Skip to main content
Loading video...

Good Games - Dominant Species: Marine, Dual Gauge, & Startups

Transcript 31:23

welcome to jungus games this is a new good games vlog where i'll be discussing my initial impressions on some new games that i played recently and enjoyed i'll be going through each of them in alphabetical order as you can see and i do want to mention that if you'd prefer to listen to this vlog instead of watch it then you can do so by searching for the john gets games podcast wherever you normally listen to podcasts now i would also like to ask that if you enjoy this video that you please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel in addition to that if you'd like to directly support the channel and the creation of videos just like this one then please go to johngetsgames.com support there you'll find a bunch of ways that you can really help things out and some of them come with great bonuses like voting on a few of the videos that i film each month alright let's now start talking about games and the first of these is dominant species marine now this is a sequel to dominant species which came out about 10 years ago and they have a lot of similar mechanics with some somewhat significant changes between them as well so it's definitely not a new addition it is its own thing now i do want to mention right at the start that unfortunately this is the final game designed by chad jensen because he did pass away before it was fully published and he designed the original game which is a beloved game in fact i loved this game when it first came out i was so excited about it that um i'm pretty sure i supported the p500 campaign for it which is kind of like kickstarter but not really where you can pre-order a game before it's actually produced and once enough people pre-order it it then gets made now the original game played up to six players and it put each person in the role of a subgenre of

animals it could be insects you could also be arachnids you could be mammals and that kind of thing and you played an area majority game with a worker placement system that required players to really think ahead you place down your workers onto this large list of options and you don't do anything when you place those workers down once all of the workers are placed you then start at the top and work your way down to effectively program everything that you want to do and then they happen in a specific order now i mentioned that now because in order to talk about dominant species of marine that is the biggest thing that changed between these two games thematically it's now more uh water-based obviously with the title uh you are in charge of the reptiles or the cephalopods or that kind of thing and you are still doing um area majority type stuff out on the world on the board and you do also have work replacement but now when you place your workers you immediately perform that action again in the original game you placed your workers out and didn't do anything until they were all down but now in marine you do those actions immediately and what this means is marine does not have the same cycle that the other game had in the original game you were placing and then you were performing and then you'd pull everything back and place again whereas in marine you are either placing or you can pull all of your workers back in front of you to reset in order to have those workers to place them out again now there is a great restriction that kind of goes with the flow of the original game to a certain extent where when you place workers out in marine they have to be placed after any previously placed workers that you have put down the reason for

that is because in marine as well as the original game a lot of the more powerful actions were down near the bottom and in this one that means if you don't have any workers out and you immediately place your worker down near the bottom to perform a powerful action you can't actually place on anything above that worker so you really restrict what you can do you could of course start at the top and perform some of those very important and still powerful actions in order to leave you flexible to do everything else but a lot of the really impactful things like scoring areas and moving your various species around on the board all happen in the middle or bottom sections of that action board so when you're playing this game it does have a similar feel but you don't have to worry about planning everything out it was really easy in the original game to mess up all of your pre-programming essentially uh have things not quite work out or have a plan and then have your opponents block your positions so you can no longer execute it whereas in marine your plan is constantly happening as you're actually placing these things down so right off the bat there is a lot less analysis paralysis in marine there's still a whole lot to think about don't get me wrong but you don't also have to think about the future specifically your future worker placements to make sure that previous worker placements get to do anything for you now i'm trying not to go into the details of this game because there's quite a bit going on but to stay high level you have a map in front of you and it's going to grow as the game goes on a certain work replacement spot lets you actually place new tiles out and as you are going through the game you are adding species

which are these cubes and what you want to do is have the most of your cubes on specific tiles at the right time and by the right time i mean when somebody probably you goes on to the work replacement spot to score for that tile you're probably only going to do that if you are in the lead and depending on what type of tile it is you will get to get more victory points and points are obviously good but in addition to that the really great thing about this game uh this one and the original comes into play with the cards that are randomly shoveled up in a deck and placed out on the board now in marine when you do this scoring action as long as you have a cube out there that's not endangered you actually can perform one of these cards which have a really wide variety of effects that means this game can be somewhat swingy and the original one could be as well where you could place a worker down to score a tile get these points then activate a card that does something huge like crash an asteroid down onto the planet that happens every game that's actually the end game trigger or various other things like dump a bunch of cubes on the board or wipe a bunch of other cubes off move a bunch of things around there's just a lot of variety with the effects from those cards and you have got to be paying attention to those if you ignore them then your entire game plan can be totally wiped out and that does bring in a decent amount of analysis paralysis back now i've played this one once it was about a week ago and it was a three player game the marine version of the game the sequel only plays up to four players which is obviously less than the six players of the original

i have played six player games of the original and it was fun but it took like five or six hours uh now when it comes to marine my one three player game of this did take essentially three hours although there's a bit of an asterisk there in the fact that the game and trigger is a little bit variable uh you have this asteroid card that i mentioned before and as soon as that is performed then the game will end after that round and you shuffle that into the bottom five cards of the deck in this play it was the second to last card and based off of how things went and i'm not going to go into the details of it if it had been like the first or second card instead of the second to last or last card this game would likely have been 30 to 40 minutes faster and that's because of the way the overall rounds work which i'm trying not to go into the specifics of so this game uh easily could have actually been closer to two hours instead of three uh but just like a lot of these kind of games the the end of the game got pretty slow because there's so much to think about because when the game is over you actually score every single tile out there for majorities that means that there is a ton of back and forth that you are doing a ton of calculation that you're trying to do to make sure you are in a good spot and also a lot of swings in that case because a single cube being removed from a certain spot could have pretty big impacts now this one is a tough one to talk about in a vlog form because there's so much going on and you know there's a temptation to just focus on the differences between this and the old game which a lot of people obviously haven't played but with that being said there's one other comparison that i want to make

between these two games before i move on now that has to do with speciation which is how you put cubes down onto the map now in the old game you effectively put more cubes down onto the tiles that got you more victory points which meant there could be a really big pile up effect on those tiles whereas in the new game it's actually inverted so what that means is the tiles that give you the most victory points you place the least amount of cubes down onto so that means you essentially are motivated to place a ton of cubes down onto the tiles that don't give you very many points and then you want to migrate away from those tiles onto the other tiles that give you more victory points so it felt a lot more fluid and all of us really liked that change in this three player game all three of us have played the game many times so there was obviously a lot of discussions about the differences between these two games and i will say that all of us ended this game saying we really do prefer this version this marine version of the game um the biggest reason is the change to the worker placement not having to pre-program everything out um that really did help i mean obviously the game was still long we were had a lot of things to think about but it could have gone shorter and we're also just enjoying ourselves really just kind of considering everything there's also a lot going on in this game and we played it in tabletop simulator we are quite competent with tabletop simulator these days but i do still think that can add time especially considering um the details of all of the cards that you're trying to pay attention to there's just a lot of things to keep on your mind now i don't actually remember how the scores worked out i know i didn't win this one and i'll be honest there are some significant mechanics that i have

skipped over but i just don't want to go into all of those specifics i really wanted to come around to the position where i say that um a i'm really glad that i owned this game and uh b i i could see myself playing the original game again in the future but i really do think i would be gravitating towards this one it is worth noting that we played a standard game and you can very easily change the overall length of the game by removing cards from that deck and that's a fully supported variant in the rules you can play a shorter game by removing some cards you can play a longer game by removing less and you can play an epic game by keeping all of the cards in there now as far as i'm concerned i feel like in the future i am going to be more interested in playing the short game where i remove some of the cards in my discussion with my opponents at the end of the game both of them kind of disagreed with me i think they liked how things got near the end of the game but to me i still felt like the game could have been an hour shorter and several or many turns shorter and i still would have really enjoyed it and i still would have felt like i had a good arc going across the game so that's probably something i'll push for a little bit more depending on the uh the amount of time that we have to play but i certainly wouldn't say no to playing a standard game i think it's unlikely that i'm going to play a long game part of that is because you have a defined number of these species cubes you can place out and in general once they die you don't get access to them again and in this game which was a standard version of the game um i ran out in fact i think pretty much all of us ran out um there are some ways to get them back but you have to be maybe not lucky but

you have to be in the right position to actually make use of those ways and you cannot count on them so if the game goes even longer you're gonna have to be even more careful with your cubes as you put them out and perhaps that makes the game more strategic but i do worry that if i played the long version of the game i might just find myself in many of the last turns with not much to do because i overspent my cubes obviously that would be my problem but it also comes back around to me being slightly more interested in playing this one with the short version but i do also want to say that i'm very interested in playing this one more in the future um it is a chaotic game for sure i don't want to sell this as grand strategy there's definitely strategic things that you need to keep in mind but the tactics are very much there and the swings are super powerful um this game feels like you are just slugging each other in the face over and over again um you might get pummeled by a specific move that just wipes out a bunch of your work but hopefully a few rounds later you can pummel back with another massive swingy turn and these usually come in the form of those cards fortunately you can see those coming for the most part sometimes a new card will come out that totally changes everything and somebody can capitalize on that soon but it's a little bit hard to do and again i'm trying not to go into the specifics of it so this is a game that is certainly fun but also you have to go into it expecting it to be crazy uh you have to go into it knowing that you are going to have some massive downfalls with your plans and you have to know that you will probably have opportunities to swing back really hard as well and you hope to be on the top of the pile once all of the swinging has

stopped so yeah i think i should probably wrap this one up uh by saying that um i am looking forward to playing this one more in the future i would totally play it at four players um i think that would be even more fun honestly with the more congestion out there but i would be actively interested in playing that one with the short mode instead of the standard um three players work fine and two is probably fine as well although in general i played three to four player games and i am actually going to be making a tutorial video for this one which should be going out hopefully within a week or two so um if this sounds intriguing then keep your eyes out for that where i'll talk about a whole bunch of other things uh mechanics i didn't talk about here like the various um thermal vents that show up and uh the special work replacement pawns and the domination i didn't talk about any of that stuff but either way i think i should still probably wrap this up it's now time for game number two and that one is dual gauge now if you've been paying attention to my impressions vlogs for the last couple months you will know that i have been falling in love with cube rails style games and dual gauge has been right at the top of my wanting to play list for honestly about two months now but i was finally able to get it played last night now saying that i played dual gauge is actually not good enough because dual gauge itself is more of a gaming system than a specific game this game system came out a few months ago and in the box there are two different maps there is portugal and there is detroit and i played a game of dual gauge with the detroit map the reason it is important for me to specify this is because this system is quite flexible and each of these maps brings in

their own tweaks and mechanics to be a significantly different gaming experience from one map to the next it's not just a new coat of paint it's essentially a different game with a overarching uh similar set of rules now this system was designed by amabel holland and published by holland spiel and they have announced that there are going to be more expansion maps that will be coming out in the future uh potentially for a long time if the game does well now i said that i played the detroit map which was a little bit risky because the rules actually recommend that you play with the portugal map first and then play detroit later uh in this case i actually played a four player game of it you could play up to five players and um everyone i played with had played the game many times and they were more interested in playing detroit than portugal so i said you know what i'll jump into the deep end right out of the gate and see how i go uh spoiler alert i did very poorly like the person who won had double the points that i had or double the money and i was not even close to uh the third place player but i also had a great time so you know that's certainly something to keep in mind now at a very high level the way this system works is actually quite different from most other cube rails style games and the reason for that is because there are no cubes or even anything remotely like cubes in most cube rails games you are putting down cubes or fancy little train tokens to build routes out onto the board and those routes are associated with the color of those tokens in dual gauge that is not the case because instead you are building out track that any company can use so this track is um

universal essentially but there are two different types because the game is called dual gauge you have narrow and you have standard and the types of trains that you can run on these tracks will have to match up with the types of tracks now standard gauge is a lot more expensive but it's also more efficient you can go farther with less trains so you have to balance that with the narrow gauge which is cheaper but also less efficient i'm not going to go into all of the specifics here but as a general arc of the game you start by auctioning off initial shares in these companies and then as you play through the game you're going to do a single stock round where you can buy up to one stock which are disks associated with that company and then each of the companies will run operation and the person who has the most stock into those companies gets to control them they can lay track out in fact you really want to otherwise things go poorly for you you can place new stations out which is good and bad you can also buy trains and then actually run those trains by using them to essentially draw a path through the various tracks that you or maybe other players slash companies have actually built out onto the map to connect these cities together and then you get a payout depending on the size of those cities and the number that you hit you then either pay out that money that you got to the shareholders which means each person who has shares in the company that just ran will get a certain amount based off of the number of shares they have or you can withhold it which means that money stays in the company but the stock price is going to go down now after that the stock price will go up depending on the number of these disks that were removed and i know i'm going

into the nitty gritty here but that is really important because each of these disks could be a stock again if you buy it and put it in front of you or it could be a station that's placed out onto the map these stations are very costly they depending on the map can really hit the stock price for that company but they also unlock various options for them and also can block out other companies and i'm trying not to go into the specifics but again at the end of the operating round those companies will increase their stock price by the amount of these tokens that are removed so putting stations out also increases the rate at which the stock price goes up which is a good thing if you have those shares now i did say that i played the detroit map instead of portugal and on the detroit map there is a mechanic that does not exist on the portugal map at all it's called debt and um you can or are forced into buying these debt tokens and putting them onto a company which is going to be worth negative stock value at the end of the game but put some money directly into that company so that it can build track and spoiler alert if you don't build track the company is forced to withhold and that is going to do bad things to the stock value i've already gone into way too many details here so i'm not even going to talk about the way you actually buy trains but essentially this is yet another experience where you have shared incentives which is um you know a thing that you see in games with stocks essentially there might not be cubes out here but this game took one hour to play and that is a big part of cube rails at least as a general over arc i'm not sure the exact definition of cube rails but in general they're trained games with stocks in various

companies they usually take between 60 and 90 minutes to play uh sometimes even half an hour so i was very pleased to see that a four player game of dual gauge only took 60 minutes so it was a very brisk experience in this specific play it was almost a single gauge game i built some standard track right at the beginning which is very expensive and then for the rest of the game only the narrow track was built out there which was a little bit interesting and i think that is just part of the detroit map the rules specifically say not to play the detroit map the first time you play but again i was the only new person to that setting but i think part of that is because track is really expensive so you have to take these debt tokens to be able to afford the standard gauge and the debt tokens can be very punitive so it's hard to balance the benefits of laying the better track compared to those debt tokens and in this play we just kind of all mostly leaned on the other kind of track the cheaper track to get our way through the game now one really important facet to this system is the fact that each one of the trained companies has a unique aspect to it which is again going to be different from one game to the next on the portugal map one of the companies just starts with um the person who's the president gets a bonus share which means they start with two shares instead of one which is great and on the detroit map there are companies that give big uh payouts if you get to a certain spot the company that i ran which was the blue company could put a free station onto the board if it connected two different spots and that was essentially my goal for the whole game and i pulled it off although i didn't do very well i don't

think i figured out how to leverage that in order to actually win but that's fine but it was very interesting trying to leverage the asymmetries of these various companies as well as their asymmetric starting locations some of these companies are just worse than others and part of this game system is figuring that out and figuring out how to still squeeze some money out of these uh these companies now i did mention that there's going to be more expansions coming out in the future and i am very interested honestly in playing the new expansions uh expansion maps as well as the portugal map uh honestly i'd be totally fine playing the detroit map again i'm curious to see what another play of it would be like but um overall i think this is a really elegant system and i'm super curious to see where things are going to go in the future i know on the portugal map it's super punishing to play stations to the point where people essentially don't whereas on the detroit map that we played there were several stations that were put out although i think i probably put out one too many and that might be part of the reason why i did so poorly um circling back on cube rails in general and why i'm enjoying them so much this game only took 60 minutes so i came dead last but that was fine because i wasn't dead last forever also i couldn't tell how dead last i was gonna be until the very late stages of the game where i was like you know what that blue company that i have three stocks in it's just not gonna get competitive and that was unfortunate but it was a 60 minute game for uh four players so i'm looking forward to playing more 60-minute games of this in the future i do want to teach this one to some of my friends who are just as new to cube rails as i am i think it would be an interesting

experience playing this and i would definitely play the portugal map um with people who um are not super experienced with all of these cube rails games uh i'm currently falling down to the rabbit hole of these types of games and i'm bringing some of my friends along with me to a certain extent but there are lots of people who've been playing these for years and years and years and i think that really can affect your approach to a lot of the gaming experiences for these now i've actually purchased dual gauge already as i said before this is published by holland spiel and they actually do print on demand for their games which is pretty interesting that means when you buy the game they make the game so it's effectively never out of print although sometimes it goes out of stock when they run out of certain components about a week ago i put in an order for this one before i'd even played it so i had high expectations going in because i'd already bought it and maybe part of the reason i enjoyed it is because i've already put money down to play it but i really don't think that's the case i think this is a really cool system and it just it's a wonderful playground for more of these experiences i know that with the new expansion maps i think one of them is supposed to be incredibly restrictive and i think another one is supposed to be the opposite just abundant massive runs all over the place and i love the idea of being able to try out each of these experiences so that you're not just playing dual gauge you're playing dual gauge detroit or dual gauge portugal or dual gauge wisconsin i think that's one of the expansion maps and um and realistically these are all going to be different from the discussion i had at the end of this game with the detroit play um people already um were talking

about you know maps that they like maps that they didn't like um in the same way they talked about games that they like in games that they don't like uh so i'm excited for the system it's very new i'm excited to get a copy of this one and i'm really looking forward to playing this one more especially teaching it to some more of my friends i hope they're not getting too sick of me forcing all of these cube rails titles on them for the most part i don't think that's the case yet anyway at this point it's time for the final game i'll be talking about today and that one is startups now this one was published by oink games and all of their games come in very tiny usually brightly colored boxes with as few components as possible to get usually a pretty big gaming experience now in startups there is a deck of cards and on those cards there are i believe six different companies uh each card has a number in the top right corner and that number matches the number of that card that are in the deck that means there are nine of the value nine cards in the deck and six of the value six cards in that deck now you shuffle that up and then each player starts the game with a bunch of these tokens that have a one on one side and a three on the other and the way the game plays is on your turn you have to draw a card and then play a card when you draw a card you can either take from the top of the deck or you can take from a discarded card that is a face up on the table and this is where those little number tokens in front of you come into play if there are two cards out there on the table and i want to draw from the top of the deck i have to place two of these tokens out one onto each card that is currently face up as a discard now if you take a

card that is on the discard area you get those tokens on them so you have an incentivization mechanic here which i love in games if you take a discard card that is not the last one then you also have to place these tokens down onto each other card that you have skipped over depending on the order in which you place these cards down now the next thing that you do after drawing one card is you play a card you either put it face up in front of you or you discard it adding it to the end of that discard in the middle of the table now when you put it in front of you it will stay there for the rest of the game and this is where the game gets very tricky because you play until the entire deck is gone you always remove five random cards so you can't exactly count everything but once that deck is gone players are going to score for the cards that are in front of them now the way this works is for each of the card types in the game there will be a president and that player is the one who has the most of that card in front of him so let's say i had four of the value six cards in front of me and one of my opponents has two of those cards well i am the president because i have more than anybody else and then what happens is i am going to take a number of those one tokens from them equal to the number of that type of card they have in front of them i have four they have two which means i take from them two of those tokens that have ones on them and then i flip them over to the three side what that means is my opponent just lost two points and i gained six victory points because i am the president in this company that they also had some cards placed in front of them what that also means is if you are the president of a company and you are the only player who put cards down of that

type then you don't steal points from anybody and you don't really get any points at all for doing that you don't lose points so i guess that is good but this game is really all about being the president of a company aka having the most cards for companies that your opponents have also committed cards out to now your opponents are only going to place those cards down if they think they have a shot to try and be a president of those companies so this is kind of a stock game but it's really strange because you are pretty reticent to commit this card being put down now of course in this game you draw a card and then you must play a card from your hand and the thing is you will have a three card hand when you draw that card it'll go up to four and then you have to play one of them out so it's not like you can hoard a bunch of these cards and this means if you want you can just draw and discard draw and discard for the entire game if you want to and never play a card out in front of you but you're probably not going to win so you definitely have to play the odds to a certain degree trying to maybe hide the fact that you have a couple cards of a certain type in your hand to lure your opponents to playing some of those because they think they can vie for it and then be like ha ha no i'm going to play those out and take the presidency now one last mechanic is the fact that if you are currently the president of one of these types which means you have the most of those cards you cannot draw those cards from the discard pile so that is also a strange thing where if i am the current president of the sixes and an opponent discards a six i can't take that six i can only get more sixes by drawing randomly off the top and more often than not when you draw randomly off the top you have to lose points by putting those

one tokens out onto cards that are out there in the discard pile now i played a three player game of this and it plays up to seven and what do i even say about this game um i enjoyed it i had fun overall the decisions were very peculiar um i was able to snipe a big presidency at the end of the game it was with the nines and i had a couple of them hidden in my hand and an opponent didn't realize that and they decided to go for it they played four of those out while i had two face up in front of me and two in my hand and what i did was i just waited hoping to draw the last of those uh nines it's possible that nine could have been discarded at the beginning of the game in which case i could have maybe played my last two out i would have equaled my opponent and no one would have gotten the bonuses which would have i guess been best for the other person who wasn't part of that contest but i was lucky enough to actually draw the last nine and then i played those out so i had five to their four which means i stole four of their points and turned those into 12 victory points of my own uh when the dust settled um i won on the tiebreaker with a score of 22 um i don't necessarily feel like i played the game better but i'm also kind of curious if there's a way to even play this game well maybe there is i've only played it once but my opponents who i played with have played it many times um and they were totally down to play it they enjoyed it but they also vocalized that um to them they're also not super sure how you play this game well there is a lot of swinginess there's obviously randomness about which cards are not going to be in the deck and which cards you randomly draw

from the top of the deck so you are certainly making decisions the decisions are very important but sometimes the result of those decisions can be a little bit opaque but the game took like 25 minutes maybe even 20 minutes to play it was very quick so as far as a gaming experience i enjoyed it i thought it was uh really interesting trying to balance committing to these presidencies which also locked you out from taking those cards i also leaned into the fact that i could discard cards that other presidents really wanted because they couldn't take that to bolster up their position but of course if those just sit out there they're going to collect more and more of these points until somebody takes it but just because you draw it doesn't mean you have to play it so there's all of these competing factors going on in the game and i think i would totally play this one again in the future but i would look at it as a incredibly tactical uh filler type experience i think it's probably likely that you can get better at this game but i also think the best startups player in the world is probably going to lose this game a fair number of the times they play it and that's fine as long as you go into it with that mentality to try and ride the ups and downs as you're trying to do the best you can i did play this three players that's the minimum player count it plays three to seven and i am curious to see what a higher player count game would be like i imagine seven players would be just total insanity uh but i'd try it again it would be a quick game overall um you would have even less agency i suppose but you know if the game is quick enough then i would certainly give it a shot to see what that experience would be like so this is not a glowing recommendation for startups but i did enjoy the experience i thought the

mechanics were fascinating and i would not turn down playing this one again in the future although i don't think at this point i'm gonna go out and get a copy of it for myself well at this point i have no other games i want to talk about that i played recently that i enjoyed um i've just continued to plow through a whole bunch of these cube rails games and i still have like eight that i want to try so i'm certainly going to be talking about more of them in future good games vlogs but there's other stuff that i also want to try that's coming in um i was able to get a copy of polynesia that does not currently have a tabletop simulator mod but i might make a private one so that i could play that one with my friends i did buy that copy because it looked neat hopefully i'll like it and hopefully i'll talk about it soon we'll just have to see but either way i think that is going to bring this one to a close as always i'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including these producer-level patreon supporters if you too would like to directly support the channel in the creation of future videos just like this one then please go to junketsgames.comsupport also if you enjoyed this video then please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved