Skip to main content
Loading video...

TDG: Space Empires: Close Encounters

Transcript 20:27

Hello and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, I once started a band called 999 megabytes. We haven't had a gig yet. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Space Empires Close Encounters.

no heat.

Heat. Hey, Heat.

All right, ladies and gentlemen. Space Empires Close Encounters of the Nerd Kind. This is an expansion to Space Empires 4X. Space Empires 4X is a great game. We reviewed that recently. Don't you love Space Empires 4X?

A fantastic game.

It is. It's great. It's got the exploration. It's got the extermination. It's got the exploitation. And it's got the expansion.

Yes,

it's got everything. Anyway, I really love Space Empires 4X. Well, uh so years ago when I was uh writing uh for uh the newspaper, uh GMT sent me my very first review copy of Space Empires 4X. I loved it. Not long after, I went out and I bought the expansion, Close Encounters, uh for Space Empires. I never played it. I never played it with the expansion. I just never got into the expansion for various reasons. Um, recently the good people at GMT Games sent me Space Empires and all the expansions. We'll be reviewing the others later. Um, but I was really excited because it kind it finally gave me a chance to play Close Encounters. Uh, and we have actually played it twice with Close Encounters.

Now, we played a cooperative version the other night. We played um a competitive version tonight. And I'm going to tell you right now, we're going to look at this more as an impressions video because there is still so much stuff in this expansion we really haven't touched, right? We we there there's there's a lot here. But first of all, um you have achievement cards in this expansion. And the achievement cards essentially everybody gets two. You pick one and these are kind of like permanent perpetual um advantages you get during the game. Um this comes with ground forces. You can actually use uh military ground forces to conquer um colonies and send these forces down with transports and send them down to the gown to the ground and take them out. Uh you actually when you take out alien ships you find at barren worlds uh you can actually get alien technology cards that will help you.

There is um experience. Your ships can actually gain experiences. They they can be skilled veteran elite. They start out green but you got militarymies or technology you can do. You can build up um golly. What else has this one got? This is Oh, it's got the It's got the uh um

industries

in you can build industrial centers that will give you um command I think industries give you command points

the CPS and then you've got research points and that's kind of and you have to play with kind of a different uh ch different sheet because they it works differently. You can only convert was it 15

yes

CPS to research under those circumstances and then you got to make up the rest with your your research. So it's a very kind of different way to approach that. Uh, also too, your home planets, instead of starting out with 20 CP, they start out with 30 CP, which is another kind of big um idea. You've also got these fleet cards that you can have so that they are um you can actually just kind of put a marker on the board for one of those and you put your entire fleet on there, which is really cool. Um, so there's that. You've got this uh kind of command board. It's almost like an access and allies command board, but it can mark ship experience, too. So you can keep track of experience as you play through it. Gosh, is there anything else? Am I missing anything?

Uh, for the most part, I think that's pretty much the most of the stuff that we've covered.

Yeah, I I think

that we've hit up.

Yeah, I I I there there's probably some more stuff here, but what's nice here is all these rules are modular. They're optional. You can play with what you want and not, you know, you don't have to plug everything in uh at the [snorts] same time.

So, let me go ahead and start with you, Ray. uh just just what are your what are your thoughts and and about some of these specific ideas here in Close Encounters?

So, first off, what I want to say is one of my favorite things about this expansion is it's almost 100% modular.

Right. Right. Right.

So, if you want an easy game, just put one or two things in. As you everything's get going, then it's going to get a little bit harder um and a little more difficult and it's going to take a little bit longer and more depth. That's what I really like is there. This game does it go this expansion adds so much depth. Um, some of the things that I really really like, um, I like the alien technology cards, the alien technology deck. So when you when you go take out those aliens, you're it's there's more advantageous to do that rather than

there's an incentive to do. Yeah. Okay.

And and you know, it's it's two because it's kind of difficult to take those barren worlds in the deep space anyway. And now there is the the incentive more than just colonizing it.

Oh, totally. Totally.

Um, I I really do like uh these cards here, the

the achievement card. Not achievement cards. Advantage cards. Yes, the Empire Advantage cards. I really like those. Although I don't think the balance is quite quite right.

So, we this game we're playing, this game we're playing, I had the Immortals.

Uh, I got two cards. I had I had one race that could colonize asteroids. I was thinking about that, but I just thought this card is too good. Why don't you tell them what this card does? That card sucks. So, the immortals is actually really, really super tough because every round of combat you can ignore one hit. So, if you are playing the immortal race, you want to just get a couple forces out there and just go just just go attack your enemy as fast as you can. Get to them as fast as you can because chances are they have not built up their forces and there's absolutely no way they can stop you.

Yeah.

Because if you only have two ships there, you're going you have to hit with both ships.

Yeah.

Just to take out one of theirs because they're instantly going to ignore it. Um if you only got one ship, they just take it out.

Yeah.

There's no

Yeah. can't you can't like like the the aliens um with the immortals, you can just go in and pretty much just win because they can't take you out. You can ignore they can't retreat whereas, you know, your opponent can retreat has the option to retreat, which is probably the wise move.

Um but yeah, it's it's OP. Honestly, I don't know that I'll play with this card again because it is so OP.

Um now, what did your card do? What did your empire do?

So, my card basically just gave me uh uh cloaking.

And what does cloaking do? Cloaking. Normally, uh, once you get the cloaking technology, you build your raiders, your raiders are going to have cloaking, but it's only for the raiders. Well, what cloaking is going to do is when you get cloaking level one, you can actually use it for your destroyers and your CAS.

Yeah.

Um, and your scout ships.

Um, so basically, you're using it for your regular ships as well. And all that does is when you enter combat for the first round of combat, you get to basically fight as an A. You're basically attacking first for the most part. Yeah.

And then you go back to your normal attack um level wherever you're at. So, not nearly as powerful as that of mortals. Uh, but to me, it's

I mean, if you there's technologies that will do the same thing as that, not yours.

I get that. I still It's It's kind of a first strike card, right? You know,

it is. I mean, it's it's it's cool that they do that. I I really like how they do that, you know, just like there's some others that uh you're a combat oriented uh squad. So, if you initiate combat, you always get a plus one to your attack roll.

Is that That's the warriors.

The warriors. Yeah. But if you're the defenders in combat, you get a minus one on all your attacks. So basically, you almost want to just retreat and then next turn just you go re-engage combat.

You're the one that wants to attack all the time.

Yeah. So every those those cards really make you change your gameplay. And I do like that. It's like when the Immortals came out, I had to instantly change my strategy and go 100% defense. I had to build up my defenses really hard so that he could only hit my ships on ones and twos. Yeah.

Um but then I had to try to build ships up and I just couldn't build them up fast enough.

Yeah. Um we we we were playing the other night where we were doing the um cooperative. We're actually playing a cooperative game here against the and we kind of we kind of screwed some things up early. It didn't go very well. But um I know in that one we had we had we were doing the um the research facilities.

Yeah.

We [snorts] kind of screwed up on that initially too. But uh I know it's it you were getting the free free ground forces and so I was building up green for green ah

green land forces. I was looking forward to kicking some alien butt with my land forces. We never actually got to that. So we actually haven't engaged in ground combat yet in any of the games we've played.

But um I'm looking forward to it because that that looks like it's another great way to kind of take out your enemy's colonies. And this one I just bombarded the hell out of your colony.

Oh, you just Yeah.

You just destroyed it.

Yeah. What did you think of experience? What's your thoughts on experience?

Uh, so the the experience is it's unique. So the experience is I mean you're basically starting off as a green. Okay. And unless you take the military academy um and and then you can then I think you start one level up, isn't it?

Yeah. For every time for the first two militarymies uh you you do you move up to either I think you move up to skilled and then veteran I think is what what it is.

And then but but you you can gain experience by destroying ships. So, as you destroy shifts and what you have to do is you have to take what is it double their hole size and you have to roll under that 10 and then you can go up. Um, it's it's cool. I do like that because if you are one or two levels more experience than your opponent, you're just going to get more attack die or plus one on your attack, maybe some some other advantages.

Yeah, definitely get some other advantage. Uh, if you get high enough, then your your maintenance cost goes down.

[clears throat]

Um, the only thing I don't like about it is it's a lot more bookkeeping that you have to do because that one group or that one fleet's going to have that advantage. Yeah.

But then you got to remember, okay, so when I'm doing my bookkeeping for maintenance, okay, this one I don't have to pay for. And you're already constantly flipping all the time trying to figure what everything is. And that's and that and I got to tell you, as much as I love this game, and I do love this game, I don't mind the bookkeeping, but it it does kind of accumulate after a while when you throw in a lot of the new stuff is you're you're you're kind of there's there's there's there's more downtime as you're trying to figure stuff out, you know, and okay, what's what have I got here and what have I got here and

what is this going to cost me? And, you know, so so there's a little bit more of that, which is not a huge drawback for me. It certainly doesn't kill my enthusiasm for the game, but it's there, you know, it's it's part of the game. Um, so yeah, I I kind of felt I kind of felt like skill and or the uh experience is interesting. I'm kind of looking forward to to to to exploring that more maybe in future games. Um, I don't know that I'm completely sold on it yet. Sometimes there's something to be said for a little more simplicity because you already have

technologies of attack and defense and and the tactics which manipulate that too. At least, you know, let let you go first and stuff.

Well, and then if you get something like your Immortals or you're a warrior clan. Yeah.

I mean, you're you're pushing that combat. I mean, you're you already have the advantage of combat, right? So, if you go in and just take out the smaller groups, then you're just going up so much faster. And then once you climb the ranks, you get elite and legendary on that track.

Yeah.

It's really hard to take. It gets to the point where your race becomes so powerful that it's it's almost impossible to touch.

Yeah. Yeah. Certainly the terrible ifs accumulate and you can you can be very very powerful here.

Um, so I like that. Now, there's also too one other thing we we haven't really played with yet is one they have boarding parties. And I actually with my race, I specifically cannot do boarding parties, but it's a technology and you can build boarding ships that when you're in combat when they attack an enemy ship, they actually turn that ship into their own ship, which again is something that's pretty cool and it kind of again it goes deeper into what you would expect from,

you know, an actual naval space combat scenario there, right? So that's that's pretty cool as well. Maybe something we'll see in the future. So, let me just ask you kind of overall uh as an expansion. Do you do you like what this brings to you? Do you think it's too much? Do you think you'll be playing with stuff here and there? Do you think you'd prefer to play without it? What is your thinking?

So, I I really like I really like this expansion, but for me, there's only one or two things that I think I want to play with.

What's that?

Personally, it's Well, um I I like the Alien Technology cards.

Yeah.

Okay. That definitely for sure. And then the fleet boards is nice, but you can theoretically you can do that in just the core game itself,

right?

Um and I think I I want to explore more on the the the the military

and and the skilled. I want

the the experience, you mean?

Yeah. On the experience. I want to see how that goes.

Now, the uh

advantage cards.

Advantage cards. I like them.

I'm not 100% sold on them just because I think some are I I think I think they can really shift the game in the favor of one or another. Yeah, I'm thinking I think that's my biggest problem. I I need to get more familiar with the deck and

kind of take some of the OP cards out right now. Didn't you say you said something you saw something about the designer was talking about uh issues of um

balance? I I I I saw I saw a thread that he was talking about on BG and it looked like it was a thread that was just talking about just different balance. People can give their suggestions on balancing stuff. Now, take in consideration there's two more expansions after this one. And if any of those balance issues come out in those expansions, I don't know.

Yeah.

Now, this is the latest printing of the game. So, and I didn't see when the thread came out compared to when this came out to see if this would have had any of that stuff in there.

Right. Right.

But that's something I want I want to look into because I'm I'm really curious about that. I like to see how balance plays out. And I'm I'm one of those guys when I play a game, I like I like to see good balance in a game and if stuff's super unbalanced, that kind of skews me a little bit,

right? So, for me personally, I'd like this expansion, but I would almost play with one or two pieces of it.

Yeah.

And just the core game.

I agree. I don't think I would dump everything in a game. It to me that would just be overload. Uh, I think for me, uh, like you say, the the Alien Technology cards, like I say, I I do I do like the asymmetry that the Empire Advantage cards come, but I might want to callull that deck a little bit and see if, you know, all the ones that are maybe a little too OP, maybe take them out because it just seems like, you know, halfway through the game because you reveal these at certain times and if you're playing a game and it's like reveal in combat and you see that other person has just this major powerful card, you're probably not going to want to. I mean, it changes the game and it may not it may not be a game you want to play anymore.

Oh, yeah.

Um, so there so there is that aspect to it. But I agree. I like

So I like the alien technology cards like these. Experience is something I'm willing to go I'm actually really looking forward to the um maybe playing with ground forces. Yeah, I I want to see because there's several like you got your marines and you got your infantry. But the other thing I was going to I forgot it comes with a bunch more counters. So you have more of the counters which is actually really nice as well. So you can get bigger fleets. I know you have, you know, you're putting your fleets underneath it, but when you only have like, you know, two mines in the core game and this gives you like three more mines that you can throw out in the board.

I do like the fact that you have more counters.

Yeah, I do. I do, too. Although that does mean

more organization, right? It takes a long time to kind of get the game set up and organized. I We got to get We're talking about we want to get some kind of maybe 3D trays or something that can kind of

more easily organize everything.

Yeah. And they're out there. I just got to print. And we should point out too the um little trays for the uh counters there. Ray printed those off and he printed them off in the colors of the empires and they're great. I I actually had years ago I had a friend of mine print some gray ones and they worked fine. They were great. And then Ray says, "I think I can do better." And he did. He came up with some some absolutely beautiful and functional little trays that holds the counters because again that was always one of my problems whenever I played Space Empires is you you you got to keep the counters stacked and they were always you're always fumbling and you're always moving and these things are just so nice. you can just pick them up and you can move them together and it's you don't have to worry about it.

So, I really appreciate that. Thank you, Ray.

I I did submit the file to be uploaded to uh BGG, but

I haven't seen an approval yet on it. Okay.

But once it's approved, it'll be it's and it's just under the core game is what

Okay, that's good. Under files or

It'll be under files. Yeah.

All right, great.

It'll it'll be the newest one once it finally gets out there. Hopefully, it's out there by the time this video is up. You just download the STL and print it away.

Yeah, that'll be that'll be that'll be cool when that's available. All right. Uh, any final thoughts?

No. No. I I mean, I I like it. I like a lot of what this what this expansion does. I think there's some balance issues on this expansion, but me, I don't think this is if if you love Space Empires 4X and you really really really want to get some more stuff, this is a good expansion to get.

Yeah.

If you like Space Empires 4X and you're not sure, I don't think this is the expansion that you want.

Okay. All right. Well, and we and we still haven't played the other expansion, so so we'll see what that brings to the table.

But it it's like I said, it's all modular. So it, you know, and the rule books you can download to see what it does to,

right? Absolutely. Absolutely. So let me ask you on the Cody scale as an expansion, right? Bearing in mind we love the core game. Just as an expansion, what this brings, what would you rate it?

Based on what's in it, [clears throat] what I've played, and everything else, I'm only putting this expansion at about a six.

Oh, really? Really?

I got the core game at a nine.

Yeah. Yeah, me too. Absolutely.

But there's there there's balance issues and there's some other stuff that I I have to figure out. Now, this can easily jump to a possibly a seven or eight. Yeah. With with more plays, right?

And once once I dig into it a little bit more, but initial thoughts, initial play of this one,

it's it's only a six because it's not one that I necessarily have to have to the table.

Okay.

The core game gives too much. I should point out that when I did buy that uh edition of Close Encounters, I actually gave my core box and my Close Encounters expansion to Ray. So, he actually already owns this. Um, so my feeling is I liked it a little better than you. I because I and if nothing else, the cards I think are huge. The especially the Alien Tech cards are huge. So, I'm going to go ahead. I'm going to give it a seven and I think it will probably go up with more play. Uh, but right now I'm going to give it a seven. So, uh, well, thank you ladies and gentlemen for joining us today on The Discriminating Gamer. As always, we ask you to please give a thumb to this video and subscribe to our channel. Please check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, military history, history, and books on history.

Um, it would mean the world to me if you would thumb thumb and subscribe to that channel as well. Also, please check us out on Facebook, Twitter, all that good stuff. And uh if you really do like what you see here on the discriminating gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. You know, Ray, I am really suspicious about my stairs. They're always up to something.

And I don't know where I'm going. And I don't know where I've been. Please somebody

scared yet? You running?

No, I'm not.

All right. Still going after destroyer.

Kate, it's like double fours or less to even hit you.

No. No. Close. And then these guys. No. Oh, you got one out.

You got one. All right. Wow.

Progress saved