Skip to main content
Loading video...

Stellar Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 16:21

hey everybody today i'm taking a look at stella which is a small box card game designed by matt riddle and ben pinchback this one is for strictly two players and was published by renegade games back in 2020 and before i get into my thoughts and review on stella i just want to give a shout out to kianda dot co dot uk who sponsored the show so if you live in the uk and you regularly pick up board games be sure to check out their great website but let's get on to stella okay so a game of stella is going to look like this when it's set up where you have this communal row of cards here next to these numbers are these number kind of spots and that's going to be important for one of the main mechanisms in the game um we'll talk about that a bit later we have the main deck of cards here and each player is going to have their own telescope which looks a bit like this i've already put one of these starter cards on there you can see here you have this four row a three row two twos and then a one and that's going to be where you're going to be placing some of your cards as you acquire them throughout the game you've also got a separate tableau of cards in front of you which is called your notebook and that's going to be one of the main ways the game scores by multiplying things in your telescope by things in your notebook and again we'll talk about how that works and you're always going to have at least two cards in your hand and you're gonna at least draw one more um each round so the turn sequence is gonna look like this we're gonna add a card to your hand you're gonna play a card from your hand then you're gonna play a card from the row and then you're going to refill the row and let's break that down into individual parts so first part you can probably guess how that

works you're going to add a card from your hand from the row of cards here so let's just say um without thinking about it too much let's just take this number three here and i'm going to add that to my two existing cards into my hand then the next thing you're gonna do is you're gonna play a card from your hand and you can play any of these um the four five i've got another five here and that number here is where this this is going to be important because let's say i played this number five card here um what i'm going to do is i'm either going to put it in my notebook or i'm going to put it in my telescope now when i put it in my telescope i'm mainly looking for the star value here i'm going to put it in my notebook i'm trying to create runs of cards so for example here you've got these little black hole symbol if i have say a one two three four or five in a row consecutively that's going to be a five card run and then i'm going to multiply any any stars i have of those matching symbols so let's say later in the game i had this black hole in here i would multiply this star value by my longest run of the same type in my notebooks it's got quite a weird obtuse scoring however there are some further obtuse rules because if you ever play a card into your telescope that has an existing symbol of one already in your telescope you have to play it adjacent to it so let's say i put this comic card here like this we've got these two symbols here again trying to get stars into them as well now additionally to getting stars in your telescope you're trying to get these numbers as high as possible

because at the end of the game the telescope is divided into three segments where you've got the top area here with these five cards you've got the middle area with these three cards and you've got the bottom area with these four cards and if you have the biggest value or the highest total value here in relation to your opponent then you're going to score an additional 10 points for each of those segments that you dominate now the number you play here is additionally important because if you remember i played a five here that means that i have to take the number five from the card row and play in the opposite area that i didn't play my other card in so you can see i played this card in the telescope therefore the number five because this number here is a five has to go in my notebook again trying to create runs of cards if i can now i could do that the opposite way i could have played a card in my notebook and played the opposite card in the telescope but you have to do the opposite each time now if you didn't have a number there so let's say i i took a three with a three on it and if i have to draw a three from here i would only take it from the top of the deck so you really are adding a random element in there which will kind of relinquish some control and what you can place in your tableaus and of course at the end of your go you're going to refill the uh the row of cards here for your opponent to do the same thing and you're gonna keep playing until you've filled your entire telescope up with cards so let's advance the game some more and show you how the scoring works in detail so at the end of the game your player area is going to look something like this where your telescope is completely filled up with cards and of course your

notebook has been expanded as well and then you're going to go through this method of scoring all your different items the different categories you've got a nice little score aid here and you've got the little scorecard here if you need to use that um but what you're going to do is you're going to have a look at all the different suits of cards so you've got the planets here you're going to have a look at your planets or your longest run of cards of that particular type in your notebook so you can see here i've got a three card run so that's going to be uh that's quite a decent run but you've also got the satellite cards which are basically wilds and you can choose to allocate them to any of your different suits at the end of the game to try and expand that run so you can see here i've actually extended it to a four card run because i've got a one two three and four now these don't necessarily have to start with a one they could start with a three you know it makes a difference you can get like a three four five and that would still be a three card run but just for example sake i've started from a one here and then i'm going to have a look at my you know my longest run so that's four multiplied by the number of stars in that particular category so my planets i've got two stars here so one star on this planet card and one star on this planet card therefore it would be four times two for eight points you can also see there are further restrictions on my telescope because if i ever play a symbol i'm gonna have to keep adding on to that symbol in future placements so i can't just put say one of these planets here and then one all the way over here you have to have them connecting in some way or another it doesn't matter where it is so with this planet it could have been a planet here here or here or here as long as it's touching so everything here is

technically legal so you've got all the right planets touching each other with no exceptions now if you cannot place a planet legally because you can't abide by those restrictions then you have to put the card face down here which will basically act as no suit but it'll count as three points in relation to area majorities but let's show you one more example of um of another run of cards here so you've got the black holes here like this you've got these weird cards as well that go from zero to six but don't have any stars on them so these are really good to have in your in your notebook so you've got a zero one two three so that's a four card run i'll have a look at my um my black holes here i've got three here so that's gonna be three times four for 12 points in that particular category and you're gonna go through all of the different types and calculate your score that way and then as i said you're going to go have a look at the majorities here so my top area which is these are five cards it's going to be a total of three because if you remember these face down ones are three um and then add this one for eight nine ten eleven twelve thirteen all the way up to eighteen so that'll be eighteen there and i'll compare it to my opponent however his highest would get those ten points and you repeat that process for all the different areas and additionally you'll get a diversity bonus if you get all the different symbols in your telescope um which i'm not sure if i've managed to do that here but that's going to be it basically you're going to keep going until you've filled that telescope up calculate all these different categories and the player with the most victory points is going to be the winner

so let's go into some of my thoughts about stella so first off this game has some really tight play i mean i love games that put restrictions on you but you have to work within those restrictions and there's quite a few going on here so first off of course the actual spatial element of placing things your telescope is really cool i mean are you going to try and spam one thing down here as much as you can and bear in mind you do have to connect them but are you going to go for those big star multipliers and try to get a big run and combine them off each other but probably bearing in mind if you keep going for those bigger stars like this one here you know it's only going to have a one in it in relation to the area majority so i really do like the way that these cards and scoring criteria conflict with each other that's one of my favorite things about board games i love that conundrum is this going to be more useful here or here and what's going to be the net gain and that's what this game is all about you know am i going to play in my telescope am i going to play it in my notebook and what cards am i going to draft and then what cards am i going to play because this this actual drafting system is something i've never seen before it's quite obtuse again it's completely fresh never seen it where you play a card in one area that card you play you have to play the same number from the row in the opposite area and that is a really puzzle uh or puzzly head spinner that can um create some kind of variables within variables and i love that management of your hand and how you're going to use it and when you're going to strike when the particular card you want is in the offering so i really like the way that works it does almost feel like the designers have reached for that mechanism and maybe tried to

deliberately find something unique and build a game around it but i think they've reached and grabbed gold with it i think it's a really cool mechanism never seen it before i love it when games do fresh things particularly when they are you know thought-provoking and innovative i just think it's brilliantly executed and i think that would merge with the rest of the game well this creating runs as well as the spatial puzzle the conflicting scoring all comes together in a wonderful package so yeah very happy with the mechanisms and the actual decisions you're bombarded with from start to finish in this game and i love the way as well as the game develops your telescope gets tighter and tighter and tighter when you might need very particular cards to fit in a particular place or you might actually have to sacrifice one of your spaces to put one of these cards face down and only get the kind of three for the majorities rather than the full benefit of that car so yeah lots of things to consider here and those kind of card games have really become my forte at the moment i really appreciate clever designs that are simple but again the the weight behind the decisions you take from start to finish are meaningful and this game offers plenty of that stellar takes around 30 minutes to play from start to finish that's including setup and pack away which i think is spot on for a game like this you know i would you know this is technically a filler and i would categorize it as a filler but it's one of those thinky fillers this isn't one that you're going to just get out and always play it you know just sit back relax and just go through the process you're going to have to stop and think about each of your moves there might be some scope for some ap but because it's only a two player game you're only sitting through your

opponent's turn and it's all part of the final part of the process so i think without that extra degree of complexity the game would feel a bit generic but because it has that drafting system and the restrictions it really does add that meat to the bones and make it feel like a almost like a filler plus game despite fitting in a you know in in 30 minutes which i think is fantastic so the weight of the decisions and the you know the bombardment of decisions from start to finish in relation to that 30 minute time frame i think is spectacular the replayability of the stella as well i've got no issues at all you're going to be engrossed each time you play this game you're going to have a new puzzle to work out because you know the cards you have in your hand and the ones available in the offering are the ones you're going to have to react to so yeah i mean essentially there's not a ton of variability or anything like that but because it is so engaging and it is so you know head down you're in your board how you're going to play these cards most efficiently um is you know that that for me keeps me coming back so i think these kind of clever games always have that hook for me and these are the ones that really do stick around so yeah i've got no issues at all with the replayability and i can see myself playing for this one for many many years to come the level of player interaction is also well embedded because of course you are sharing a common draft pool which inadvertently or deliberately you are gonna start getting understanding on your opponent's shoes and getting in their way and you know sometimes you can do that deliberately you sometimes you might just do it passively but i also love the way that they've chosen to add that extra mechanism that extra scoring mechanism of the area majorities which means that you cannot ignore what your

opponents are doing because if they really go for that majority system maybe control all three regions then they're going to get a huge 30 point swing whereas you might have completely gone for a star system and that might not be so well balanced so you need to really keep an eye on what your parents are doing at least make sure you get one of the areas to stop them getting that full swing of points so yeah i think that's a brilliant idea because to be honest this would have been an excellent game even without that error majority but because they've added that in it actually adds to the game from a production and artwork point of view i think the game looks very polished i like the way it's taken a realism approach rather than like a sci-fi approach it's got that real astronomy feel to it feel to it which i think is kind of an unexplored territory really because there's no there's no kind of gimmicks here there's nothing made up it's all based on fact i mean you've got little tidbits and all the cards the cards themselves are good quality they're nice kind of slick and nice to handle um and i like the way that you build your little telescope out and it's got a real nice artwork on the back of it um so yeah i've got no issues at all with the production i think it's very well polished product um all the artwork pops nicely it looks good when it's all set out and you know if you're into this kind of theme then i think you're gonna really like the uh the visuals of this one i really enjoyed the sense of progression in stella the fact that the board or your little tableau gets tighter and tighter as the game goes on and also you might need a particular card to create those bigger runs in your notebook you know you might have say the you know the zero one and three and you just need that two you need to get it played so you can sneak it in there and get a massive multiplier for that

particular card type and that can be where the tension really lies in this one so yeah it does have great forward momentum things get tighter and tighter more restrictive but at the same time bigger and more grandiose in terms of the multiplier so yeah has a really great full momentum and um yeah from start to finish it feels like you are going to be engaged and engrossed in the gameplay so final thoughts on stella so to be honest card games like this are what really excite me i love having ones like this in my collection and loads going on here just great weighted decisions from start to finish but still simple but quirky rules and i like it when games try something a bit different this one certainly does that but still has some familiarity in terms of the spatial puzzle you know you've got some simple concepts there like making runs of cards but that drafting system is so so interesting just completely off the wall nothing i've seen before play a card and be forced to take the matching number and play in the opposite area and that just creates a whole new dimension to the game creates loads of opportunities um but at the same time feels like it's squeezing you and you you are very restricted in the only three cards that you have in your hand to work from um so yeah i think this game is absolutely brilliant a lot of depth here a lot of things to consider different ways to score spinning a lot of plays at the same time by keeping an eye on what your opponents are doing because you've got the majorities you want the runs you want the big sections here to get the stars on the board you don't want too many stars on the board because you don't want to start falling behind on the majorities if you can you want to get all the different types in your in your telescope in the first place and of course you know sometimes you might

be placing things in the wrong area and you can't move them you're stuck there for the rest of the game so this is a game you're going to make some mistakes on but i think you can get better at it and um those kind of games will hook me like i love having games like my collection i can see myself playing this one for years and years and years to come i think it's a brilliant fresh design and it's games like this that just yeah this is what makes me keep coming back and trying new things and because you know once you think you've seen it everything a game like stella comes along and it just reignites your passion to try new games and i love it especially when a game does that in such a succinct amount of time because we have so many games now get games that are quick but still pack a punch are what really get my juices flowing so yeah i'm a big big fan of stella i think this one is criminally overlooked criminally underrated i don't think this one is even in the top 2000 on on bgg and it certainly should be because it is a real polished refined design that i think is great so um definitely give this one look if you like your thinky little card games if you like two player games you want something a little bit different but again something that's very restrictive and thinky then be sure to check out stella this one definitely gets a strong shield of quality from me go check this one out

Progress saved