Survivor 50: Game Design Notes
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jimmy with Stillmeyer Games and I love the show Survivor. So, I thought I'd talk about season 50. A few elements of season 50 through episode six. So, if you haven't watched through episode six, I'm probably going to say some spoilers here. In fact, I'll I'll definitely say some spoilers here as I analyze the game design specifically of Survivor season 50 so far. So, here is the giant cast of Survivor season 50. They picked 24 contestants spread out over not all 50 seasons of Survivor, but many different seasons of Survivor dating back to the first season. A couple of things with this. So, 24 is the biggest number of players they've ever had on a start a season of Survivor. And I think that was the right call. I I I think that was the right call. Like, in for a returning players season, it's been a long time since we've had a returning players season. I think uh generally fans want to see more people.
So, cast a little bit wider of a net and then try to find ways to eliminate them a little bit faster. Like, double eliminations, triple eliminations. Talk about that in a little bit later. But, I think 24 players was the right call. I I mean, they probably could have Well, I don't think it could have gone any any bigger. But, 24 is a lot of people. Um it's hard to As we've seen from Beast Games, it's hard to invest in someone individually when their playing time is spread out across so many other people. So, 24 I think is probably the max they could go. But, I'm glad they did that. Um I'm glad that they spread them out over many different seasons. Some of the casting decisions I thought were a little interesting. Not about specific people, but in that there were certain seasons where they picked like three people from the same season or two people from the same season even though there were 50 different seasons to cast from. I thought that was a little odd, a little interesting. But, maybe it came down to certain people weren't available or weren't interested in coming back on Survivor. I don't know. I I found that a little bit interesting that they they had uh repeat multiple people from the same season. Although, at the same time, I can understand some of them. There were like uh Kyle and Camilla.
They were a powerful duo in their season. It was interesting to see them very briefly at least uh be on the same show together again, on the same season again. It's also an interesting way to have two rivals from previous seasons go head-to-head on the same on the same beach. Um but, I think maybe that could have been saved for a separate season. Like, brought bring back powerful allies and powerful rivals for those stories in the in a future season rather than picking multiple people from the same season. So, I don't know if I am the biggest fan of that part of it. But, I still enjoy the individuals that they ended up casting. One thing with casting in a season where everyone is returning is that there is the risk of pre-show alliances. And I think maybe there was a lot of that from I I've heard interviews about cast members about how a lot of these cast members knew they were being cast and talked to each other openly before the show.
Um I think the So, Survivor kind of goes out of their way once they get people on the in Fiji, they go out of their way to prevent them from talking to one another. Um to prevent those types of things that we don't get to see as the audience. And that's the key here. The show is created so the audience can experience it. And if we are seeing people if we are missing seeing people ally with one another and have those types of discussions, then we are missing out on something that's fairly important to the show. So, uh I don't know. I I don't entirely mind pre-show alliances, but I wish the show maybe could acknowledge them a little bit more and maybe just directly ask people about it and show that in the edit of who they talked with before the season uh so that we can know that as the audience.
And last, I thought one interesting decision was that they cast three returning winners. They cast uh Savannah, Kyle, and Dee. And I just thought that that was an interesting number of having three returning winners. I can't remember if I think each of them may have started on a different tribe, which kind of makes sense. Three tribes, three different winners to see if those are the ones that are targeted very early on. Um I don't know. I think they could have gone with zero winners. Three was an interesting number. But, maybe it was because of the three the three tribes to start the game. And unfortunately, we saw two of them uh Kyle being one of my favorite uh people to play Survivor have to leave fairly early in the show. Dee is still there though, six episodes in. And so, um good luck to Dee for the rest of the season. She's quite a player.
So, that was my first kind of point, that the contestants themselves. Let's switch up the the angle here and talk about some of the uh one one also unique element of this season is celebrity tie-ins, which is somewhat of an another interesting choice to have a celebrity tie-ins. They have They keep saying the Billie Eilish boomerang idol. Um and in terms of idols uh idol design, I think this is a very interesting idol design in that when you discover this idol, you have to send it to someone on a different tribe. And if that person is kicked out is voted out or leaves the show, I believe maybe it's only voted out. Um that idol returns to you. And so, you're Are you trying to send it to someone that you want to be an ally with later on that you want to protect? Or are you sending it to someone that you hope gets voted out so that you get the idol back in the long run. I think it's a very interesting idol design.
Uh having Billie Eilish tied to it has largely been uh irrelevant in other than we get to see hear people say Billie Eilish's name a lot, including in this video right now. So, well done to Billie Eilish for getting that uh that free promotion, I guess. Also, there was an episode that heavily rotated around a musician named Zac Brown. And I actually thought that parts of this episode were pretty cool. They showed Zac Brown fishing and like he Like, in I would have I would have expected that a celebrity coming on the show would just kind of show up and maybe eat a good meal with the contestants or hang out with them for a little bit. But, Zac Brown actually went fishing and caught some fish and prepared that fish for the contestants. It definitely made Zac Brown look very cool.
I don't know what entire purpose it served for the show itself. Um but again, it was great promotion for Zac Brown. And some of the contestants seemed to highly value that. And so, I'm sure it was I mean, these are celebrity These are celebrities. And the people appearing on Survivor as returning contestants are somewhat celebrities themselves as well. So, I'm sure this is a nice treat for them. So, I appreciate it from their perspective. Um And I think we know that that Mr. Beast will appear later in the season. He's also a fan of Survivor. I am Here's Here's I think my my ultimate take on celebrities on the show. If they bring more fans to Survivor and let Survivor have another 50 seasons, I am all for it. In terms of entertainment value, I don't get much out of it. But, uh but genuinely, if if they bring more fans to the show, I'm all for that. I I I want Survivor. I love Survivor. I want Survivor to keep going for many many years. So, that's where I end up on it.
I'll switch the view here for my third point. I have five different points here. Is uh the element of fan voting in this season and what fans have chosen to vote for or vote for vote against. So, I thought this was a really cool element of this season. I think Survivor likes to experiment with different things, different strategies, different methods. And asking the fans opinions for an official vote on it for this season and then revealing it as the show proceeds without the players knowing what the fans voted for, I think is very clever. Um that said, I've been a little surprised by some of the things that the fans have voted for. In particular, that uh the no rice decision early on. I have no absolutely no desire as a fan of Survivor to watch the contestants starve. And I know they don't actually starve. There is food on the beach, they can catch fish, they there are ways for them to get food. Um but, having a little bit of rice at the beginning of the show uh so that they can be more alert and more entertaining for us, I I I am absolutely an advocate of that. So, I was surprised that the the fans voted against giving the Survivors rice and maybe beans uh to start the season.
Other than that, I I the fans voted for chaos. Um they voted for idols to be on the show, they voted for there to be there to be a tribe swap. Um I think I voted for most of those things. I I was fine with most of those things. I do I I do want the players to I'd like to see really really clever alliances and shifting uh shifting alliances and social games. Um that to me is very entertaining to watch. And when you throw in too much chaos, it prevents that from happening. Including in my next point that I'll talk about, the blood moon. But, uh I'm I I I think more I'm focusing here on the idea that the fans got a choice. They had They had the power to vote on this season. I thought that was pretty cool.
My second to last point is uh there was a a pretty big thing that happened in in episode six, this blood moon event in the show. With the blood moon event, the the remaining contestants, I think there were around 18 17 or 18 remaining contestants, they were split into five tribes. Maybe it was 15. They were split into five tribes. And uh they had to compete against one another. And it's kind of temporary. They like merged and then they were then they were immediately split into five into three tribes. And then they had to compete against one another. And then each of them had to go to tribal with one person from each of those mini temporary tribes uh having immunity. This is like the ultimate chaos in the show. And yes, they needed to do something like this. They needed to find a way to vote out more than one person per episode to get because they started with 24.
But, it was a very chaotic moment in the show. Um And I think they probably could have done some things that were maybe a little bit more entertaining, a little bit more interesting. One idea that I had is that they could have sent everyone to Tribal, given everyone an extra vote, and said the top two vote-getters go home. Or even only let people have one vote and say the top two vote-getters go home. I think Tyson had on his podcast had an interesting idea about the tribe swap swap as well. Um kind of like merging as they go through the votes. So I think there were different ways they could have done this. Um So I don't know. I I am on the fence about what they did. There is one element of of this this swap or this uh this merge vote that I was definitely not a fan of. And that was uh I I And I actually like part of it. Part At the very beginning of it, before they started the swap, before they started the merge really, or as the merge was happening, they sent the contestants into the jungle to find an advantage.
And Ozzy found it. And the advantage says, "You have to go to Exile Island." It did not say that you you miss out on the vote um because I think they didn't want to reveal that to contestants at that point. But I think at the very least that advantage should have said, "You are safe on Exile uh for the next 24 hours." Because crucially, Ozzy had to pick someone else to go with him. And so this type of chaos is not the type of chaos that I enjoy in Survivor. The chaos where you have to make a decision and you don't know what that decision means. And that was the case with Ozzy. had to pick someone to go with him to to Exile. And ultimately, Ozzy is protecting that person. He doesn't know that he's protecting that person, but he is protecting that person because they are not going to um they're not going to Tribal Council that night. He picked Rizzo.
Um I don't know if he would pick if he would have picked Rizzo if he had known about this. So I I'm okay with a little bit of chaos as long as the players have agency over their decisions. And my last point is just something that isn't about the game design of the show, but I thought was interesting is that um the I'm blanking on the name right now, but the weather the the the guy What is his name? Rick Devens, yeah, Rick Devens. He planted a fake idol at Tribal Council, which I think is incredibly clever. Um and I'm very curious The show keeps playing it up and reminding us that it is there. So I'm curious to see if it plays a role and how Rick Devens will use it later in the season. So it This is not a thing that the show designed, but I do like that the show uh doesn't that that the show gives players the materials kind of to make fake idols or to use the wrappings of idols that they've already used uh to do stuff like this. I think the show enables this type of creativity, which I think is wonderful. I love when the show enables creativity in the challenges, in the social game, um and even something like this where we'll see if it actually has a payoff later in the season. So Rick made the move, but the show enabled it to happen through the show's, I guess, uh set design in a way.
So yeah, those are my thoughts on Survivor season 50. I am of course enjoying the season. I enjoy every season of Survivor, and I look forward to seeing how the next what, maybe six episodes play out for the rest of the season. So yeah, I'd love to hear your thoughts on the game design of Survivor 50. Let me know about that in the comments below. No spoilers after episode six though, if you don't mind. Thanks.