Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hellboy: The Board Game - 2026 Revisit

Transcript 24:07

Hey folks, welcome back to the Dungeon Dive. Daniel here. I hope you're doing well and if you're not, I hope you are soon. Okay, today on the channel we are revisiting Hellboy the board game. I've had an itch to play this recently and over the last week I've played a couple of games and this game is really great. Uh this is a game that always flirts with my top 10 but never quite makes it on the top 10 list and I don't think it's going to but it's a game that's just right outside of my top 10. Uh to me this feels kind of like a mix between Warhammer Quest Silver Tower, a game that I love, and uh HeroQuest. And I think that makes a lot of sense coming from designer James M. Hewitt who was the designer on Silver Tower. He worked with Games Workshop and I know he was a big fan of HeroQuest. And so that kind of lineage makes a lot of sense and there's just a heck of a lot to love about Hellboy.

[snorts]

Um this video is not going to be an overview on how the game plays or anything like that. There are plenty of videos on YouTube if you want to see something like that. Uh you can watch my original review or many of the other hundreds of videos on YouTube but I'm just going to briefly talk about about five of the things that I really do love about this game. Now there are a couple of negatives and I want to get those out of the way first and uh the biggest negative is really the disparity between the Kickstarter version and the retail version. It does make it hard to recommend especially now as prices have started to uh climb a bit for the big box Kickstarter version. But this was one of those games where the Kickstarter version just came with so much more just in the base box. The uh base box for the Kickstarter version is a very big box. It's much uh bigger than the retail version and it just comes with a lot more stuff and a lot more variety.

And it's really hard for me to speak to the value of the retail version because I've never played with a just to that stuff. So, I know some people uh really like the retail version and hey, that's great. You can always get the retail version with some expansions. And so, just so you know, the stuff that I have and the stuff that that I think that that makes it great is I have the Kickstarter version of the base game. I have uh the following expansions. I have conquering worm, wild hunt, darkness calls, and the BPRD archives, which allows you to create almost an infinite number of missions to play. So, there is a lot of variety. I think the second biggest negative is the use of the tile system to create the maps. I just find a lot of these tiles to be really boring and I don't think they add a lot to the game. They add a little bit of time in setup and it makes it a little hard to judge, you know, how much space the game is going to take on your table when you are setting it up. I guess one good thing is once you get everything set up, you don't really need to be uh going back into the box to be uh pulling new things out. So, it is a game where you kind of set up and then play.

But, I kind of wish that Hellboy: The Board Game leaned even further into that kind of HeroQuest inspiration and just used one large game board with random rooms and corridors that you can make work with any of the scenarios. You know, maybe it could even be double-sided where one side was in an interior location and the other side was an exterior location. I think I would prefer that. Uh constructing the board with these tiles, the tiles always kind of move around. They're pretty high-quality cardboard, but you know, you're not drawing tiles to explore further. You're setting up the map at the beginning and I just don't think that tiles are very exciting and it doesn't really make a lot of sense why they are tiles because you're kind of they're just artwork. You don't really interact with anything other than tiles. There's no reason for this game to be constructed with tiles.

It could have just been a HeroQuest-like board. But uh let's get into some of the reasons why I think Hellboy is so good. Okay, the first reason that I love Hellboy is that it does a great job of capturing the feel, the theme, and the vibe of its source material, the original comic book, uh Hellboy and the BPRD series. Uh Hellboy is just an absolutely amazing comic book. The writing is great. The art is great. The vibe is great. It has a very cool kind of folk horror meets Lovecraftian weird horror with some Arkham Files-style investigation, a little bit of government paranoia, and some X-Files uh type situations along with, you know, this kind of high-flying super adventurous pulp action. And it's just a a joy to read, a joy to look at.

It's always fun. It's always um just action-packed. And there's a lot of weirdness and mystery. And I think the board game really does capture the feel of the original source material. And that's, you know, when you are adapting something to a new medium, I think that is important. You know, it doesn't have to be a one-to-one translation, but when you are adapting something it needs to feel like it respects the original source. And I think Hellboy the board game does that, and it does that in a variety of ways. And one of the main ways I think is with all the characters. So, you have a great stable of different characters in the Hellboy comics and in the BPRD comics. This last couple of games I was playing as Liz Sherman and Hellboy. These are kind of a pairing that I use a lot.

And the characters in the board game, they all feel very different. When you are playing Hellboy, it's a very different experience than playing as Liz Sherman. Sure, they have the same verbs, they have the same actions, you know, they're moving, they're attacking, they're investigating, they're defending. But the way they do those things feels a little different. All of the characters have special moves, the characters have weaknesses and strengths, and they have different things that they can spend their actions on. And so, you have to utilize the characters' strengths to kind of offset the other characters' weaknesses, and it does feel like you are playing together as a team, as a cool superhero team in a comic book. And I think a lot of times I games we are playing multiple players, they don't really take advantage of that idea of really working as a team. And in Hellboy, the characters can help each other by boosting each other's attacks and defense and their die rolls and things like that, but just all of the characters and all of their special abilities and the different things that they can do, their different strengths, their different weaknesses, it goes a long way in emulating that kind of comic book superhero team experience, and that's something I really do appreciate.

The other thing is that kind of pulp action adventure. Uh there's a lot of combat in Hellboy, and the last couple games I was playing I was playing against these uh skeletal warriors, and I always love playing against skeletons, but there are like fishmen that you can fight, you can fight against Nazis, uh there are robots and monsters and big Cthulhu-like things. And it does take that kind of more pulp action style, that kind of, you know, more It's more like Arkham Horror, Eldritch Horror than it is Lovecraftian. It's more Brian Lumley, because uh you know, Hellboy can like basically punch Cthulhu and do damage to these uh big beasts, and just the pulp adventure is really fun. But like the comic book, it's more than just adventure. There's also some investigation. You have to take time during the missions to investigate points of interest in order to pick up these investigation tokens and these little insight tokens, and then those will often help you if you have a certain number of them, they will help you when it comes time to confront the big boss. You know, the more you have, the better you will do. Uh you have to take time to investigate things and to rest and to recuperate and to put together a strategy, and that also happens at the very beginning of the game, because you will be allotted your group will be allotted a certain number of coins that you can spend on these requisition cards. So you can take a

look at the mission you're going on, and then you can spend your coins to buy all kinds of uh different things that you can use, different weapons or different utility powers. You can also hire these backup agents, and they can come along with your group, and they can help you either on the battlefield or they can be off the battlefield giving you um advice when you are taking time. They can like kind of like check in on you and give you advice and help you. And then each of the characters also have a number of starting gear cards. So, when you're putting together your group of investigators, it's always fun. It always feels like you are kind of at that that uh that planning stage of a great mission, of a great heist in those kinds of movies, in those kinds of stories where you really want to be careful with how you are planning and I like that a lot. Okay, another thing I love and this is one of my favorite things about Hellboy the board game.

This is one of the expansions and this was the BRPD Archives and uh each of the expansions came with more cards to add to the Archives deck. And uh these are cards that you use to construct random missions. And so, you know, me, I like playing one-and-done games where I have a whole bunch of a variety of different missions I can play and I can put together a mission uh pretty quickly to go on. And I think this works really well. You have I think about six or seven different sub decks and each of them is uh organized into with a different icon. And you basically take one card from each of those sub decks and you do that randomly and you combine those and then that creates a mission. And you have some choices I could you want to play a a medium-length game, a short game, or a long game and then those will usually dictate what kind of map is laid out and how many rooms, how many corridors, and the shape of it and all of that. And then you will usually pick what kind of investigation you want to have and that will tell you how you set up your encounter deck. And then you get to choose the group of enemies that you want to fight. So, the more expansions you add to this uh system, the more different groups of enemies you can fight. Uh there's a couple of twists that will add some variety and then you have your confrontation with a random boss. And there are quite a few bosses, and the bosses have a deck of of behavior cards. And then along with the BPRD archives is the basic modular

nature of how you set up your decks. And so we do have this deck of doom here, and this is kind of like the mythos deck from Arkham Horror or from Eldritch Horror. This is how the game fights back. And each of these cards, I guess one thing that also really does strengthen the the the theming of this game and makes it really feel like Hellboy is the use of a lot of the art from the comic books, and I think it looks fantastic. But each one of this deck here, this doom deck, the deck of doom has all of these little icons. And this is where this game kind of reminds me of Warhammer Quest Silver Tower and how you would construct the deck of map cards in that game using the various icons. And depending on the scenario that you are playing or the scenario that you have constructed, you will be told to create your deck of doom using different icons.

There are generic cards that are always always used, and I like this system a lot, too, because if you want to make the game a little easier, you can substitute in some of the green generic cards. Or if you want to make the game a little more difficult, you can substitute some of some of the red generic cards in. And so you have a pretty good control on the difficulty of the game. And then also depending on which characters are in your party, you will mix in one of their custom cards. And then you have these other kind of twist cards. So there's all kinds of variety in how you are going to set up the various decks of cards in this game. The encounter deck is also the same depending on the scenario you're playing or depending on the scenario you've constructed, you will set up your encounter cards with the various color-coded icons, and these will tell you what you find when you're out exploring. You can find clues. Clues are things that you need to investigate in order to get those insight tokens. It'll tell you which minions to set up on the board, some special uh monsters or things uh some special hazards that might come out. Sometimes various pieces of scenery will come out. Some of these have their own little special rules that you will have to deal with. So, all kinds of a variety. And when you start adding in your expansions, you also have a ton of

different enemies that you can face and all kinds of different bosses. So, we have like 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 different bosses. I mean, that is just awesome. I love having all these bosses cuz you never know never really know what your final confrontation is going to be. And so, having these different bosses that you can fight is great. Along with the boss behavior deck, so same as, you know, the deck of doom and the encounter deck, your boss behavior deck will use icons that will uh change the behavior of the boss depending on the construction of your uh behavior deck. And then we also have a whole bunch of different minions. Uh you know, we have these frog monsters. We have, you know, these kind of German elite Nazi guards.

We have these beasts and uh evil turkeys. Uh we have the Nazi knife fighters. Always fun to punch Nazis in uh in games. Uh different types of, you know, folk horror beasts and and spirits and giants and uh skeletal warriors. So, yeah, just the variety is really cool. And the randomization with the BPRD archives and the modular nature of everything makes every game feel different. Another thing I like is how the encounter cards work. And often when you draw a new encounter card or when you set up your map and you are placing an encounter card and then the heroes examine that encounter card, what is revealed often creates an interesting kind of little one-room scenario, a little one-room kind of puzzle that you have to figure out. And some of them can be really interesting. And so you know, if Liz and Hellboy here were moving into this room and then we would start maybe in this corner here and I would place a minion C, whichever minion C was. Let's say minion C was one of these skeletons. And two, I would place a point of interest.

That would be a token. I don't have any, they're in the box. But you might place a point of interest and then that will coincide to something else written on the card. So that's something that you have to deal with. Then you might place a sinister bird, which is kind of like a plague of frogs, which is a threat that the enemies that the heroes will have to deal with. And then you'll place some more scenery. Scenery can be things like statues or benches or little little plinths with magical relics or books on them and those might have different ways to interact with them. And then also maybe a frog swarm. And so setting up this one card on this one tile or in this one room, if you were using like a HeroQuest like board, would create a pretty interesting little scenario. And there is a lot of variety in how these encounter cards play out. And it's always fun to draw one because it's always not just combat. There's always something else to do.

There are clues to investigate and the clues you will place out on the board. I think the Kickstarter version came with these kind of pre-painted deluxe clues or what are these Pretty sure these were pre-painted. I don't think I painted these. I don't remember. I think I think these were pre-painted. Uh but you can move in and then you can investigate these clues and that's how you kind of push the investigation forward so you can find out who the big boss is that you're fighting. And you know, you will gain those insight tokens and you will be able to use those to give you an advantage when that confrontation comes. Okay, a couple of mechanisms I like. I love the dice system in Hellboy. This is one of my favorite dice systems and I wish it was used more. And so each of the characters will have basically four different stats, you know, melee combat, range combat, examination, and defense. And those are color-coded into different dice with yellow being the weakest.

Next up is orange, then red, and then black being the strongest. And so as you can see Hellboy here, he has a medium value of defense. And so when Hellboy needs to make a defense roll, you will grab three dice and then you always roll the blue kind of wild D6. The skull is bad, it's a disaster. This will add two successes. This is kind of a wild card that you can make into anything or sometimes that might trigger additional abilities. This will multiply your highest die value by two and this will add two successes. There's the one success and then sometimes you will be able to re-roll. And so every challenge is the same. You take the three colored D6 that correspond to the stat you're checking along with the blue wild die.

However, you can spend actions to boost these dice up to their next strongest value. And also other heroes in your party can also spend their actions to boost. So let's say that you were going up against the boss as Hellboy or the boss was attacking Hellboy. And so Hellboy had a defense of three and I wanted to maybe spend an extra action to boost one of those orange D6 up to a red and then I was playing with Liz Sherman and she could spend an action maybe to boost that red up to a black and then I would roll all of those and I would total up my successes. So 1 2 3 4 5, but this multiplies one of the highest, that would be 4 5 6 7. So I would have a defense of seven.

However, sometimes when you are doing an action, you will have a dice that get lowered. They will get you know, maybe you're shooting through a space and for every other model in that space, one of your dice has to be lowered to the next lower value. And if you only have a yellow and that gets lowered, it goes away. So a very, very good dice system. It's always fun. It's always exciting and I would love to see this kind of dice system used in more games. And one of the other mechanisms is the injury and the hit point system. And so as you take damage, you will start filling up your little damage track here with these random damage tokens. And then once all of those get full, the whole track is full and you take more damage, you start flipping these over and these will usually lower your stats. So now, you know, one of my dice for my examination or observation is is lowered a value. Oh, it's lowered again. My defense is lowered. Oh man, so I would be, you know, just totally having bad luck here on this observation or examine, uh my uh range combat is lowered. My range combat is lowered again, and then if all of those turn into injuries, then your character is knocked out. Very cool, very simple, and it adds some cool

narrative touch to taking damage. And that's always more exciting than just taking damage and getting knocked out. When taking damage, you know, makes you play the character a little differently. And finally, very quickly, another thing I love about Hellboy is that it is one and done. It's not a campaign. This is a very easy game to get out, set up, either play one of the existing scenarios, or construct one of your own using those randomized cards. You can play the game, have a great time in maybe two, two and a half, three hours, depending on the length of the scenario you've chosen. You can put everything away, and just have a one-and-done great time, a zero-to-hero dungeon crawl. And that is my favorite kind of game, my favorite kind of adventure game, is a game that doesn't have a campaign. It's a game that just lets me play a single game and have a fulfilling, complete, experience.

And Hellboy really does give me that every single time I play. So, there are just a lot of things to love about Hellboy. I mean, silly things. You know, I didn't even write these down, but just the size of the rule book. You know, you guys know, I this is something that I talk about a lot, but just having the rule book be the size of a comic book is great. This is my favorite size rule book. I love it. Uh the game comes with a good documentation. It comes with some good player aids. Uh there is a universal head uh cheat sheet for it, so you can uh get up and go pretty quickly if you've forgotten some of the rules. Uh the components are nice, except for the tiles. I just think the tiles are a little boring. But, um yeah, overall, there is a lot going for Hellboy and um, I think a lot of that does stem from just the strength of the original source material. It's so good.

And I'm so happy that uh, the board game emulates that on my tabletop and it gives me this kind of thrilling pulp action adventure experience that I can just have a heck of a lot of fun with. It's just a real shame that there is that disparity between the Kickstarter version and the retail version. And you know, getting the Kickstarter stuff is more and more expensive as time goes on. But yeah, I just love Hellboy and I've been itching to play it again and I'm so glad I did. I still don't think it's going to crack into my top 10, but it's close, you know? Maybe the more I play it, the more it might move into that that heralded

territory, whatever my stupid top 10 means. But uh, all right, so I hope you enjoyed taking a look at Hellboy in 2026. We'll talk to you later. Bye-bye.

Progress saved