Dragons of Etchinstone: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And today I'm going to be doing a discussion over The Dragons of Etchinstone. This is the solo palm game designed by Chip Theory Games. Um, where you play in the palm of your hand, but as you can see, I was playing on the table. uh where the entire goal is for you to pick one of four dragons once you have the expansion. Um and you're trying to go through four regions to end up amassing enough strength to defeat the dragon that you have chosen to go against. Um now a couple caveats to this to this whole discussion. One, uh this is only over the base game. I'm not covering the siege expansion or the north veil expansion. I think that's what it's called. Um, and there's a couple reasons for that which I'll get to in a sec. Um, is it North Veil? Yes, it is North Veil. Uh, second, I wasn't even sure I was going to cover this game at all. Mainly because whenever I had seen that they were making this, I had checked out any type of preview that I could. Uh, luckily OneTop Co-op Shop had a cover of it and I was like, "This is not a game for me at all." Um, and tip typically, I mean, I don't shy away from negative reviews at all uh, for that. But, uh, I don't like to go out of my way to pick games that I know I'm not going to like just
to then [ __ ] on them uh, because I knew I wasn't going to like them. Uh, but a friend of mine had this game. uh he liked it and I was like, "Ah, sure, why not?" I mean, I know what I'm getting into. Mindset and everything. Uh it plays a huge factor into your game. If you go in expecting not to like it and you're probably not going to like it. Um but I was like, "Okay, this is the kind of game it is. I'll go ahead and still give it a shot." Uh unfortunately, I was not swayed. I really, really do not like this game. Uh, this is just going to be one of those games that isn't for me. Um, so if you're coming in expecting me to sing its praises, you're not going to get that. Um, I mean, the positives that this game has going for it can kind of alleviate a lot of the negatives, but first and foremost, I thought we were done with Palm games because I I feel like there's not that many out on the market because they're just always kind of a pain to play. Uh, the only other Palm game that I have played, which I don't have in my collection anymore because I never took it with me anywhere, uh, was Palm Island. And that was kind of a a resource management uh, like settlement kind of game that you play in your hand.
And at first it was like, "Oh, this is gimmicky. Cool. You could you can it comes with a little travel thing you can put in your pocket. You can stick it in your wallet. You can play it on the go." Um, I never [ __ ] did that. We have cell phones. Like it's just like if I have 10 or 15 minutes to spare, it's not to fiddle around with a bunch of cards in my hand that they could I can drop them or anything like that. I'm just going to get on my phone and doom scroll. That might just be a generational thing. This game, I think, suffers from the exact same issue. The palm element is still very annoying in my opinion. It's I mean is it serviceable? Sure. I think it works best if you are at home playing uh where you can just if you drop them it's not that big of a deal but I I don't expect this I mean maybe on a plane like if you're traveling with it.
It's just if I ever went to any type if I was at like the DMV or something and someone popped this out and was like playing it I'd be like oh Jesus Christ. Like if I went with with my friend who likes this and we were trying to kill time and he pulled this out to play a game, just get like I seventh grade bully him, knock him out of his hands and watch him pick it up. Um like get that [ __ ] out of here. Uh but I mean in terms of like the actual way the the the palm effects work, like they do a decent job. Like you have like all your cards that you know they're they're all relatively the same type of cards. So you have you have your your hand or you have your deck and then you have the region that's in front of it and then you draw like your four cards. And so this is like what it's supposed to be.
Um whenever it's in your hand, your entire deck, the region you're battling um and then you have your hand of cards. So you're you have four hands of cards. Then you like slide the top one down to see what you're going up against. In this case, it's a one journey. I'm in region four, so I have to go against this and then you try and match that with the four cards in your hand. Um, I find this to be again kind of cumbersome because you have to sit here and it's not like you can do much with this. I mean, I guess you could sit here and just look at it and be like, "Okay, I'm going to use this one as my reserve, this one as my actual uh actual card, this one is going to be my enhancement, and this is going to be my boost." And then just leave it at that. But obviously they want you to use both hands to be like, "Okay, I'm attacking this one. I'm gonna use this red to enhance that to make it a 14 attack.
This is a 10 uh this is a 10 initiative and I'm going to use this boost as a four. So I definitely kill him and then I'll rotate this one." You know, it's you're still messing with it. I don't know. like I I find these games to just still be kind of annoying to play overall. Um, so the palm effects I I and and to be fair, whenever you get to the final boss, which is the dragon, when you go and actually get to the dragon, you're drawing seven cards and you're making So I like in a in a regular encounter, you have four cards and one is like your reserve. So, you're using three cards as like your attack. In the final encounter, whenever you're fighting the dragon, you're drawing seven cards and you're making two sets.
So, you have to manage. You have to sit there with I have four cards. Uh, so you have to sit there with seven cards and be like, "Okay, so this is going this is going here. This is going right here. Um, and okay, which one is my Okay, so this one's gonna be my reserve. And so here's my first three. Okay, so that's over here. Um, uh, okay. So now I'm gonna do the same thing over here. And, and this one's my attack. And this one's this one's going there. Okay. So now here are my two sets of and it's not like you can fan them to where I mean I guess actually I guess you could do that but it'd be easier if they like slid up or they did some cool thing where you could put them diagonal and not cover the numbers but you're just sitting here with seven cards and it just feels so cumbersome. I know Siri. Uh but yeah, this this just I mean I would much rather never play this in my palm and uh and just play it on a table, which is how I was playing it. So then we come to the actual gameplay. I I despise it.
Everything about this game I find to be extremely extremely random. Um where you have virtually no agency. I've tried this game multiple times and it was the the issues I had with it just always kept, you know, arising. And that's the fact that you you essentially have two stats that you that you manage, attack and movement, because you will only ever be attacking or moving. So, your region card has one of four um possible enemies to fight and one of four uh terrains to traverse. It's just it's way too random for for me. Some people might like it. Some people might like that that element of like, oh, drew my cards. But I mean, I can't tell you how many times I drew my hand and then slid the like slid the thing down and it was like, "Oh, okay. It's a travel card. I only have attack cards in my hand. Cool." So, literally can't use those for anything.
But you can divert. you can sit there and you have to discard one of your four cards to so now you're down an option because the reason why you have four and use only three is to give you some agency and it's not so it's like okay cool I have you know two sets to enhance my cards but it's literally like I mean if if like let's say this was my my hand here and it's like okay cool I have only attack cards in my hand like I have a 14 attack, seven attack, and 10 attack and one movement. Okay. Well, the card that is at the top, the key card is a one movement, which is a 14 is my is my option. I I clearly can't get that. Oh, and it's it's uh um treacherous. So, cool. That's neat. Well, okay. I'm hoping the next card the next key card is another is an attack cuz then I can actually fight whatever is going to come up. So, I'll get rid of the movement card, put that in the back, and discard the key card. And okay, cool. It's a two. It's a two travel. So, now it's a 13 move. Literally still can't do it.
And I guess I'm going to lose time. Now, the journey is actually not that bad. Uh, unless it's like hazardous or something or or a storm where it could be like, hey, if you take the time penalty, you also take damage, which is just a a double combo. They try to uh mitigate some of that by if you can if you can get a enhanced movement uh for like the train because there's four different types of ether I think is what they're called. Um like if I can get a boostment boostment a boost enhanced movement of like purple ina in this case then the reserve card also adds its boost makes it a little bit easier but that doesn't matter if you literally don't draw any movement for that and then if you even if you try to divert by getting rid of one of your four cards oh I drew into another journey so cool now I lost time I can't even try and get a partial success where I still get the XP I just still lose lose the time as well. I just outright lose. So, I actually just lost time. And then cool. So, now like these cards go away and then you draw a whole new set.
And then you're like, "Okay, cool. I got my new hand." And uh oh, they're all movement and cool. It's a level three attack and I have no uh I have no attack now to even fight this thing. And it's just it it happens so often that it's it's infuriating. At least to me it was um just because like and there are some cards like I mean mainly purple uh not mainly only purple and not even every single purple that can be used for an attack or a movement. Um but you have to hope to draw into them. Um, and you have to hope the other randomness is every card can be enhanced.
And this could be neat, I think, like if if you had um if if it was used in a in a different game, but the fact is like, okay, to get my purple nine, cuz right now this adapt card just does six damage by itself, and you can just play it for that, but you really want to try and enhance it. So to enhance it, I need a purple a purple card. So okay, luckily I have one. Cool. So I can use this purple to actually make this a nine on top of the fact that I have this four here that I can use as my boost. So that would be a 13 to attack, which I mean in in region four that could that would kill uh two of the two of the enemies. So, not only is it completely random on whether or not you're attacking or or journeying, it's random on the cards you're getting. And then even if you have a good hand, this was kind of an, you know, an additional element of randomness, even if you get the cards that you have like, okay, cool. I have a bunch of movement cards. Sweet. and then you draw into a into a movement like as the key card, you're like, "Sweet, I can actually do that." And then you look at the number and it's like, "Oh, okay.
Well, that's a 14. I can only get to 12." Which again, you still will get the XP. You'll just also lose the time. But you might not even get that because sometimes you'll draw into a hand that can't enhance each other. So, you're just like, "Oh, all right. Well, this is just a complete wash. I I mean, chances are you'll probably be able to get half like because you can still boost it. So, like you're most likely going to be always getting partial successes, but it's like very rarely are you getting actual successes um at least in the later game because whenever you I mean, like I said, the journey just causes you to lose time and the way you move on in regions is whenever you see the dragon card, like when you cannot when there's not five cards left. So, the losing time causes the deck to go by quicker. Therefore, you don't have enough time to upgrade your cards. The less time you have to upgrade your cards, the less likely you are going to do any good. Like, if you're basically if you don't succeed really well in regions one and two pretty much, you should just reset because it's just not it doesn't there's no fail for it's not going to cascade into something better because it just gets harder and it's also more random so therefore it's harder. Um, but but yeah, so I mean like that's e that it's just so infuriating to me to
sit here and draw a new hand and be like, "Okay, cool. I got my higher level cards. Awesome. And I can't use them. All right, neat." Uh, now I know I mentioned I wasn't covering the expansions. Um, but I know the Siege expansion doesn't have any of the journeying. It's all combat. Um, that's all I've kind of looked at is there's no journey phase. It's just I think you still use movement for stuff, but it's mainly attacking. Uh, that would be to me that would just be better. But I'm not This game is not for me. So, I'm not even going to try the expansions cuz even if the expansions enhance the game, I still don't really like its core system, which is the the deck element, cuz it's still going to come down to randomness of of drawing.
Now, when you do succeed, uh, or even partially succeed, because also whenever you're being attacked, uh, which I think is the better part of the game, I think the journeying really just needs to be completely removed. Um, I could have handled the combat because the combat still has some element of a puzzle to it. The journeying doesn't really. [snorts] Um, but whenever you attack something, let's say it's a one, like it's an it's a skull one with no modifiers, it's like, okay, cool. Uh, we'll just do region region one just to make things easier. Um, because none of them have any modifiers. Uh, it's like, okay, if it's if this it's skull one, then that means it's this red panda guy. He has seven health, eight initiative, one attack, and uh, one one defense of a particular ether. Now, this part isn't terrible. You look at your hand and you're trying to figure out, okay, I have well, in this case, I only have movement, so again, it would just be a complete crap. Actually, it wouldn't because I do have a nine attack.
Now, these wouldn't be up in region one. They wouldn't be level threes and and fours and stuff, but uh the puzzle is you look at your hand of cards and you're like, "Okay, I can't beat his initiative." So, because there's two types of way, the two ways you're going to get attacked. Early damage and then consequential damage. Early damage is is basically if you don't um beat their initiative. And then it's based off if you actually defeat him or not because there's no health managing or anything like that. But if you're sitting here like, okay, I can do nine damage with the cards in my hand because this is a nine and I can put this uh ether or this enhancer behind it to give it the purple nine. So, I already can kill him cuz that's nine damage over his seven health. Okay, that's neat. So, which card do I want in my reserve and which one do I want in my boost?
Well, the enhanced card is actually what you use for your initiative. Right now, it's five to eight. All right. Well, I actually have this card that gives me plus three. So, I can actually just hold on to my level four card and do this card as a plus three. use it on my boost because no matter what I'm gonna kill him, so I'll just go faster than him and therefore I'm not going to suffer early damage. That's the puzzle. And when whenever that works, it's like, okay, neat. Um, and then you just look at the XP that you get and you just assign it to the cards. Each card you look at has its value of XP on the bottom, and you could spend that as you see fit. You can uh level up multiple cards. you can level up the same card a couple times.
Uh the only restriction is if you take damage and you downgrade a card, you can't upgrade the card you just downgraded. So the extra element of a puzzle is the type of attack you're doing. Because if you're attack because it's defense has uh you know a particular ether. In this case, it's yellow. So, if you attack with a yellow um attack, then its defense is going to kick in. But then the opposite goes for you. So, for example, if he was to let's say I I couldn't kill him or he was doing early damage, he would do one damage back to me. Now, no matter what, you have to take the damage. Even if like, so it's one damage. Okay, I can. You look at the shields and it's like, all right, I'll just downgrade this two down to a one.
But if you have a shield that matches its attack, then it accounts for double. So this three shield, three yellow shield would would block six, which would be complete overkill, but that can matter depending on uh you know cuz that that would double if you didn't defeat him and it got early damage, which would just be two in this case. But it can add up to where it's like, okay, if it was, let's say, a three attack and you're getting attacked both ways, that would be six. Therefore, this yellow shield would count to block both of those and it would just get downgraded from a three to a two. And then you discard all the cards. The attacks work pretty much the same way as the journeying in that if you outright kill him, then besides if uh early damage, then you don't suffer any penalties. If you only get half its health, then you still take the damage, but then you still get the XP.
And if you don't get half its health, then you don't get anything, but you still take the damage. Uh the combat whenever that lines up, you know, is is way more interesting than the journey part. Again, it's just so unfortunate that half the time you're playing when you're at the higher regions. Like regions one and two is a nice sweet spot of like, oh, okay, yeah, that that one that kind of stung, but you know, I still got partial. uh it's not so high that me downgrading a card, I still get to upgrade a few cards. Uh that's fine. Then it's into regions three and four that you're just really feeling the the randomized the randomization and the of of the previous regions. So that whenever you're journeying or attacking any anytime you get into a combat and then you draw and you're like, "Okay, well I got one four and then two twos and then my one." So Oh, and it's it's it's a four attack and he has, you know, poison and an ambush. So neat. I guess that's just that's just a huge loss right there. [snorts] Um I I just I I cannot I can't I hate it. I hated it so much every single time. And I mean and the problem is is like I won more often than I lost. And I just I still did not have a good time.
But the only saving grace that I can give this game for me is I actually like the final fight the jur and like and which is interesting because as me as like a person for books, shows, movies, video games, you have to stick the landing. Otherwise, it doesn't matter what the journey is. If if your destination sucks ass, then it was all for not. Take Game of Thrones for example. It's like, "No, seasons one through four, they're so good." Yeah, except the ending and that's all people remember. Um, and but even with this game, I I did like the final fight. I just I hated everything on getting up to it. Um cuz the final fight again is still interesting. It actually it it's one and done. Like there's no health, there's no back and forth. It's basically it it feels more fair than the oneoffs that you get. Now, of course, every everything you go up against, the journeying, the time delays, or the attacking, and the partial success or full success, that's all going to come back to bite you or help you final fight. But what's neat, well, one, the dragons look badass. Uh the art um what what there is of it is really good. Um but yeah, the dragons look awesome. But whichever one you pick, which there are four of in the game, they have, you
know, varying combinations of and you know, difficulties. Like Roding is the one that you go up against first. He has nine initiative, nine um nine attack, and four defense. Uh and then you know Verhost is 13 initiative, eight attack, four defense and one defense. So he has multiple types of defenses and the other two have increasing uh you know initiatives and health and all that. So it's uh it gets incredibly more difficult. But what's really cool is you have a final journey and you have a final uh final fight where you take seven cards. Um one, two, three, four, five, six, seven. So you take seven cards and you can actually mulligan your seven. You discard one card and then you shuffle the other six back in two. And the shuffling whenever you have to go from region to region again makes me think who's playing like the palm thing doesn't work now that you have to set cards aside to then shuffle them. But anyway, so you can actually look at and be like, "Oh [ __ ] Okay, I'm in the journey phase. I got all my attack cards." So yeah, I'm going to discard this card and then shuffle the other six into the deck and then get the other ones back. Now you only have six cards instead of seven, so you have to make do with the six you got, but you can still mulligan.
But whenever you're looking at the journey phase, it's basically like let's just do Verhost is like now it's kind of a threshold or it's it's a it's not really a step-by-step thing, but it's like these are your milestones. So you take like I mentioned earlier, you are making two sets of whatever of of three cards and you're adding them together. So it's like, okay, cool. I got 14 movement here um with with a boost of one. So that's 15. And then hypothetically, let's just say I got 10 here with a boost of three. So 14 + 1 15 + 10 25 + 3 28. And then you compare that to the highest one you got here. And it's like oh okay sweet. So I got and then if you actually happen to manage the boot with again same with journey rules. Oh cool. I did get a boot um of the color here. So now you actually add the reserve boost there. So I got 23 meaning that I am getting a two delay penalty instead of what could have been a three delay or four delay. Um, then you discard all the cards that you just used and you draw a whole new hand of seven.
And then you do the exact same thing with attack where you take both sets, combine their initiatives to compare to its initiative. And if you don't meet it, then he does an attack uh an early damage. And then you uh add up both the attacks to compare to its health over here. So if you do basically the worse you do the more damage he's going to do back to you that you have to absorb. So if you get high like in this case Verhost his highest is 29. So if you can get 29 attack then he's only doing 13 damage and you just have to out of all seven cards have to absorb 13 damage. And if you do, you win. But then you also have to take into account if either of your attacks in this case are yellow, uh, then he will absorb four damage. And it's not for both. It's just if even if both your attacks were yellow, he's only still absorbing the four. But if you have an attack that's yellow and attack that's red, he's going to absorb four and one. So, he would absorb five total damage, which would subtract. Let's say you had 32 and you're like, "Yes, I got over 29, but one of your attacks was yellow." Then you're at 28. Therefore, you don't meet the 29 threshold and you go to 21 and you now have to absorb 20 damage. I know I'm pointing to it like you can [ __ ] see it. But then out of all seven cards, you rotate or you can just add up all your defense and sit there and be like, "And ah [ __ ] I only have 19 defense." And then you that then
you lose or but if you if you get 20 or you get more than 20 then you win. The reason why I like the final fight is just because it almost absolves itself of the randomness. you know, you're going to I mean, yes, you're still drawing from your deck of of whatever that you've leveled up and [ __ ] but chances are you're not going to draw all attack cards on the journey phase, and you're not going to draw all journey card, movement cards on the attack phase. So, you have your whole hand of seven to mix and match and be like, "Oh, I'm in the attack phase. Cool. Now I can use this journey card, this movement card as the colored enhance card for my attack. And it's just it it it works a lot better in the final fight just because you have way more mitigation. Um uh and and even then it's not an all or nothing. Like it's not like you go up against Verhos and it's like oh you need 25 movement that's it. like it's you you can you still get something. Oh, hey, I didn't get 25. I got 21. So, that's three delay versus uh then the attack is like you can even look at your entire hand of seven and be like and count up the defense except for the reserve card and be like, how much defense do I have?
Can I even absorb [clears throat] any of this? Um, and then try and play around with I mean if you have a really high attack card like Oh man, I have a really high uh or I was going to say orange actually. I don't even think that might be the highest on orange would be a 10, but uh cuz each each color has like their strengths and weaknesses and they tell you what what that is in the in the rule book. Yeah, I think yellow would be the highest attack. So, you would need like this reign of blood level four as a 14. Um, which you could use this red movement. If you happen to draw Burning Bridges and get Reign of Blood in your hand, you can be like, well, I don't need the seven movement anymore, so I can get the 14 attack. Cool. Yeah, it's a 14 attack minus one because of it shield, but still I can absorb that um because he's quick. He's just he's not uh so 13 might be hard to beat. So the eight damage getting added on might still be a lot, but your shields count for double if you have yellow shields.
So hey, cool. That my fleet footed that I have, that's a yellow shield. So his yellow eight attack I can absorb with just this one card. Again, I think the seven the seven cards for the final five for both the journey phase [cough] and [clears throat] the attack just works so much better. that actually I see the puzzle um that they're throwing into this game. It's just unfortunate that you go through the four regions. And and that's the thing is like if this was like two regions and then the final fight, I would probably give it a a bit of a pass. But four regions starts to get really tedious to me as well. It's kind of like uh okay, the cards aren't interesting enough.
Like they're just higher numbers. are still random. So, who knows if I'm even going to get to use this when I wanted to. Uh, and sure, now I'm in region three and doing the same thing. So, yeah, it just it it didn't work for me. I know the North Veil expansion adds like unique mages that I um from what I was reading because I I was thinking about play, you know, playing this game with the the expansion just to give it give it another shot, but I just could not muster the energy to to try and play this again. Um but I think the North Veil modifies a set like a color set with special abilities. So, like what I was just saying about the four random or the four regions being very tedious, it's like, well, at least the cards will now have special powers. Uh, and then the siege expansion, from what I understood, gets rid of the journeying and is just kind of like almost a tower defense kind of thing, which again gets rid of my issue with the journeying, but I I just don't think it's worth. And I think you still do a final fight. So, so maybe maybe those expansions would actually make me like the game. The problem is I've also heard that which again kind of works is that the Siege expansion pretty much makes it unwieldable in the Palm, which I don't even like playing
this as a Palm game. [snorts] So yeah, I mean maybe the expansions would make me like this game, but I don't know. I I don't really care enough to actually try that. Um, so yeah, that's that's that's my my thoughts on Dragons of Etch and Stone. If you like the games that I like, this one might be one to avoid, but um I mean some people I mean you might this might be right up your alley. On a scale of 1 to 10, um, man, I really don't like most of of this game. Um, I mean, again, it's it's a probably I don't remember how much this game cost.
I know I feel like it was relatively cheap uh to with this and then the two expansions and stuff, but um it's good production. It's easy to play. Like, it's easy to learn, easy to play. You're not going to be struggling to figure it out. Uh, the final fight is good. I'll go with a five. Yeah, like I want to say four cuz I really don't like most of this game. It was just frustrating every single time. I mean, the the partial success by still letting you upgrade, uh, you're almost I mean, very rarely are you very rarely are you outright succeeding, but you're also very rarely outright failing where it's like, I got nothing. I'm just getting I'm only lo I'm only losing cards or I'm only downgrading cards. That also rarely happens. So, you're at least able to be like, "Okay, I can't kill this thing, but I can at least get half its health.
So, I'll take the damage, but then I can upgrade some of my cards." So, you're still making some slight progress, and then maybe later you can outright kill something uh or outright journey. So, then the card that you downgraded, you can actually upgrade back. Um, it might all come out in the wash. It just doesn't feel good. So, I'll put this at a straight five, but it's definitely one of those games that I will Luckily, it's solo, so no one's going to be asking me to play it. Uh, I'll I'll never never touch this game again. Um, except right now, I just did. But yeah, that's it. That's my thoughts on Dragons of Etchin Stone. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Uh, and like, comment, share, and subscribe. And have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.