Frutticola Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
Hey everybody, today I'm taking a look at Fruiticopia, which is a two-to-four player board game designed by Giovanni Fiore and Virginia Gigli. This one takes about 60 minutes to play and has an economical edge to it where you are trying to harvest fruit, turn that fruit into jam, and then sell it at the market. Now, this game was a Kickstarter campaign maybe a year and a half ago or so, and it's just been fulfilled. It is being described as a 2020 game, but I personally would consider it a 2021 game and considering I've just received it. So, Virginia Gigli, you may notice his name, he's very famous and an amazing designer to be honest, and one of my personal favorites after designing games such as Grand Austria Hotel, Lorenzo il Magnifico, and Coimbra. So, top-tier Euro games there. So, this one is a worker placement style game that and it's going to look a bit like this when it's set up. You've got this main board here, which has these different tiles that you can you can gain throughout the game. You've got this scaling market here, which is going to show how much fruit is worth, whether you're going to sell three of a particular style of fruit or going to sell the relevant jam that that fruit turns into. So, as you can see here, the apples are going to be worth 10.
You've got this round tracker here, which is completely superfluous. You've got money, you've got fertilizers and pesticides, and you've got these different trees here. Now, these trees are going to be worker placement spots that you can go to to acquire fruit. So, these are going to change depending on the player count. So, as you can see here, this tree is going to provide strawberries, lemons, and apples. And this is going to be the cost it's going to cost you to acquire those, such as cost cash again, pesticide, or fertilizer. Additionally, you've got a storage space here, which is going to show your capacity of the fruit that you can store um any time. You've got your different types of workers here, and you've got two different types. You've got farmers, and you've got the other chaps here with the shovels.
And at the start of the game, you are going to either be given five cards at random, or you can do a draft for these should you want to. Um and these are going to determine what you can do from turn to turn, at least how many actions you can get. Because as you can see here, there's a a few different bits of information on each card. This one here, and the big number in the top left, is going to show the initiative. You've got the uh different characters here in the top right, which is going to show the order in which you're going to place your workers. So, something that's something that's a bit different about this game is that once you've selected your card you're going to use for the current round, you're going to take the relevant workers, and you're going to line them up in this kind of queue system based on the card. And that means that you're going to have to play them it'll place them on this order, which um it can be quite important. Um you've additionally got a particular player power depending on the card that you've played from round to round. For example, this one here says uh you can gain one additional fruit of the same type when using the orchard action. So, that's going to let me get um going to let me get fruit a bit quicker.
And these are going to scale all the way up to the higher numbers, um where you can potentially take a lot more actions, but potentially get a hindrance um by doing so. Um we'll talk about that a bit later. Uh let's talk about some of the worker placement spots. So, they're pretty simple, and this is quite a straightforward worker placement game, um at least on the face of it. Uh you've got this one here, which basically lets you sell your um your fruit and your jams. So, uh if you use the uh the worker with the shovel to on this spot, you're going to get a bonus of plus one. You've got these inclusive spaces, and you've got exclusive spaces. That That basically means on this small on these small cycles, only one person can use them. But the uh the bigger ones, you can do that as many times as you want. And that's going to decide how how actions of that you can do per placement. So, for example, um in in this example here, if I went here, I could sell three pieces of fruit or jams, um but as that goes on, you know, that's going to diminish. But, as I said, if you use your other chap, then you are going to be boosted by one anyway. You've got the uh the chemical plant here, which lets you gain pesticides or fertilizers. And again, if you use your farmer on that spot, you are going to get a plus one bonus.
You've got the um ability to turn fruit into jam by using this spot, where you are going to cash in two fruit and convert it into the relevant jam. So, for example, I could get rid of these two oranges and pick me up an orange jam to replace it. Which is going to be a lot more efficient in terms of uh keeping space on your player board. Um and you've got this action here, which lets you recruit these dummy workers, or suppose these these bonus pawns, these assistants, and they are going to go at the back of your queue, um but they are going to give you more actions, but of course, you are not going to get the bonuses of certain spots, such as these, which will increase your ability to do certain things. Um on top of that, you've got the actual ability to gain the fruits in the first place by going to the trees.
And some of these are going to have costs on like this, so it's going to cost you either pesticide or fertilizer. And then you are going to take the the fruit that is picked on the trees. You've got a wild bush here, which lets you take any tree whatsoever. And these are going to change depending on the player count. So, only certain um the the variation or the the setup of the fruits you can get is going to change slightly, and the cost is going to change slightly depending on the player count. Now, on top of all that, you've got some different objectives you can go for if you want to play with them. You've got public objectives, where you know, the first person to do a certain thing, for example here, the first person to sell a batch of fruit or jam for a total value of 50, can claim at this spot here to get an instant bonus of 15 money. Again, the first person to have 12 fruit in their warehouse is going to get the going to get the bonus. And of course, other players can go there, but they're going to get diminished values.
And first person to get one of each tile something that's worth mentioning is that you do start with a capacity of nine, but you have got a potential to increase that by acquiring certain tiles by going to this spot here. And I think this is going to be one of the main spots that is that's going to be used from game to game. So here you are going to just well just like the other spots, you are going to place one of your workers on this spot here. And that is going to show how you well it's going to decide which tiles you can buy. So the first spot to go to is going to be free, but every person to go after that is going to cost a bit more money. If you place your farmer there, you're going to get a discount of two. And as I said, you're going to also have to pay an additional fee to pick up these certain tiles which will let you do different things, giving you instant bonuses, giving you end game bonuses, and giving you separate powers.
So that's pretty much how the game's going to play. It's going to play out over four seasons. So you're going to start off with the with the spring, go into summer, then autumn, then into winter. At the end of each month or each season, sorry, the fruit is going to potentially shift up in value um depending on the player count. So for example, in a in a two-player game, the the prices are only going to shift up at the end of summer. Um and the at the end of the game or at the end of the the four seasons, when it's December, everything is going to shift down value, but everybody is going to get an opportunity to sell all of their jams and and fruit that they've acquired throughout um at the Christmas market. And there are a lot of cards and tiles that correspond to the Christmas market, which can kind of boost the money that you're going to get.
And the player with the most money at the end of the four seasons is going to be the winner. So, let's talk about how I feel about Fruiticola. So, Fruiticola is a game that's been getting pretty mixed reviews um so far, and I think a big portion of that is because of some of the production issues here. Um it might look very um very clean and very um striking from the face of it, but I did have some issues um with the way the game is put together from a components and production standpoint. So, for example, you can see the resources in this game are these different fruits, and these are all round. And um you know, you can probably imagine as the game goes on, um there are moments where these are just going to go rolling everywhere. They're quite hard to um keep all together. Um but, you know, they have made somewhat of an effort to make the bottoms flat, but they're still round little pieces, and they can kind of roll all over the place. That is one of the minor issues, and I think that's been blown out somewhat out of proportion. Um however, there are some pretty big issues that I had. Um number one, paper money. I think paper money is rubbish. Um there should have been coins. Um again, not too big of an issue. The biggest issue I had here was the punchboard itself. So, the trees, for example, when I was punching these things out, these little stands, um it's almost impossible to get those out of the punchboard without ruining them, um which is really disappointing and quite frustrating, to be honest. Um and that was a real shame to see. These trees don't stick into these stands as well as I would have liked to. Too many corners have been cut
to um that could have been easily rectified just by paying a little bit more for production. So, when I read the rules to Fruiticola, I was somewhat underwhelmed. I was thinking, you know, this is a standard fair worker placement game. Let's get this over with. I'm I'm a bit underwhelmed by the rules, and um I can't really see this being very interesting. However, when I started playing this game, I started to understand how some of the individual small um and interesting mechanisms do completely flip this game on its on its edge, really, and, um, stretch your brain in different ways that you wouldn't anticipate by reading the rule book alone. For example, these cards here are extremely interesting, not only because you are playing them simultaneously with the other players to decipher who's going to go first, um, and being first is important because there are only actually a very few worker placement spots, um, depending on that player count, and, you know, you might want to get to a certain spot before other people. For example, there could be a really good tile out here that you want to get to, um, and, you know, you want to be the first to do that.
So, initiative in the first place is is very important. But, on top of that, the actual workers you're going to get and the actions you're going to get from round to round is equally, if not more, important because, you know, I could go really quickly and only get three actions, or I can go I can kind of guarantee that I'm going last, but get a whole bunch of actions. And on top of that, you've got to actually work out which workers you're going to get in the first place. So, I might get three farmers here, which will get me first initiative, but I might want to get that first initiative in order to sell, um, sell three fruits, or three or three jams. And you've got to bear in mind that you might not get a bonus for doing that. And the same applies for these different orders here. So, these are pretty scarce if you want to get a particular type of fruit, but some of them require particular workers to do it. So, all this is quite interesting, and you have to, um, decipher whether you are willing to pay that little sacrifice, whether you are going to maybe push your luck and hope that somebody doesn't go a spot so that you get the boosted action by placing the particular worker there, which is fantastic, and, um, adds a lot more depth than might first appear at face value. Um, on top of all that, you've got an power that you're going to get from round to round, which are generally going to be more powerful the, um, Well, actually, to be fair, it is quite balanced. So, you can either, um, you know, get things such as, you know, gaining one additional fruit of the same type when using the ordered action. So, this is going to let you gather fruit a lot quicker.
Uh or you're going to get the ones that you're going to get a lot of actions, but potentially you know, get a bit of a punishment. So, if this one I cannot use the uh the house's action, which means I'm not going to be able to get these assistants. But, these cards have lots of interesting things um and they're all pretty much individual. You know, such as being able to use my workers interchangeably. Um such as being able to um sell two two types of fruits if they were three because normally when you go to the uh go to the market and and sell fruit, you have to sell three at once in order to get the uh to get the market price. Um but, that one lets you do it with two. So, being a lot more efficient and um being able to uh buy and sell things or grow and sell things a lot quicker than you would be able to do otherwise. So, I love the variation in the deck here and the consideration of the hand management and card play that you're going to have to uh weigh up from turn to turn. I think that is fantastic. And um something I haven't seen before, particularly this order of workers you're going to have to place.
Um and on top of all of that, you've got to manage up your resources because you're going to have to have a steady income of fertilizer and pesticide um in order to get the fruit in the first place. But, I think the thing that I took away the most from this game was how interesting these development tiles are cuz they do really wild and wonderful things that are extremely powerful and you pretty much want to do everything. And I think that is so key for a game like this where the rule set is pretty simple, um but you do do want to do these different things just to just to give you something that other players can't do. And they could be simple things such as as I said, increasing your um increasing your storage or just getting fruits instantly, being able to uh raise the price of things when you sell them. Um and they are divided into two sections as well. So, after the end of the second season, uh they are going to ramp up in their complexity and the power in what they can do. So, there is that scaling ability and that progression which will ramp up as the game goes on. So, let's take a look about what some of these tiles do. Um I want to show you all of them because I always want you to discover them yourself because a lot of the fun, at least for me, was was in these tiles.
So, for example, these ones here. So, whenever you sell fruit by selling three at the same time, you always sell them at plus one value cuz normally when you sell things or when you when you buy things Sorry, when you sell things, you sell them at the at the value here and then they'll slide down. But, doing this one will always keep the prices strong for all of the fruit, which is extremely powerful. This one here lets you basically combine combine any two fruit to to make one of the relevant jams. So, it gives you so much more flexibility there. This one here, when you harvest these particular fruits, you get one extra. This one here lets you not only gain the fertilizer and the pesticide, but at the end of the game, every pair of those is going to get you four points, which is quite significant. Uh you've got this one here that whenever you make jams, you get to take another action another worker placement spot straight away. So, you get a turn back to back, which could be really important because, you know, when you produce jams, you might want to sell them while the market is still high before other players get in there and reduce that price.
And I know and in the Christmas sale at the end of the game, everything is going to be worth plus two. So, all these are so good and so valuable. And you know, the second pile as well, they really do ramp up. So, this one here, depending on how many sales I make in the Christmas sale or the Christmas festival, you are going to get the scaling ability here. So, if I sold, you know, six jams, I'm going to get a plus 25 coins for doing so and I'm going to get the additional storage capacity. This one here lets you just sell five things instantly. So, you don't have to waste your turn in order to do that. This one here, you know, depending on how many fruits you've got at the end, you're going to get points. This one here lets you make five jams instantly. And this one here gives you like an extra worker placement spot that only you can go to, which means that you can sell three jams no matter what worker you use. So, you know, that's a It's a to get more use out of your assistance, for example. So, all of these are just fantastic. All of them you want. And um that that kind of scarcity to getting them is really strong in this game, which I absolutely love. So, in you know, to summarize the mechanisms and the decisions, this one it has so much hidden depth, so much scope to rack your brain over, and to prioritize things, which I think is great.
There are different things you can you can do here to increase the replayability. Um you know, the Kickstarter version I assume all the versions are going to be Kickstarter versions is is going to allow you to use things such as a unique player powers. They uh can give you kind of variable setups in terms of the fruit you're going to start with. You've got lots of different end game um sorry, in game goals here. You've got these abilities here where if you collect three of a certain type of tile, uh a particular type of tile, then you're going to get the uh bonuses here. And these are all variable, and you can chop and change uh from game to game to give you lots of replayability. On top of all that, you are never going to use all of these tiles from game to game. Um there's a big stack of them, and only a few are going to be taken. So, again, you're going to see different tiles every single game. And that also applies to the cards, because you've only got five. There's a big deck of cards here, and um they've all got really cool powers on. So, again, give you a different feeling from game to game, where you're not going to see everything um in every single game you play. So, I think the replayability in this game is actually really strong.
Um the interaction as well is what you'd probably expect through a uh worker placement and kind of a stock manipulation game, or kind of a a resource speculation game, I suppose you'd call it. Uh is Yeah, you've got the real scarcity of getting to these spots, that race and the the tenseness and the turn angst of getting to the spots that you want. Um additionally, you've got the uh I said the market here, where you want to be selling things while they're still worth a lot of money, because as soon as your opponent goes there and starts selling, that value is going to diminish pretty quickly. The progression of the game as well, I think is really well done. So, particularly because you're going to be gathering the tiles as you go throughout, and these tiles sometimes synergize with each other wonderfully. You know, for example, some of them might say, you know, as soon as you produce gems, you can sell them. And some might say, as soon as you sell, you take another action. And then some might say, you know, when you sell a particular type of fruit, you get to sell it higher. So, once you once you combine those different things together, you can take some pretty powerful turns and do things that other players can't do. And um I think that bit of that very small but very powerful engine is a big part of why I like Finca.
And the time investment as well is something um that is great in Finca. Four seasons are uh very very quick. The game only takes about an hour to play, and there's still tremendous amount of depth here that you need to explore and um rack your brain over. So, yeah, I think uh a game of this magnitude to play in 60 minutes is really well done. So, I can't complain whatsoever about the time investment. The turns are pretty snappy. You know, sometimes you are taking quite a few actions from round to round. You know, such as six placements and potentially more than that. Um and sometimes you're only taking three placement spots. So, yeah, there's there's no real scope for um for being bogged down and taking too long and dragging on too long and outstaying its welcome. I think the game does a great job of staying in that under 60-minute time frame, which is uh two thumbs up for me.
So, overall, I think this game is really well done. Um I'm I'm really surprised actually about why this game is getting such mixed reviews. I can only attribute that to maybe being disproportionately focused on some of the production issues. But if I'm talking about the gameplay, you know, in isolation, this game is so solid. There's some really unique things here such as the card play, you know, the the workers you're going to get from round to round. The market is interesting. The scarcity of the worker placement spots is great. The In particular, the the uh development tiles are absolutely amazing. They add so much depth to the game. Add so much flavor to the game. And And it really does remind me of a game like Raccoon Tycoon where every single power, you know, you want to have it. And the fact that you're not going to see these all from game to game is just going to add so much more interest for me to keep getting this one to the table. So, am I missing something here and I'm not understanding what the other people are saying in terms of it not being a great game or are they not giving it a fair chance because it is so good and just a really well-rounded Euro game and economical vibe where you're trying to get as much money as you can. And that really does shine through. So, all these separate elements come together in a very simple framework, but just mesh together beautifully and certainly going going to be a contender for my uh pleasant surprise of the year. Um I think it's a great game. Really really strong. That is Fructicola by Giorni Fiore and Virginia Gigli. Check this one out and do not um you know, do not
immediately presume that some of the reviews are right. Find out for yourself because the gameplay is really strong. This one is going to get my shield of quality um and I'm proud to give it that. And again, I'm really gutted that this one has not got the buzz um from the from the get-go really. So, I hope you've enjoyed this review. If you have, please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos, too. For everyone else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.