TMNT Turtle Team-Up: My Favorite Mechanism
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemaier Games, and today I'm going to talk about my favorite mechanism in the new way to play Magic the Gathering. It's called the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Turtle Team-Up. This is a cooperative game for two to four players. You could play it solo as well, I think. Um where you're playing against a a boss, a series of bosses. Fully cooperative play. This came from a a few weeks ago I I filmed and posted a video about um collectible card games and expandable games and how I was kind of surprised that while there were many living card games that feature cooperative play, there really weren't many uh uh other games, other collectible games or expandable games that feature cooperative play. Like Magic the Gathering is a dueling game. A lot of these are dueling head-to-head games where you're trying to reduce the opponent's life to zero. Even in Magic, Magic has a very popular format called Commander, it is a free-for-all. You're trying to to outlast and defeat all the opponents.
Um and yet, living card games are very very popular. So, I thought and then in in the comments someone mentioned, "Hey, there is a new way to play Magic the Gathering that features cooperative play." And that is in this uh the the Universes Beyond series for the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, they have this new cooperative way to play. I bought it immediately. I played it the other day with uh with three other people, and we had a lot of fun. We played twice in about 2 hours, so each game took about an hour. At four players, you have a pretty high life total for the boss. Um I'll talk about how that works in a second. But, I do want to say up front, like I'll talk about a few of the mechanisms, but overall, I'm just kind of elated that there is a cooperative way to play Magic. I like they they didn't just throw some random cards in a box and say, "Hey, play this cooperatively. Here are some rules that make that work." There are specific components in this box that make it work particularly well cooperatively. Um uh the the basic idea that you're doing Each Each player, there's kind of two things that make this really work. One is that players act simultaneously. They act as a team.
And so when when you're going through the phases of a magic turn, it's pretty much distilled into like the things that you do before combat, combat, and the things you do after combat on your turn. And you do all those things simultaneously. I'm not waiting for the other players to play a card. I am I was playing Donatello. I was just playing cards and untapping them and and casting spells, things like that on my own simultaneously with the other players. And then we all did combat together against the current boss. And that's where the the other element of the cooperative play came into play where you have this little tracker that tracks the current bosses life total. And I say bosses as in both singular and plural because you start off the game with just one random boss card. You have these boss cards that that are in play that just give you a little twist, something that you have to work around while you're playing.
Um so you have one of these in play. That boss has at least in a in a four-player game has 30 health. So we have to reduce that boss's health to 30. There's no blocking. Um and I'll come back to that in a second, but there's no blocking. When we deal damage, when we like attack, we're always dealing damage directly to the boss. Um then when you defeat that boss, you get rid of one boss and you they you then draw two bosses. So you then have to defeat two bosses. Um however, these bosses their total life total is still 30. They share 30 life. You're just dealing with two different abilities at the same time that makes it a little bit difficult. When you defeat those bosses, you then have three bosses in play. You have to deal with three bosses and take them out. And in a four-player game, you then also have to put out four bosses and defeat four bosses. Again, even when there are four bosses in play, it's still just 30 life. So you're basically reducing the opponent cooperatively down to zero life four times in a four-player game is is the idea. A little bit different if you're playing a two-player game or a three-player game.
Um so I thought that worked really well, too. That we were just, you know, attacking together, doing things simultaneously, reducing the boss to zero. It was a different puzzle every time in both games because the bosses came out in a different order. While you're doing that, and I won't go too deep into this, but you also have these event cards. So, whenever the boss has a turn, they are going to reveal two different event cards. Some of them are creatures and some of them are just like things that happen. This one says, "Destroy all creatures with flying that the heroes control." So, these are cards designed to kind of hurt all the opponents. And they are rough. This is actually one of the reasons that I think it's fun to play this game back-to-back because we knew some of the things that we were getting into the second time we played. And there's one card that deals two damage to all all creatures. There's a couple that have you sacrifice the creature with the highest power, things like that. Um so, they they are they're dealing, you know, they're they're doing destructive things to the to the players that you have to deal with and discuss a little bit.
Um the other thing that I think makes this work, there's two other things I wanted to mention. One is um the the creatures the boss controls, they are not blockers. And I think this is they probably tested something like this to see if it could work and they realized that having the players choose which opposing creatures autonomously are blocking just doesn't work. And so, whenever the heroes attack, they are dealing damage directly to the villain. There's no blocking. All of the um creature cards that the boss can plays can play, say they can't block. So, you don't have to worry about them blocking, but they will attack on on the boss's turn. And the one thing that we found that I would recommend is uh we won handily both times that we played.
However, we made the second game a little bit more difficult by saying that every time the boss played a card, played a creature card, um or had creature cards in play, they all have haste. So, they're going to they're they're they're all ninjas. They're ninja in into play and they're dealing they're they're attacking right away. This kept us on our toes a little bit more than in the game where we had a full turn to plan out what we were doing with these creatures who couldn't block us in the first place. Um so I thought that helped quite a bit. Also, I I guess the last thing is that I really enjoyed the the actual cooperation that was happening between players. There were a number of cards in our decks and we were each playing as one of the turtles. There were a number of cards that normally in a game of Magic you were only playing these cards to benefit you. They're you know, instance like that that pump up your spells or or or that uh that yeah, things that usually are good for your own creatures typically. But in cooperative play, you're really looking out for the best interest of the other players and there are moment moments where or a number of moments where it might be better for someone else's creature like say a creature has double strike to pump up that creature instead of your own creature because they're going to deal more damage. And I thought this was it it was just a shift in mindset that I thought worked really well the way that the these decks were crafted and I think that many Magic cards would work for this format. Um and that instead of uh only being self-serving, you were actually looking out for other players and finding the most optimal way to uh to to solve the problem of defeating the boss. So yeah, overall I had a I had a lot of fun playing the two games of of Turtle Team Up. Again, I thought what it was a
little easy. Maybe that was a four-player thing. Um and even that that it was still easy too easy after we had the the boss's creatures attack us right away when they came into play, but there are other ways to make it more difficult as well that are in the in the rule book. So, there are other ways to scale it up and make it harder. I'd love to hear your thoughts if you have played this version of Magic, if you've played a or really any cooperative version of a typically competitive game that you thought translated really well. Um let me know about that in the comments. Let me know your thoughts about translating this type of game into a cooperative game. Thanks.