Skip to main content
Loading video...

Forest Shuffle (Smoky Mountains) - Board Game Review - Basically A Roster Update

Transcript 13:03

Well, it's Groundhog Day. Again?

Hi everyone, I'm the Broken Meeple. Win or lose, I'm going to be honest with you. And this is a new edition for Forest Shuffle called Smoky Mountains. It has otters on the cover. It's a 10 out of 10. Okay, fine. We'll find a way to talk about it a bit more. But yeah, it's a running joke that pretty much anything that has otters in it is already going to get like several extra marks from me. What can I say? I love otters. But this is Smoky Mountains. This is what now? The third main iteration of Forest Shuffle? I mean, I've got Dark Moor. I've got In fact, let me drag these out. Oh, not sure why they twist my body quite so much with my surgery there. Um but yeah, Forest Shuffle. So, the base one, I've got both expansions in here. In fact, three expansions. I can't remember that. Everything that I've got released for it is in here. Quite a big box. And this one still gets played every now and again. But for a little while, I've been playing the new Dark Moor version. So, Dark Moor basically introduced Moors, a couple of extra little rules tweaks. And of course, Dark Moor is a little bit closer to home because I'm from Somerset. So, it's not too far to get to the nice beautiful hills of Dartmoor. So, you know, this one has been nice from a nostalgia perspective. And now we got Smoky Mountains. This is kind of like a United Eastern United States theme set around autumn time. So, you get these beautiful greens and browns, you know, and like reds and stuff, you know, and certainly from an artwork perspective, I would say this one's the best of the three. You know, without even a shadow of a doubt.

But the question is is that we get a lot We've now got what? Three of these. And Dark Moor had an expansion as well. Is there really anything new in this or is it just more of the same? Well, it's Groundhog Day. Again? Well, let's just answer that question immediately and go, "No, there really isn't." If you want to know how to play Forest Shuffle, then check out my original Forest Shuffle review. I'm not going to go over the entire game again here. But, if you're familiar with Forest Shuffle, then pretty much you'll be able to jump into this straight away. In fact, if you're already familiar with Dartmoor, you'll be able to pretty much jump into this instantly with barely reading the rules because this game is pretty much 95% the same as Dartmoor. Dartmoor's unique selling point was the moors. So, the moors came in and you could have two things above it, two things below it, and different things wanted to go in moors. But, they were basically a different thing to trees and shrubs. So, you know, they were basically like a third terrain type. Well, this time you get rivers. Now, you do get some rivers which are you know, special rivers, you know, proper named rivers that give you a special bonus or something like that.

But, you also have basically the face-down effect of every single card which can be a river in itself. Again, much like the moors. And again, you can have two things above them and you can have two things below them. But, the difference with the rivers is that there are certain things that can only go in a river and they have to be below it if need be. You've now got fish creatures in here which again function just like any other animal. It's just fish have to go underneath the cards on the rivers because well, go figure, it's a fish. You know, do you need me to explain that? But, you still get trees and shrubs in the normal fashion. But, the difference here is that when you play a tree, you now have the opportunity at that point to play a river face-down from your hand, so you're sacrificing a card for it, directly below the tree. So, you can end up with essentially three different scenarios. You can have a tree on its own which functions just like any other tree. You can have a river on its own which functions pretty much like a moor from Dartmoor. Or, you can have a combination of the two which allows you to play animals in a certain restricted fashion on there. So, you can have like the water creatures below the moor, but you can also have certain creatures, you know, like you know, some of the birds that have got water restrictions can be, you know, above the water on the tree itself. So, there's kind of like a mixture you can do with this setup. But, other than that, that's basically the difference. Yeah, it's essentially Darkmoor. The moors don't function very different from what the moors did previously. It's just that the creatures

will have a certain restriction of whether they've got to be on dry trees or whether they've got to be on wet trees. That's basically it. In terms of the abilities on the animals, I mean, we've seen a lot of this stuff before, so either flat points or different, you know, different types of red squirrels will get you points. Uh get a bunch of, you know, the same insect on something. Um you know, there's not like a massive thing like butterflies or dragonflies in this where you have to get like a set of seven in order to get points. You just get four squirrels on that. Uh but yeah, you got insects, birds, little mice, uh you know, different types of plants, you know, some mammals, and of course, you know, coyotes, which are lovely, and of course, otters. You get otters in this. Lovely cute little otters, and skunks, and raccoons, and a you know, basically more cute creatures.

But, does the game feel that different? I mean, abilities-wise, it's pretty much the same. I mean, the the Darkmoor ability where you get to uh look at cards from the deck until you get a certain type, they're a little bit more prevalent here than in Darkmoor, but they are here. So, you know, if I try to find an example, I'll let you know. But, you know, all right, here we Oh, perfect. So, you know, I can play a rock vole, and then it lets me reveal three cards from the deck into the clearing and see if I pick up an insect. Well, there's one, the skipper caterpillar, so I can play that one for free. It's a cool ability. I do like it. It's one of the better ones in better things about Darkmoor is that ability, cuz it on the one side helps you search for a particular thing you need, but then on the flip side, it could still whiff, and it means that you've put a bunch of stuff in the middle for your opponent to get first dibs on. So, there is like a risk reward with doing it. Not to mention utilizing these abilities on a regular basis mean that the deck goes through quite quickly. I'd say games of this version of Forest Shuffle are actually a little bit shorter than the others because there are a few more of those abilities that let you sort of circulate through the deck trying to find specific types. But, that's the game. I mean, the game is like you say pretty much Dark Moor. The rivers function very similarly to how the Moors did before, which then begs the question are they running out of ideas as to how to make these Forest Shuffles different from one another? You know, Dice Tower Game A Llama and voted, you know, you know, made this one their favorite, you know, giving it a 10, you know, one of them gave it a 10 out of 10. And I'm like, 10 out of 10?

I mean, if you love Forest Shuffle, fine, but, you know, I kind of want to award innovation, not just rehashing the same thing. Yes, I like Forest Shuffle, but let's not forget originally I gave Forest Shuffle a six, right? So, that was my original review. It was above average. Since then, it's risen up to an eight. It has gotten better over time. So, you know, this is definitely now we're now at a stage where, yeah, Forest Shuffle is a great game. But, it's never got to the levels of nine and 10 out of 10 because the same issues that were in original Forest Shuffle are still apparent here. You still have the two biggest issues, well, probably three biggest issues in the game even after all these expansions, even after all this. Firstly, you don't want to play this game with more than three players. I mean, hell, most people don't play this game with more than two, but yeah, three is really your cap cuz, you know, at that point you run out of table space, which is kind of like the second issue. You need a lot of table space for Forest Shuffle. And this one requires you to have like, you know, bird, sorry, bird, sorry, tree, river stuff below it, so you're going to need even more space to house these cards. But, you know, you've with four more players, you need so much space and the down time and the length of the game is just too much, you know, there is no point having the extra players there because again, it's mostly a multiplayer solitaire game unless you play this with two or three players cuz then you can at least have an idea of what other players want and do something about it. With four or five, it's just pure chaos. What's the difference? So, they haven't fixed that problem. And the other problem, which won't be fixed

until they sort out the app, is the scoring. You know, I don't give the game brownie points for the scorer app because firstly, the scorer app is an app which, you know, the game should be easier to score without that. Secondly, the app only works if you don't sleeve your cards. Uh yes, you can use it with sleeve cards, but then the light keeps tricking the thing. It constantly gets things wrong. You ideally want to play with this game unsleeved. All of mine are unsleeved purely because of that app. And in this case, we don't have the app ready for it yet. So, you're going to have to do this manually. And when you do it manually, it takes a while. Going through all your different things, going all through the the top ones, then the bottom cards, then the left ones, then the right ones, then the river ones. It takes some time and a lot of it is because a lot of these scoring types require you to count how many trees you have, how many squirrels, how many birds, how many insects, that kind of thing. And it takes a long time to go through and find out how much that is, not to mention remember how many you got when you're doing it. Like you need a spare notepad nearby to jot down some notes as you're trying to add things up.

What I would have loved to have seen in one of these, and I'm kind of annoyed they haven't done it yet, is they should have given you kind of like a little pad, maybe not necessarily a dry erase one. That That'd be even better, but you know, a pad with all the different icons in the game that require you to count how many you have, and then basically, as the game goes on, you can mark how many of them you have. So, by the time you get to the end of the game and you've got to score up, you've already jotted down that you have eight insects or 10 trees and stuff like that, which makes it a lot easier to then score up. In fact, I'm you know, I think somebody on BGG has actually done something similar. I remember downloading it. I need to print it out, but basically like a little little sheet that you can laminate. If I put that in all the boxes and just have a dry erase pen handy, then I can constantly mark off like 1 2 3 4 5, you know, like a tally chart, how many of the icons I've got, and it will make scoring so much easier. But, they should be doing that, you know, we have complained since the dawn of Forest Shuffle about these flaws, about the down about the the the craziness of playing this with four or five players, about the length of time it takes to score and all that.

It's It's flaws in the game that has still flaws in the game, and you would think that after, you know, all these expansions, after all these iterations, they would do something to maybe address those issues, but they're just not. They're just basically giving you a new paint job, and it's almost a bit like the Madden games from EA games, you know, those ones, the ones where basically they just update the roster and don't do anything else with the game. That's kind of what this feels like. These Forest Shuffles feel more like a roster update than they do like a brand new Forest Shuffle that's fundamentally different from the previous one. Dark Moor was more different from the base game than this one is different from Dark Moor. So, it's you're pretty much just picking which one you fancy playing based on the artwork and what creatures you like to look at, which granted is probably going to be this one for me, but that's because I like otters, you know, slightly biased, and because I love the autumn as a season, the autumn's my favorite season, and this is all like artwork to do with Eastern United States in the autumn basically.

So, the artwork in here just gels with me, but that's purely a subjective thing. That's not the expansion suddenly doing things better. It's just this expansion kind of calling out to my inner my inner animal lover in my inner animal autumn lover. I don't know. So, it's kind of hard. It's the same rating as the others. It's an eight out of 10. It's a great game because it's basically just Forest Shuffle with the tiniest of tweaks. There's not much else to say really. So, yeah, I mean, which one do I prefer? As I said, this one but for reasons not to do with the fact of how the game mechanics work, you know, I mean, the Moors are similar to the trees and that in this and the first one now has expansions to add more stuff into that one. So, honestly, if you gave me Dark Moor Forest Shuffle or this one and just said which one you fancy playing, I could pretty much just coin toss for it and I'd get one that I would like.

They're all the same rating at this point. Eight out of 10, there's very little difference. So, uh I don't see where 10 out of 10s are coming from. It's a solid game still because it's pretty much the same game. So, that's it for me on this episode of the Broken Meeple. If you like what you see, then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on BoardGameGeek when it goes live on the page. Don't forget to check out the original review I did for Forest Shuffle. Although, bear in mind, my rating has changed since then. The flaws are still present, but the game has grown on me over time. In fact, uh In fact, I wonder if I did a top 10 list where I talked about games that got better over time, Forest Shuffle might be on that list. So, have a look for that one as well. Until next time, remember, it's only a game and I'll see you on the next Broken Meeple video. So, take care.

Progress saved