Turing Machine: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to board games unlocked and we're doing a no run through review for a turing machine um if you can't see the uh the actual titles because they made a stupid box there we go it's um no it's it's not it's not bad um we're doing a review over this instead of a run through it's because this would probably be one of the most boring games to actually watch there is zero banter we might as well just each have our own laptop and just be actually running a turing test and to see who does it faster not me because i don't program or anything uh so this was one of the hot games for gen con by a company that has never been talked about ever uh what are they called sapien scorpion scorpio scorpion scorpion mosque uh this is a logic game that's purest form and in really its purest form this is i've explained this to a lot of people of as compared to search for planet x because that's one of the more recent logic games to have come out not really counting deduction logic of like shock homes or anything like that i think that's that for me that's a little bit different of thinking um right than this oh yeah the game's in the story right picking out individual parts right-handed this has you nothing but questions yeah right yeah like search for planet x right but where search for planet x is shrouded in a theme and uh i like i like this game but this is a
game that is i'm going to play with very specific people at very specific times and that's it right uh because would i say this game is fun no but for me it is but it's also i like sudoku where it's kind of in that same vein i used to do those puzzles a lot as a kid and it's kind of in that same vein of just over time you just slowly um reduce your amount of options to where it can only be one thing right uh but overall what do you guys think of turing machine overall uh i think it's really great for what it is i think it's really odd but yeah but but it works well for some people some people are just not going to get it at all and some people are just going to get angry and frustrated and throw things right um but to have a completely abstract game yeah i mean it's theme is the alan turtle abstraction yeah and it's amazing at it you know it's one of those games that the development of it impresses me a whole lot more than the actual gameplay agree yeah right and i would say this is probably one of the first times i've had player eight and i never once looked at my player eight no because it's so weird i feel like this game should be easy to teach i even mentioned it oh i can teach you guys in like five minutes that's true however yeah it's it's weird to convey because my um the first time i taught this i read the rules i was like oh okay well that's that tried to teach it and
my friend kept thinking these were gonna give him the answer right he's like so if it's a check mark is it is it is it he's like is it the left answer always the left answer i'm like no but it's weird that you say that because it's it happens to always be correct like the the check mark is always the left answer in this sequence but that's not the case right um and then he was like oh it's just true false statements yes yes that is it and that i think is the hardest thing to convey both even conceptually like i like these type of puzzles and it took me a couple minutes like oh it's just giving me true false and yeah answers that's it because we had one that was which one is greater and you know small uh the smaller what's the smallest number and i'm like but how do you know which color is because it's right it's like oh because my blue is now the smallest so if it's false then i know blue has to be larger than the next smallest number right i don't know that the next smallest number is the small number as no blue has to be larger than that one yep and that's basically this entire game these give you vague answers some of them i mean to be fair do give you just a straight up answer right um and you can run with that but that's luck it's like this is not a much of a luck based game this is this is one that you use your brain to deduce things yep exactly what you think did you enjoy it have you played search for planet x it's the one where you're trying to find it
yeah it's app based and you're okay i don't remember that you have it it's i can't say not a game for me because i didn't i didn't understand the game 100 the first two games that we played the only two games that we played but i i i still i i wrap my head around as far as like what they're trying to depict um all i i'll sit out of reviewing this because i can't give it an adequate review right um but i think it's an interesting idea i think the cards could be clear but that's for the way that i think sure everybody thinks differently and i've seen so many people in the hobby who their minds are abstract as far as how they interact with things and i can see this working really well for some people whereas some people are like i don't know what the [ __ ] is going on right yeah this is probably one of the most polarizing games that that i've played in quite some time not in so much of oh well someone's going to like this theme or someone's not it's like this by sheer mechanisms are going to turn people away and pull people in because when the guy explained it because i was this wasn't even on my radar at gen con i was waiting in line to pick up their other game critical and this guy behind me was just kind of we were just shooting the [ __ ] and he's like oh have you seen turing machine i'm like no he's like well it's it's very easy to you know to learn but it's very crunchy i'm like oh okay like calico or cascadia you know that's what i was thinking ballpark figure of filler games that are crunchy and he didn't
technically lie to me but he also failed to explain that no this is just a pure logic game and if you just don't think that way yeah because some people might also want to sit down and play this and then just feel awful about themselves right like i almost did when i looked at the answer for the game we just played and i looked at the wrong one and i was like i didn't get a single one right i'm so stupid right well yeah i i saw people talking about it no one actually has a how to play yet which i totally understand but i tell people talking about it and i kind of get the concept but every time there's you know and as i said three or four times when we sat down there's something i'm missing yeah right and as soon as i got it i go okay yeah now i'm getting it now i understand the whole game i don't need a player right completely separated from this i've taught the crypto to oh you've played the crypto okay and this has nothing to do with the crypto but it's the same company oh is it really yeah the same company oh wow i find it it to be one of the most difficult games that i've taught the crypto so simple and it's theory it's you you turn the numbers into the clues but people don't get that and i've tried to explain it five different ways and nobody ever understands when you get it you got it yeah until then kind of lost yeah right and yeah cause i saw the crypto and i almost picked it up but i was like okay it it it's giving me the same vibes as touring machines so i don't really want to just pick up two games that are like this they're completely different games are they more of a party game yeah is it okay
a lot lighter you're saying you don't want to play this at a party with a bunch of your friends sit down and just come up with a sequence of three numbers i mean to be fair though it's super quick at least the two that we played yeah and we and uh we're just like i put those back here six six or seven questions that's all it took right yeah um so i've done four total games three of them that were based off luck and then this one was an even spread but still with four verifiers it after that it pretty much goes up to five and but there's only in the entire rulebook there's only two that have all six um and those are well funny enough number 16 is two difficulty and two luck and the number 20 is three difficulty one luck sure um how do you guys feel about luck being in a pure logic game i mean i guess i guess theoretically it always is going to be there so i would say even sudoku you can just start off by putting the right number and then it's like oh hey man look at that right so at least for me coming from a statistical background because this has a lock a lot of times it mitigates it by saying you could guess like four for the yellow and you could just instantly get right but by guessing three one or two you get more information from that one guess and considering that the game is about how many guesses does it take for me to multiple people if i'll go for it yes um which for me that's the entire thing is how many guesses did it take me versus you um
so if i get more information by doing something i call it less lucky i might do that you went the opposite way you said let's just go straight yeah yeah and um because to me and my way of thinking i and i totally get what you're saying it is 100 more information but for me it's like well the way i'm gonna think if that's a four or not like i'll take that bet i'll take that risk but i love that actually in the game because it's rewarding both ideas it says you want to go wild on just going for the lucky draw here's the reward yeah you get less information if you're wrong you get a lot more information if you're right the more person who's trying to mitigate risk you're going to get a lot more information but you're not going to completely get information and yeah you're right it is very strange because based off the information i got from that which was hey it's not four it's like okay well it has to be these others i still it still came down to where oh i know the answer unless i'm missing something and you came down to a 50-50 right which is just very odd even though and that might have been because you went for five questions and i went for six right who knows which one you know actually gave me the answer but yeah um it does come down to kind of it is a race uh and i'm hoping that the higher level ones it you actually are kind of going down your sheet so like where it is kind of crunchy and then six or seven rounds yeah yeah just
because to me that would be more fun uh i would hate if all of these just kind of came down to six questions and you're like okay on the other hand that has the same flaw as search for planet x which is you get one thing wrong misunderstood written down the wrong way yep you're blown yeah you have it will be luck if you get it right then yeah exactly right and i've had i've had multiple i've had a game of this where that happened and search for planet x where it's like i just either misunderstood the rule or or uh i remember one time we playing search plan x and you wrote something down wrong yeah and i'm like and then you just have to sit there right for the whole time knowing you just have no shot at ever getting it so that's where these kind of games can suck uh right and then the longer ones were it's like yeah we're like round four around five six and people are still doing this and you're like well i obviously don't know it you know i'm just gonna look it up i'm just gonna like figure it out so probably not the game for you if you don't even like that as a possibility that there's no coming back if you just because you're not gonna know if you're right or wrong until way later and you're like well i already asked so many questions right like i'm well behind everyone else there's no chance of me even winning this game yep um yeah i mean that's that's pretty much in comparison um would you guys still put search uh for planet x over this one those are the two only logic games i can
think of i i'm sure there's more that are more like this but those are the two i've played and own at this moment i'll put a search above it i would do and probably just for cleanliness honestly at this moment i would not but i've only played search a couple of times yeah and it is so much longer yes and it is so much more involved and you have to keep all these little facts yeah this can be over in you know six or five six or seven questions yeah we did it the harder ones of course more might be yeah but i i couldn't even see like the ones with all of them start getting a little tired of it still going on yeah and then also you guys you're trying to get points it's whoever has the most points and then um and it is kind of like oh hey i found the planet x first so i pretty much won um for the most part i'm not saying i'm not saying it's it's a definitive win but it's definitely a leg up yeah uh and and yeah i think i think in terms of i get what you're saying is that the clues in search are more helpful yeah like they're definitive yeah very specific uh like hey here's the rules so you're given more to run with and in terms of the way that the game functions i actually think this is a cleaner game yep because it is just pure true false statements it's not okay well asteroids have this rule and gas pockets have this rule and and comments have this rule oh but
they're also worth more points and it's like there's victory points for each of these and then you're putting theories out there and also you have four these actions and it's like i just want to figure out where the [ __ ] planet is and that's that's why i would put this one above it right now just because it doesn't have those layers of complexity complicating the simple deduction of the game right right i mean plan it's more of a playable game this is more of a thought exercise this is this is um this is multi-player multiplayer like if we all basically were sharing trying to figure out a sudoku puzzle then but we're a duo who could solve it the fastest but even right knowing what numbers you guys are guessing each round doesn't tell me anything unless i know what your answers are i never once paid attention to what numbers oh god no yeah not one so again like okay and this may be kind of telling search for plant x makes the assumption that you will analyze what your opponents do there are columns for you to put down what questions they ask that's true this one does not this one's basically saying ignore everyone else that are not helping you who can the game the competitive nature of the game is who can do deduce the answer by understanding how the rules apply and how all the situation yeah works to another car so like for instance my first one i did two threes so i didn't have to do the double you know what is a triple double or no repetition because as soon as i checked how many
threes there were that there weren't two threes in it i knew instantly then it can't be a double number as well like you just know that that's true and i just went weird i was like oh let's just do all threes right and just see okay if that comes out if this comes with a check mark then i obviously know the answer this one and then it just immediately gives you you did all threes you'd also just instantly know that that's what it was well right so literally i did three three and i was looking at like do i do another three or do i just pick another one and i pick one i should have done just because i really almost did three three three i was like you know what what if i mean because again i was like i'm gonna lean into the luck a little i know for a fact right one question what are the chances of it being that uh and even still go in that route i didn't get the answer immediately you know by just getting a check mark here but i still got the answer because of that uh and yeah i remember the first time you guys all went one of these was like completely out whenever i went to pick my numbers it doesn't mean you can't i think it was the yellow threes oh i think it was yeah uh and that doesn't mean you can't pick that it just means you have to wait right um i could but i was like oh whatever i'll just pick something else so this is supposed to be one to four yes one to four i mean statistically it's unlikely that anyone would run out in a round but it is certainly possible i would think that they would add a fourth one just so that it could never happen right that's a good point yeah it is weird
that because it is supposed to be simultaneous play but it's not like there's there's a rule that specifically says oh just wait to get the number from someone like it's like it says oh hey first come first serve figure out a different number so you're right it is weird that they didn't just make an extra an extra set because that's 15 numbers yeah um 15 yeah this is just 15 extra cards yep yeah take away 15 of these cards and make 15 of those cards yeah and that's the other thing again that raises production costs no not if you take 15 of those cards away like 30 of those cards yeah because these uh verification cards have four sets of numbers that are associated with the problem that you pick but i've in my thinking i thought these were like oh man you like when you're doing purple it it rotates it right no it doesn't so the orientation is always the same so i have no idea why there's four different sets except for if someone wants to memorize how a partic if 758 goes with that then i know what the answer is gonna be if you really memorized right your order of cards which dear god if someone wanted to do that play something else man well they're only doing that to win yeah right people and other people yeah they don't care about them do you have friends no if they're doing that they absolutely do not they go to demos of oath sworn and parade the demo players uh
so i think overall i enjoy this uh i don't see hit it hitting the table a lot um but it's a heavy thinking filler right right which is a very weird with a very like with a theme that they were like whatever like sure no one's done the turing test right and i don't even know i mean i don't know much about the turing test but is it this no no okay nothing to do with the touring okay this is just named after the fact that it's an analog computer okay because you're putting the punch cards together to give you an answer yeah well and they even specify because they they the way the rules are explained they mentioned verifiers and stuff like that but then they're like remember verifiers are not players i thought this entire time it was a deduction social deduction game where you had answers that you were given people were specifically asking you a question nope these are the verifiers you're asking them a question and just and that's where you're getting now an ap programming class this is not a bad thing to put into an ap programming class right right as a beginning of understanding you're giving computers logic problems to solve right this is it yeah or i can see a bunch of programmers playing this at lunch at work yeah drunk on power in the world yeah this was this did kind of give me feelings of like an educational game more than like a fun tabletop yeah kind of game it's a real specific
mode of thinking that some people just i bet a lot of people are pissed that they bought this at gen con which means i can get a coffee cheap it was 30 bucks it was like and i'm like okay sure why not sure and and it's fun and luckily it's not just the 20 problems i mean my biggest negative of the game is the fact that too to figure out the problem it's that oh we'll turn the you know whole thing up and they're all right here so whenever i was looking at 12 i to figure out the answer i was actually looking at four yeah so i know the answer to four already hopefully if i play it i forget but i think that these people could have come up with a way of putting some kind of a sliding paper with a hole in it so you could only see the one answer yeah or what would have been nice is if these i get it production costs and all that but it would have been nice if they actually came out with scenario and they were in envelopes right so then you have the solution card in there and just big bold letters on like a card like this or a card like this that says the number yeah so if someone's like alright you could have seen the website with all the i have um i was wondering if they laid it out it is out and they laid out well so you can like see what you need real quick and obviously not see out of their other answers whereas it's right there i did pull it up um it's not an app which i wish it was so yeah it says website under construction so you can do a custom game uh oh i guess that's where you get no cheats daily challenger you click play then it
tells you um okay well here's that code so then there's 16. i don't know if that's supposed to do something um maybe it's supposed to pop up what the solution is uh yeah but it tells you okay grab card 16 18 19 and 20 and then that and then solution are you sure yes and then it tells you oh the code for this one was four four two right um so i mean that's at least i don't know what this is actually input your code to see if you actually got right wrong code is not correct oh yeah that's exactly what it is which is great that's better yes um so far on the website it doesn't tell you it doesn't give you an option on luck versus um but i'm sure that that would come hey i want a purely difficult game i don't want any luck but for an under construction website it's not bad and that's exactly what this game needs if it was only 20 solutions that would just be boring right and so limiting given given literally the i mean i don't know someone like my buddy uh he majored in the math he could probably tell me what how many problems you can actually get it's a lot it's a lot yeah you have it's more than you will ever solve in your lifetime yeah so uh he will he's not gonna play it much well the turning machine probably could solve in his lifetime uh all right so on scale of one to ten what would you guys give turing machine we'll start with you if you just want to do n a cause you know yeah
but actually to that point you know i'm thinking of my ranking too i'm like it's hard to do justice because for the general population i'd say probably four to six right but our our rankings have never been based on what yeah other people are going to put but to the target market yeah seven yep nine nine i'm actually right in the middle i'm at an eight uh i think i i do enjoy it but it is one of those that's like man am i really feeling logic-y right now not really do i want to have fun but but at the same time i give search for planet vaccinate right because but it does it does the logic in a different way yeah it's but it's like so i mean i could see one if we if we did a much more less luck based one i don't mind the luck in it because it i do think it does reward punish the luck aspect of it but like i ain't even think this through in this one puzzle you could have chosen 333 and instantly had the answer true because the only answer that could be with that one and you know that one question is it has to have all three threes so you could just randomly pick that your first question yep stopped and the thumbs up and you were guaranteed to beat everyone um somebody who did the same thing i did three through three and just asked this one and got that that was the first question no no i guess you would get it right because it would been the there's the answer right there three repeating threes if that had been there oh this
one so no actually this one number because it's not how many threes there are this is how many threes there are you're right yeah that one so so i know it was one one one but let's just say it had been three three three you could have picked three three three ask that question it would have been true you would instantly know the answer oh if yes absolutely if that was the and i'm and i'm guessing that's that's the reason why it wasn't that answer because it's a little bit of luck because otherwise then it'd be all luck in that case right so they they must have thought of that beca to where no one clue is ever going to give you the answer it does seem like you need you need a little bit of luck for the game to be for it to be a game almost it's just deductive sure yeah but i'd be kind of pissed in that situation it'd be like okay cool let's play something else right yeah yeah i know i agree and i'm hoping out of all the problems that they do that there's nothing to where it's like oh man i guess i'll just do these and just get it hey i only asked one question um because in that in that scenario that wasn't the answer i'm sure i know but if that what like if you know for a fact that it can never be done by one question they also know that 333 can't be the possible answer that's true that's an interesting thing true yeah that's that's a good point so so the clues or the verification questions are kind of so it either could directly be the answer or it can't be the answer like yeah so either someone could get super lucky which again
we picked one with luck in it everyone knew there's a potential of luck of winning or they're smart enough to make sure denver does and then someone like me who then knows that answer all right knows i can just cross off 333 from it well not necessarily because there still could be one three but that's just saying there has to be three threes so i know that three three three is not the number of threes in the code right so i know that it cannot be all three three right but they still could have three so eight well you're i guess your explanation you said i'd mark out all the threes and it's like sense in that one yeah that one line and really i would mark off and if i had to guess i bet you that's why they have luck to make it fair to me more accessible to people who aren't so logical it's like someone could just jump in and you know still have fun right no and again like i'm happy they do that i actually don't mind the fact like if somebody just magically got with one question it's like well that was cool i mean that was awesome that's a prayer but that would be that would be annoying if that was even a possibility for every single problem or like really okay so i i guess and i think that they probably explained it poorly as difficulty and luck yeah um i i would have just rather had to straight difficulty yep uh because because a higher luck game should just be lower difficulty yeah yeah it's just it's really weird the the rule book is really just bad in general um which smaller companies that's one thing that i've seen fairly common yeah it's just hard to find someone who will do a rule book well
because yeah it's a fair amount because how do you explain this to someone like without sounding condescending right okay brett well so this is what in the book do they have examples of specifications your player aid kind of does and what's still kind of annoying is whenever zach was like okay so what's number 14 mean i was like okay i'll look it up because they have a criteria card explanation but it really just explains the card again right so i was like oh yeah okay yeah let's look at card 14. the verifier verifies that the number of oh but that's exactly what the [ __ ] it just says on the card so thanks for not explaining that yeah i see yeah i see but maybe three or four examples is what it took for me to click right yeah it's like but someone's going to take 10 and someone's going to take two and what's the right number of examples no i got it i got it but i agree with you this is a i'll call a hard game to teach i figured you would just do because i thought we would all just run and be like oh okay yeah we can probably just play one game i know how to explain it now uh nope uh so you learn it at gen con uh no not now that the now that's like the actual convention yeah like they were interested to see how they're practicing it all day you have to be in a really efficient way can you imagine you go sit down the demo and you ask and they're just like you know you're just you're sure you want to do this just go buy the game take it home you'll figure it out you're right half the fun is figuring out how to play you almost have to do a test a test game yes
to kind of ex to help it's like okay so and and and give an answer it's like like the first game designers on games like this just set up a playthrough example of an entire turn of someone oh i took these numbers and these are my questions i pick a this is what i get this is what meant this is how it works first game was you and i got a check mark on three and it's like okay everyone this is what zach and i did we got a check mark therefore we know that yellow's three right if it wasn't then we know it's either you know whatever what are the other numbers one of the other numbers so um i'm still gonna stick with eight i think it's actually a pretty genius design uh i do lump it in with search for planet x um and it's really just how i'm feeling in that given moment which one i'd rather play right so you guys got anything else all right cool well that's our thoughts on turing machine everyone i hope you enjoyed let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you