Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dungeon Crawlers That did not age well with time or new editions

Transcript 12:40

And be sure to check out Trading Card Market, the very best in sports cards, trading cards, trading card supplies, LEGOs, and so much more. tradingcardmarket.com, the best in all your gaming needs. Hey everybody, it's your old pal Rob. We're going to just make an adjustment there. There we go. I can actually see myself. But uh

I'm not going to edit this out because I never do cuz cuz we just do it the way we do it. So, today I wanted to talk about dungeon crawlers that did not age well. Okay? And we're talking about games that that came out, had all kinds of hype and love, and just absolutely dropped the ball going forward. Whether they tried to do second editions, third editions, second acts, third acts, and so forth and so on, and just completely fell flat on their face. Uh I cannot I cannot start this list without uh taking unfortunately a shot at good old Mantic Games.

Um Dungeon Saga. You know, I really liked that game. It was different. It was bookcase. You could you could have all the different things uh you know, available to you in a bookshelf. But somewhere along the way, they kind of dropped the ball on this. It had a lot of feel to it, but then the cards and the AI, and you know, making it kind of lost its identity. Uh the the the the very first, you know, bookcase was very very good. And then years later, of course, they came out with the second uh volume of this. And this was not not as good. Um it was simplified.

It was dumbed down. Um not that that's a bad thing because there are great games like HeroQuest and so forth and so on. That that, you know, a game that has aged perfectly, okay? Dungeon Saga done the complete opposite and and went the other way. And I I I just felt that this did not hold up well and it's where it's at, lost in limbo. Which is a shame because, you know, you know, everybody thinks I hate Mantic. It's just um I really don't. I I really root for them and then every single time I'm disappointed. Now, from what I've heard, they've done a great job with Halo and um I believe another game that they were coming out with. But it just seems like they can just never get over the hump.

Which I can never understand. Worms was a disaster, I think. Uh some of the some of the other IPs that they did uh didn't turn out that well. But, you know, you keep rooting for them. Uh you know, they have their fans and for them, that's fantastic. For me, it just doesn't work. This list or or the games I'm going to be talking about. Um I I I I think there's just one game that kind of inspires this whole talk and there's just no way around it. But but we're going to get that out a little later. Another game that kind of didn't age well but ended up on the better side of things is uh Magic Realm.

Now, Magic Realm in the beginning is a complicated mess. And people loved it because for its for what it was for its time, it really was something special. It really was. It really was. Now, we're talking you know, early '80s, okay? When there wasn't a lot to compare it to. And it was hard to get through, hard to understand. I've seen certain people try to do play-throughs for it and become incredibly frustrated and just completely walk away from the game. Get it. Understand it.

On the other side, as this game aged and became kind of like a grail thing just because of the game, but not the gameplay, Dragon Down came out and is basically a

[clears throat]

an ode to Magic Realm or a successor to it and has really done everything perfectly. And by doing that, it kind of killed Magic Realm, if that makes sense. And when when that happens, you know, this is this is a tale of a game that just as it aged, it got worse and worse and worse. Um you know, you could put out as many supplements and you know, or fan-made things that you want, it still just doesn't work. There were just too many things where you know, this thing was a grail game and a an unplay- an unplayable grail game is the best way to to to put this one. I don't you could put it any other way. And it's a shame that it is where it's at, but you know, in a way we're also very thankful to Mr.

B and the fantastic Dragons Dawn, which is just I mean, just everything that you wanted out of Magic Realm and and a and a fantastic experience for sure. Then we come to the game the game that I really think highlights this entire video. And that's The Sett. You know, when you talk about The Sett, you talk about three chapters of of greatness and complete disaster. Um

[clears throat]

you know, the first the first incarnation of it was really just special. Special, a game onto its own. Okay? And you know, it did so many things. The expansions were tremendous. The book that came out that enhanced that was just glorious. Um just a fun fun game. Then The Sett 2 came along. And this is where there is a lot of push and pull with this particular game. And this really comes down to um people that love it and then people that are just so in love with the first version of it that it you know, that they'll defend it till the end of days. The second version and a lot of the the scenarios became a race against time instead of a dungeon crawl.

And that's where it kind of falls apart, but there were just so much content, so many beautiful miniatures for it, so many tiles and adventures, and the things that you could do. And if you were a die-hard Descent person and a fan of Fantasy Flight, you would defend that thing until the cows came home. And then the you know, the purest, which were the the the first volume of it, um they they they just rejected it. They would play it, but you know, in a way rejected it, which was a whole 'nother story onto itself. But then came chapter three, which was um that total disaster, uh Legends of the Dark or what whatever you want to call that thing, which used an app, which didn't make sense to have the terrain or even have a board game because you did more in the app than you did on the table.

You spent more time trying to put something together that you could have followed through with with with cardboard and paper. And I remember some some fat kid in Canada uh giving me a hard time, and he still has a receipt coming um about what I said, and all it was was my opinion. And um he took offense to it, and but never would say anything to me personally, um coward that he is. And this became a great huge debate, but I can tell you this much, people from volume volume one and volume two hated the third incarnation of this game. They bought it, they hoped, and then they came out with volume two of the third incarnation, and that did not do well. All these things that they said this this this game was going to be three chapters and it was going to be this monumental wonderful experience was just a big pile of garbage. And people that were saying that this was going to be an all-time classic, well, where is it now?

Where does it rank now? Oh, it looks like Rob was right. Right? This Rob. Okay? And I was right. And it not to, you know, self-high-five or or pat myself on the back or toot my own horn, toot toot. But, you know, this was a game that was a mess. And it tried to take another turn from what was, you know, I I had no problem with with with the second edition. I had no problem with the first edition. I actually liked them both. They both were different enough that gave me different experiences. But,

[sighs]

that pile of crap that was the third edition was an incredible incredible mess and continues to be so. Um, and for people who loved this game, you know, loved this game, to see it die the way it died was a horrible horrible thing to one of all-time classic games. So, if you have all the old stuff and you're holding it near and dear to your heart, at least you have the memories and you can hold that close because it this is one that you just don't come back from and I don't think slapping the descent on another version is going to help all the people that felt burnt by this.

So, I mean, there you have it. There's a couple of them. I would love to hear what I mean, I can go on and make this a 2-hour video, but we don't want to. But, I will tell you this much. I would love to hear your thoughts on this. Maybe the games that I've talked about. Maybe you have a different opinion of it. Or or maybe there's some things that you felt that I didn't include in here that you really want to scream at the top of the mountain about. Well, that's what we're here for. Discussion and and and sharing our information with each other. So, again, um volume two of 64 days of Tuesdays and Thursdays of done just dungeon crawls on those days for 64 consecutive. We will be doing in volume two here uh is wrapping up and until next time.

It's your old pal Ron. We'll see you soon, everybody. And thanks for watching the video. Be sure to head over to tradingcardmarket where you'll get the best in sports cards, trading cards, trading card supplies, LEGOs, and more. Trading card market .com.

Progress saved