The Broken Meeple - Essen Review Compilation
Transcript
so this is the first of a series of compilation videos where if I've got too many games to review I'll just do a ton of them in one big video see all these games here all these lovely oh my oh my hey guys just so that you know what this is all about this is a compilation review video basically we get these periods during the year where there's either a drought for board games or there's a complete flood of board games particularly after a convention like Essen with Essen so many board games get released just there alone let alone the rest of the year let it get it becomes impossible to do a video for each one even all just the popular releases there's so many games to review and I just physically don't have the time especially as I'm trying to get season free even remotely started and it's difficult in this so many games so an idea I've had is that I'm gonna do a compilation video every now and again how often these will happen kind of depends on the market really but certainly around convention season and certainly on the lead-up to Christmas it's gonna happen so maybe you could call this my excuse for a Christmas video I don't know because it's not really something I tend to do so I've done some review videos for games on their own this is just gonna be a case where I review anywhere between five to ten games and spend about five minutes apiece on each or at least attempt to do five minutes apiece on them you know how I can talk so these will be games that I feel don't need as many plays to get my first fort you know then won't be first
impressions only in which case I will let you know if their first impressions or it may be a case that I just feel like well I've played it enough but I don't think the general audience want this as a full-on review like I don't think there's much shall we say buzz for it so we'll see how this goes hopefully this is an idea that works with you guys you know I mean if you wanted more reviews for me then while you're getting between five to ten in these videos alone so how bad can that be I brought welcome to the world amiibo compilation video hopefully the intro explained it all so in terms of what games I'm gonna put in this one well y'all have to read the description to find them all because I'm not gonna tell you every single game as I'm looking at them here is almost like being Christmas as I'm surrounded by games and I don't just mean the ones back here so you know I'm just gonna go for each one in turn briefly review some rudimentary forts and try and keep it to roughly about 5 minutes per video so I'm hoping that this will be about a 40 to 45 minute video because I'm gonna go over eight games here no particular order no particular theme or anything like that
just a bunch of games that I want to talk about in QuickTime so let's see yeah first up I'm gonna start off on a very like high note here we go Camelot second edition this is a grits peels reprint of a classic gateway game camel up in this one you are involved in a race of these camels that are going round a one-way track and your idea is that you don't own a camel you're betting on which camels going to be in the lead in each round as well as the eventual winner and loser but these camels act all weird you know when they share a space one jumps on top of the other and then the one on the bottom can carry those camels along and it just it's it's pretty random you roll dive through this weird pyramid contraption and you place your Cup your cards down to say who you're betting on in secret and you take tiles from the board to say right I reckon blues gonna be in the lead at the end of this round and you get more money if you do it earlier it's pretty much a random zany fun game and you shouldn't be like going into this with a serious mindset but I was hmm on the original get a camel AB mainly because I didn't think it visually looked the part it was all why it was bright in color ball but the pyramid was kind of flimsy the production quality was not that good and I felt like you just could have used maybe one or two more extra rules or just a bit more improvement in certain areas and maybe when I first played it I probably took it a little bit too seriously myself thinking Ed's is just a random luck fest now though edgert spoilers come out with a second edition printing and for those of you who are thinking I've got the first edition should I get the second edition one only if you want two things at this box
firstly the production quality production quality Ennis is superb it is so colorful so bright the artwork is fantastic the board has a pop-up tree oasis every time you open it the pyramids may not plastic so it doesn't but crush it actually works oh no you can shake it in the dice come out and the camels are solid blocks I swear if I threw one at you I could give you a concussion they it's jumped up to 12 in terms of production quality so if you didn't like the first one or your first edition boxes war-weary now grab this secondly this introduces one or two new rules I'm not 100% familiar with the old system so I'll just if I if I'm telling you to suck eggs you know then you know just just bear with it but the main things in this is you I think you have an extra tile with those betting slips at the end of each round so there's now four instead of three there is a partnership rule because this game can go up to eight players I'm not aware that the base set could do eight players and the way it works is you have a partnership card where as an action you can say right I'm gonna go into partnership with you and each of you is allowed to share one betting tile that you've used in the round it's designed for six or more players in case you get a point where somebody just because they're out of turn order can't get the betting tile they really want very simple it's an auto include you know it's not even a variant it's an auto you must do this with six or more players the main addition though are too crazy camels I think maybe an expansion or promo might have done this for the base game but it's only wasn't in the base game you have a white and black camel
that have go backwards along the track they have a separate die of their own there are rules to dictate which one moves away over time as soon as the die appears and the idea is is that these are disqualified camels and they can in the game as well although I've never seen that happen but the idea is is that whilst they're going backwards they can camels can go on top of them and they can carry them backwards so it just adds more zany random fun to the game Camelot is I'm really warming up to this now you know I get it it's a zany fun gateway game I've taught this to new players it's fantastic now I've really upped my rating of this but some of it has to come down to the fact that a it can do a gateway game in Britain for lots of people in a short space of time and secondly because this just looks a sub line this is the best produced games that I have seen Eggert field do and if you were a fan of the original Camelot or we're all thinking maybe maybe not you should wrap this one III would give this personal rating of something like a nine it's you know it's a random luck fest yes but it's a it does what it needs to do perfectly and I love to bring this out for gateways sessions now so this is an I almost fought giving it a ten but maybe the luck factor you know will annoy some people but now this is a solid gateway game you need to grab it okay let's continue down the Gateway front here I'm what sir let's go on to this one okay we have a dual stained-glass of sin trap now I've already got us all down here and as all
is a great game it's not my favorite eight-way games but I mean you can you can't deny that this thing is just the happiness you know everybody's heard of this game now people have played it at Gateway events cafes and that people just gravitate towards assault it is a superb design for that this is basically a kind of sister game to it it still uses that mechanic of you take tiles from the middle and in fact that is an identical mechanic to what's in the zoo the only thing that's really changed is now the tiles are translucent and you are building these stained glass windows think sort of sagrada but without any dice rolling and the idea is is that as you take the tiles you're trying to place them on your windows so they match the colors but you have a little porn in that left hand side of yours or player board and you have to move it to whichever window that you're building on and it can't go backwards without you spending a whole turn to reset so you have to be careful not only about what towels you need but also not dropping excess ones but also have where you move that porn I mean if he's all the way at the very end then you've got probably got to spend the whole turn resetting him and it's like when's the best time to do that other than that though it's just basically a different method of scoring the minus points are cumulative instead of on their own now but other than that the game is pretty much 95% as or and this is the inherent problem here the game itself is good I like it I'll play it but I see no reason to have this
game if you're only original Azul unless you really want to make just a little bit more meaty than Rizal this is definitely kind of the next step I mean you could call this a gateway game I suppose but then you've got the zoo which is a much better example of a gateway game this one is a little bit more meaty maybe for those players who like the mechanic but just want a bit more involvement in which case this could be the game for you personally though I don't like the fact that this is 95 percent assault literally you have changed a scoring method and what you do with the tiles that's it the picking the choosing the dropping excess ones it is exactly the same it so similar that I don't know it just the whole the whole thing of it as much as it is cool it just feels like it's got the words cash-grab literally printed on the front of the box I mean all they had to do is print the word Azul on it and make it the same game practically and suddenly everybody's hyped over it not to say it's a bad game by any means but I have a duel why do I need this and if you're going to ask me which one of the two would I pick I'll pick the original is all it is easier to teach it is less punishing it's you know I thank the tiles are easier to see because the translucent towels in here look good but I guarantee you there's gonna be two colors in the wrong light you will not be able to distinguish at times and it gets infuriating when that happens but the other problem I have but this is one that people have with the original Azul which is exasperated here in the original is all people for lack of the tiles what come out I mean let's say a bunch of red towels come out I've
already done most of my breads you know it kind of hampers me for a term granted that does happen the original is all even though it's not quite as common as that and there are ways around it this one though that is taken up to a whole new level because you have your window panes in front of you in there random you've got each of each player's got their own set but it's random how you set them up you just go there's my windows you might have a set of windows that pretty much wants a ton of whites and then they don't come out where in this game though having that happened to you is far more damaging because people can just get ahead and start completing windows flipping them over scoring multiple points and you're you're hindered because your windows just happened to not want the tiles that come out and yes this was in the original Azure but I feel the problem is made worse here because of the whole thing of I've got to move this porn and I've only got whatever the windows in front of me say I don't have the means to say okay well I'm just gonna put this color on this window because blank pulsating that's like two wild symbols and that's about it so that if it was a problem for you an original Azure it's gonna be the same here but as a game is fine I'm but the thing is I only gave us all about seven last time because I thought this is well-designed is it's perfect for gateways I recommend it to all game cafes and stuff like that but it only gives me so much enjoyment so I gave that one a seven this I can only really give a 6 it's it's alright yo I like the tile choosing mechanic I'm just not a huge fan of the whole window building and poor moving thing in this one I don't think that's is interesting or as cool
as the mosaic building one in there especially when that one you can flip the board over and do some other cool stuff with this here you just have two different methods of scoring but we do but I just I'm a little bit annoyed that this is just a 95 percent cash grab you know literally just that and as much as I want innovation in my games I want to see new stuff I want to see new ideas being formed this feels like it was literally Oh while we were designing the zoo we just happen to have this one other way we could do it and well now we get to print it yeah not the way I want to see games being developed yeah like I said I'm not saying that's exactly what happened don't quote me on that but I can say it just got cash-grab written all over it so you'll enjoy it if you like us all you'll enjoy it but for me six that's about as far as I can give this one okay I believe I've got two more gateway games here so let's start off with a recent Kickstarter that I just got in the post dice hospital yeah be waiting for this one a while while Sir alley cat games have been you know giving this one a go since like the faint UK games but Expo and even before that and it's had a lot of buzz it's had a lot of hype and I played it during its production so it wasn't just since I got the Kickstarter I've played it before you know the x dice Hospital is a dice manipulation game where you're all taking charge of your own Hospital when you're trying to cure patients they come in on these ambulances I've got the deluxe version which has these funky freedy ones but they're just tiles normally and with
these dice they're in three different colors and the pips regard their life span or life expectancy so the lower they are to one the more critically ill they are or critically injured they are and they are close to dying whereas if you can get it to five and six they're mostly nearly healthy and what you do is that you have these nurse little nipples and you have different rooms in your hospital and you're basically using your workers in such a way that you're manipulating the dice the wards might say to dice with values of one or two go up by one value you know you put the nurse there and those two dice go up by one value and the idea is is that you're trying to raise the value of as many dice as you can so that in a single round you can cure as many people as you can more on that bit a little bit later but and yeah as you go for each round you'll be able to acquire more specialists which gives you more meeples and some special bonuses and more wards to improve your hospital so you can have more efficient actions available but other than that it's mainly a case that you will draft an ambulance full of dice based on their value this will dictate the turn order for choosing specialists and wards you're simultaneously do all your various people to their activate this ward for these dice or whatever and there's a little bit of admin for if you neglect to treat someone in the round they start ticking down towards zero you don't want anybody to become a fatality because negative points but let's say it's looks the part very pretty on the board you've got all sorts of different color dice and the puzzle of
manipulating all the dice isn't really good in an engaging one the rules are pretty straightforward I mean I could consider this to be a gateway game maybe next step but certainly it's not too difficult you've got dice don't let them tick down use the things the graphic design is pretty straightforward the rules are pretty comprehensive as to what everything does and you can opt to not use a few things like player abilities and stuff for that if you want to make your game easier there are one or two things I have as much as this is a cool gateway game and I do like it I do like playing it is something I will keep and recommend there's one cut a couple of gripes one the scoring system where you score based on how many people you can cure in the same round I don't get fir matically how that's supposed to work I don't remember hospitals out there being rewarded more for curing all at the same time surely you just want to cure dice as fast as you can why do I get more points for curing seven people and around as opposed to Rio I do seven in one round and then maybe one for the next five rounds why is that better than me doing the same number of people but spread out throughout the whole game it's kind of odd and it does lead to some sort of wards being a little bit worse than others I think but like I say it's a gateway game it doesn't last too long you're talking ninety minutes max although you better hope the game only lasts 90 minutes max because this can be played one to four players solo mode great fun nice little simple objective tiles you've got to meet get the most
points whatever to player very good back and forth really quick you're deciding whether to draft a particular ambulance to fought your opponent that kind of thing the problem is is that the player interaction and this is next to nil you draft the ambulances and somebody might take your specialist award that is literally it you have no other means of player interaction in this game which means that putting three or four players in this game is entirely pointless exactly that all it does is adds time and when you have four players even with the simultaneous rule because you're gonna have to teach one or two rounds one at a time so that people get the hang of it but then even if everybody knew what they were doing were on simultaneous with the activations you're still looking at good 19 minutes for a four-player game by the time you get through those eight rounds and that's almost over stretching it 90 minutes is okay but I think for what is pretty light puzzle game of dice manipulation I'd rather the game took no more than an hour and with two players it won't by yourself it won't three and four players though kind of depends and if you've got anybody who's AP and takes a while to do their activation you're just going to be sat there waiting because there's no forced timer its Magus a decent game all round I recommended the café's I think if you like the idea of a hospital theme and you like dice manipulation there's this one that go for for me I give it a 7 it's a decent game I'm glad that kick-started it it will stay in my collection and hopefully gain cafface will start having it but I feel I'm going to be playing this one solo in two player a lot more than I'm going to be
playing it free and four player for that reason okay in the last Gateway game or they yeah definitely the last gateway game we're gonna talk about here and that is days of wonders new release which is huh not the most amount of buzz I'll admit especially four days of wonder the river the river literally to sum up what I think of this game in one phrase I could call this my first worker placement game that's effectively what the river is you are you have a bunch of workers and you are building these tiles on your map along this river these buildings allow you to produce certain resources like brick and stone and wood you know the typical free and also store resources you have limited storage you have a few spaces on another board where you go to gather the resources to acquire building cards to actually build the buildings and these aren't buildings with special abilities is literally it's a card with a picture of a Hut on it and it requires free brick and to wood you know that's pretty much all the difference is there's some bonus points for building early there's a really funny turkey turkey poop I know turkey meatballs as they are so Turkey Palacios is the correct term for it which are basically wild resources and like I say first game I've seen with turkey beat balls is pretty sweet but the game is pretty straightforward you just take in turn do your worker placement like every other worker placement game gather resources build buildings and acquire tiles put them on on your river and you're hoping to have the same type in various columns to
score more points but as you build these tiles there's a bit of a I would say a bit of a weak excuse for a catch-up mechanism which is as you build too many tiles your workers like stay put and get fixed so you have less workers as the game progresses but other than that you know it's it's really straightforward and that's the thing with the river it looks nice it's colorful it's bright you know it pops on the table just like every other days a wonder title does days are wandering is more known for doing they're really good gateway games you know Ticket to Ride and more 44 and those have a camel or you know stuff like that but they have done some meaty stuff like five tribes in the Amitai as well this is definitely like gateway gateway level and certainly as I've played it I enjoy it I will play it but I don't think I'm gonna own this one and it's not what I'm gonna seek out myself personally but that's not to say I think the game is bad it's it's relatively generic you know it's not like there's anything brand-new here as a mechanic but what this does is that it fills a niche everybody who is like I want to play a worker placement game but who do I which one do I grab first people usually say Lords of Waterdeep which is a great game I have it on my shelf down there but I want to play Lords of Waterdeep with the expansion I don't want to play base set boards of war deep anymore and even base set Lords of Waterdeep it's not the simplest water worker placement game in the world I mean come on there's a reasonable amount you've got to teach somebody even in a base set version of Lords of Waterdeep not to mention it can take a fair while
to finish if you're teaching multiple players this box is a 2 to 4 players very to 45 minutes yeah you are talking no more than an hour tops with this game and probably 45 minutes it's actually pretty accurate you could get this done in 30 minutes 2 players I'm pretty certain it is nice and short but if you're now thinking well I want to teach someone worker placement which game do I do this one this is something that every game cafe out there needs by minimum this should be one of the first games they should be thinking of in there because worker placement is not an easy mechanic to teach people there's a lot of games that use it but they're usually quite meaty this feels the niche it is now the perfect game to teach worker placement with it's still enjoyable I don't think it's boring you know even though it's really simple but if they can't learn this game and they're going to struggle with every other worker placement game you throw in front of them this is just the perfect introduction colorful easy still has some like different parking Tate you know do you want lots of storage for the resources you're gonna focus on one in particular are you gonna build buildings or you're gonna worry more about the column split or are you just going to try and build it as fast as you can to end the game whatever there's a few different paths but nothing brain burning you know decisions should be pretty quick you know the game is quick but it's a worker placement game you can do in less than an hour where where did you find many other worker placement games that do that so yeah I still give this one about 7 personally it's it's enjoyable I will play it if he wants to learn worker placement I am
happy to pull out this game get it out and join in with them and I hope that by the end they understand the concept of worker placement so that you can then throw Lords of Waterdeep Rangers or the North Sea Stone Age you know and all these other relatively simple worker placement games so I give props it fills a niche but yeah gamers probably aren't going to go mad for this one so like I say bear in mind what this game is before you start going nuts over it just because it's Days of Wonder so gets a seven for me and I highly recommend it like is there a is there a seal of approval for broken evil there isn't yet unfortunately but definitely every game cafe needs this ok those four games I've been a mostly positive about let's get to something on this list where well the one game on this list I'm not particularly fond of here we go yeah discovered lands on them talk about a big disappointment yeah I was psyched to think all unique game system and key forward yeah this would be great with discover as well like so the game's unique I've got two different terrains that you know people might not necessarily have different cards to explore and it's a survival game I can play solo oh yeah and I have only played this solo okay so you know do not all these games I have played enough to do full reviews on I'll let you know I think there's only one game I got do first impressions on this list but this one I played through the scenarios one to four I haven't done the weird PvP one at the end and it's just generic purely
generic it's you basically move your guy on the map you spend a certain amount of stamina points in order to do various actions and you're trying to survive get food get water you find shelter build fires explore landmarks fight off animals fight off monsters whatever and you're trying to go and we were trying to actually find out what the end of the scenario is because you don't necessarily know when you start there's basically a little narrative story that you're playing through although I say story in his looser terms because I think this kind of story is about generic as you would get on something out of CBBC or something or like a Nickelodeon or whatever this is like a really generic storyline and you can see coming a mile away at least I did in this Cathy you know you start finding these little things like oh is this what this is gonna be and lo and behold it is he knows I where's the surprise this is it would actually goes too far to say that this has a worse storyline in it then charred our stone that's impressive the stone have a pretty poor storyline this is even less entertaining than that so what's the good thing about it well it being unique means that you will see stuff that you won't see in someone else's Cappy okay that's all well and good the survival aspect is done pretty well you know you do feel like you're kind of on the edge no trying to find the water in a meeting I had animals chasing me I've got to get back to my fire or do I go out at night and stare in which cases a bit too much and I will say it's very streamlined the rule books done very well in this and you know aside from a little bit of looking out
for rules I pretty much managed to get straight into this game just set it up which does take a while to set up for your first time I will warn you sorting out all the cards and stuff but it's quick to get into and the actions are streamlined you just spend your stamina stamina costs are usually one for everything you do and less otherwise stated the scenario she tell you anything else you need to know and you just get stuck in and trying to survive so you know it is nice and easy to play but it's got player elimination horrible idea player elimination in the game at last 60 to 90 minutes that's just wrong absolutely wrong bad discover and the story as I said is pretty generic and once you played for the scenario you know the story so where's the replay value the replay value is purely just to go through that survival aspect but do you know the story it's generic it doesn't change every game so where's there anything new the PvP mode have not tried it it's only scenario 5 but again why wouldn't want to do that especially if it's play elimination and I have heard instances where I don't think I had it in this one I'm I know I did have it yeah there was one boss bout but you've got boss battles where you can help each other beat the combat but then everybody has to win the combat in order to get through and once you've won it you're at the game so why am i helping the first person get through is like what makes no sense his there's some strange design decisions in this and I feel that the idea of it being unique hurts the game it makes it feel just incomplete so yeah
discover just really didn't work I mean you know player elimination don't want that yeah the boring easy to predict story component quality is only so-so as well it just like to say I expected more from this publisher this designer and even this concept this at most gets a five from me it's it's okay but there's so much better it could even be a four it just really didn't hit the mark very disappointed with discover lands on though okay all you Rosenberg fans yeah this one I've been wanting to review this for a while Rick Holt I think it's called that Rick Holt or raid cult I don't know what the difference is I'm just gonna say him how I feel and you know feel free to correct it but Ray colt is a new array Rosenberg game very much in his usual fee you don't have to feed your people funny enough I mean God that makes a change but you still have to grow vegetables harvest vegetables and use them in some way or another to get victory points except you don't in this one haha got you yeah there's no victory points in this what you were doing is you were trying to feed the tourists and there's a track rounding outside of a board where they have requirements for what food they need you're growing the vegetables in these greenhouses and then harvesting them out of there in order to feed the tourists and move this little porn across the tables and you know idea is is that once the seven or eight rounds are finished winner is whoever got the furthest that's it it's a race game no victory points you just basically see who got the farthest and
there's a couple of tiebreaker rules so bit different from your usual fare but you know I can say it's nice to have something a little bit different but it's a worker placement game so you have a limited number of spaces on the board they don't really change other than player scaling you go and cut the greenhouses you plant vegetables and each where any one vegetable can be in each greenhouse there's greenhouses a different size you will harvest the vegetables out at every night at times and you can do other various things on the spaces but the interesting little quirk with this I mean for starters it's a fairly light worker placement game nothing too taxing here I wouldn't say gateway level at all but you should be able to understand this one pretty easily if you play any other worker placement game or even just any other um rosenberg title the game itself is wonderful players and it takes it says on the box forty to sixty minutes i don't know what time zone these guys live in or what interdimensional trickery they used to pull that out but this will not take you further sixty minutes no no I mean sixty to ninety is more reasonable yeah you could maybe do this in less than 60 minutes by yourself yeah and I have tried the solo mode it's it's a stupid excuse for a campaign it's basically a story mode gives you this little weak narrative and gives you some extra cards oh well great you literally could just ignore the story mode and just rip out the cards and stick them in the normal game you know that's probably just as good but yeah 60 to 90 minutes is a more accurate time scale if anybody is getting this done in 60 minutes for four players I need that I need evidence because I do not believe that's possible but it's well reduced its renegade game
studios so you've got little carts for the various vegetables you've got wooden resource tokens and you've got these cards you use five in every game and you pick a set and you pick five out of that set and these allow you to get some bonus or some special ability but you can share them as well there's an action space where you share the ability with your neighbor a bit like a seven Wonders style thing and if you share it then both of you get that ability that's really cool and I like it but there's also a problem with that you only use five out of a set of something like seven or eight and there's about five or six sets in this game you really don't see a lot of these cards very quickly but they're one of the best aspects and you want to see more of them so I almost house rule that you just use the entire set and kind of works alright I don't think it's unbalanced the game since I've done it that way but yeah it wouldn't be nice to have seen more of these cards come out each game five just seems really limiting it does sort of affect how the game will play but it's not like they have that game changing effects that's gonna drastically change the way it plays each time so I just think why not have more cards available I just found that kind of weird and story mode wise who cared about story mode but nice to have a solo mode it not gonna complain looks the part no and I do like it it's a nice simple array Rosenberg style worker placement game joy growing the vegetables and harvest amount like from the greenhouses it's nice to be able to get that feeling from an early Rosenberg game in sixty to ninety minutes rather than something like governor or Lahav or anything like that which can take anywhere from two to three hours this is kind of on par with news Ford in terms of complexity but
news Ford I found pretty generic wasn't a fan of it this one I like a bit more so I still enjoy it it's a good little game I give it about seven decent if you like an early Rosenberg fair and just want something a little bit simpler okay two more let's start with the last one which I can do let's see yes this one passing through Petra now this game I knew nothing about when I first saw her no idea didn't even know this was gonna exist but shall we say yeah the bit of a thing would ready gate game studios to say no with anymore there was Rick Holt and I've done more great renegade game studio stuff really architects the West Kingdom check out the review of that this is passing fruit Petra and it's a it's an interesting Euro tile pushing game more manipulation you have a player board and you are moving these tiles on a row at the bottom of your player board and then moving to them to the top as like permanent settlers and basically what you're doing is that you're trading with you're letting the traders trade with each other effectively this is a euro game which is set in Petra traders are coming along there's big caravan in between these Canyon pieces that you actually put on the board and the idea is is that you're you would trigger certain actions by moving a pawn on this little grid and with those actions you're manipulating the tiles on your player board in such a way that you can conduct these various market actions and
the market actions allow you to move on these various rondelle's to get bonuses but also to place our influence cubes and there's no victory points in this game either this one you just have to get all nine of your cubes out first and that's it as well as grabbing tiles from the end of a plaza or from the canyon itself and manipulating your board you can also grab these villager cards that give you special bonuses or one-off cool gimmicks you know now it's a pretty straightforward game actually I was expecting it to be a bit heavier but no this is something you can get wrapped up in about an hour to an hour and a half pretty easily and that's a good link for the game for me and production wise it's okay the artwork is good I like the artwork on the tiles there's a good amount of detail on there and I like the villager card artwork the board looks pretty basic it's kind of like a generic sandy board you know we have a few buildings put everywhere and the rondelle's are okay they're clear you can see what's what but the canyon pieces are they look cool but they're fiddly as all get-out you actually might need to kind of force them into the board and the little clips in order to get them to sit properly and obviously when you're taking tiles out at the end of the plaza you have to move this giant row of trader towels through the canyon to fill it up and that gives a little bit fiddly and annoying at times even though it does look the part you've got a little picture and standee at the end and you've got the canyon pieces so it does look nice on the table but yeah from renegade game studios I was kind of expecting maybe a little bit extra and a part work on production quality but it's
still decent if a little fiddly I enjoyed this one that tile pushing is actually good fun it's simple the actions are quick turns are quick because you don't have to do much on your turn and apart from the market action and even that doesn't take very long because you've already planned it out but it's quite cool that you're thinking well I see I can get these red tiles here they trade with the purple ones but I haven't got enough purple ones on top sorry don't be my phone very professional but yeah red purple red purple tiles you know they can trade with each other it's like well if I move them up there I can do this but then they go away and then once I need I need them blues after that but I could grab them from the canyon or they've just come into the plaza great I'll grab those and you're restricting on your location actions by where you are on that little grid because if you're right at the edge of the grid you can't do that specific location action so that's a really neat little trick as well I don't see that in a lot of games but it's fairly straightforward doesn't take a lot to get through and it's an interesting little gyro I liked it a lot better than I thought one gripe rule book rule book is generally alright however there is one or two rules in the game suppose maybe one rule one of them was easy enough to understand on second reading but there's one critical role in this game about how you place influence cubes on the rondell as you go past check go on to FAQ s go on to BoardGameGeek speak to the designer make certain that you have understood that rule because if you don't you will break the game and it is very badly worded in the rule book the rule book would
actually be really good except for that one maybe two little rules in here which are like so important but the way they're worded is like beyond belief it got through play testing it's like seriously did no one read this bit of the book and think hang on that looks a little bit or I'm not entirely sure sounds like it was a bit too much like within an echo chamber when they were designing this but the game itself is good fun just get past that little hurdle with the rulebook and you have an entertaining towel pushing game that caters for two to four players and gets done within a quick amount of time so I overall have enjoyed this one I have not played it a lot I've only played it twice this is kind of first impressions really but I would say that this deserves at least a seven possibly an eight I do enjoy that towel pushing mechanic it's just a nice little puzzle and not too difficult and you've got different paths to victory so yeah this was a surprise hit for the year for me actually passing for Petra okay last one and it's a biggie this is one that I have been wanting to play a lot and finally I have Western legends yes this was a big hit on I think it was Kickstarter where it came out and everybody was gunning for it and no pun intended but I annoyingly didn't back it and I wish I had this is basically a sandbox you wrote esque euro /mf right it's kind of hybrid really western themed game and you take control of a
famous cowboy or cowgirl from you know the law and you basically go around this map and do what you like really you can do anything from play poker to ran bandits to rob banks to prospect for gold to game cattle game cattle do you deliver it to the rail yard do you deliver it to the opposing branch do you want to be a wanted player and do lots of a you know get victory points each round but then have to run away from the sheriff and marshals do you want to be one of the marshals so that you can go and round up bandits for more marshal points and also go and arrest players who are playing in the negative fashion there's all sorts of cool things that you can do and you choose what you want to do you grab items what you know you gain money you grab items you get weapons you upgrade them you can get mounts you can get provisions hats that sort of thing and it's not that complex a game there is a little bit of like rules checking that you have to do to begin with but I expected this to be a lot more complicated than it was and it actually wasn't mainly you just have to make certain that you get how the fights work and how the cards work if you can get those into your head then you're pretty much on the way with this there's a couple of variants you can play for an easier first game and stuff like that maybe if you want to take it really easy you should use those but I jump straight in with everything and we managed fine with a free player game I think it was free place yeah free player we did just fine but I was wondering whether I would like this or not because of the Western theme I'm not a huge western bar for fat
but this was really enjoyable it's it's not the best game ever I will say there are some gripes with it like I say the the books not perfect and you know certain being wanted is hard to pull off you know you can easily be a marshal because you can just be nice and go and kill bandits and that if you want to be wanted you've got to make certain you outrun that sheriff and other marshal players a lot but it is doable and it certainly had quite a lot of fun to do first game of both this I was a proper marshal and I went around killing off bandits as well as killing off the occasional player who decided he was going to rob banks but it was it was a good bit of laughs now you have to go into this with a kind of roleplay aspect this is one that encourages roleplay play some western music on in the background you know do voices you know really get into your character and just only what you're gonna do in this game you know it's the car mechanic and this is really fun as well I love the way that all the cards are poker cards and you can either play poker with them you know go to the saloon play poker there's the flop there's your two cards
I'd try and make a poker hand get some money but I like how the the highest value of the poker card is what dictates like the outcome of a fight and the poker cards all will have special abilities on them like one can be a cheap card in poker one counts as a goal for prospecting one gives you a bonus in combat and there's a little subtle varieties like this there's story mode story cards that you've got a complete every now and again in whoever contributes to the story art by fulfilling a condition turn it over bandit spawn you read a bit of narrative it's just a wonderfully formatic western themed game and it can go on a bit long you're talking a good two hours of gaming wasn't say on the box I count for two to six players 90 to 120 minutes I'm not sir and I would want to play this with five or six players I think that would just be way too long but two to four players it's worked pretty well even though with less players you have less stuff going on the board I find that three and four is a good sweet spot with this game you know two is maybe a bit too little and five and six unless you all know what you're doing can be a bit long but I find three to four players about two hours with this makes for just a wonderful sandbox you're like I don't know if it's a year or a Meritage really I mean yeah you're not really using dice you're using card so I'd say you're you don't roll dice but there's an element of luck obviously with what cards you draw and what cards the opposing like npcs do so I suppose I'd call it more of a hybrid I suppose but if you're a fan of westerns and you want the sandbox experience this is
definitely one to look at I've enjoyed my place of it so far not had that many plays though so maybe you could call this a first impression but so far I'm glad I got it I wish I had the expansion's I wish I backed it when it first came out and Kickstarter you but you know this is definitely one that if I see the expansions I'm grabbing in an instant because this is one of my highlights for the year so let's say not perfect has some issues but all in all I would still give this at least an eight possibly a nine I am really enjoying it but maybe I got to be a little bit more critical and think that there are some I would like a bit more variety new items you know there is a bit of luck involved is quite a long game so I'd certainly give this a high eight this is definitely one to have a look at if sandbox games are your thing and they certainly are for me there you go eight games eight games with my Forte's bit of analysis and a little rating at the end because well I know you all like number ratings this has been quite a good fun actually it's basically like being at Christmas but this will happen in the future you know there'll be times where I will I'm only gonna do so many reviews a week in the new year I'll get onto that when I finally wrap up I've been able to start season 3 but the idea is is that there are some times where there's just far too many games and I can't afford to hit burn out I need time for myself my stress levels are already high enough as it is with work and living alone and doing everything myself and stuff so
it's I've got to make certain I don't stress myself out too much and when you've got so many games here that you just want to try want to play and people want to know your thoughts about you can't do a 20 minute video review about each and every one of them and three minutes five minutes like some people do isn't long enough to do detailed analysis of certain games but for games like these I felt like I focused on certain ones that were more buzz you know like hyped up games and then they can get a review video these compilations will allow me to sort of basically give games like this a voice cuz did you even know this one existed well hopefully you do now so that's the idea of these videos they will happen every now and again it just depends how many games there are to review and how behind schedule is a bit of a get out pause so that's it for me for this first compilation video I'll see you on the next video top ten review compilation whatever it seems to be and this one's gonna be out too think early December time so there's plenty of more days yet to work your way up for Christmas presents I'm not expecting much this year my cellphone we kind of have something with the family where we don't get each other that many Christmas presents anymore cuz I'm the youngest of a family of five and I'm in my mid-thirties so yeah we don't have many presents we need and if I ask them to try and buy me a board game good luck with that so that's it for me I'll see you on the next video and remember out of all these eight games doesn't matter if there's too many for you to try just
remember they're only games you don't need to try them all you don't need play every single game just play the ones you like and be happy take care see you next time you
you