Small Islands Review
Transcript
hey guys I'm Luke actor and this is the broken me boot giving you another board game reviewer and most of you will probably not have even heard of this one this is probably the definitive of a hidden definition sorry of a hidden gem I found this at the expo from me so games Bert I know that about five or six other publishers have done this as well around the Asian region but this is small islands and I'd never even heard of this game I just saw it on the table at the Mesa game stand and thought well that looks quite pretty and it kind of gives me a kind of Carcassonne vibe I'll have a look at it and see what's what spoiler alert I'm glad I did Wow just to put a little tagline this game is making me question if I want to hang on to Carcassonne it's that oh god yes now I'm not saying like this is like ten out of ten material but in Carcassonne was never that as well but Carcassonne was a tile laying game it's been around since 2000 it's a gateway classic a staple and it's a great one you build up a little map in the communal map you put your guys out in it and you score points this has a very similar type of feel you're putting out tiles except you're building a very pretty like archipelago type location you build up multiple islands and the islands have symbols on them and what you're trying to do is every round you're trying to build islands in such a way with the help or hindrance of other players so that you can score the most points in each round via some objective cards there's a basic way to play the game where the
objectives and the conditions are all on one card but I recommend you just jump straight into the advanced version which has the cards separated out so you have a separate deck of conditions and a separate deck of objectives you always get to pick from free in any given round and you basically go hmm I want to score for the anchor symbols okay but in order to get the condition I could use that one that requires anchor symbols that could work or maybe the condition could be that it has a couple of temples on it well some of those islands have got temples you know what I'll pair that with this and so you can create your own objectives each round but it plays very similar to Carcassonne I mean you have two tiles in your hand always and then you draft one so you draw one from a face up line and then you pick from one of the free to put out onto the board and of course like in Carcassonne it must make sense so Islands connect wire and sea must connect to see etc but here's where the differences start coming in with this one as I say all that they've got various resource symbols and stuff about over the island so the cards that you're trying to achieve in each round based on those symbols so you're trying to I might have a condition that wants me to get ten one not ten sorry lots of dragon fruit on it I forget was Dragon for its star fruit but tons of that on an island so as I'm building an island I'm going all that tiles got some more that fruit okay I'll stick that onto that island and then other players might add to the island because they want to score in it as well and in order to score if you
meet your condition you put a little wooden house on there but there's limited spaces and your island may or may not have a lot of house spaces usually you do but there are big occasions where the island is small enough so that turn order makes a big difference in terms of how great there's only two houses on there and if all of them make the condition I'm not gonna get a place I guess what do i do do I abandon it or do I just Bo hope for the best but on top of that the the way that each round ends is pretty sweet because you you don't end the round after a set number of turns there's a stack next to the face-up line of tiles where you you draw from those first but as soon as that stack runs out somebody can place their ship tile which is another tile that's surrounded by ocean and when they place that they end the round and you go on to an interim scoring phase but you only get one of those in the game and there's maximum four rounds I mean it could end in the third round but most of the time you're gonna end in the fourth round but in doing so you might think right well I've got a good position here I'm going to put my ship next that Island and I'll start with scoring in the first round and that worked out quite well you've now spent your ship tile it's stuck there in the middle which means you can't end the round in a future round somebody else has to end the round so you might be in a position where as I I really don't want everybody else to get loads of points but I now can't stop the round because I've already played my tail was it the right decision to do that in the first round or did I act a bit too prematurely yeah
it's a cool little system but oh my god it's just there's a lot to talk about with this game because it's it sounds like just another Carcassonne clone and it is very similar in some kind of diversion which one I prefer but you know the way that you everybody builds up the islands in different ways you know these these objectives they require different types of islands you might get a can you might get a reward that rewards you for having loads of tiles in one island great I want my Island and huge and grand and like whatever but you're probably only scoring that one island whereas you might think oh hang on this card's giving me bonus points just for having bonus just for having a house down or a discovery token which is like a randomized point thing it's like well as long as I meet the condition I'm getting the reasonable amount so maybe I'll just make a bunch of tiny islands and score each in one of those you know so you've got different tactics at your employee each round depending on which of the objective and can and reward cards that you pick so mechanic wise I really enjoy this and as a bonus you've got a solo mode as well where there's a very well thought-out AI deck of multiple levels of difficulty other than later difficulties I are they even possible but they it makes the AI act in different ways so it tells you where the tile should go based on where you've placed your tile so you have even more tactical choices because you're think well if I place my tile there there's chances are he's not gonna be able to put a tile down so they'll get it and they'll get an extra point the solo mode
works mine in this I have to say but component-wise as I say the box look beautiful as it is the rulebook is easy to understand you know not too complicated but pieces wise yeah I mean you just got like little wooden counters and a few little wooden houses I mean it's very pretty we're not talking stellar but the tiles very nice quality very nice I mean these are quite thick and I can show you better in this camera and I can the other one but you know they've all got this kind of shall we say you know colorful artwork and as you can see there's a space on the right there for how symbol and there's free symbols there but I mean there's all sorts of different ones so like in Carcassonne you know you create all sorts of weird and wonderful like combinations and your islands your map will look different every single game but the graphic design is easy to see you can clearly see what symbols are on these things even at a distance with the camera and like I say and God for autofocus a and you've got a fair amount of these tiles in the box so it's not like you're short on them but you know the box could be a bit smaller that's the kind of thing though because that bit in the middle is complete wasted space I don't even know why the box is this big I think it's just because the rulebook was that big that's cheating you could have made this a lot smaller although if Taiwan wants to make an expansion for this game then by all means please do because I would kill for an expansion for this because it's just a really good gateway level
game I mean would I say its gateway enough yeah I don't think you need to be an avid gamer to understand this build the map collect the symbols and as I said if it's real gateway level you want then just to draw the advanced rules and use the objective cards where they're all printed on the same card so you don't have that extra decision-making to do you just give everybody free objective cards they pick one then you get straight into building the map building the Maps easy you just connect it up so it makes sense you do just telling them that look at the condition on your card what do you need I need two lotus flowers and the temple on the island well great get the tiles that have those symbols and plug them onto the board easy easy easy easy the game doesn't take too long I mean you've usually wrapped this game up in about about an hour you know you could do it in 45 minutes or less even with two players but and so the mode should only take you about half an hour but longest I've had this game go about an hour and a quarter and that was with new players and even I was a bit hazy on the rules and one of those players was a slow player so typically you are looking at a not quite fiddly ball but you're certainly looking at a nice short like game but I'm staggered by how much I enjoyed this one it's weird it's not like it's my best favorite game ever I'm not kind of talking like that but when I fought I'm playing this and I thought this is giving me a similar field of Carcassonne but I think I prefer this I mean try to convince me otherwise I should hang onto Carcassonne as well as this cuz I'm getting rid of this I'm liking this game
I'm keeping it but this was working a game cafe as well you know I mean it's yes it's got all the like Taiwanese writing all over it but I mean it's got English in there so you can easily play this game it's not the language won't be a problem but it's colorful it's pretty it's simple it's got multiple tactical decisions to make it has a solo mode it will take you anywhere between 30 to 60 minutes to play it's easy to teach once you've got the rules in your head teaching this is a breeze it's just a solid gateway game and I like these games where you build a communal map because they just they're so nice they're so like that picturesque they pop on the table and it means that it will look different every single time so as I said this was a hidden gem I didn't even know about this game before the UK games Expo I literally just sort of looked at this and for okay this looked pretty hour I didn't have time to try it the expo but they were kind enough to give me a review copy and I said I'd have a look at it and I'm hooked there's this is an instant into my collection I I do honestly think I dunno Carcassonne with expansions is still good fun but you know that can drag on a bit longer you've got the farms and the more expansions you add the more convoluted it gets but Carcassonne still fun game I'll probably hang onto it but this is really really good I mean I I would love to see expansions for this you know add more tiles give some more interesting stuff to do on the islands perhaps more objective cards you know but I've got a
solo mode here and it's just it's just a very nice pleasing game it's what kind of like that Zen level that I think of without tak you know go but it's just nice pleasant little gateway game I really like it I don't know exactly when outside of the UK games Expo you're gonna get this as a retail release but certainly if you see this on the shelves anytime soon or wherever you are I highly highly recommend you grab this okay I mean like I say there's not like the best game ever but I just think for what it sets out to do it sets out to do it perfectly and I love it I get like booming like this whenever I come across these hidden gems where I'm like I never thought I would like this game or I never expected this game or I'd never even heard of this game let's try it and then you find a classic this has you know I mean I could honestly if this was a like American release or something of that I could see there's been a spill to yaris like nominated it's that kind of family way category that I think would work well so yeah small islands for me gets a high level eight rating it is a really decent game you know I I will bring this out every now and again you know and certainly enjoy playing it doesn't take too long I reckon I could teach my parents this as an alternative to Carcassonne but yeah solid eight this is definitely a game you should look out for if tilemap building is your thing and you want something that's maybe a bit different from Carcassonne but still family weight level definitely check out small islands so that's it for
me I'll see you on the next broken me pool review and hopefully I've got a couple more you know Taiwanese games to review so you know if you're looking for something a bit more different and unique from the typical norm then you can look forward to some more reviews coming in the near future so that's it for me take care and remember regardless of whether your Island's big or small or you've way too many lotus flowers on my Island for my liking it's still only a game take care and I'll see you on the next review you