Skip to main content
Loading video...

Earth Express - Board Game Preview - Speedy Growth

Transcript 19:43

Hi, I'm one of the Broken Meeple. Win or lose, I'm going to be on this video. And here we have a preview for the Kickstarter, which is starting any day now for Earth Express. This is not going to be a full review. I'm basically going to give you an indication of what's in the box, at least at this point, how the game plays, what it feels like from first impressions, you know, after playing it a fair few times, and how it kind of compares to the big daddy of the main Earth, which is sadly not on the shelf behind me because it's currently in my game bag after having played it again recently. So, Earth Express claims to be a faster version of Earth, one that can be played with up to eight players in a time frame of anywhere from 15 minutes to 45 minutes or even 30 minutes on average, and is meant to basically give you a kind of the same feel of Earth, trimming out a few things here and there, making it a little less finky, a little bit more streamlined in places, but allowing for a quick version of Earth to be played when you don't have the time to sit together and play the full-on finky experience.

Particularly if you've got the expansions with it, whether it be the first one, Abundance, or the upcoming one, Animal Kingdom. So, in terms of, you know, what did I feel about getting this one? Earth obviously is one of my favorite games. It's been in my top 10 the last 2 years. It's going to be probably a top 25 game for life at this rate, you know, it's a game I love to play. The idea of coming up with an Express version, whenever any game decides they're going to do some really streamlined version or like a cut-down version, I'm always a little bit in two minds cuz sometimes it pays off and you get this really solid, like, you know, smaller version of the game, which may or may not replace the original. But then sometimes you get something like, say, Sanctuary. Yeah, exactly. So, if our Nova, and it doesn't always work. But I'm basically going to going to tell you how this plays and you hopefully you can make your own mind up. SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY. In the big version of Earth, you were trying to build up a 4 by 4 grid of cards and they were made up of terrain and flora cards. These basically gave you ways of growing trees, getting sprouts, you know, triggering abilities, getting points, end-game scoring opportunities, the works. And the idea was was that you built up this 4 by 4 grid in front of you, but during the game one player would choose an action tile and then they, as well as everybody else around the table, would simultaneously resolve it. Whoever chose it got a bigger bonus, everybody else got something a little bit lesser. But then everybody went through their display of cards from top left all the way down through their grid and triggered any abilities that match the color of the action that was being selected. So, if someone chose blue, you

went through and triggered every blue ability that was showing on your cards. And this repeated until somebody filled up their full grid. There were all sorts of different powers that you could trigger, lots of different icons, lots of different, you know, ways to play the game, lots of strategies, lots of little tactical bits, and you basically churned through a ton of cards in order to play through the game. You know, it's a fantastic game and you can check out my review if you need to. So, what Earth Express is doing is condensing that down a little bit. You are now instead building up a grid of nine cards and you play over a set number of rounds, five in fact. Each round you will play two cards from your hand of cards, you'll have seven at the start of every round, you'll choose two to play, and each round you will play two cards, except for the last round where you'll play your ninth. So, everybody plants at the same time. The turns are entirely simultaneous. During your planting phase, you will choose the two cards to plant, but you will have options to use seed tokens for various abilities. We'll get onto that in a minute. Once that is done, everybody then again simultaneously chooses one of the bonuses that is on the top one of these action tiles. It will be yellow, blue, or red. There is no green action in this case. Resolve the bonus that is on there, which is the same for everybody, and then they will go through their grid, much in the same vein as Earth, and trigger off all the abilities that were of that color. So, if I choose yellow here, that's not yellow, that's not yellow. This gets me a tree growth, okay? Cool. I can put a tree growth on this particular fauna and happy days and keep going with all the different yellow abilities. That's effectively how a round goes. And at the end of the round,

you will have five cards left over in your hand from the original seven, which you will pass to your neighbor on your left. They will you will then receive five from the person on your right, draw two more cards, and then you have your hand of seven for the next round. So, there is an element of drafting, although the drafting is a kind of more of a means to an end. This is not like a a Sushi Go setup where the drafting is like a mainstay of the game. It's just a added little extra here. You don't really have a huge amount of scope to hate draft here. But during the planting phase, you have a couple of little extras that you can do with the seeds. These seeds, of which you can, you know, try and get them by various means, card abilities or converting other resources, allow you to do one of two things. Discard and redraw cards. So, if you don't like your hand, you can sort of go, "Well, I don't like these four. Fine. I'm going to take these four out of my hand and draw another four." Sweet. Fantastic. But what you're also allowed to do is germinate. Now, this shows up in the uh the new version of the Earth Abundance expansion. So, the idea with this was that you could spend seeds to name a type of ability on any card.

And because you've got objectives and you've got cards that you're looking for, you might need to name, "Right, I need something with a lot of growth spaces. I need something with, you know, uh less than four growth spaces. I need something with a that gives me a seed power. I need a red card. I need a winter card. I need a cold card." You know, that type of thing. And basically what you do is that you flip part of the deck over, look through until you find such an example of a card. So, this one I'll take for example. Put the rest back and then this one is now in your hand, which you would no doubt probably plant cuz you were searching for it for that reason. It's basically a way to mitigate luck of the draw as long as you can keep up a decent, you know, supply of seeds as the game goes on. This is done as well simultaneously during the whole planting phase. As well as that, you still have the familiar thing from the big daddy Earth, which is you will have a personal objective which you can score points for. There will be two public objectives, which will be on the main stay for everybody to have a go with.

And instead of four fauna, sorry, fauna cards, you will have two fauna cards, which are these brown objectives, which again apply to everybody except it's first come, first serve. So, the first time you get there, you get more points than the person who comes second. Except the one difference here is that if you do it at the same time in the same round, you all get the same prize. There's no like turn order that breaks the tie or anything like that. It's it, you know, that competitive nature is kind of removed here. It's basically everybody gets the prize if you were there at the same time. I mean, you've only got five rounds, so they can only be so nasty. God sake, why isn't it we can't learn to live together?

Yeah, there's not a lot to learn here, is there? I mean, the rules of this are crazy simple. I'm not going to comment on on components because most of this is hijacked from Earth and, you know, it's a prototype at the end of the day. You know, there will be stronger versions of these. For example, the cubes will actually fit in them. You know, that was quite amusing. But essentially what you've got is you're going to have three displays where you will put your 3 by 3 grid of cards. And I like the fact that you can basically set it up so that it's vertical or horizontal depending on your table space and how you like to perceive your cards. Nice little twist. And you'll still have the familiar tree pieces, you know, with the canopies and that. You'll still have the sprout cubes. Except the sprout cubes are not piled onto a card like they were before. You instead have a little track at the side of each of the cards on these three little track things and basically you just mark how many sprouts the card has based on its capacity maximum as you go along. So, instead of having like, you know, 50 cubes over all your cards, you effectively have a maximum of nine cubes just basically going up and down on the tracks. But points-wise, they work very similarly.

You still score for trees like before, one point per tree, more if it's a completed tree. Sprout cubes, one per sprout. You know, seeds, one per seed, you know, that's all the same. Planting cards does not cost anything now, though. You now do no longer have to gather soil to play cards. You just choose two cards to play. So, you might think, "Well, aren't some cards like miles better than others?" Potentially, but there is a catch. The VP value on the card ranges into the negatives as well. So, you might have a card that's particularly sweet, but it carries a penalty. So, I've got a, you know, a die, what is it? A Dehurian Lurch here. I do I love nature, but I do not propose to know much about flowers and plants. You know, I'm more of an animal sort of person. Well, that doesn't make sense to me. But then you are very small.

But I don't know. It's pretty, what do I know? So, with this one, it's a five VP card. The abilities are kind of basic. It's got a pretty good tree space on it, you know, but it's a half-decent card. But then I might have this one here that can get me quite a decent amount of tree space. It's also got high sprout capacity. It's also got a decent tree space on it, but it's minus one VP. You're getting a lot for that. So, you know, you have, you know, VP swinging both ways. There are no events. That's been taken out. Frankly, take it or leave. I mean, I I don't mind the events from the big game, but it's probably one of the weaker elements, especially in the scoring phase. So, removing the elements is not exactly something you're going to lose sleep over. But, you know, everything here is very familiar to someone who's played Earth. If you have never played Earth before, though, this is a pretty good jumping-on point for learning the system, you know, and you know, but one thing that everyone's going to ask is, "Is this a replacement for Earth? Do I need to own Earth if I have this one?"

Well, I don't think so to that extent. You know, I love Earth and, you know, I can't give ratings for this. It is a preview, but I've enjoyed my time with this. But I don't feel that this is one that I would say, "Right, Earth is gone. Out into the dustbin it goes and now this is the one I keep." Because Earth has more going on, you know, with the Abundance expansion, with the new Earth, you know, Animal Kingdom expansion, which is going to add the animal meeples and other sort of effects going on, as well as the different types of powers that you can get. I mean, you don't have green powers in this. You don't draw extra cards with powers. You don't have the soil as an extra like consideration. So, there is less to think about here. You know, if you want the more meaty version of Earth, you play the bigger card the bigger game. And it's not like that game took that long to play unless you play with a five players. That is not recommended under any circumstances.

But, this one does provide a good stepping stone into the system because I had a problem with other games like Sanctuary where I thought the stuff they trimmed out made the game considerably worse rather than, you know, a decent spin-off. This one I don't feel does that. It doesn't trim off anything I would consider to be vital to how Earth plays. It's just you know, if I want a little bit more meat to my game, if I want more effects and more stuff to trigger, more combo-tastic niceness, then I'm going to play the bigger Earth game. It'll have more variety for me. Here, you do have a lot of cards. I mean, for crying out loud. I mean, this is a pretty decent amount of cards here just for even for a prototype. You've got a lot of objectives. They're all double-sided, both the green and the brown. So, and but given that you're only using, you know, three greens each per game and two browns period for the whole game, you are getting a decent amount of variety out of the box for this as well. But, where things are a little bit more constrained is more the action tiles. You only have three of these that you flip over. So, essentially what happens is you at the start of your round you flip one over, so you know that you've only got a choice of blue or red. You do the round based on that. That goes away. Flip the next one, next one, shuffle them all together, and then get another two because you're doing five rounds. This can cause the annoyance that if you focus on a particular color that your color doesn't turn up as often as others. There is a little bit of a luck of the draw factor here as well. I mean, people dis Earth that reason, but you know, it's not like you escape it here.

The Earth Abundance expansion and the seeds here do the same thing. They germinate and find you the specific cards that you need. So, you can mitigate it to that extent, but yes, there's going to be luck of the draw. You might just be, you know, you might just draw some cards or get drafted a few that are like, "Oh, this is perfect for what I need. Fantastic." You might germinate and find the exact card that's that that is, you know, exactly for the thing that you need. And because you do less turns in this one, achieving the brown objectives particularly, in the bigger version you had more time to go for it. You know, there was more turns. There was more ability to make up for maybe a bad starting hand. Here though, you don't have much of that mitigation. You know, if you start off with a hand of cards that doesn't really have anything to do with the brown objectives, you're going to be at a bit of a disadvantage compared to somebody who started off with a hand of cards that's like, "Oh, yeah, this perfectly fits those. I mean, it's a blue ability and it's a tree. And I've got two of those in fact. All right, fantastic." Yes, you have the the seed ability to discard and redraw cards, but it's not a guaranteed way of getting past it. You start with three at the beginning, great. It costs three to germinate though. It's only going to get you one specific card. And even then, it's random which one you get. So, it's not necessarily going to help you as much as you would like. So, you know, that luck of the draw factor, if it bothered you in Earth, it's probably going to bother you a little bit more here. I'm lucky. That's not a superpower. But, that is counteracted by the fact that this is a shorter, quicker game. 15 minutes is a bit optimistic though. I mean, to play this in 15 minutes, you would have to play this by

yourself or or two player. And you would have to basically play at lightning speed. You know, like do no thinking between turns. No, you know, no reading the card effects or anything. I'm pretty sure most people would opt to not to do that. You know, this is you can play this in 30 minutes. However, if you start upping the player count, you're going to hit that 45-minute back sort of boundary, possibly even more if you've got really slow players. Now, it should not often do that. But, bear in mind this game claims that you can play this with up to eight players, you know, eight people because technically it is all simultaneous. But, you've got a lot of cards going around then. And with every simultaneous game, you are only as fast as your LOWEST COMMON DENOMINATOR.

[screaming]

SO, IT DOESN'T MATTER how simultaneous the game actions might be. If you've got eight of you around the table, I guarantee that at least half the table is going to be slowing down the other half. So, you're going to be here for quite some time. And I have tried this at all the player counts. There is a solo mode in here where you uh go against the AI. I'll explain a bit more of that in a minute. But, I've tried this with two. I've tried this with three and four. I even tried this with six and with eight. Eight is not something I'll be repeating ever again. Six, probably not either. This for me just feels like a good filler to play with up to four players, maybe five. I could stretch to five, I think, if they are familiar with Earth. But, you're really looking up to four. But, the rule set is very simple. And if I was to if I was thinking, "Uh I don't reckon you might be able to handle Earth." This is a good one to just throw them into and see if they get used to it. If they find if they handle this fine, then great. Whip out the bigger like Earth and then play that one. But, if they start struggling a little bit with this, you know that maybe they need to play this a bit more often before you even dare throw the big daddy in them.

So, it's a it's it's kind of a that's kind of its role to play. It's not a replacement for Earth. It's a stepping stone. It's an alternative. It is by every which way but loose, a filler. You know, at least if you play with the right player count. 30 minutes, good for the length of game. This is why Superman works alone. The solo mode is pretty neat here though. You basically face off against Gaia and it's about beating her victory point score. And the idea is is that Gaia will slowly but surely get a few victory points as the game goes on based on what abilities they trigger. So, the more abilities they trigger, the more points they get. But, predominantly they will get quite a fair amount of points based on what they have at the end of the game, you know, what you know, things you've got, etc. But, the idea is is that they have their own grid of three by three already set up. You don't have a hand of cards anymore. So, there's no drafting. There's nothing like that. What you do is that you basically pick your cards that you're planting from the nine that Gaia has.

So, I might decide, "Well, hang on a minute. We've got blue and red up here. So, if I want to trigger blue abilities, then I don't want Gaia to basically trigger a lot of blue abilities cuz every time they that Gaia gains anything, it's basically converted into victory points." Well, as I look at my display here, somewhat conveniently this was not arranged, there's only two blue cards here. So, if I plant these two, if I don't if they work for this, then I'm like, "You know what? Yeah, cool." So, I'm going to take this one, the marula and the potato plant, plant them in my own tableau, you know, further a field. And then the idea is is that, you know, the cards will get replaced and so they'll always like basically have a, you know, a selection of nine. But, if I then choose the blue power, they have less of the blue abilities to trigger and so don't earn as many points. So, it's similar to how the what the Gaia worked in the previous game. You are trying to do well yourself by building a decent efficient tableau of cards, but you're also trying to sort of I wouldn't say game the system, but you're trying to sort of goad Gaia into not gaining as many points herself because effectively, the better you do, chances are the better they do. You've got to kind of reach a balancing act. It's a very simple solo mode to throw in though. You know, there's not a lot of piloting involved. You are effectively doing what you need to do all the time. You still deal with this. You still deal with this. You know, so most of the game is pretty much the same as a multiplayer and, you know, goes at a bit of a quicker pace. But, you have a victory point score to beat and you're still doing all the necessary stuff. So, if you're into solo mode for Earth, this is a pretty solid one as well. So, you can play this with multiple players or

alone. You know, and it works well. See, there's two sides to every sword. So, all in all, Earth Express has the makings of a solid side spin-off to a game that I already loved. I don't think for me it replaces the game. Like, overall I would still prefer the bigger game to this one. But, I think it's a solid alternative. I want to get people into the system, but I don't know if they can handle it. Play Express. I only have maximum 45 minutes to play the game and I would like a little bit of fun with Earth, okay? Play Earth Express. You know, I need to you know, I only have a small bag or only so much space in my game bag to take to game night and I can't fit Earth into it. Take Earth Express. If somebody said all I have is this one and that's the one they're going to play, I'm not going to lose sleep over it. I'm not going to be like, "Oh, I wish I was playing the bigger version." Or saying, "Oh, this is not as good." It's like, "Well, yeah, I prefer the bigger game, but I would still get a decent amount of enjoyment here." So, you know, I think they're onto a good start so far. Be interested to see how this develops, what tweaks they make to the solo mode and any or tweaks to the main rules. So, if you like what you see, go check out the game on the crowdfunding page and, you see if you fancy making a pledge for it. I for one have got good positive first impressions of this so far. And I've given you the lowdown on how it feels to play as well as, you know, how it feels compared to the big game. It's up to you now to decide whether it's worth spending your cash on. Thank you, Mr. Carraway. I'll take it under advisement.

So, that's it for me on this episode of the Broken Meeple. If you like what you see, then please follow me up on YouTube and follow me up on BoardGameGeek when it goes live on the page. You can check out the last two top 50 lists in the top 10 to see what I sort of my condensed thoughts about Earth, but you can also check out my official review for the game on my channel as well. Yeah, spoiler alert, I love it. Go figure. But, also don't forget to check out other videos that I've done recently as well as consider subscribing to the Patreon which helps to keep this channel going, acquire the games that I can't get as review copies, and the like so I can produce more content for you. Uh by all means, check out this game on Kickstarter and see whether it's worth spending your money on, you know, and thank you for watching. Take care. Remember, it's only a game and I'll see you on the next Broken Meeple video. Take care, everyone.

Progress saved