Detective: A Modern Crime Board Game Review
Transcript
in detective you're working together to solve a crime but this isn't any old board game you're not solving a crime in detective you're reading through Case Files interrogating witnesses matching fingerprints in the lab and researching your findings on the Internet you're doing real detective work this video represents my return to making considered passion of board game reviews if you'd like to help fund more go to patreon.com/scishow to base look up the files on the people involved so you pull up the site on your laptop or phone and type in their name there is a photo with height weight shoe size date of birth and criminal records the website is perfect it's unassuming workman like like you'd imagine a real police database would be and it's great that you don't have to install an app you just log in on whatever device you're using that day time is scarce the rule book warns you that you won't be able to follow up on every lead meet every witness or test every fingerprint and it's not lying at the end of case two we had 10 cards left over full of juicy text that we'll never get to read if you make the wrong decisions then you won't be able to solve the case so you take those decisions seriously is it worth interviewing the neighbor what are they really going to know as a team you discuss the potential merits of each lead I love that these discussions aren't about gaming mechanisms we're not
arguing about mathematical probabilities we're having a conversation that sounds real about a case that sounds real instead of accessing the efficiency engine part of our brains we're using our emotional intelligence our knowledge of how society works how people work your gaming instinct tells you to interview them anyway loot every crate in the dungeon but you're 34 years of experience on this earth tells you that you're wasting time and you need to listen to that because in this game it's right but it will toy with you you follow a lead that should be fruitful and get nothing then the card teases you with the prospect of more if you choose to dig deeper spend a token you can flip the car imagine what could be underneath it could be a wall of raw text it could be the breakthrough you've been looking for it could bust this case wide open or it could be nothing but it probably isn't is it you already wasted three hours searching the archives you may as well double down by spending the token skill tokens are hard to come by in one case we'd spent all of ours by day three with no way to get them back card after card would pass us by unflagging of life from the underside you've also got to take into account how many hours you're waste driving across town to each new lead what's running under detective's hood is a slick barely noticeable system that creates tension it's exactly what a game like this needed detectives unique selling point and what got me excited
about this game is that it requires you to research real-world information to solve the case it's a genius conceit what better way to make players feel like they're real detectives than by breaking the fourth wall of their fictional precinct and telling them to step out into the real world beyond it you'll be googling names and maps to give crucial context to witness statements and Case Files it feels incredible when the information you find on Wikipedia suddenly clicks everything into place my only complaint is that it holds your hand a little too much the game tells you when to turn to the Internet by showing you this Wi-Fi symbol it takes some of the joy out of the exploration because often you'll find the answer you're being led towards within seconds of typing it into Google I understand why the designers have done it to avoid the world's worst detectives from overthinking every sentence of every case and spending 50 hours on Google convinced that portal games have hidden a code in the way that the paragraphs are spaced I just wish that the rest of us weren't forced to play the game at the speed of the slowest players detectives biggest weakness is thankfully superficial the text in the game is clunky repetitive and at times cringe-worthy it will beat you over the head with cliches of bad coffee pouring rain and how hard it is to find anything in police archives here's an example the rain starts to annoy you but what irks you even more is that some stickler did not want to mail the scans so you had to go down to get them
personally you reach the precinct entering the official entrance on the other side of the lobby away from the hustle and bustle of detainees you pass the investigation room on the right corner faster rattling you spend the next several minutes savoring the legendary Richmond PD vending machine coffee known as the worst sludge the writing is obsessed with them I knew sure of police work there is nothing in that text that is relevant to the case it's padding and you'll read it on every card in the game you will laugh at and get frustrated by every mention of coffee and rain it will break your fourth wall but not in the way that detective intended look I don't want clues that are delivered cold I love the story telling in Sherlock Holmes consulting detective but here it's got no character no humor it's like it's begging you to skip it which for a game that has board games that tell stories emblazoned on the box is disappointing it tells you just how much I love this game that I can live with the bad writing and I would urge you to look past it to where the game excels is in its mysteries they're sophisticated multi-layered cases that will really challenge you there were moments in Detective when we were sat around throwing out theories trying to work out motives and corroborate witness statements with material evidence that was some of the best times I've had with
a board game ever the five cases are linked by a series arc you can unlock leads in case one that will help you in case five it fills you with this wonderful paranoia that everything is connected if I had a pin board and bits of string I would have become Charlie Kelly ranting about Pepe Silvia the few flaws in detective are blips what shines through is the most complete crime solving experience in a board game interrogation reports that show the suspect stress levels a police database DNA matching and turning to the internet for clue you have to delve so deep into this story rich with intrigue that you can't help but be immersed if you like cooperative games and solving crimes you have to get this game Sherlock Holmes consulting detective is one of my favorite games of all time and detective takes that 37 year old concept and breeze up to speed with the modern world and modern board gaming this universe can run and run and I can't wait to see what they do next with it but already it's one of my favorite games of all time detective a modern crime board game gets a seal of actual love if you liked this review and want to see more like it please subscribe to the channel and consider pledging your support at patreon.com forward slash actual oh I'm John Perkis thanks for watching