Dark Souls: the Card Game - Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for Dark Souls the card game and the expansions the expansions the Forgotten uh paths and The Seekers of humanity um so I have done a discussion before over the Dark Souls card game and I think I did a separate discussion over the expansions but this is going to kind of replace all of that into one one overall video uh so a long time ago at least what it feels like and way early on my channel uh the Dark Souls board game came out and boy was it atrocious like that was kind of like steam Forge like hey we have the IP it's like oh sweet I love Dark Souls and then you realize oh this doesn't work as a board game I mean their boss fights were really good uh the way that they had that set up but everything up to that was just was was horrendous um and then they made a card game so this is steam forge's uh you know production and it's actually really good CU it's a deck builder uh and a very difficult one at that so let's go ahead and talk about uh some of the negatives about the game cuz I mean this game isn't perfect it still is a uh it still is a deck builder and it's very it could
be very very brutal because you rely heavily on your deck your means of attacking and your means of Defending all rely on your deck so you can have encounters that you draw that could just I mean the very first encounter in the run through was I lost because it was like it was supposed to be two enemies but one of the enemies that came out was like a link so it it was a dog and it brought in another dog and I killed two of the enemies but the third one is what you know caused me to not uh have any cards left and because I had no cards in my uh hand that were about defense then you uh it's just like oh okay because your deck is your life so if you're taking damage you either choose from your hand or your deck and you kind of as you it eventually dwindles out um and your cards also require certain stamina cards to be able to perform some for either a quick effect that you can pop back into your hand or um you know for a better effect you discard it and that works for defense too if you're defensive cards like if you're taking three damage but you're getting rid of three cards to not take the damage then just you're breaking even it's the exact same thing but that's kind of where the theme comes into play and I've always said theme doesn't make good game mechanisms and I I still hold on to that it can be very
annoying when you're like I'm discarding all my defensive cards why aren't my defensive cards just innately there why don't I have like a build and that's just cuz it's a deck builder you eventually will because you start off with like very weak cards like every single card is a one stamina thing and unless you get hosed you eventually will start gaining Souls which is kind of again thematic to Dark Souls yeah it's going to be brutal at the very beginning but eventually you'll make progress you'll start killing enemies you'll gain Souls which means you level up which means that those enemies that were tough are no longer tough uh and I think it's a very unique deck builder because I don't see a lot of games that have like your means of attacking at least deck builders your means of attacking your means of Defending are relied around stamina cards and like for example eventually like you'll have like ones that just have one effect on them like hey here's the one intelligence card well for Two Souls you can get one that has Intelligence or faith and this basically replaces two cards in your deck um cuz now you don't have to rely on drawing both of those symbols you just need to rely on drawing one of them in this card and then that can make up for it and then eventually you'll get enough souls to get the double one and this counts for both so instead of needing multiple cards to do like in my
case a pyromancer where the hell are they a pyromancer blast or pyromancy flame like to do the quick attack range for one damage um required a faith and an intelligence well that needed three cards plus this one to do a one damage quick quick attack or a two damage regular attack uh now it just requires the one so now I can actually just spend the one card to do a quick attack and let's say it's against an enemy with one Health and a weakness to Magic well now your action efficiency just becomes a lot better um this is definitely a game where you pick your character and there's a ton of them like they did a really good job at basically getting all the different classes with all the expansion so pyromancer Herold sorcerer Warrior cleric assassin Knight and Thief um all those have their own starting decks uh but it's like this is my build this is what I'm going for so you don't have a whole lot of agency and like oh I want to be a pyromancer but I'm going to I found a massive weapon I found this um you know this fume Ultra great sword that requires strength I think I'll build for that I mean theoretically you can but that's not what your character is about uh so you eventually will start like a deck builder getting rid of shitty starting cards and getting in
better cards and then the game naturally has a really good progression um I like the fact that you do have five bonfires which is against the theme but the game has to have you lose in some way uh that was kind of like a play with the Dark Souls board game but I was like well how else would you lose if you just had unlimited attempts so the game has to have something to keep you trying uh and there is kind of a meta at least in my mind like you do have some Choice from the bonfire to be like oh I should try this harder one and maybe risk reward if I defeat it that's going to get me ahead because I'm going get a ton of souls uh which can give me a bunch of cards early on I'm just that much further ahead to just kind of go out and maybe I can fight the harder boss uh before I go for the easier one uh but typically you go to a level one encounter you go back and rest you level up you go back to a couple level one encounters you rest you level up and then what I do is it's like okay around the third or fourth bonfire rest I'm going after the mini boss or the easier one and my run through is the Moonlight Butterfly and you beat that and then you're like okay the very last one I'm going to go after that uh but if I lose then I'm to um then I just lose the whole game I do like that and what's also really neat is the bonfires give you something like it's like every time it's like okay get a level two stamina card get a level five get a common treasure
get this it does reward you for resting so you're not just completely like well I keep dying I'm not having any Souls so I can't level up it it gives you a little bit of stuff and I also like the fact that each time you rest out of bonfire there's like an innate progression because it increases how many cards you can have in your deck uh you start out with 28 and by the end of the game you have you can have 40 so uh and they do have remnants of humanities that do count as cards that it's like well I don't have enough souls to kind of fill out that you know 40 I got 38 okay we'll throw a couple remnants of humanities in there those are at least buffers to count as damage or if you have them in your hand you can draw cards uh so the game while difficult and can be completely unfair I think does do a pretty good job at self-correcting now I'm not saying that you can't get hosed every you can get hosed in a in any deck builder especially any competitive deck builder at least this is cooperative in some way uh I think every time I've played it it I mean again go watch my run through very first encounter literally very first card flip was like a ton of traps and you know more enemies than I can handle and it's like I lost the first encounter do I restart nope that's part of the game let's just see what happens and I was able to barely eek by uh yeah I was behind but then it's like
I barely squeezed by the Moonlight Butterfly and then uh barely squeak by again I think that is good you want to have kind of a tight game instead of just completely stomping um the enemies uh there's a ton of variety in the game which I enjoy uh because the problem with the board game was that every time you went to an encounter it was the exact same encounter it was like here you are just take these stupid minis put them on there do the exact same thing over and over again which I get matches the video game but the video game is like oh bonfire boom they're back okay we're in we're in IT board game was okay let's put all the minis it took you like 5 minutes to set up every time you had to rest which you had to rest a lot and in the video game it's just it's Snappy so it doesn't you don't think about oh the enemies are going to be in the exact same spot when you grinded which this game doesn't really let you grind uh it just it it's super quick in the video game and here they do a really good job of just having a ton of enemies so that uh yeah you're going to the same location like I know it's at the Ashen wake I know what's at the hidden passageway or the deeps or the haunted wood if those are my level one encounters but I don't know what enemies are there and that gives you enough variety so I like that like the Ashen wake which actually I never triggered
any of the traps was an abyss energies the player who triggered this trap must spend one Faith or suffer three damage spike traps the player who triggered this trap must spend one deck or suffer three damage and Swinging blades the player who triggered this trap suffers two damage and is pushed to an adjacent empty Square so what's neat about some of those stuff is that like the Ashen wake will give me one common treasure has two regular enemies and three traps I know they're there but I didn't trigger any of them so I know there are three traps there now maybe some of them get triggered in the first time I encounter it and those are gone now so now it's a little bit safer um but you get to see what's around and you might not know what enemies are going to be there but at least that gives you some variety because I swear if this game was like oh you're going to you know the Misty Cliffs again here are the same enemies it's like this is extremely tedious so I actually like that there are just going to be random enemies in those spots and that creates a different puzzle element um so you might be wondering like how does this game like I've I primarily play this solo and that's mainly because Dark Souls is a solo game yeah you can bring in kind of um uh you can bring in like allies like summons to help you this I never felt the need to because you basically get in
each other's way like if you need to move or deal with anything you kind of have to spend both people's movement to do that uh it's just going to bring in more enemies more you have to share Souls which I mean you should get more souls whenever you have more enemies to kill but it's like okay well yeah you need so we only have eight who's getting the Five Card who and I just it's just much easier to I'm selfish uh to spend the souls that I want to spend to be able to just put them all in my deck it's easier for me to just deck build um but that does kind of create a more difficult challenge because when enemies attack if it's a targeted attack there's no missing really it's like oh it's attacking the back left corner well no one's there um so then attacks that row okay no one's there then it goes to the front row and then attack so basically you're always getting hit except if it's an area of effect attack that in the rules specify that if no one's in that area if it's if it's attack in the far left side of that entire column if no one's there then it it completely misses but if both PE if two people were there in the multiplayer game it would hit both of them so that's kind of that's the the tradeoff uh I have played this with one of I've never played this at three or four like I think it goes up to four uh I have never done that I don't think I ever would do that I have played this Max at two and and that's still fun
but to me this is kind of more of a solo deck building game uh the biggest negative honestly that I have about this game is actually the rule book which is not surprising coming from Steam forged because in their own rule book and this is an older game they they flop back and forth and never actually specify what is the top and the uh bottom of the board um because normally the way you would play it is you would flip a card and you would kind of what is this art just Forest Clan cleric that's like the worst art I've seen I guess they all kind of have that that art um it's it's like a cell shaded monk anyway so you kind of want to have it in the orientation that's facing you know the way the pyromancer is so like they just never mention whether this is the top of the board or this is the top you know so like if you have the uh like the board if this is the top or this is the bottom or this is the top uh you would think that hey I'm reading it like this you know whenever it's it's not upside down so the top is up here here but in the in the rule book it's not clear at all they never specify here's the top and here's the bottom um so going off their examples which again in certain sections of the rule book are backwards in fact sometimes they're showing enemies on the on the player board like on this one that the
players are on they're showing enemies on there so it's just horrendous the way I did it in the run through see seem to work best uh in my mind because the way the tax is 1 2 3 4 5 6 um and because you're facing each other like you just kind of take the card and you just Orient it as if the enemy is facing you um I've played it where you kind of read it legibly like so if the py Baner if my card is reading this way then I place the enemy card that way so that's how I read their cards but you can just flip and be like oh well they're facing me to attack me so I'll just flip the card the opposite way and that's where I'll place it and that's how they're attacking it it works as long as you're consistent I think that that's the key on how you're going to deal with enemies um but the rule book yeah is pretty is pretty all over the place it's not a good rule book um the game is not difficult to learn it's a very solid straightforward deck Builder um but yeah just little things like that or it's like okay well I defeat an encounter what if I keep going do I keep my hand like like if I if I beat an encounter with two cards left do I go to the next encounter with two cards in well that doesn't really make any sense so the way I've done it is I draw up to my hand limit because that's travel to the next
thing which my stamina would come back uh I think that's only fair to be able to be like like okay well I defeated a level three encounter now I'm going to the boss I have two cards in my hand it's stupid if the boss gets to attack me and I have two cards in hand so I I draw up to my hand limit of six because I mean it's really going to it's six of one it's just okay do I discard cards from my hand to be to get ready for the fight because it's like if you're going to go into the fog door to fight you're not going to like expend all your stamina and spend all your spells and then run in you're going to prep for it so and that's personally how I do it I don't think in the rules it ever specifies um and so that's just kind of how it is uh so now let's go into what Dark Souls is all about which is level design no there's no level design here it's the name of a of a card uh it's the bosses and the bosses I think work very very well they they represent the bosses that they are and I like that the board is representative of like whenever you're picking an encounter board um it basically will tell you how like what bosses you're you want to fight and the bosses that they have cuz I haven't made any more expansions was the Moonlight Butterfly uh and great grey wolf Sith then they
have um because they have three double-sided boards they have the Bell gargoyle the Asylum Demon the last giant the pursuer Old Iron King Smelter Demon Abyss Watcher High lord vuler vort of the Boreal Valley and pontiff Sullivan so pretty good range I'd say of I mean it seems like Dark Souls one and Dark Souls 3 CU I've actually never played Dark Souls 2 so I don't know which bosses are actually in Dark Souls II I've only played one and three um but yeah that's just kind of you the the layout of the board is I mean it's a little bit different some of them are the same like one side is the same like uh in terms of the be like the level one two or three encounters and the The Other Board is a little bit different but it's the same for both of them it just depends on which bosses you want to go fight but at the same time you uh you don't have to follow this at all like it didn't have to be great grey wolf Sif and the Moonlight Butterfly I mean honestly like I could have just shuffled the these bags up and been like oh okay it's going to be the pursuer and Old Iron King they mention it in the rules that's it's like hey you don't have to follow these these are just how we've paired them up to make one a little bit easier and one a little bit harder but you don't have to follow that and that's cool I like that I like how it isn't just like well you can only
play with these two uh uh so that's that's a neat little element and yeah like the bosses feel like the they're designed pretty much like the boss like the Moonlight Butterfly is a pain in the ass boss unless you have range if you have magic or a bow it's like oh okay it doesn't really matter where it's at CU I can constantly hit it uh and if you're a melee build like a big chunky you only have the massive two-handed great sword It's like got to wait for it to come up front no got to wait for it to come and land uh otherwise I can't hit it and that's exactly what it does great grey wolf SI is a I mean hits super hard um just Buffs itself like the double sword swing resolve this attack twice does like a leaped attack that does five damage which is insane but then if you do break its first phase then its second phase is super depressing where it's like yeah all it does now is a limping stride and it's weak to everything and it has you know one defense and you're like oh my God cuz that's how you feel cuz you watch the the wolf limp and you're like I'm sorry that I have to do this uh and I mean all the other bosses I mean I haven't fa I don't think I faced every single one of these but uh like the Bell Gargoyles there are two that come out uh the Asylum Demon is pretty easy vort is one that they recommend you
start with high Lord voler has his hands so you have to shatter his his hands to to beat him it's it's really neat like yeah would I have liked them to make more expansions to the game to bring in every single boss that would have been awesome cuz I I really like they made a ton of expansions for that for the board game and the minis are amazing like I've thought so many times that I was just going to keep it for The Minis uh I thought I was going to do that with bloodborne I thought I was going to do that with Horizon zero Dawn I don't own a single one of those games anymore cuz I would just look at those Min and be like these are amazing I'd have to pay either you know paint them or pay for someone to paint them and then I'd look at and be like I don't even like these games why am I keeping these minis uh unlike my oorn which I guess you know well actually I'm covering it so I'll keep covering it but yeah my oor minis I'm actively getting painted cuz that game is amazing uh but they made a bunch of expansions for the board game it's like yeah you know your board game sucks so which I've heard again that I think there's a fan-made edit of the game that someone has mentioned makes the game good and that's awesome for people who want it who really liked the game and now it's better that's great I'm not getting it to do a fan-made thing but yeah I really wish that they would have pumped more expansions into this um so speaking of expansions let's talk about them let's talk about the secrets of
humanity first because this is a very uh it's it's a thin thin expansion basically it adds Embers and it adds Invaders In the run through unfortunately we didn't get to see an Invader that's probably for the best cuz I probably would have lost the whole game what it does is it adds Embers into the common deck you just shuffle them in here and what Embers do is one they kind of act as a remnant of humanity you can discard it to draw a card but when it's in your deck it increases your deck size by three but you only have one of these you can't have like all the Embers but every time you draw one you have to flip a token and grab that Invader so in that case it was whoever the hell that do is man eater Mildred and you Shuffle that into the enemy deck so it is a potential enemy that can show up mine never did but but these kind of act as little mini bosses so if this comes out it acts as one of the encounters enemy spawn um and they have their own AI deck so in this case with my dude that was shuffling because I never got an ember or anything you do start with one in there depending well depending on number of players you start with one per player so if he if he got drawn which I'm glad he didn't because again I
probably would have just straight up lost cuz I he would have been rough um Oliver The Collector this card's defense is listed on its Behavior cards inste of this card every time this card suffers damage draw and resolve a behavior card so he has 1 two 3 four five cards that um that he has so whenever he goes you actually draw an encounter card oh it's doing that's his actual item uh he's going to be doing a precise thrust which he has two defense because of this and it's magic and three and he so he'd hit me for three It's Magic so I'd bypass it he has four health and what's cool is when you defeat them well one if you lose the encounter they go back into the deck but if you defeat them then they're removed and then you actually get their item in this case I would have gotten the minitar helm which would have been super awesome that would have been a defensive three and I could have used that but that's that's is really cool like because Invaders don't um uh Invaders don't happen all the time in Dark Souls so I like the fact that Embers you can draw like they're just shuffled into this massive deck and again with the expansions you don't have to use both of them in fact they mention hey just use the cards from the expansion if you want to more you know precise experience uh I just put it all together so The Embers I like that you
can have in your deck to get so you can have three extra cards which could be very very beneficial uh to just survivability and that it's just a an enemy that can show up uh that is unique adds more variety so that's really what the um what the Seekers of Humanity expansion brings in the Forgotten paths expansion uh I also really like one because they just they add you know more bosses um both of them add more bosses and more uh more characters to play as like the seers of humanity added the cleric and the warrior and then more enemies and then the Lost giant Old Iron King pursuer and Smelter Demon and then the Forgotten paths added the pyromancer and the thief and then the uh Asylum Demon Bell gargoyle great grey wol s and the Moonlight Butterfly so uh but the Forgotten pth added terrain and traps which we actually did get to see in the run through um and I think they're both great additions like there smaller expansions just added more to the game um the biggest sin honestly besides the rule book of this game is actually it's box size cuz my God is it just awful it is so bad I wonder if there's a 3D printing there must be a 3D
printer thing hopefully for this that because the way I have it set up is bags upon bags and I've made it somehow work but anyway a Terrain is just assigned to a location so in my case it was the Misty Cliffs uh was assigned the High Ridge terrain but it didn't have to be it h i mean it happened to be very thematic in that case but it's now linked to that so you know oh if every time I go to the Misty Cliffs I don't know what enemies are going to be there but I do know it has a High Ridge effect so if I don't have any range in my deck that's going to cost me a lot of stamina so do I keep going that way but it could have easily just been bog or fog or Gog um it could have been a tangled undergrowth or treacherous footing um or sweltering heat so they are linked to those and I I think that's just some variety think they're pretty cool and then the other thing it adds was traps and there's a lot more traps uh to deal with luckily there are some in here that are just nothing uh but you don't know what the traps are like until you trigger them uh and kind of the way the traps work they they're like they're a little fiddly because whenever you see how many there are it's like you draw from a random deck and you look at where it's attacking it's like oh this one's attacking in that top right section
that's where a trap goes and you do that for how many there are and that's kind of how they get placed it's not the worst thing um and you don't even have to trigger them like if you get pushed some enemies will push you that can land you in a trap sometimes the Trap will be it might be a lucky escape with no effect it might be a pitfall it might be a rockfall and poison mist or whatever and I also like that the the fact that the traps are like hey spend this stamina or take this damage um like it gives you some agency like I also like the fact that there are lucky escapes that it could like my three could have usually just been three lucky escapes I would never know and I also like the fact that the traps are tied to that location until triggered so in my ash and wake scenario I didn't trigger any of the traps but uh if I did let's say I triggered two of them and it was the abyss energies and spike traps then if I went to the ashon wake again it would just be the one trap left like you don't keep filling it up with traps it's like well I've already triggered that I don't need to go back I do I do like that element of the traps so overall I think they did a fantastic job with both of these expansions by adding in just more variety again like with the secrets of humanity forgotten pths you can just just focus on those cards either shuffle them into the common the core game or
don't even touch the core game and only do the stuff from the expansion to really have a focused experience where you always will have traps and terrain um it just added more like that fit within the Dark Souls card game so I think these expansions are are great uh yeah I mean this is kind of a I mean I steam Forge I I'm pretty sure I don't even know if these expansions or the game is even possible to get I don't know if it's like out of print or hard to find or whatever I would have liked them to continue supporting it uh I know there's an Elden ring I think they're doing an Elden ring board game I would have loved to see Elden ring like this um it's it's just a very clean deck builder with a you know kind of shitty rule book uh and it can be insanely difficult but it also doesn't take long that's the thing is my entire playthrough took about an hour which is pretty good because eventually if you die you're going to run through your bonfires and you'll lose that way uh but it does just have a really nice natural progression and it's Cooperative like you can play with multiple people and positioning matters like uh you have to attack in a column so if they if an enemy is jumping around and you kind of can't get to it
then you kind of have to bide your time I will say one thing that is kind of weird is you only get one attack you get one attack and one movement and uh and like you you can do multiple actions but you can only do each of them once so it's like if you have the stamina to do like a fire blast twice it is kind of lame that if I I do my pyromancy blast or my pyromancy flame and let's say I had the I had the the stamina card that had both my intelligence and faith in it and let's say like I wanted to do my pany flame quick attack I can't spend that and pop this back into my hand let's say I had another one you can't do it again which is kind I mean I get it that might make the game a little bit more tedious uh but at the same time every encounter starts with the enemies going like as soon as they spawn they all attack so you're kind of just already getting hit and that might make the multiplayer a little bit more tantalizing because it's like well in a Solo game here are the two enemies coming out they both do four damage that's eight damage just coming my way uh better you know better deal with it uh versus like oh okay that one's attacking I am in that spot so I'm going to get hit but the other one is attacking no one's in that spot but you have a higher threat value so it's going to hit you you get to share the load a little bit uh which does make two multiplayer just
better uh and yeah positioning matters and it's like okay can you deal with that thing because I don't have any heavy attacks I I'm not saying that this game is bad multiplayer I'm just saying I've only ever played at two because I feel like it would just get really messy on trying to maneuver and Swap and stuff with four people but who knows it might be super fun I don't I I don't actually know uh so yeah that is my thoughts on the Dark Souls card game on a scale of 1 to 10 I'm going to include both the expansions and this uh I think I'm going to give this an eight I I really do like this game a lot I don't play it all the time um but every time I do I'm like because I hadn't played in quite some time and then I looked at the I was like looking through the rules and I was like oh yeah like it all just kind of came back to me it's it was very clean they do have a decent amount of variety with the enemies and the the bosses and the the characters and the characters do feel like the characters when you play a warrior you feel like a warrior when you play like a pyromancer ton a ton of uh loot that you can come in and sometimes you get stuff that works for your build the one thing I don't know if is is actually in the rules but I don't know if you can sell items like if you get Treasures that don't do anything for you I think you could in the I think you could in the board game but I don't know if it's
in the card game maybe there's like a home R rule or something that it's like oh you're not going to use this fume Ultra great sword well sell it for some Souls uh I don't actually remember but that should be added if it's not uh yeah it just kind of comes together if there's an insert for the game somewhere which I might look at after this that would also help out quite a bit and maybe just like a there's I'm sure there's a file out there if you're confused by how the layout Works um but yeah I I really really like it and I wish steam Fords made better games like this one than what they currently make uh but that's it everyone that's my thoughts on Dark Souls the card game with the two expansions let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful every time upd this for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you