The Witching Hour - TCbH Review
Transcript
All right, folks. We're going to be kicking off October with a suitably spooky title that being the witching hour Post Curious's next puzzle tale, which is in a distinctly more board game-ish format. Now, if you've been following our channel for a while, you know that we've been covering the publisher's releases since the very beginning with the tale of Ord. And also, you know the drill. These are narrative mysteries with all sorts of cryptic told within and as such we'll be keeping most of the content off skated and as spoiler free as we can. But, if you must avoid all possible spoilers, know that we will have some b-roll that has some unlocked content from the game and some barest hints at the fringes of what's going on so we can actually give context to this review. And if you want to check out, then that's fine. But, before you do, just know it's a really well-made one of these types of games.
It seems particularly designed for approachability, has a touching narrative, and doesn't require any ancillary technology external to the game aside from maybe some note-keeping materials and a straight edge won't go amiss. Got it? Okay. Well, then let's get to the game. Plot-wise, the only thing you need to know going in is it's the '90s and you're a teenager who's on the precipice of her 16th birthday, which is a relief because there's a history of missing kids in your town all under 16. Some even in your family and local folklore says it has to do with witches, which is crazy, right? Because it's like the '90s. What if witches really exist?
Does a mall baby chilly fries?
And that's the setup of our adventure over a likely several sessions unless you're really making a day of it. For in our case, you'll be uncovering the town's history and perhaps getting involved in something a bit more personal by way of puzzle after puzzle after puzzle. As with my favorite of Post Curious's stuff, there's some guided flexibility here. Many moments where you'll have a few puzzles, or even only parts of puzzles in front of you, where Mrs. TCBSH and I can work in parallel, scrutinizing each element and trading off in turn. You're still funneled into an overall progression, but it's clear discovery and agency were priorities in this design. Puzzle-wise, those familiar with Post Curious will know what to expect. A good mix relying on logic, visual, and thematic clues, using about every trick in the book.
Nothing here felt altogether revolutionary, though there's heavy usage of the included, and at times very welcome, transparency sheet and dry erase marker, which allowed for some novel utility. Each puzzle, no matter its shape or size, ultimately resolves in either a clue, which is then in turn an asset for another puzzle that you'll have to solve at some point, or more than likely a number, which then corresponds to a number on the back of a card, which is drawn from the story deck. Which this deck is used to great effect. It's a solution keeper, it's a storyteller, it even acts as a UI to some sort of analog version of 90s point-and-click adventure video games. This deck is the arbiter, revealing more plot, more materials, maybe having you open new envelopes, or presenting more choices until its conclusion. Overall, the game flows well, proving suitably challenging without being totally opaque, with the addition of what I really feel is the most organic iteration of a hint or clue system that this publisher has made to date. Gone are the days where you're clicking on links online. Here you're revealing hints for each puzzle in a tabbed envelope. And I particularly like that the first hints on the progressively revealed clues here are generally just a summary of the
things that you need, essentially just telling you, "Yo, have you unlocked this stuff? Because if not, then go do other stuff until you get the things that you need to be able to solve this puzzle." Which was usually just the right amount of knowledge to keep us on track. That said, there are a few other highs and lows I wanted to point out. The writing in this is strong, more tangible and character-driven than a lot of these games. However, the back half of the game feels very narrative-heavy. Lots and lots of scenes and bits of info that build the world and maybe contributing to a fiendish puzzle, but sometimes it feels like, "Yo, when are we actually going to get to the next thing we can get working on?" Which you do, you just get a lot of story in between.
Fortunately, it is important both for the narrative and the puzzles and is written well. Also, I love the interface that opens up about a third of the way through the game. I don't mind showing some images because it's not inherently a puzzle itself, but it really grounds the game and helps with immersion that you, your player character, is navigating and discovering a physical space. That itself felt like a bold and interesting new step for the publisher, where many paths are gated, literally gated by puzzles that you may or may not have the materials to conquer when you first encounter them. Then there's this guy, which I'm not going to tell you everything that was involved in solving this freaking thing, but this thing.
It's not even that it's opaque. I felt really good about this puzzle when I had everything I needed, it does involve ultimately the transparency, but I was really proud of the fact that I saw through the matrix. I didn't need any hints or anything. There is some complex stuff going on here, but I saw it. I was like, "I know what needs to be done." But the act of actually doing what needs to be done, especially with this transparency and more importantly this fine tipped but not as fine as you really want it for this kind of precision work dry erase marker was just tenuous. Ultimately, it didn't take that long and clearly because I got it, the logic within is sound, but the point is that there are a lot of solutions solved or at least encouraged to be solved vis-a-vis transparency and this a little bit too fat tip marker. Some, most even, worked beautifully, but some required us to turn to our other note-taking materials for more precision. But if that's a low point, it's a valley amongst a mountain range of highs. The Witching Hour is a little bit more board gamey than Post Curios' other titles.
From its packaging to its uniformity to even its UI, it's maybe a little bit less whimsical, but all the more accessible for it. I could easily see this as a jumping-off point for these types of games, but it's no less challenging or satisfying than the best-in-class, just very welcoming, reinforced by a wistful story and cozy autumnal creep. And that's our review. But let me know, what is your favorite puzzle tale or just narrative puzzle mystery, Post Curios or otherwise? Put it in the comments below and as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing all the things that help our channel grow. Likes, comments, subscribes, the checking out our Patreon, and sharing these videos across the inner webs does tremendous amount to support us. But, above all else, thanks for being such a great community.
You know that I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.