Signal Review - Quick Take with Tom Vasel
Transcript
I've struggled for a while on how to talk about signal from DVC games. This is a cooperative game where one person is an alien and everyone else is a human and you are making contact but you do not speak the same language. This is not the first game to do this. This is maybe the fourth game with this theme. But this is definitely the most esoteric one I played to the point where after reading the rules I wasn't sure we were playing right. Now part of that is the rules are terrible. But part of it also is the rules are oblique on purpose. What? I'm going to try to tell you how it plays. Okay. This is a tough game to explain but I'll do my best. There is a bunch of aliens in the game. I'm going to spoil one of them for you but it's not that big of a deal. Each alien um has a pattern, a transmission that the experts, everyone but the alien, needs to get. The alien's going to Everyone can see this but the alien sees the other side and sees these three rules. The experts are going to place piece on the board. So let's say the experts place I don't know this on the board. They place these sp- pieces on the board here.
I then will follow the rules as the alien. Move all wee- white pieces away from each other. Okay, I'll move that here and that there. Move all black pieces away from each other. So I'll move that here I'll move that here and I'm moving that one completely off the board. I'm trying to make this here. So now the experts they've used a transmission token to get me to that point.
[clears throat]
Now they're going to try another thing. They're going to keep They're going to watch how I follow the rule which in this case is pretty simple. White pieces away, black pieces away. So if they can figure out a way to maybe just do something like this and I move that one off the board. I move the Maybe these are here and I move the black pieces away from each other. And I move the white pieces away from each other. Man, I made it. If we pull that off, then there's a second rule. From now on I have to do the repel, and then pull. All black pieces go towards white piece, then remove that white piece. And then annihilate. The third round, I have to do both these rules, and then move one black piece towards another black piece until they touch. Remove all black and white pieces touching each other. Now, you might sit there and go, "What is going on?" I get it. Then and like, what are the exact rules about moving? It's all open to interpretation.
The game here has some rules and things that you can consider and understand, and players will have some of these cards that might help. Like, the alien reveals the names of all three rounds. If I tell you the rounds are repel, pull, annihilate, that might help you out figuring that. And that's sort of the game, sort of. Yeah, this one's tough. Uh it's tough to talk about because it's such a weird oddity of a game. When I went through it, it's like, okay, we we put these pieces out, and I follow the rule, and I can't talk, and I can move, and how I interpret the rules is up to me, and how you interpret me interpreting rules. This game deliberately has gray area, and you know what? I hate that. I hate a game that's not necessarily black and white, unless I mean, I shouldn't say that. I mean, with RPGs and stuff, I don't mind it so much, but in this game, it kind of drives me crazy. It's like, "Move this this next to this one."
So, next to it is this next to it? Is that next to it? How does this work exactly? Move them away from each other. How far? That's up to your interpretation, and you're trying to get to a certain thing, and everyone knows that where you're trying to get to, but they don't know these nebulous rules that you're following, and it's weird, man. So, I applaud the ingenuity of the people who made this. I applaud the the thought that went into this, but it's not really, I think, a fun game. It's an exercise. I don't even know how to rate it. I'll give it a six. It's in the middle for me. You know, it's okay. But I can't really say, "Wow, this was amazing fun." Because we're just This feels like the whole time we're just trying to figure out what's going on. It's like Contact the Movie.
But you don't watch, you're part of it. And these things sound fun to you, part of them. And I I'm sure there are some people out there who the idea of this will be super intriguing to. Like, "Oh, wow." But is it an entertaining activity or is it an interesting exercise? And I think it leans towards interesting exercise. But the obliqueness of the rules, the headiness of how to get from point A to point B through these very weird restrictions placed upon you. Oh good, we've all learned how to make first contact. But was it worth me buying? I don't think I can say that. I don't think I can say this is a game you should get. But it's an interesting one for sure. So, I don't know. That's Signal, Jasper Beatrix designer DVG Games. Like I said, six out of 10, I think.