Earth Abundance Review - Beyond the Base Game
Transcript
so is this expansion essential decent or not worth your time and money hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and this is the broken Meo and I am only this is beyond the base game where I talk about expansions to games because a lot of people don't usually want to although in this case a lot of people are talking about it because this is Earth abundance this is the expansion that is on Kickstarter for I think two or three more days because sadly the publisher forgot to post the game out to me after I came back from my 40th so I've literally only had this for a few days and everybody is talking about it because Earth is one of the hottest games of the previous year it's one of my favorite games of all time remember it turned up in my top 10 of my top 100 like I really really love this game so naturally everybody is very excited for an expansion to the game me included but of course as with all of these games I've been given a prototype copy of the game all reviews are honest I'm not sorry in advance everybody got that so is this expansion essential decent or not worth your time and money well you know we're going to get into that there's not a huge amount in this expansion from a Content perspective in fact most of it have already kind of merged in with my set you can see that I have got a folded space insert which you know slight plug it's a very good insert you really want to consider grabbing this with the UV printing it is gorgeous but it gives you a few more pieces to mingle with all the rest so I've got a few more of the green cubes I've got some more of those tree pieces and Etc and and the folded space insert actually
holds all of this expansion bar one element or two it does struggle a little bit maybe with the extra board but not too much you won't get much lift with that and you already have a spare little cubby hole for the pink leaves for the sixth player so that's not a problem the only thing that is a bit of an annoyance is that it will not fit the new Score Pad so uh where did I put that score pad I put it somewhere oh it's in the Box well basically in the normal version you have a Score Pad that is yay big and it fits exactly in the cubby hole it's meant to be because it's designed for five players the new Score Pad is designed for six players which means it doesn't fit in that cubby hole yep sorry that's just going to have to be something you're going to have to squeeze in there although we'll get on to why that's not such a big issue a little bit later other components include a fold board for the sixth player I don't know if this will be a full board in the full version but you know you've essentially got one complete one here and then some overlays for the other boards the overlays allow you to incorporate the new germination uh iconography but also increase the number of icons on the bottom of the thing in the reference chart so that people can follow and understand what every icon in the game does these fit pretty seamlessly on top of your board they're pretty easy to use and they won't slide around all over the place so y they do the job so what are these new rules that you've got well firstly you have interactive player abilities so essentially not like oh they I punch you in the face and I take your stuff no none of that one thankfully this one basically introduces three variants of simultaneous abilities where where other players get something as well as you so
some of these cards will have abilities on them don't worry there'll be photos to show you the exact icon but for example here I have one that says I get four soil and then other players including myself can decide to get two Sprout cubes as well so everybody gets a little bit of something but I also get the soil now there's three variants of these you have any players only other players and then just your neighbors so you or choose a neighbor so neighbors will just be the person to your left and right like a kind of Seven Wonders style thing other players will be everybody else except you and all players can include yourself as well and of course all these abilities are optional this is to try and introduce an element of the game where even if somebody else is doing something on their Tableau it may interest you to know what they're doing they might have something that scores based on what neighbors are doing in which case you might not want to build certain things in your Tableau because you know it's increasing their points or you know that every time the red action is chosen somebody to your left is potentially going to give you more Sprout cubes you might factor that into your game now it's not exactly making the game Super interactive as a result I mean the game wasn't that interactive to begin with it was essentially simultaneous turns but you did whatever you did on your Tableau and didn't really care too much what other players were doing yes there are some abilities here that key off oh the opponent's getting points if I do this but given that you're getting points for doing it as well are you going to be that fuss that the card you play gives the person your left two points not really I wouldn't really care it's like yeah I'm playing this terrain it's going to give you two points it's also going to give
me four points for the card it's also going to give me another 10 points for whatever it's doing I don't really care if it gives you a little bit of something so honestly these interactive abilities have not really like changed things up for the moment from a sorry for the for the the best part of a gameplay perspective but there's also one other aspect that gets in the way and it is not at the moment in the rule set the rule set does not stipulate exactly what the timing is for when these abilities trigger the assumption is that they go off at the time the ability happens so I go through my Tablo and I go right four soil two cubes right get Sprout Cube do this compost and then I get to this one it says right all players can now get two cubes the problem is everybody is going through their Tableau at the same time at different rates some people might only have two abilities to trigger some people might have 10 a new player might be struggling to go through all their abilities and see what's what I might be able to zoom through all my abilities all six seven of them in about 2 seconds flat when you have to announce these different interactive abilities the game start grinding quite a bit and I am not surprised that a lot of other reviewers are not mentioning this point because this has happened in every game you bear in mind that everybody's going at their own pace so they're doing their own simultaneous things if you constantly have to keep interrupting the game Flow to say everybody gets this not only does everybody have to hear you announce this but also mult multiple people are shouting this so the whole thing becomes like a cacophony of chaos not to mention that the timing of when these happen
could influence somebody's ability to do something else like for example I might be triggering an ability that says right I could kill a couple of trees and get a bunch of soil well haven't got any trees on my Tableau so it's not really going to help me right now right I'll carry on do my abilities and then as I get to the end somebody to my left announces oh by the way you now get uh two tree pieces because of this ability I'm triggering it's like oh right well now I've got to go rewind back to here to know that I had two trees and then spend the two trees on that there may be some clarification by the time this gets released but at the moment as the rules are written at which point they do not stipulate what the timing of this is it is a very clunky mechanic to have to deal with especially in high player accounts we'll get to that later but you know that is a bit of an annoyance I don't mind the neighbor one so much but having every other player have to do something does just make things a little bit chaotic and a little bit frustrating at times you know the the smoothness that this game had before is lost by introducing these elements surely you can't be serious I am serious and don't call me surely the germination seeds though are definitely I think the best aspect of this game and they're pretty straightforward they essentially are represented by a little token that you get one or two of at the start of the game and you can cash these in for a few effects so you can cash them in for cubes and compost in soil and trees and you can even scrap cubes to get these tokens as well as even scrap one of your leaves that you use to claim objectives you can scrap one out of the game for a seed that's quite a tall order I got to
admit but it's there if you want it but the main thing that lets you do and honestly this is pretty much 90% of the reason you will take these seeds is because it allows you to search for cards that you need for objectives you announce an objective from a whole list of them you know the ones you see on all the ecosystems and forigners and that and you simply flip the deck over have a look through find the first one that counts and let's see here we go I got a mushroom here Aspen Boletus whatever so this is the mushroom I was searching for it could have been the water habitat symbol I was looking for it could have even been that the card cost four or more victory points you know you know that is or three or less soil I could have named any objective that related to this card and this would be the one that I would grab this is something that I think the game actually does benefit from quite a lot because a lot of people complain about the card luck in this game and yes there is some card luck but it's a short game when you're not playing with five players and you know you will not notice it as much because you draw through so many cards that you're going to find something that's useful yeah you won't find maybe the one card in the deck that lets you compost 20 cards at your hand when you've got a full hand of cards but you're still going to find stuff that's worth playing so it's not a big deal but here having the ability to you know go through the deck and find specific stuff to get you onto those Foreigner objectives is a big deal and pretty much the main reason you would use the seeds because honestly the rest of the reason you would use the seeds is only if you've managed to get some of the cards in here that generate more seeds but there's not many of them I mean I'm looking for this big par here and there really is not many cards here that get you seeds there's a few but that's about it so bear in mind when you
mix this into all of these other cards you may be hardpressed to find some of these that generate more seeds and if you get them they're going to be pretty powerful cards to play just because of their Rarity but let's say that you get them by other means okay giving up a leaf for an objective is quite a big deal giving up four victory points effectively in cubes for a seed is quite a tall order as well and the fact that you can give them up you can cash in a seed for free cubes well I just spent four to get one so why would I do that um you know these are very situational bonuses that you can get from them but I would say that pretty much the seeds are there for the searching for the cards and in that respect love them to bit so it's definitely probably the best part of the expansion okay that's a start that's very Earth friendly in terms of added variety you don't get a huge amount extra here I mean you do get like a bunch more cards which more cards is great although most of these are using the abilities that I've just talked about so if you don't like those abilities you're not going to have many left over at that point but I was kind of hoping a few more of these These are the ecosystems the climates the islands and the Foreigner objectives yes they're double-sided but I mean we're talking six ecosystems four climates four islands and six forer objectives so basically just that I I feel like we could have got a few more of these I mean the the world is your oyster when it comes to like the amount of forner objectives you can can have and the island and climates are the best thing in the in like you know in terms of like differentiating your starting position I love the way these islands and climates
combined together and just having another four of each and bearing in mind this is on two cards cuz they're double-sided so it's not like you can use them all the time you've got to take the same card and then use the opposite side just would have liked a few more of these if you're going to do an expansion I mean but you know if they do more of these as card packs like promo packs in the future I'd certainly grab them but yeah just would have liked a few more but you still get a decent amount of the cards I mean these are you know a good chunk of them you know a mixture of events and terrain cards and Foreigner cards so these will certainly bolster up your decks which are already substantial to say the least and if you're concerned that it's not going to fit don't worry about that I mean if you don't sleep this game it will fit in the inser absolutely no problem but I sleeve my game and I've still got as you can see plenty of space in these cyh holds for various cards I guarantee you these will fit when sleeped I mean certainly it's going to fill them up to the point where another expansion is going to be touch and go in fact I don't think it will fit any more cards in terms of another expansion so be wary of that if you've got the insert but you know if you don't seve your cards then yeah you've got space for days it ain't going to be a problem uh the sixth player oh boy six player if you like it it's there if you want to play Pink it's there but this wasn't a game that I liked playing with five players five is Right Out do you honestly think I am looking to play this with six I mean just because it's simultaneous turns does not mean that the turns finish at the same rate for everybody five players is clunky and
long as it is six players literally just made it worse it didn't get any better trust me it got more problematic and this compounds the problem I mentioned earlier with the whole sort of neighbors and crying out simultaneous abilities and stuff like that because if you've got people crying these out you know left right and Center then well it's just a complete mess so if you want to play it with six it's there fine they've added it in I'm not going to like you know downgrade it for that sort of thing but I never really care when they add players to games 99% of the time and here it's another case I don't think we needed the sick I think they just did it so that you could have a 2v2 V2 team thing or 3v3 but other than that I just ah whatever it's there if you want it we're just too different I was kind of hoping that the abundance expansion was going to be one of those must grabs like you got to get this expansion you've got to do it it's going to make your game so much better we're talking like Arc NOA Marine world's level of must get sadly abundance doesn't really measure up to that now it's not a bad expansion but I do find it a bit underwhelming because the main aspect of this that I sort of go oh yeah this is really cool is having a bunch more cards the problem is some of those cards are tied to an ability I don't like and having a little bit of extra variety with these you know starting cards always nice and the germination seeds I think the seeds are a good addition that's certainly a bit that I think they should have maybe focused on with this expansion not bothered with the whole interactive powers or maybe just kept it to neighbors rather than every player in the game but certainly
these little seed things I think are definitely the Highlight Point couldn't care less about having a sixth player never want to play this with five Alone six that just seems insane you know I mean I've tried it once I have tried it with the six players and never again is what I say basically um but the other things that you get those interactive Powers I just they need to tighten those rules up that's the problem and I know this is a work in progress prototype they still got time to do it you still have time to fix this but it's kind of disappointing that other reviewers have not mentioned this I've watched a bunch of other reviews and nobody mentions the problem with the timing of these interactive abilities and I'm sorry there is no way you got to the end of a game and didn't encounter this problem because it's is a problem that is encountered in every single game I played of this you know the how the fact that these like different interactive abilities keep keying off at different times and can affect what other people may have done on their turns you need to have a concrete rule for when these apply not just simply when one player gets to that point in their Tableau because it's just going to mess things up and make it really grindy and really messy so come on you've got a really nice smooth engine builder here one of my favorite games of all time don't make it clunky that's the last thing I want to see from an expansion so the expans is okay but I don't think it's a must grab and if I was to play Earth without the expansion I wouldn't really be missing that much you know yeah the seeds are a cool addition but if that's the only thing I'm going to get from this expansion then I can kind of live
without it it's just one of those things but it'll be interesting to see if this uh you know gets little touch few touchups between now and full retail release this is after all a preview prototype as always but I still give my ratings ahead of time because I still want to know if I'm willing to put my money where my mouth is this one I would probably give a six out of 10 overall above average it's got one element that I particularly like it's got a few extra pieces you did get some more cubes and more tree toppers to you know in case you were running short on some of those I think this expansion could have been better I was really hoping that this would be like a must grab must have and it hasn't reached that point at all yet but I'm hoping that between now and Retail release they will tie up the rules with those interactive powers and if they can do that and make it a really good satisfactory way that still makes the game smooth and elegant then we'll have an expansion that I can happily give a seal of endorsement to for now I would just be maybe a little bit wary so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meele if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on boor gang G when it goes live on the page don't forget to check out the review I actually did for Earth if you want to know why I love it so much but also my top 10 of my top 100 you can check it out where I talk about it on that one I won't tell you what position it came in that top 10 but spoiler alert it did and of course let me know your comments below do any of these expansion elements sound great to you have you actually played this prototype expansion in which case what do you think of the comments I make about those interactive Powers I'd be interested to know or do you think that this expansion is one that you're going to skip and wait till retail release I'd be interested to know your thoughts so take care and remember regardless of
whether you've got any seeds to plant this summer it's still only a game so take care and bye for now