Skip to main content
Loading video...

Calico REVIEW | More Than Just the Best Cat Game

Transcript 9:56

ever since exploding kittens blew up on kickstarter in 2015 there's been a ton of these cat themed games coming out over the years some of my favorites would include cat lady as well as the isle of cats which are two very solid games but i'm here to tell you that calico is the new title holder for best cat game out there now i know you're probably thinking so what best cat game might not be saying all that much but that's part of the reason why i hesitate to even refer to this as a cat game because in general it's just a fantastic game regardless of the theme whether you're into the cat theme or not it's undeniable the quality that's on display here in this game so it's not a perfect game and i will get to a couple criticisms later but for now let's talk about what you're actually doing in calico each player gets their own recessed dual layered player board which represents a quilt at the start of the game you get three random goal tiles from a possible six and you place them in these three spots on your quilt on your turn you'll have two tiles in your hand all you do is place one tile anywhere on your quilt and then draw a new tile from the common supply of three players take turns doing this until everyone's quilts are full and the game ends each tile has two features a color or a symbol displayed here for colorblind players along with a pattern essentially you're trying to place your tiles adjacent to your goal tiles to meet the indicated goals while also chaining together tiles with either the same colors to score these three point buttons or of the same patterns to attract cats to your quilt which can often be the biggest ways to get you points so then what does it actually feel like to play calico well even though the

rules are fairly breezy and it moves along fairly quickly this is ultimately a game of risk assessment knowing when to cut your losses and knowing how far to gamble on something even the smallest opportunities for points in this game which are usually the colored buttons which gives you three points usually involve connecting three colored tiles so you're not just gonna get three points by placing a single tile even the smallest measliest little three points involve some sort of investment that you might not know that you're going to get the net result out of at the same time the higher point values whether it's the goals that you have on your board or these cat objectives you can go for that attract cats to your quilt have an even longer investment sometimes you need to connect five or seven tiles in a specific way and when you're only holding two tiles in your hand and you've got three in the common display that you're going to draw one from at the end of your turn this quickly becomes a game of priorities and you need to decide how much do you want to invest in trying to go for a particular goal somewhere with knowing that you might still need three four five more tiles to see that through and what if you get halfway through meeting this objective and you later realize that the tiles just aren't working out for you and you have to pivot if you're a perfectionist this type of game might drive you crazy it might be frustrating it might feel like you never can do quite what you want to do but it doesn't quite have to be that way and that's one of the best things about calico is the option of playing casually versus playing more intensely this really is a game for

just about anyone based on the playing time the ease of rules i mean you can set this up teach it and play within an hour and your brain is going to get a significant workout again if you want it to if you want to play it sitting back casually with someone where you're not really thinking a whole lot about your moves and just kind of enjoying watching your quilt develop you can do that but if you want to sit down and really go head-to-head with someone and you want to try and build this quilt in the perfect way you can and maximize your scoring you really want to stress over those moves you can do that as well there's nothing that feels like it doesn't belong here everything feels well thought out there's no bloat to the rules there's nothing that feels like oh if they had cut this out it would have been a little more accessible or a little more streamlined everything just feels well thought out and i mean look at the level of care that has just gone into everything from the amazing artwork by beth sobel not only on the cover but i mean the player boards all these pieces the component quality of everything these dual layered boards the bang for your buck on this game is about as good as it gets in board gaming to be honest with you i think i got this brand new for about 32 bucks canadian and for that price you usually don't find a game of this high quality in terms of the production as well as the game itself so hats off to aeg and flat out for that and it's exactly because of this level of polish and care from everyone involved in this project that it makes it so tough to find anything really wrong with the game i do have one issue though it's not a huge huge one but i find that once you go above two players the game doesn't get any better i find adding a third or

fourth player to me reduces the player interaction rather than increasing it and for me personally when i'm really excited about a game and i want to show it to other people the thought of playing with more players usually makes the game more interactive let me explain why this isn't the case for calico this is because when you play a two player game the only interaction that's really coming into play in calico in general has to do with the common supply of tiles that you'll be drawing from at the end of the turn maybe you don't need any of the three tiles in particular so maybe you draw one that you know your opponent needs in a four four-player game though you can't be drafting tiles off the front of the board denying three different people if everyone else on their turn is just taking the tile that works best for them but you're spending your turns trying to deny other players and you're not really getting what's best for you you're gonna quickly fall behind so a three or four player game there's a lot more emphasis on sort of just taking what works for you and getting the points where you can not really worrying as much about the other players so for me when we're talking about player count calico unquestionably succeeds best as a solo or two player game personally i think two players is where it's at three players still very good four players it's still great it's still going to work really well especially if you're playing with people who don't take too long on their turns who don't suffer from too much that analysis paralysis it'll still be smooth enough and enjoyable enough with three or four but personally my player count of choice for this is going to be two and i find that anything above that it becomes a little less interactive now i want to talk about one of the negatives that i found other people have

had with this game that i don't think is really a fair criticism and that has to do with the randomness i've seen people complain about the randomness of tiles saying that oh you know it can be unsatisfying if you don't get the tiles you need but i'd like to explain why i don't think that's a fair enough criticism about the game and to do that we're going to take a closer look at the player boards so those three goal tiles i mentioned at the start are going to go in here in these three spots so throughout the game as you're drawing tiles obviously you want to be trying to place the next these goals to meet them but i want you to take a look at something look at the surrounding spaces that actually go around the goal tiles here here and here that leaves a few spaces on your board that aren't actually going to be adjacent to those tiles at all if you look along the bottom there's three here there's a couple up here and a couple over here so you have these sort of let's call them dead zones where you can kind of store away these tiles so if you have a hand of two tiles that don't work for you you have to use you have this sort of economy this sort of resource that you have to manage throughout the game you almost have these seven free spaces you can get rid of a tile without affecting your goals so if a tile is either sort of good for you or not good at all you can tuck that away but that's a resource that you're essentially using up that you won't have access to as much of later on the flip side you have these goals as i mentioned before there are goals you can go for with these cats where for example leo rewards you for having five tiles of the same pattern in a straight line like this and that's going to get you 11 points

when you look at your player board you can see this pattern here and this pattern here you can use this board the the border around the board to actually connect for that goal so you can use fill in these three to get that goal of five instead of actually spending five tiles so the depth of this game really comes out through all the spaces in their board and i find that having the randomness of the tiles gives you more depth of strategy because you have to figure out when to actually place those in the spots where you're committing to your goals when you can tuck them away in the corners but when you're also using those and they're going to maybe block other connections that you have across your borders so everything really matters and i find the randomness really just adds the depth of strategy here rather than punishing and really we're all operating under the same level of luck in here so i think it's perfect for calico so despite my minor criticism about the reduced player interaction at higher player counts i do really like calico i think it's a fantastic game that works well with families as well as more serious gamers who want to sit down and have a more competitive game night i mean really it's one of those games that does a lot with a little it's got simple rules you can get it to the table very quickly and yet it's going to put your brain through quite the workout the other thing i want to point out is this is the first published design by kevin russ and as far as debut games goes this is about as good as it gets this is just such a clean polished design and there's just so much to like about it yes the game won't be for everyone but if it's not for you you probably know that

if you're looking for a very interactive fighty game or you're looking for some epic long campaign game you know this isn't for you but if you're looking for this type of game then the folks at flat out and aeg have delivered on every front yes it's the best cat game on the market but honestly to think of it as just another cat game would be a disservice to calico this wasn't a game that was made for cat lovers this was a game that was made for board game lovers and it just so happens that the cat theme is a nice added bonus for those of us who love cats so did the world need another cat themed board game maybe not but if they're all gonna be this good i'd say keep bringing them on so thanks for watching and we'll see you around you

Progress saved