The Hungry Gamer Reviews Arkham Horror LCG
Transcript
Ooh, that looks tasty. Welcome folks to the Hungry Gamers back with another game review and today we're talking about Arkham Horror: The Card Game designed by Nate French and MJ Newman with Josiah Duke Herriott and Nicholas Cory from Fantasy Flight Games and this is the latest edition of Arkham Horror and I believe that makes this edition three. And thank you to Asmodee USA for sending me a copy of this so I can make this video. Additionally, please make sure you turn on your Klingon subtitles cuz if I make any mistakes in the rules overview, that's where you'll find the corrections. I will also point out that while I'm not going to be showing any of this in this particular video cuz new stuff and spoilers, I will be talking about these expansion investigator decks when I get to the end of this video and I talk about my final thoughts.
Additionally, I have been playing this through with two friends of mine, MicroMax and Bob who needs no last name. And I've been playing this through with them because they are Arkham Horror experts. They have pretty much everything that's ever been made and their copy has all of the most deluxe bits and components that you can possibly find. And so as I keep playing through this with them and really dig deeper into the way the deck building works and things like that, I'm going to come back around and we're going to have another video talking about this version compared to the previous editions and their thoughts as experts of the game on all of the new things. So that will be coming, but for now, let's just talk about this game from the perspective of somebody that had not played this game very much up until getting this. So the last thing I want to say is you can see this lovely play mat. This is thank you to Game Toppers who sent me this awesome horror themed play mat for my game topper. It's very very cool very appropriate for this particular game. Now, with that said, if you are not interested in how this game is played and you want to jump to my final thoughts, then you want to go to the time stamp on the screen right now.
For those of us still here, let's talk about how this game is played. So what's going to happen is I'm going to move these bits out of the way is each game you'll be playing through a scenario and you'll find the details in the campaign guide and this game comes with a three game campaign, so a rather quick one. And that's going to give you the basic setup of what you're doing and each player will also then pick a character. Right here I have Joe Diamond and he has his own deck of cards and you'll also get a certain number of resources that you're going to have as well. I'm going to slide him and what's important to know about the characters is that all of them have their own stats. See we have their will, investigate, fight, and agility. So for Joe, he's very good at investigating and fight, not so good at agility and his will. He has his mental health and his health health. He has a power that he can use which is anytime he successfully investigates, he can draw a card once around and anytime the elder sign gets pulled, which is anytime this is pulled out of the bag, this is what it's going to do for him and I'll talk about the bag and pulling things out of the bag in just a bit. Now, your story is going to have you set up with what it is you're trying to do and it's going to go through in several acts. So you kind of got a little book here and it'll tell you where you start out and in the very first scenario, you start out here at your friend's room.
Now, I'm going to kind of go off script and I'll be showing different rooms and buildings so as to not really spoil the story here as I kind of go through how the game's going to work. So just kind of know that I'm not going to go through the story, but I will be showing some cards. This is the very first thing, so there's nothing of note here. What I will point out here is on this location, it has its shroud number which is basically its difficulty. Most of them have an ability you can use if you take an action there and it's how many clues there's going to be then this case two per investigator. So we would place two clues there which are clues that can be found and usually clues are how you advance the story. And again, I'm not going to talk too much about how that works other than to say that that is something that can happen. Then we go through the game. And the first round, you skip this first phase, but for now, I'll do it anyhow. So the first thing that happens is you place a doom on the agenda right there. And down at the bottom, it's going to tell you how much doom there's going to need to be before it advances. In this case, three. Then if the doom threshold is met, you advance the agenda.
Then each player draws the top card of the encounter deck. And these, to the best of my knowledge, are always going to be bad. And there's various types of things that you might see. You might see something like this which is simply going to be something bad that happens to you. So you'll put unspeakable truths into play in your threat area which is right in front of you and then after you discover one or more clues, you will take a mental damage, a horror damage and you can take two actions to get rid of it. Or it might be something like this which is a bad guy that's going to fight you or will be able to attack you and they have their stats up here and then over here the agility is how you evade them. Again, I'll talk about tests in a bit. And as you can see, there's a variety type of different bad guys you can get and a variety of different types of events that can happen. Again, I'm not going to go through them all so I don't spoil things for you. Then we go into the investigation phase and players can take actions in any order that they want and this is where you're going to do the bulk of the game. So perhaps I might decide I want to do an investigate action here. Well, I would take a look and I would see that I have an investigator four and that shroud is two. So the difficulty to get one of these clues is going to be two. And so I would then reach into the bag and I would pull one out. Because I'm starting with a base of four, I pulled that out plus one so I have a five, I would have succeeded. And for Joe, I would then get to use my power. But there's a whole bunch of different types of things you might have in there. You might have a negative and I will say there are probably more negatives than positives in there. There are some bigger negatives. There's things like
this here which is an auto fail and then there are these three tokens which are going to be different based on the scenario and your scenario card will tell you how those work. And then there is the aforementioned elder sign which is different based on character. And anytime you do any kind of a check, that's how those are going to work. Other things that you might do on your turn, you can play a card. And there's a whole bunch of different types of cards that you're able to play and there are things like this here which are items or weapons. And at the top, it's going to tell you how much does it cost to play them and you're going to have a certain number of resources and you'll gain resources every turn and cards will give you resources, but you have to play the resources and use one of your actions and then you're able to play it. You might have something like this here which you use on a skill check which is going to boost your skill. So for example, if I was doing an attack action which is done just like the other actions or a fight action as it's called, I could play this and I would get plus two, one for each of those and then it's going to do something down here. I will also point out that every card has a symbol up here which you can then discard to boost your actions and other players at the same location as you can discard one card to do that as well.
There are items like this that you'll see that says put a certain number of secrets on it. In this case, four. So I would put four supplies on there. That's going to tell me I can use this four times. Again, each card is going to tell you exactly what it does and it does have a cost to put it out. You might have something like this which is an ally which is someone that has their own health and damage that they can take and abilities that they're going to do. Again, and they'll be traveling along with you and if nothing else, they can take damage for you. You might have cards like this that have the fast symbol, the lightning bolt. That means you're going to be able to play them pretty much at any time whenever the situation warrants it. Again, it does have a cost and cards like this as well which simply you play it and it does a thing. In this case, get three resources. You also have the ability simply to gain a resource as an action.
You can do an action that's on a location where you are. You can attempt to evade an enemy that is on top of you that you're dealing with cuz you can't move away from a location if someone is already fighting you and that's when as I said you're going to use your agility score to get away. Or you can move to a different location. Now, as it is set up here, there's no other location that I can move to. And before I show you that, I'll say that when you finish your turn, you then flip your card over and that shows that you're done. The game also comes with these generic tokens that you can have and move around. That means you haven't acted. That means you have, it's your choice. But as you're moving to locations, and again, slight spoilers here, you're going to look at the card and it's going to tell you what locations it's connected to. And so we see that this is the type of location this is, the pink spade. We have a red square and a blue triangle. And we look down here and we see this one is connected to blue triangles. So I could put this right here and this one here, we look down here, is connected to pink spades. So I would take one of these and that says they are connected both ways. But you might also have one like this here where you'll see this is connected to everything but but something might not be connected it. So if you'll notice that this is not connected to your friend's room cuz it does not have the pink spade.
Well, this one here is not connected to the quad either. Well, this one is connected to this location. And this one's also connected back. It is but obvious and so as you can imagine, it is possible to have locations that are one way only in which case you would flip it over this way and it would go towards the location that it is connected to. And then you can move along those pathways. And you're going to play through each scenario has three or four acts and you're going to play through the whole thing and hopefully you will accomplish your goal. I will also point out now that this is a game that is a bit of a fail forward. You do not have to achieve everything to move on to the next scenario, and as you do that, there will be different results to every location that you go to. I should also point out that before you actually go to a location the first time, they'll be flipped over this way.
Then when you get there, you get to flip them over and kind of find out what the details are. Again, as I said, minor spoilers here, but hopefully that gives you a broad idea of how the game works. Each turn, you go all the players go in whatever order they want, and they take their three actions as they try to unravel the mystery at foot. Now, with that said, what do I like about this game? Well, the first thing is there is a very good variety of characters and cards to feel like every deck that you're playing is different. And it's the same thing with the different scenarios. The scenarios, even though it's the same mechanics, they do all feel unique in both story and in mechanics as unveil different cards and things like that. And I really do like that, and I think that's very, very clever.
The next thing I'll say is the movement is really clever. I really like the way that you're able to move from place to place, but it's very specific in that this is a world that is set up. Some doors don't go to other doors, and the way that you have to figure out where it is you're going to move, and you build it out with the cards, really, really works well. And to that end, I know they are new, these little tokens that tell you what's connected to what, are fantastic. It takes what feels like it was probably frustrating before as far as as a big area builds out, it makes it make a lot of sense. So, I really, really like that. I also like that the different characters, as they're built, they're fun. I enjoy them. Just take the deck and play, and that includes all of the expansion characters. I love the differences in those expansion characters. I love the way that that they work. I love their differences. I love their powers.
It's just fantastic. This is one of those games that you want to pursue every single deck. You want all of those characters. You want to be able to put them out there, play through, cuz the way they play is so different, and I really, really, really like that. I'm going to talk about the expansion characters a little bit more as we go through. Next thing I'll say is it is [clears throat] top-tier adventure card game mechanics. Just really, really good. It is so clean. You know what you can do. But, every round you have so many choices because you have your card, but you can't just willy-nilly play stuff. You have to have the resources to play them, and it's not overly hard to get the resources, but you have to pay attention to what you're doing. And you have, as I said, so many options, and there's so many ways to boost your abilities, and other people can share.
It's just fantastic. It is one of three adventure card games that I am willing to play on the regular. I will play this one again because the mechanics are just top-tier. Fantastic, fantastic, fantastic. Next thing I'll say is the leveling up that you do in between scenarios, you earn X amount of experience points, or victory points they're called, and you can use that to kind of bring new cards into your deck and take some other cards out. It's really easy, but you really do start to feel more powerful, and I really do like the way that works. It's very, very good. Very, very clever. The next thing I'm going to say is, if you are a Cthulhu person, it's just really cool cuz the events that come out, the locations, the items, everything really feels Cthulhu to me.
Now, I'm not a Cthulhu expert. I've played some Call of Cthulhu. I've played various Cthulhu games, so I know enough about it to know this feels Cthulhu. And if you're a big fan of Cthulhu, you're going to get so much out of it. Very, very, very clever. Very fun if you're into that mythos. Next thing I'll say is expanding the game is very easy. It's so easy to get a single one of those expansion investigators and suddenly have all these new cards you can play with. The expansion is easy, and you can do minor expansions without breaking the bank. Getting one or two of those decks is not that bad. And so, I always appreciate that. This is right up there with Sentinels of the Multiverse, how you could buy single decks, and it's really, really easy. So, I really like the way that that works, and I think they've done a good job with that. Next thing is I love that it is fail forward, and I guess it's not really a fail forward so much as it is there are levels of success that you can have.
And I like the way that works, and I love that, depending on what you've done, will change certain cards. So, slight spoiler here, skip ahead 30 seconds if you don't want to hear this, but depending on how you deal with the first scenario, the next scenario, one of the locations is either on fire or not on fire, and it just changes everything, and that is wonderful. I love the way that works. I love the cooperative nature of it, how you really have to talk about what do we need to do? Who should go where? What makes the most sense? Maybe I should go there, but no, no, but you have this item, so you can use this item over there, or you're this character right here, and that character can finish using this item that that he has, and then can pick it back up. Really awesome the way that you're able to synergize stuff. The cooperative nature of it is just wonderful.
And the last thing I'll say is, and this is something that I have not experienced a ton of, is the deck building. Each of the characters, it tells you on the back you must take these four or five cards. Beyond that, here are your choices. You can take this many of this type of card, this many of this type of card. And so, you're building these investigators how you want them to be, and that ties into the co-op stuff. As you're trying to figure out who's going to do what, how are these things going to work, and you're taking cards from all the different investigator decks, which I said were fun to just play, but then you get to start deck building. The deck building is where this game really, really starts to shine. So, with that said, what are my quibbles with the game? Well, I think the deck building is where this game shines, and so you have to be interested in doing that deck building. You have to want to say, "Okay, I don't want to just play with the deck as is. I'm going to pull stuff out. I want to be more fighty, or I want to be more investigaty." And you have to really do that and dig into that, and to do that, it means you have to know the cards. You really have to understand everything, and there's a kind of a broader meta behind this game, and I think that's why the game becomes very replayable even with only a few scenarios. Now, I'll talk about that in a moment. Is you get to build characters in different ways, and you mix and match them, and you approach things in different ways, but you have to do that, and that is, in some ways, a game in of itself. And also, it means you're going to need to buy some of those expansions. Now, now as I said, I really think those investigator expansions are fantastic. I
really like them, and everyone that I've played, I've really liked, and then watching Bob and Max play other ones, I'm like, "Ah, I wish I had played that one." They're just great, but you need to get those to really, really great to really, really get the full experience, I think. Maybe not all of them, but you definitely need some of them so you have access to these different cards so you can build your decks how you want. Next thing I'll say is there's only three scenarios, and even though I think there is fun and value to replaying scenarios, there's only three in the core box, and so you're going to need to pick up some expansions down the road. They don't seem like they should be that expensive because each scenario right now is a deck of cards, like, you know, this thick and some and a few pages in a rulebook or the campaign book, but you're probably going to want to do that, and so this is not quite a lifestyle game like a Kingdom Death Monster, but it's kind of a lifestyle game. You're going to drop significant money into this as you keep getting more and more and more, which is not unlike the other adventure card games that I've liked in the past. Next thing I'll say is the game and the bag.
And by the bag, I mean where you're doing your test, it's punishing. I don't know if there's actually more negative things in the bag than positive, but it feels like there's more negative things. You really have to expect that you're going to get damaged all the time. You're rarely going to go through and just full-on win a scenario. Now, I've played the first scenario a whole bunch of times now because I wanted to try all these different characters, and I kept trying different ones and playing them out and playing around with them. And only once have I fully succeeded on that first scenario. Now, you get to continue on, but it's a punishing game, and all the tests are punishing. This is not one of those games where it's you're always going to get something good. You will regularly just fail. And that might not be something you're into, and obviously, as I mentioned, this is very, very, very Cthulhu. You're you're not going to get the most out of this game if you're not interested in the Cthulhu mythos. But, there you have it, folks. That is Arkham Horror with the investigator expansions. I think all the investigator expansions are really good.
I really like them. I love what they do. I love the potential for deck building. I think the mechanics are top-notch. I think this is an absolutely a top-tier adventure card game. If you're into Cthulhu, this is a must-buy, I think. If you are really into adventure card games, this is probably a must-buy. And I'm really high on the game, and I am not a Cthulhu guy. Now, there you have it, folks. That is my first video. This is just the review of the things. There are just going to There's going to be at least one more video, maybe two, talking about the differences between previous editions and this one, and all the expansion content that is coming but for now if you found this video useful please like subscribe share maybe become a channel member. As always thank you so much for watching have a wonderful wonderful day.