Skip to main content
Loading video...

Battlestar Galactica Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 15:42

hello welcome back to the channel this is a channel where we give you reviews play through his unboxings we generally like to talk a lot of bollocks a tabletop game in general in this video we're going to be talking about an ancient hidden trait against the ancient is it's a more vulnerable hidden trait again we'll be talking about battle star galactica the board game and in this game you will be attempting to jump the galactica so many times to reach the wonderful planet of cobalt whilst at the same time worrying about whether or not you've got some sneaky bastard traitor in your midst so in this video we're gonna be giving you a very very brief overview of the rules because this one does my nighting quite a bit we tell you what we do like we don't like then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not battlestar galactica ball game is still worth picking up today and playing in the future so remember if you knew it please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below hit the like button and all that [ __ ] see you after this

alex so battlestar galactica the ball game how to play this game so first things first if you're wondering why we've got a non-english language version of battlestar galactica that is because we sold our old copy years and years ago for various reasons but we decided to but again had a look at it found out that it was really really expensive but we found a spanish copy on amazon for about 20 quid and i painstakingly went through and pasted up all the cards placed it on the board basically translated the whole bloody thing and uh yeah gave myself a migraine in the process so uh yeah that's why we are using the spanish copy of this game so if you're looking for english copy tough [ __ ] really in it so battlestar galactica is a hidden traitor game so you're going to have certain people that are going to be the human players which take on the role various characters from battlestar galactica get a tv show from a long time ago and tv was actually pretty good yeah and then you're going for some players who are going to be cylons attempting to disrupt the human players plans you're not going to know who the cylons are until they reveal themselves so there's going to be loads and loads of accusations and mudslinging and maybe a little bit of [ __ ] slinging in this game right so you'll see one of the focal points of the board are the dials that represent different resources that you really need to keep an eye on you've got food fuel morale and population and if any of these dolls ever go down to zero then the players will completely [ __ ] up again and they'll be out they'll lose they'd be

dead right so each player will then randomly select a character there's quite a few characters in this game you've got laura roslin who's the political leader you've got soul tie who is the military leader you've got lee adamo who is a pilot you've got cara fraser starbuck who is also a pilot and there's william adama who is a military leader and they're all prominent or semi-prominent characters from the tv show you'll see that each one of these characters has a positive trait and each one of these characters has a negative trait so for instance if you're willing to dharma it says inspirational leader when you draw a crisis card all one strength skill cards count positive for the skill check and his negative ability is he becomes emotionally attached and you may not activate the admiral's cause right you'll also see that you will have some starting cards in the bottom right of the player card so for instance laura roslin will draw three politics cards yellow cards and she'll draw two green leadership cards these are her starting skill cards which we'll get back to in a bit so you'll give the admiral two new tokens and the president will shuffle the quorum deck and draw one quorum card and then depending on how many people are playing a game you'll shuffle a certain amount of you are asylum card you're not a cylon or you are a cylon supervisor cards into a deck you shuffle it and you'll deal one to each player right you will then take some of the base star i don't mind these are they they're more like crappy cardboard tokens you'll dump them on the ball below the galactica you'll put three raiders down there as well these are the immediate threats you're gonna have to face as soon as you start the game yeah so there's loads of other

little fiddly rules that can't be asked to go into all that crap so on your turn you'll follow a certain amount of phases right the first thing you will do is you'll receive your skill cards for that round you'll look at your character cards like you did before during setup and you'll draw that many skill cards and add them to your hand yeah so that's what you could do is you can move you can move to any location on the galactica and if you're moving between the galactica and colonial one you'll have to discard a skill card human players cannot go to the cylon ship right they can't do it yeah so once you have moved or not then you'll get to take a few different actions right there's loads of different actions you can take you can activate your location right so for instance if you find yourself in a press room you'll be able to draw two politics skill cards if you find yourself in the armory you get to attack a centurion on the boarding party track this is a track that's in the top left and side of the board you've got to be careful because you don't want these centurion nuggets trying to worm their way in and steal your vegan breakfast right or if you're in the command space you'll get to activate to unmanned vipers so you can activate the ability on a skill card what you do is choose a skill calf in your hand and you'll put in front of it and you'll do what it says on the card right so for instance if you've got the investigative committee this says play before cards are added to a skill check all skill cards are played face up during the skill check right including the ones from the destiny tag talk about that a little bit right you can look at your character sheet and you'll be able to use the character action that we talked about earlier you'll be able to activate a viper and if you're piloting a viper

which is one of the characteristics of starbuck then you'll be able to move or attack aside on ship right remember we said you've got to be careful of those crappy cardboard tokens right this is how you get rid of them you can use the ability from a title or quorum card so for instance you might have the authorization of brutal force this says destroy three raiders one heavy raider or one centurion then roll a die and if two or less lose one population and discard this card right so a lot of these squirrel cards are useful but there's going to be a little bit of a penalty as well you know what i mean so the next thing you could do is you could reveal your loyalty card and this will reveal to the players whether you are a cylon right so if you reveal your cylon card as an action then you'll have to do the following things you will have to discard down to three skill cards you'll give any title cards to the next player in the line of succession for that title you move your character to the resurrection ship which is the cylon ship that's at the top of the board you'll receive one random super crisis card which may be played by activating the caprica cylon location right reveal cylons don't get any school cards or anything they can only move to cylon locations yeah and you can only perform the action on your location you know what i mean so the next phase of this game once everyone's done all their actions and stuff is the crisis phase this is where those sneaky cylons can really put the knife into your back yeah so you will reveal the top card of the crisis deck there's three types of crisis you've got cylon attacks you've got skill checks and then you've got events as well yeah if it's a cylon

attack then you'll follow the instructions on the card it'll tell you what to place on the board and how far they're moving that sort of stuff so skill checks have a difficulty level that's displayed on a card there'll also be requirements of different cars that have to be played and each player will then donate certain skill cards from their hand in the hope that they can equal or match the requirements of the crisis right you'll also draw two cards from the destiny deck and also add in any cards that the revealed silent players want to use and then you'll shuffle up the deck and one by one you will reveal each card and place it into one or two parts you will place it into a pole that is good for resolving the crisis and one that doesn't resolve the crisis like i said if it's equal to or more than the requirement of the skill check then the players will get a bonus if not they'll get screwed royally so there's also a little bit of combat in this game i'm not going to go into this too much but basically what you're going to do you're going to roll with d8 you're going to consult your combat chart and ships cannot be damaged or destroyed by stars require free damage tokens to be destroyed yes so you've got to be mindful of that it's quite a lot for a crappy carpal token and there's various rules for pilot and vipers blah blah blah blah so the humors will win the game if they successfully jump enough spaces to reach cobol and the silent players will win if one of the four resources is depleted to zero at the end of a player's turn they will lose the game if at least one of the saturian bourne pies reaches the end of the track or if six or more galactica locations have damage tokens on them then the galactica will be destroyed and you will be

flushed down the toilet like a very sloppy turd so what do we like about battlestar galactica the board game so the first thing that we really like about this game is the way that the theme ties in with the mechanics really really well this was one of the first prominent hidden trailer games that built on the success of games like shadows over camelot this took the excellent groundbreaking tv show from the early 2000s and translated into a really exciting intense if not a little bit long ball game right all the characters are accurately represented and have different quirks and attributes that match the characters in the tv show this game does do a really good job of amplifying a sense of paranoia and tension because you never ever know who is going to be the cylon player so you're constantly watching all of your friends and family and if you're a salon they are going to be watching you right so yeah we really like how about this game you're not here so the next thing that we really like about battlestar galactica the ball game is way that the players are not focused on just one portion of the game you've got the political aspects of the game you've got to keep an eye on you've got to keep an eye on the other players you've got to take risks by sending people to the brick and then you've also got the pilots that are useful to nullify the threat of the boarding parties and the base stars and all that sort of thing that can destroy galactica yeah so you're not just worried about that central mechanism of the hidden traitor you've also got threats coming in at all angles like the

resource depletion it's not just a case of putting out fires you've got that sense of paranoia just to stoke those flames you know so the next thing that we really like about battlestar galactica the ball game is the way that the skill checks create that edge of your seat feeling in a ball game this was really quite new for all the time we've not really seen this before in around think that's when it was released let me have a look 2008 right so yeah we've only really seen this in shadows over camelot but this game adds a lot more complexity and it's not just a case of like you're asylum you're not a silence you've also got that solon sympathizer card that can add a little bit of chaos into the mix when you're doing them pesky skill checks yeah i mean the way that the skill checks create that squeaky bum time still quite unrivaled in board games you know so what don't we like about so first thing that we don't like about this game is that it's too bloody long right every time we play this it takes three or four hours and truth be told if i'll be nice we are the first couple of hours are really really exciting but then you start to get that fatigue creeping in and when you feel that the game is more or less lost you do have that sense of what's the point in carrying on with us we aren't going to win we can't win so we're just going to spend the next hour going through the motions and maybe hurrying up the silent victory because you know that you cannot win this game yeah so it's too long and on occasion not every game we played but on occasion this can feel like a lost cause around

halfway through the game you know so the next thing that we don't like about this game is if the cylons reveal early it does put them at an advantage right they're gonna be able to activate all of those lucrative positions on these cylon locations there's a bit of a discussion on you know somewhere it analyzes how much of a disadvantage the human players are in this game i know the general consensus is that one of the expansions i don't know which one sort of fixes this maybe it's the pegasus expansion i can't really remember but yeah if a cylon player chooses to reveal early it does put the human players at a distinct disadvantage and that sucks so the final thing that we don't like about battlestar galactica is it's out of print and it's never coming back this game is never ever coming back well that's not strictly true the mechanics and the rules that have been transplanted out of this one and stuck into some sort of cthulhu on a ship thing that fantasy flyer about to release just after they're making this video i've had enough of [ __ ] cofu right i want to see this game reprinted it's not going to be reprinted and as a result it is going for stupid money on ebay and other price gouging websites yeah like i said we had to pick up the spanish version from amazon we downloaded the vassal module open that up and took all the card scans and printed them off and put them in sleeves we found a board scan we cut out the locations we painstakingly went through every part of this game and pasted it up and changed it so we had a full english copy for around about 25 quid which is a bit of a bargain really but yeah i wouldn't pay the 400 quid asking price that some people are asking for this and that's a

real shame because the theme is unique it blends with the mechanics really really well and i just don't want any more cthulhu crap yeah why fantasy flight decide to paint everything with like a fulu veneer is beyond me and it's starting to do muddy now yeah so i don't know i would have just paid the extra money to try and get devices back but then i don't know it's easy for me to say twiddling my thumbs and playing with my ball bag in here right so to summarize is battlestar galactica the board game worth your time on bother today and in the future so we're going to say maybe maybe not right if you can find a cheap copy or you can be asked to translate a copy like we did or you know somebody that you can steal it from then battlestar galactica is definitely worth your time and bother but if you are looking at ebay or some of the stupid prices on other less reputable websites that we've been banned from then i would say no it's not worth the money i wouldn't recommend this for purely financial reasons because it is out print and it does cost too much money yeah but if you've got a copy then it's definitely worth playing the sense of tension in this game is still unrivaled i haven't played a hidden trait game since this that gives you that sense of tension even though i do prefer shadows over camelot for the simple fact that it doesn't keep you on the edge of your seat all the time yeah but like we said the theme is bolted down really really well this game does fall apart if the cylons reveal too early and it can drag on for a little bit too

long yeah it just feels like you're going through the motions quite a bit if you find a way to cut down on the time length if you can teach this game really easy if everybody comes into this game already knowing the rules then you are sure to have a wonderful time with battlestar galactica and even doubly so if you are familiar with his source material so there you go that's battlestar galactica ball game remember if you're new here then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below hit the like button and all that [ __ ] we'll see you next time

foreign

Progress saved