TDG: Memoir '44 Refresh
Transcript
Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, I just got back from an appointment with my life coach. I didn't make the team. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Memoir 44, Refresh from Days of Wonder. Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
Now, Memoir 44 has been around for over 20 years. It is a classic light war game based on the Commands and Colors system. I have reviewed many Commands and Colors games on this channel. I've never actually reviewed Memoir 44. I'm not going to give a complete rules breakdown. I'm going to tell you the basics, but really I want what I want to discuss here is kind of what sets this apart from its predecessor game. Now, in Memoir 44, you are reenacting some of the battles in Northwest Europe during that campaign in World War II. One of you will take on the role of the United States Army, and the other will take on the role of the dreaded Vermacht as you battle for supremacy in Northwest Europe. Now, as I say, this is a commands and colors games. What that means is you have three sections of the board in front of you. You have your center, your left flank, and your right flank. And you have a series of command cards that you're going to put in front of you. The number of the command cards is dictated by your uh specific scenario that you will set up using hex's as terrain uh and various other features as well as any kind of special unit designations.
Now, you've got these cards in front of you and then on your turn, you play a card. Now, this card may activate a certain number of units in a certain section of the battlefield or it may let you do other fun and interesting things on your turn. So, you play that card and then you fulfill it. When you fulfill it, you can activate units more often than not. And how that works is essentially you designate which units you're going to move uh and attack with. You move them and you attack. Now, different units will move differently. They'll attack a little bit differently, but your basic units here are infantry, which usually can move once and attack, or they can move twice and not attack. There may be some restrictions on movement based on terrain. Now, you also uh have artillery pieces. You also have uh tanks. They can move and fire differently. But when you shoot, essentially what you're doing is you're calculating the number of spaces away you are and rolling die accordingly. So, if you are adjacent, if it's a close attack um with infantry, you can roll three die, assuming there's no terrain. Uh you can roll three die to try to hit your enemy. If they're two away, you would roll two. If they're three away, you would roll one. Now, as I say, some terrain may mitigate the unit that you're attacking, that you're targeting. It may give them some cover, and the attacker would roll less dice.
But generally, all things being considered, you're trying to roll either a grenade, which is always a hit, or you're trying to roll the dice face of whatever specific unit you're attacking. So, if you're trying to hit infantry, you want to roll infantry symbols. If you're trying to roll tanks, you want to roll the tank symbol. If you want to hit uh artillery, well, then you need the grenade. Um, but that's basically what you're trying to do. All things being equal, kind of the the command star doesn't do anything. Now once you've played that card, you can go ahead and discard it and then draw another card that you can use in a subsequent turn. Now essentially players are going back and forth and doing this. And if ever you can succeed in eliminating every single figure in one of those units, you can take uh one of those figures and place it kind of as a medal. And then depending on how many medals you get for a specific scenario, the first one to reach that will win the game. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out.
Please subscribe to that channel. And now back to the review. Now, that is just kind of a basic overview of gameplay. There's a lot more nuance. There's a lot of different things. There's different cards that can come into play. You can have paratroopers uh come into play that you actually drop from the top of the board and and see where they fall. Uh there's a lot of really fun and interesting uh ideas and concepts here uh in this game beyond just the basics. But I do want to say again that primarily what I want to discuss is how this game is different from pre the previous edition of Memoir 44. Uh first of all the plastic itself these are this is these are harder plastic models. These figures are harder plastic which I know some people think well maybe they're a little more brittle. I haven't had an issue with that even with dropping paratroopers.
And frankly, I like them better. I like them better than the softer plastic. And it seems like we even get the softer plastic in Battle of Hoth, which also just came out here. I do like this harder plastic that comes with refresh. Memoir 44 refresh. Um, also too, there are some other um rules regarding elevation. So, you now have kind of elevation and if you are, you know, adjacent and above somebody, you can actually shoot over your own troops, which is something you couldn't do before. So before they would block line of sight. Now if you have elevation they don't. So that's also something that's that's really uh different and interesting here. Now the original game had I believe 16 16 scenarios and a um the overlord scenario in which you bring two boards together. Um, this one has, I believe, uh, 21 scenarios and then the additional, uh, one for the overlord with two boards. Uh, just as a note, I actually have two copies of the original game here because they are, um, uh, you need two for the overlord. So, I'm actually kind of putting them together in a tote. Uh, I'm just going to use this refresh probably as my main one just to play it on two-player, but I do sometimes for my for my classes. I will bring Memoir 44 to play the Overlord uh scenario. So, I'll probably hang on to those for that purpose. But a few other things here. Uh, the dice are really nice. Now, they are plastic. Now, my the original Memoir 44 I got had wooden dice, which I loved. When I bought the
second set, the dice were actually plastic and they were kind of cheap. I wasn't too wild about that. These are plastic in the refresh, but they're they're they're better. They're just they look better. They roll better. I I really like the dice here. I would prefer wood, all things being equal, but as far as the plastic dice go, I think they're far superior to the the later um publishings of the initial game that we saw. So, I really like that as well here. Now also too uh the kind of the sandbags and the um barbed wire before each faction had had them in their own color. Here they are a neutral gray so both sides can use them. You don't have to use specific ones from from your own side. Now, also too, one thing I liked is you had the in the original edition, you had the card holder and it was just kind of a straight card holder and it would flip and turn. And when they came out with Battle of Hoth not too long ago, they actually made a really cool um improvement and that is it's a curved card holder so that your cards it's harder to tip it over. And they've brought the curved card holder to Memoir 44, which I is awesome. I really really like what they've done with that.
Probably my favorite innovation of this game and the thing I really like that they they've done with this, which frankly I wish they'd had a Battle of Hoth and I wish they would have in other Commands and Colors games, and that is you have uh tokens now, hard plastic, really fun and and and weighted tokens that can mark your activations. So, whenever you activate units, you move them, you can put the movement token down, uh you can go ahead fire, you can flip to show that they have fired. So, you can keep track of everything. you don't lose track of what it is you've activated, what you have fired, and you know exactly when your turn is over because every everything will be there. All the tokens will be there and you'll see it. So, that's basically all the new stuff you're getting with this Memoir 44 refresh. It is a bigger box. It's a thicker box. Uh again, Ray did some comparisons on that with our unboxing video um that we put up. So, the game itself is very, very fun. I love Memoir 44. Um, I've been posting a lot of content on Battle of Hoth lately because I've been really having a lot of fun with that. And after playing several games of this new edition of Memoir 44, I am forced to conclude. I do think Memoir 44 for me is more fun. It's more fun partially because I am a World War II historian. So, it's kind of fun to reenact and re refight these these actual historical battles. But, I do love Battle of Hoth. I think Battle Hoth is an amazing game. I just played the Epic game again a couple of nights ago with my stepdaughter and she loves it.
It's great fun and I'm eager for her to play Memoir 44 at some point because I know she'll enjoy this one quite a bit too. It's just a tremendously fun game and I really think this is a fantastic new edition. So, the question is if you have the older edition, do you need the newer edition? Now, I would say probably not. No, you don't need it, but you want it because it has a lot of cool quality of life improvements. Uh, like I say, I love the activation tokens. I love the curved uh card holder. I think the dice are good. Uh, and I really like the hard plastic. Um, all in all, I really think this this this new edition has brings some real fun and interesting things to the table. Uh, if you're like me, I think you'll really get a kick out of it. And I got to tell you, I'm going to give uh I let me just back up and say about the Overlord. Okay, I love Overlord. That's my favorite way to play it. And again, I'll probably just use my older um copies of the game to play the Overlord expansion. Now, having said that, I got to tell you, this game on its own merits, just the refresh, single copy, man, it's fun. It is tremendous fun. On the Cody scale, I'm going to give it a nine out of 10. I I've just been having so much fun playing this one again, and I and I can't wait to play more, and I haven't even gotten into some of these newer scenarios yet, so I'm really looking forward to playing some of those as well. Thank you ladies and gentlemen for joining us once again today here on the discriminating gamer.
As always, we would ask you to please leave a comment here on YouTube, on Board Gamegegeek, on our Facebook page or on X. We'd love to hear back from you. We would ask you to please like this video and subscribe to our channel. That really helps us out. We would also ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where I talk about military history and books on history, fun things like that. I even post some of my lectures on there. I would humbly ask you to click on uh that uh channel and subscribe to it as well. And also too, if you really do like the kind of content we bring to you here on the discriminating gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. You know, my kids refuse to eat leftovers, so my wife told me to throw them out. So, I did. Now, I don't know what to do with the leftovers.
again. And I don't know where I'm going. And I don't know where I've been. Please somebody up in the fight. I'm gonna kill me a squad. We're gonna kill me a squad. Ah, he really wants to kill a squad.