ended up building this tile here sneaky getting here like so and claiming it as their own by putting their windmill on it and because they are touching one of these blue tiles or more than one with these blue tiles which
might be the case you're going to reveal them and flip them over and he's going to have different things on the reverse side of them so they could just have more crops on it like so or they could have these little Farms on them that look like this now these Farms aren't going to be worth any points whatsoever however they will grant the um the player who flipped it one of these coins and these coins are useful because at the end of your turn you can cash one in to get another turn back to back however you can only do that once per turn now you can also see that some of these tires are going to have this little Governor logo on it that looks like this and when you reveal one of these tiles you're going to take a governor from the supply and you're going to move it to the windmill that's just been you know it's just revealed it like so now what this means is that in order for me to get some bonus points and potentially you know not suffer negative points I'm gonna have to have a certain threshold of points when it comes to cashing out this windmill now the value that I need to aim towards and you know at least match is this value here which is the next in line on the coin track and this is going to fluctuate as the game goes on so as you can see here if this player ended up spending two coins this is no longer going to require a value of 28 it's going to require a value of 17. so you have some kind of time pressure there and you can try and time it just right to make sure that you get the numbers just right now if you successfully cash that out again by surrounding it you know which would normally I'd have to do here I would not only get the points based on the um the points of standard
but I'll get a bonus of Five Points um by at least matching that number and I'd also claim as Governor as my own and if I have the most Governors at the end of the game I'm going to get 10 points now if I did not successfully match or exceed that value then I'm going to lose five points and the governor is going to move to the closest windmill like so now in addition to the standard round structure or if you're paying for a tile picking it up placing it on the board and potentially scoring um you can actually optionally declare one of these high score markers and each player can do this twice throughout the game and actually the only two times um you can do it but let's just say I've just done it here so as normal I'll calculate my windmill let's just say I've surrounded this one so add up the points which is going to be seven eight nine ten uh 13 16 points burgermind that adjacent windmills aren't going to score I have all three different types of crops so it's going to take me up to 21 points so as normal I would add on my 21 points to the score but now I have the option to declare one of these high point markers and if let's just say I'll do it just for example wearing one I probably wouldn't do this because this isn't a particularly good time to do it but what this means is that at the end of the game if one of my high score markers is in the top three spots amongst all the players then there's potentially going to be some end game scoring here so again the person who scored the most in a single round is gonna get 20 points second most 15 points third most 10 points and that is essentially how the game plays as I said
earlier you're going to keep on playing until one of those Stacks is depleted until somebody lands on a spot that's empty then you're going to tie up all the points you've got through the game um added with the top three spaces from a high point score markers and from the player who's had the most Governors collected throughout the game and I play with the most points will be the winner okay so let's share some thoughts on sealant so you can probably tell there from the overview that this game is rather simple it's just a simple tile placement game where you're trying to extract as many points as you can by efficiently placing these windmills but there is some cool things kind of built on top of the foundation of a solid but simple you know framework the first of which is this money system I think this is a fantastic mechanism I've never seen it before and I'm completely baffled why this has not been used in any other game so I love this idea that you know money is a finite thing it's capped you could only ever have so much and that's all kind of Tethered to the other players so you know at maximum you're going to have one two three four coins to spend but potentially you can be forced to always take the next Hal in row if you have no money to spend if somebody's just camping at the back spot here and this has really played out in the games I've I've played with this one but I think it's a really interesting element of interaction where you know if you're quite happy with the next child on the rondelle like let's just say the you know the wood player here and is happy by taking the next one for free like so they're gonna get that title for free and then it means that you're forcing your opponent who's at the front here to
take the next tile because they have no money to spend and sometimes this could just work out in your favor because you know you can be forced to take or you can optionally um choose to take the next tile like so which is a nice healthy one um and again force your opponent to take the next one so sometimes you can really utilize just capping on a spot not only to help yourself but actually to hinder your opponent and something I didn't mention is that if somebody lands on this spot here you can actually um force them to lose three points but they do actually gain three coins for doing so so there is a kind of an out of doing that but you are going to force them to lose points if you really exploit that enough but yeah very simple system it stops people stockpiling money and it's just genius really I do really enjoy the management of the windmills because you only ever have four to play with and they're going to be stuck on the board until you completely surround one of your windows but of course you are going to want to get as many points as you can and not want to take those lower tiles and that's going to be of course subject to the money that you have but you want to make sure you have at least the three different types to get those easy bonus Five Points and I like this kind of networking thing where as you start to spawn out there'll be little opportunities that you can sneak in and leech off the other players like for example um if I really wanted to I could build another windmill here which has automatically been built you know nine points there essentially so this is kind of cool little Network thing that spawns out and actually reminds me of a game called Citrus where managing your your
yeah your kind of flow of your pieces is a big part of the game because if you have them all locked on the board when it comes to placing a windmill you're going to be playing pretty inefficiently and not getting it kissing any points for it but you want to make sure you have some presence on the board to get points in the first place another thing I really appreciate about this game is this idea of quick grabs versus those big point scorings so you can probably tell here that again in in the future rounds it would be quite easy for me to start leeching off other players hard work like for example if I wanted to as the orange player build a new Mill and just shove it right in here like this I've completely leeched off these two pieces and I'm going to do well for doing that and I actually only need to place one more tile to completely surround it so it has this kind of mix of just sneaking in getting quick Point scrubs um you know getting those quick points and then having your windmill back in your supply ready to deploy again but that is really kind of um counterpointed by the fact that you are incentivized to take big turns as well like for example if you really wanted to start a windmill and Surround it with all the high points towels you know those sixes those sevens those fives um and get those huge Point swings while that's going to be slower it's going to take more effort the idea that these um High Point markers are a mechanism in the game is Just genius and it's little design points like this that make the great designers stand out from the good designers because without these I think it would be much
more incentivized just to keep on getting those smaller Point grabs and be you know you're quick in and out but with this one because there are so many um points at the end of the game if you do keep getting those big swings you know those 25 to 30 point grabs then it's going to really incentivize you to do that so there really is two different ways you can play the game or a mix of the two and both are completely Justified they also want to talk about the governors I think this is such a cool little touch which adds a whole new pressure into the game and it does sometimes actually stop you doing that quick grab because you want to be cashing things out at the right time so you might actually want to very carefully manage this money track to make sure that when it comes to cashing out one of your pieces with the governor on it you're doing it when it's nice and low and sometimes this can work against you because it will just never work out you can never find the perfect tile in order to cash that Governor out to get those bonus points or not suffer those negative points it just adds a whole you know a whole new dimension to the game because it means you have to get the timing just right which is normally not the case with every other aspect of the game so and I should say that these two things as in the High Point scorings and the governors are optional modules but I think it's those little elements that add wrinkles to the game which make it stand you know above a lot of other guitar placement games so I would actually always play with those two modules because they're not complex but they do add more meat to the bones here there is a nice amount of player interaction here not too much not too little I've already talked about the management of the money that plays a big
factor in drafting and affecting other players but also you there is some potential for some pretty mean plays um should you want to do that and for example if you had um windmills kind of close to each other and you know that your opponent is struggling to get the three different types sometimes you can play a tile that's good for you but you know it's going to be a nightmare for your opponents it's going to stop them from getting the three different types and therefore those five bonus points or you can actually um place that final tile which means that they're going to have all the same type I mean they're going to get no points at all for all the effort they spent on building around that windmill so yeah it just strikes the chord just right for me in terms of meaningful player interaction not too much not too little not too mean but not too passive either the game also scales very well which is nice to say I have played this at all the play accounts and they all work perfectly fine and I think my favorite Play account is probably three but it does actually work surprisingly well at two players which I wasn't expecting them to be honest and because you are still just you know not only doing your own thing but these little wrinkles of you know the pressure of the time the um the high scoring markers um it just adds enough flavor to the game to not make it feel as abstract as it probably looks at first I'm very happy with the production of this game you know it's nothing special but it just feels like a traditional board game it's nice and colorful and it looks great when it's on the table and the tiles themselves are you know they're fine they're not the best quality but this is 12 years old and they still look new so um they've obviously held up quite well and all the wooden pieces look fantastic like a particularly these windmills they have a good presence to them nice Hefty little
pieces there so yeah generally happy with the production and nothing I have issue with okay so it's time for my final thoughts on Sealand so if you can't tell about my enthusiasm about this um you know on this video then um yeah I think this game is fantastic it feels like a classic and to be honest it's games like this which really signify why I do what I do now if some games just Fade Into Obscurity nobody plays them anymore and it's just criminal to think that's the case because this game is so well designed it has a very simple Foundation here you know simple puzzly style um tile placement very abstract in this nature but it's these layers on top that just add it and bring it to life you know add spark and add a bit of spice to the gameplay the money mechanism is brilliant absolutely love it adds so much cool interaction adds a lot of tension and you can really mess with other players and exploit the system and use it to your benefits um Additionally the pressure of managing your windmills is great you know I won't presence on the board but I also want some in my Supply because sometimes I'll be forced to place windmills and I don't want to waste those turns the mystery of flipping over these blue tiles are there going to be those high points values are they going to give me another turn are they going to have the governors on them which are probably going to have a great tile but it's going to put me under a lot of pressure and mean that I need to cash it out at just the right time based on the coin system here and the numbers exposed so all these little wrinkles and elements just um just take it above and beyond what it might appear as at face value and I didn't even talk about these high high scoring markers this is a
mechanism that I can I never see it and it's just so cool to see it implemented to such a high standard and as I mentioned earlier it's games like this which really show why the great designers are great people like Kramer you can just see it has his DNA all over it apologies to the other designer because I don't know much about his work but yeah it's those little wrinkles those little nuances which think yeah this is why they're doing what they're doing this is and just understanding the thought process and um those little balance things sort of look you know little things to balance those two um there's two strategies of quick grabs all those big Point swings um it's just genius to me so yeah I really recommend this game if you can find a copy I believe it is out of print it's going to be quite hard to come by but in the same vein it's not really in favor it's not the hotness and I suppose nobody's going to be headhunting this game so you might snag yourself a copy um for a good price but yeah if you want a simple top play some game that plays in about 45 minutes to an hour one that scales well it's a lot of fun it's gonna cease you're gonna see some new things you haven't seen before then I could not recommend Sealand enough I'm just gonna get a very solid ranking from me so that is Sealand definitely a Hidden Gem and as I said this is really why I do what I do and I love making videos like this and putting some Spotlight on these hidden gems