Skip to main content
Loading video...

Meadow Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 18:46

hey everybody today i'm talking about meadow which is a 2021 release board game designed by clemens kaliki and illustrated by karolina kayak this one accommodates wonderful players and takes 60 to 90 minutes to play towards the end of the game the game is going to look like this so i've just finished a two-player game here where we have this big tableau of cards that i've played throughout i've got my hand of cards i've got these different location cards and the main boards look like this where you have this big grid of cards that you can collect with the little deck holders here and which kind of shows where these cards refresh you've got this main central board here as well which just determines the uh which round you're on and different ways you can get bonus points so the idea of this game is that we're trying to get as many points as we can by playing these different wildlife cards all these different landscapes or different trees and stuff um and as you can see each of these cards has a has a number on them with these leaves which determines the points they're going to be worth at the end of the game but you'd also see that these cards have different symbols on them so this symbol here in this kind of triangle symbol means that in order to play this card i need to have these prerequisites showing on my tableau of cards and this is the uh the new one that is going to show once that's cars play which is going to count towards the future prerequisites so as you can see here i need a tree a grass and one of these rolling hills and i've got a tree i've got some grass and i've got one of these rolling hills therefore i could play this card

on any of those different stacks so the one of the other key mechanisms on how you're actually going to acquire these cards is based on these different player pieces here these different like pointing uh these pointing cardboard tokens now you're gonna start with either four or five of these depending on the player count so in a two player game you're going to have five numbered from one to four and then a wild one which looks a bit like this and again these have two bits of information on them so the number is important but also the buttons bottom symbol here is important for two different reasons so the the upper symbol is a bit easier on how to understand and that's going to be how you acquire cards from this grid so as you can see i've got the four here and i could plug this one into any of these different notches on the board as long as it's not taken as you can see these ones are already locked out so i couldn't go to those spots but if i want here for example because it's my four i go one two three four and i'll take this card here and that applies to all the different numbers the wild means that you can take any from that row or column so it gives you a lot more flexibility now the other side which is that kind of squared off side is also important relating to this side of the board here so let's say for example i plug this number one into this notch here and these all give you different abilities so this one here means you can take any card from the grid kind of going around that normal restriction of the number you've got ones here that let you play two cards at once you've got ones here that give you these different kind of um

these road tokens which are good for building these individual cards which i'll explain a bit later uh you've got this one here that lets you draw a number of cards and then pick one and put the other ones back and things like that so it gives you a nice little bonus power that you can use as soon as you take a card using this method here you're going to acquire the card and you're going to have the ability to either play that card straight into your tableau of cards or you can even play one already in your hand and when you play them onto your um onto your tableau you are not limited to how high they are but you do have to start each stack with one of these foundation cards which show all these different terrain types and additionally if you ever choose to go to this side of the board here and you know by using this side of your little markers then you are going to have the ability not only for the um not only the special ability here but if you ever have a number of these symbols on show for example if i had this um this kind of howling wolf symbol and this flying bird symbol uh showing on this on the tableau like i have here so i've got the wolf i've got the um i've got the uh the flying bird then as a bonus follow action i can play one of these tokens here i'm starting from the lowest one which is a two uh and play them between the two symbols that i've got on show for some bonus points and that's a little bit of a race element where you want to be the first to build these particular symbols and um get that kind of adjacency bonus by getting your marker down there and being your opponent to the punch these location cards work in a very similar system

where you must have at least one of these um free road tokens and you can acquire more of those if you run out by using the special ability on one of your player tokens like this and you're going to add them just above your normal tableau of cards and when you do that you're going to acquire these kind of location cards as the normal method and you can play them just as you would a normal card as long as you are abiding by those prerequisites to get some bonus points and additionally if you ever acquire some of these item cards you can play them on top of these location cards for some bonus points and which are kind of depicted by these kind of suitcase symbol and again that's just another kind of route you can go down and get you more bonus points and that's pretty much how the game's going to play out you're going to play for a number of rounds depending on the player count so in a two-player game you'll play six rounds halfway through the game the deck is going to change from the south deck to the north deck and where things are going to ramp up slightly and the cards are going to be slightly more difficult to play because of course you've already acquired quite a few cards by then so as you can see from the demo there the actual mechanisms of this game are rather simple you're either going to require a card by playing one of these tokens and then playing one uh in front of you or you're going to use the special ability on that token on the reverse reverse side and plug it into that main board to take that bonus action um i suppose the decisions really come on the back of this symbol mechanism or these symbols um it's almost like a almost like a technology tree where each of these cards you play has a prerequisite on them they're going

to go up and up and up starting from real basic um abilities like i have here for example you know this one this bird card only needs a tree and a bug and then by the end of it you know you need a house a tree a frog or a bird and a bug and um it basically builds a ton on top of each other one after another um getting more and more difficult cards to play which of course is going to get you bigger points in return however i suppose the trick of this game and what can leave you uh kind of milling over your mistakes is the fact that when you play a card you do have to cover up an existing card which you might need in the future so it's all about having the most symbols on show at any time and because there are so many symbols having all of them on show isn't really going to be an option so yeah it's all about planning ahead which order you're going to do things in how are you going to acquire these cards you know which ones you're going to prioritize because of course all the players are sharing the same grid playing their tokens down blocking off spots and um of course again you are limited by the numbers on these tokens as well so you know if you if you really need this card here somebody's already played here and um you haven't got your four left to go here then you know you're all out of luck unless maybe you can have your wild card token or even use the special ability here for example to take any card in the grid but everyone's playing from the same game everyone is kind of clogging up the main board i'm beating you to the punch and i'm stopping you getting exactly what you want whether that's the deliberately or kind of indirectly it's

gonna happen i do enjoy how you can plan at least a few turns in advance you know for example if you really need a difficult card to play like like this um that's crow symbol for example um i could say like i'm too simple short here i'm gonna build this card for cheap then i'll build another one for cheap and then by the time i get round for that i'll be able to smash this one down and then line up more and more moves so i do like you can string things ahead of time and you're not just reacting to the current board state however again you are restricted to the cards available to you and there is that kind of tension of getting the cards you want you are also given a little bit of flexibility in terms of playing these cards down so for example this house here needs a bug a bird and a house symbol i have the bug and the bird but i don't have the house symbol however i can choose to kind of proxy that symbol by getting rid of two cards i might not be looking to use so i could discard those for example and then build one of these cards to acquire more points you'll also see that some of these symbols here have these restrictions on which means they need to be next to that certain type of symbol or at least one of those symbols um so you've got more restrictions to abide by there which is of course going to ramp up that puzzle that tiny element of player interaction in terms of the race to get to these certain symbols is a welcome addition in my opinion it just adds a fraction of tension to the game which um of course gives you a nice foundation to and gives you something to build towards

uh prior to starting the game so it gives you a nice little path to follow these little these little cards here in terms of these landscapes and items you pick up they work just the same as these other cards do um but i i kind of like the fact that you need to almost forsake a turn by getting rid of your number two token in order to actually acquire these road tokens in the first place so you can play more cars because you will find yourself at some point in the game you know wanting to acquire one of these nice juicy cards however you have however however you haven't got the actual space to build into so a very small deviation from the actual main mechanisms or the the kind of core of the gameplay but it just adds a nice little five percent extra for you to think about despite being subject to the cards available to you i think that generally the game is well balanced because there is a plethora of cards out here you know there's not just like there's a there's a kind of a set of three cards out there that you need to choose from you are you have a lot of flexibility in a lot of different paths to go down and if you can't acquire a certain card that you need you can of course just divert your strategy and try something else but of course um you know you're always going to have that flexibility of discarding cards you need to match a certain symbol as well and i don't really think luck is as big as a factor in this game as you might think now despite being a moderately simple game and a straightforward game meadow does take 60 to 90 minutes to play and i will say in all honesty that feels

a little bit long for me um because again you are doing the same thing from start to finish yes halfway through the game you know the cars do ramp up a lot getting more points and i'm you know sometimes giving you two symbols as a reward so it does have a slight kind of forward momentum and a different feel once it hits that halfway mark however it's not massive and it does feel like the game does go on maybe a round or two too long so i would have liked to have seen it fit around more of that 45 minutes to an hour mark rather than that 60 to 90 minute mark it just outstayed its welcome slightly too long for me especially considering how simple the game is i think if there was one extra mechanism in the game something else to think about and to stretch you in a different direction i think that time could be warranted however as it stands it's just a little bit too long the replayability of meadow is okay it's more of a reactionary style game where of course you can plan a few turns in advance but you're not going to go in from game to game trying a completely different path of strategy and a different route to victory you know you're always going to be reacting to what's on the board which cards are in your hand and how they're going to string together to get the most points down and but i do find that these kind of reactionary more tactical games do hold up a bit better in terms of playing them again and again but it kind of falls back onto that that factor that it does stay a little bit too long on the table so if i want a more tactical game i tend to lean to something a bit shorter um but i it's not too bad you know there's certain things to try certain different routes to go and of course um from getting to getting these

different symbols i've got to change and give you something else to build towards i think something that goes without saying is how gorgeous this game is the artwork on all these animals and trees uh wildlife just looks absolutely gorgeous i mean some of these illustrations and artwork is just so charming it really is um a feast for the senses in terms of what you're looking at here it all just looks so homely and just so welcoming and i think when a game has this level of aesthetic beauty it's going to certainly um iron out a lot of creases and almost lay out that drawbridge for people to jump into the hobby and you know that's something i cannot take away from meadow just the visual aspect alone is going to inject a lot of life into this game the components themselves in terms of their quality is decent you have got these smaller cards but that's okay because you know you are building quite a lot of them in front of you at any time and if you have too big of a cards they're going to take up too much space all the cardboard stock is is fine and you do get these little card holders to um to put the different decks in and while you might think that's a bit superfluous a bit unnecessary they do actually do a good job of making the gameplay go quicker because you know as soon as you take one of these cards you are going to replenish them instantly and because these are on a slight incline they're very nice and easy to draw out and replenish those cars with uh kind of just to iron out that fiddliness so yeah from a production standpoint no complaints whatsoever absolutely gorgeous and i'm just top-notch and i suppose that ties into the theme

of the game now of course the theme here is a meadow you know you're building all these different things for wildlife and stuff um however i just want to quickly mention something that my girlfriend mentioned when we played this was that although the card artwork is is stunningly beautiful to look at there is no flavor text whatsoever so rather than again say like a wingspan where all the little flavor texts and little tidbits sometimes in terms of a little bit of information etc they are not on the cards in this game you actually have an index instead where you can reference the cards and find out a little bit of information about all these different animals and plants etc now i personally would have liked to have seen that on the cards and while that's not a big factor for me personally um it is something my girlfriend mentioned and it's because something that she said she liked about wingspan was the fact that when you play the game you can actually learn little bits of information about it whereas this one you can't i can't really see anybody playing a card and then looking straight into the card index and seeing oh you know what this uh this is a certain hedgehog that does this so it's just those little minor details that might not seem a big deal to us gamers are surprisingly important to people who aren't so much into the hobby and do play against the theme so just something to consider there that did um pop up when i played this one the game does scale pretty well although you always use the same central board here at the higher play account you do actually remove these wild card tokens so there are of course fewer fewer tokens being used from round to round um obviously these boards here are double-sided which determines the amount

of rounds you take and more of these different symbols are added in depending on the player count and even some of these things are blocked off to restrict the amount of people who can go there to snatch those spots so a very small tinkering in terms of the scalability here but it does work perfectly fine the game does have a solo mode however i have not played that solo mode so i can't testify on the strength of it so overall meadow is a lovely game i think this is a nice relaxing change of pace from the normal stuff i play yeah it's pretty straightforward in what you're doing and you can pretty deterministically plan a few turns ahead especially if you are quite a seasoned gamer however because there is a decent amount of interaction here on people snatching spots that you want you will have to find yourself adjusting and you can't just stick to a certain game plan because again other people are always interfering with your plans whether you want them to or not um there of course there is a other little interaction here in terms of racing to the certain spots so i think without these different things it could have been a bit too straightforward and a bit too kind of default play and just you know just go through the motions and get these cards played but because you can't just play the ones you want all the time then it is going to add a bit more flavor and a bit more life into this one it does have that said element of a tech tree which you are you might be familiar with you know a lot of kind of more euro style games but this one kind of hides that under a bit of a veil by playing all these different cars which you know rather than gaining alien technology etc you're just kind of getting the habitats etc for these animals which kind of it kind of masks what this game's about

and it's going to really uh kind of teach non-gamers some pretty interesting decisions and it's going to make them force or at least if they want to win the game they could make them force them to play a bit more strategically and plan a few turns in advance which normally these kind of games don't do so i do like the fact that you can play things in a certain order to get the most mileage out of your cards and that will actually make you think in lots of different directions and i actually did find myself thinking what am i going to do i want to do this but i forgot what i was going to do and map out my turns how am i going to use these tokens in the best order am i willing to give up one of these or taking a card in order to take one of these bonuses in order to race for one of these tokens but bearing in mind that you know are the other people going for those ones as well and are they going to beat me to it so there is a decent amount of choice here and a decent amount of planning and foresight that has to go into doing well at this game now again i'm not gonna breeze over the fact that the game looks amazing you know this is gonna be a big factor in how well this game does and you know rightly so you know i don't see why um you know a game shouldn't be rewarded for how much effort it puts into its production and artwork so yeah i think on artwork alone this is going to appeal to a lot of people and um i think it's certainly wonderful to look at i don't think the gameplay is spectacular however it is solid and it's going to give you enough to think about and keep you satisfied if you want to play this with a kind of less experienced gamers it's going to have enough to satisfy you as well as not being too much for them to digest and to enjoy themselves so

yeah overall this is a nice relaxing game and i think this would fit a future list of kind of relaxing games quite well and i'm happy with it so that concludes my thoughts on meadow certainly give this one a try if you want to bridge that gap for family weight gamers into that kind of gateway plus level because this one is certainly uh has some legs to it so that is meadow if you have enjoyed the video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved