Skip to main content
Loading video...

Jessica's Meadow: Adventure Book Solo Review

Transcript 34:24

hey everyone I'm Jessica here with another solo discussion about something that I just went out to the store and picked up the other day I was so excited about this saw that my friendly local gamestore had it in stock and what did I pick up that is correct that would be Meadow the adventure book so this is an expansion to Meadow um and I wasn't sure what this was I think there was some information about it but it it wasn't very clear to me but I was so excited to get this immediately unpacked it um there's a couple of boxes that you have to construct I made those I punched out everything got it all ready to go and just Dove right into it so I wanted to share some of my thoughts because I think this is a little bit of a different expansion if you will it's not one that's just you know if you love Meadow get this I think there's a couple of caveats and I think there is an audience for it and spoiler alert I do not think I am one of them I didn't quite enjoy this but I want to kind of just go through what these scenarios entail what's included with the expansion and kind of just talk through what it is because I did have some fun moments with it and there are some neat ideas but ultimately I'm going back to Meadow plus the downstream expansion so let's dive into this and what is this so the adventure book comes with six scenarios and after you kind of complete

punching everything and creating it um you're going to have a box that looks like this so each of these scenarios has its own box we're going to go through those and kind of just you know briefly show you what those are but the main core of this is as you would expect the adventure book so it's going to look like this this is a nice spiral bound really nice kind of you know thick cardboard um and these are is it is the replacement for each scenario so instead of using your standard campfire board that's just gone and this saves some table space so you're going to be playing through here um and just to kind of give you a quick overview of sort of what that looks like you're going to be opening it up it'll be a kind of a two-page spread if you will and this sits on the table again replacing that campfire board but it is basically the same amount of space and so each of these is going to have something that you play through it's very different it has unique goals unique rules and each of these again I'm going to briefly kind of go through what these are but just to give you an idea of how you would kind of you know flip through and play through this there are no spoilers here this is not a campaign that you play through there's no Legacy there's no secret envelopes there's nothing that you unlock it is just all here there is sort of a an idea of a campaign Where You Are kind of playing from the first through the sixth scenario collecting Stars along the way and kind of gauging your success either

in the solo mode or multiplayer um but for the most part these are not they're not connected they're they're very just different sorts of puzzles and I want to say that word puzzles because that is what I feel like these are for for me at least it's not like a new gameplay experience it is a set of new rules for you to focus on and to sort of optimize your play style to do well within that set of rules if you will uh so there's sort of a puzzle there's sort of a solvable solution um in a way again I may be totally way off way out there this is just how I experienced it and just to sort of set it up how I play Meadow is as a very kind of calm quiet relaxing sort of solo game I just go out there I like looking at the card art and just kind of thinking through through appreciating those nice beautiful pieces of art out in nature um and they don't have to be anything amazing you know like I I might see a little bird on a window sill um I might see some beehives and some bees and they don't have to be these spectacular amazing things but I like just thinking through of sort of almost having a gain be a nice refreshing breath almost just just taking it easy and enjoying it and knowing that it is not that challenging of an experience it's not necessarily difficult but it is just

really fun and enjoyable to go through this and see nature so setting the stage there for how I enjoy Meadow and what it means to me and how I get joy out of it going over to the adventure book and what these are so to go through them very briefly just to give you an idea of what to expect we'll go back to this uh the first one that you'll see this one is called beginning and this has to do with weather cards actually so you're actually going to be going up these tracks as you pick up different cards in the area there's going to be a random um die roll determined at the start of the round that sort of sets the column in a row associated with either sunny or rainy weather if you pick up those cards you'll move up and at the bottom you're always going to have two of each card out there just to take a brief look at what those look like they each will give you a different bonus but you're going to have you know rainy cards are going to be really pretty you rainy Skies but there's a lot sort of going on there that you'll see um and then flipping ahead I'll show you a couple of these Sunny cards are going to be really pretty sunny weather and you pick these up sort of as you do with other cards they'll go into your hand and you'll have to play them some of them have requirements um but they sort of get tucked behind in your surroundings area and almost sort of give like a little theme to how that part of your hike went

it was really nice um and as I played through this one I said that was all right I don't know if I'm going to really going to you know like this but it was great this was actually my favorite scenario there was not too much to extra to track it actually added to the experience and sort of gave me sort of that feeling of what was it like on this walk you know did I was it a nice sunny day or was there a lot of rain and I saw like a a lightning storm when I was walking over this bridge so it really added to it the unfortunate thing that I'll say about these scenarios is that they are not modular so I have you know there's there's a lot more cards than this this is just for some of the some of them but these are not actually things that I can just put into the base game I can't just say oh I want to use weather as a module I actually have to play it in here um with that track there might be a way to incorporate weather at least I think that might have some opportunity but for the most part you're playing through specific scenarios and you'll only see these components when you play that scenario just as a heads up um so that is that's really the first one um and I don't think I didn't grab the box but you would have a box like this you can hear everything inside I remember what's in here um but yeah but you'll you'll have there's a die in there um there are trackers for on different you know the sunny and the Rainy side and then there's a couple of bonus tokens that you might earn to be able to sort of affect some of your

cards out there so that one actually turned out to be my favorite and I think that is the least complex of the ones in here I think that's a great introduction if you play that one you're going to enjoy it if you're going to enjoy these scenarios um unfortunately it went downhill for me from there but we will get into that and why in a second here that one I love though so moving on you the next one let's flip ahead find the right page what that looks like this is called Bridges and what this one does is you're going to have this area here you're going to have different pairings and you'll notice that you know you'll fill this in with what did I do with them they're somewhere around here here we go if I had this over here you know you fill in the the different icons and place them out there to create those pairs that you earn points for and you'll see that there's a bridge right here and this has to do with left and right if I can point and without looking at myself um but what that does is let me grab the box for that this one you're actually going to split your play area into a sort of a left and a right side and build both of those out and you're going to have let's grab one of these you're going to have a board like this in the middle that kind of again splits it to the left and the right and you're going to have different little ones of these tiles that sort of you know stack on here you'll have one for each of those sections and it gives you sort of goals to complete on either side so again you're looking at left and

right once you complete one of these you'll flip it over and you'll get points for game end for completing some of those there's a couple other things going on here but then the scoring piece of this is that at game end you are actually going to score separately so you'll count your points on your left side count your points on the right side and you're only going to score the lower of those two amounts so there's an incentive to make sure that you are building up at about the same rate which does require you to sort of think about where you're placing cards how you're building it up there's a lot more to think about I think and that's what a lot of these scenarios introduce is that idea of I need to plan ahead some more I need to think in a different way which may work for you it may not depending on again what you are playing metal for if you feel like you are kind of you know you've seen everything in it you are eh I I really want to challenge I really want to try to you know work on something different these scenarios would be excellent I think um but for me I don't I I was not looking for something that was going to add a lot of stuff to track that's just me and that's mostly what you're going to see again in the bridges scenario there's a couple other cards that you'll see in there that you can gain as bonuses um but that is the big part there is really splitting your play area after Bridges what do we get oh this all right so this is this is cool in some

ways and in some ways I was like oh no this one is called windmills and it kind of is getting into that whole you know seeing tulips out there and seeing these windmill areas there's a couple of cards that you can gain let me grab the box that has the components in here to sort of show you how this works so in this one let's grab one of these there's one of these for each player colar um and what it is is surprise here we go let's see if we can do this and show off a cool thing it's magnetic so these will actually sort of lock in place because there's a magnet so I can put it on any of these and it sort of locks in place it might be a little hard to see but what you're tracking is that inner circle where is it over here that number in there is going to be tracking how often you do something and you'll say okay that great that doesn't look like a windmill right now and it doesn't the magnetic part excellent really implemented well I'm not sure if I like magnetic components at this time I feel like there's they're starting to show up in more board games I'm still undecided about this because sometimes they get like a jumbled mess of stuff just stuck together we will see but my issue with this one really is so there's going to be there are four if I don't drop it these are not magnetic there are four fins that are supposed to kind of

slot in here you know if I can I don't want to put it in because my copy is so tight I put these in and the idea is that you'll see these have kind of these you know bonuses on there you'll get to trigger one of these once per game as you do some things and you the idea is you would then take it out flip it over and put it back in but the the fit is so tight that the cardboard actually started to separate in mine so I was like I'm going to miss out on having actual windmills but I just kind of moved it like this just so I didn't damage it just be careful if you have yours that yours is not as tight production can sometimes differ so there might this might be fine in most copies mine a little too tight so I just kind of keep them off to the side and then once I use it just flip it over it functions the same it just doesn't look as cool but the other piece of this one that you are going to have in front of you you are going to have a set of these tiles you'll have a start one an end one and then three in the middle the middle ones you simply just go up in numerical order and you'll have sort of this this long line of tiles and icons that you're trying to see and as you build out you will see that you kind of have these icons that you want to see along the way and each time that you add one above this that matches you will move your little person forward there are new little ones included like these um and

they would just sort of like move forward one and that's where you track it on that windmill track the more times that you go up the more points you'll get a game end but you can never go back so if I have let's see so if there was a bird if I placed a bird I could move there and then if I placed a house above it I would move here but I could never go back to this space so you kind of have to think about the order of this a lot and for me it was a lot to think about um planning out those orders and then also you can only fit two cards above each of these tiles you'll see the the size of that um do I have one I do so like you know you're going to fit two you'll fit one above here and then one on this side and and it then you're very I don't know I I felt very focused on like how I had to build this out and how I had to plan it because these have to be placed in order as well from left to right so it's not like I you know I can put a card in here then later on I have to go you know I can go back nope got to go in order so there was a lot more to think about here I think more so than I wanted um I didn't feel like I was really going on a hike it was more like I need to get this icon I need to spin my windmill I want to get this and and this bonus needs to trigger and I need that icon I have to do this in this order it was a lot it it was more than I expected um definitely a neat concept A lot of these have awesome ideas just not

not quite for me that was the windmills then the next one was one that I was super excited about it looks like this and there's an important piece that I'm missing I'll show you in a second this one is for balloons more specifically hot air balloons which sounds awesome and the components are cool you have this giant thing which the other side is magnetic is this yes there we go it just needs to line up this is another magnetic component and it's going to be rotating around so you'll start with there's sort of this indicator on this compass compass rows Compass space Direction whatever it goes north to start with and you'll fill these spaces up I mean I'm going to drop them but basically you're going to fill them up with these so you'll create three well three up there and it actually creates that's right there's six pairs and it's very hard to see from there but you can kind of see where it says a b CDE e f those are going to correspond with hot air balloons and you're creating pairs then so to go on a slight tangent here with the original campfire board for solo you have three pairs and they're interconnected because they are all you know you can if you have one you just have to connect it to two others there's not a lot to think about there you want to do it at some point but you're not you know you're not

limited and that it might go away here the pairs are all it's going to rotate and it's going to change there's a little guide up at the top here that's supposed to tell you kind of you know what to expect what you might see it's a little hard to see from far away but it's there and the other piece of this that you are doing is you'll see that there's this this opening down here when you place your tile over here kind of like going to a campfire space as you do to use the special ability to get a goal if it matches the big number you're going to move up this track to spaces if it matches the small number you move up one space and this is where I it gets to be so you're going to start on the left side you can kind of see that there are bonuses depicted over here at a certain point you're going to decide to do a stop over which means at the start of your movement at the end of it sometime during the movement when you're moving over here you're going to decide I'm going to trigger all those bonuses underneath there that I've gotten to so if I got you know if I'm at this point it would be everything below there if I get all the way to the top it's everything and then I move to the bottom of the right track and on the right track where are we that is where you're actually going to put your uh scoring tokens that's where those would go so you make that decision of when you want to stop over and switch over but

there's a lot going on up here as well because this is going to rotate to in different directions depending on how high the highest person's token is on here you can see there's there's different directions so at the end of the round this will move um and thereby you'll see that it gives you different pairings and then it also will change the value of those of your your pieces that will let you move up the tracks did I explain that well I'm not sure but there is a lot going on here and it was a lot and I really wanted to love this one because the hot air balloons and the the artwork throughout this is spectacular it's beautiful it's it fits right in with that Meadow aesthetic and I mean you get these these beautiful little hot air balloons that you're going to collect you'll have a everybody has a set of them and once you complete that matching pair so this would be pair F you'd flip it over and you'd then have four points for game end so there's more ways to get points once again though it was a lot to think about and I didn't really think of it as a a hike so much as I need to move up this track or hey if I'm going to get this pair I haven't gotten the B pair yet I need to make sure that I have that now or I don't know if I'm going to be able to get it the next turn because this

this icon might not show up by the way the big encounters icons just hate me they never show up I don't know why I either get the Moose every time or they just never show up for me that's fine I have fun with that that's that's fun um but it was a lot of just planning for those icons and moving up and down this track it's cool it looks awesome it was just a lot again so that was the balloon scenario after that one okay comes the observation tower now I flipped to this and I was like I I need a moment hold on a second that is there's there's a lot going on here um you are going to be using there's different uh bonus tiles that you can pick up which instead of having those shared goals really these are going to be more like things that you can pick up and if you get this during the game then you get extra points at game end so just for as an example of what one of those looks like here's one of the top ones so if you got both of those icons you get five points at game end if you do not though it's only worth two points so more scoring opportunities awesome but also so many choices and this one has to do with actually stacking up your cards so as you know if you've played Meadow you are stacking on top of each other do

I have a good example probably not because I knocked everything all over the place um but but just as an example of what that would look like you know you're you're stacking up the cards and you cover them up as you meet those requirements and kind of go up and up and up and this one leans into that in a way that did not feel thematic to me um at the start of your turn you are except for the first round you are going to place a watchtower or a tower token underneath one of your columns and that determines how high up your person goes on the track here um you'll see the different levels one through six getting seven or more cards in a column is worth extra points it's great um but you can only do this once so if I put one of this one of these tokens under a uh you know like a a stack of four cards if I add to it I can't actually go up to that level I need to build out a different one and the level that you're at determines the different bonuses that are available to you when you put your uh where is it I'll find it eventually there's a piece that's that slots into the bottom to kind of give you those campfire spaces depending on player count so there's a lot of things that you're thinking about here there's a bonus down here where you choose one of these These are standard actions there's special cards that you can pick up so there's going to be a row of those

there's these middle tier uh individual tokens there are are uh getting your pairs over here there's a low tier one here there is picking up two cards and then getting a top tier one and I'm not done yet at the start of every round there's going to be a couple of new tiles available that you will actually replace your existing one with so you'll choose you know maybe I don't want this one uh and I'm going to replace it with whatever's you know you're going to choose one that's available so I might have this one instead and I would then get to use this as a Standard Tile but now it has those binocular actions and it kind of has also a a better action at the top so there's some cool ways to sort of use that um it it is it's a lot to think about I I had a lot and also as I said like you sort of a lot of these will kind of you store everything kind of loose in these boxes which works not a complaint but at least on my copy and I'm hoping it's just mine but I don't know the tower tokens each player is supposed to have five but unfortunately they are misprinted so that they actually have different colors in the fronts and backs for gameplay purposes you're just going to have yours in front of you so this isn't going to make a big difference it's just during setup that separating those out will take a moment more than intended

probably and yeah the this one I get it again I get where these scenarios are going from they they absolutely lean into different elements of the game and challenging you to sort of solve this puzzle and and work at it but this one in particular the observation tower anything in your surroundings area is you're basically not going to do anything with those you're really focusing on just adding stacks of cards and creating these so it's sort of I don't want to say I say on the rails a little bit but it sort of not forces but definitely leans you in a very particular play style or a direction of gam play that again you might like that you might like being like yeah I got to focus on this for for this scenario this is great I'm going to make the most of it for me though it it really sort of narrowed that decision space and had me playing in ways that just didn't thematically feel tied to that just nice calm peaceful nature walk that I'm used to and then finally we have the cave scenario the cave or the caves I think it's just a cave you go in one cave with this one you're going to have a bunch of cave paintings I think that are going to go into these different slots there are five different ones my favorite because stealthy elephants and

elephants in general I have elephants and some of my photography and stuff just for fun it's always enjoyable so I loved seeing that there and they're going to be up here and again if you see what these are you're going to have pairings of different icons so that's a lot there's a lot of different pairs this is filled in differently depending on player count so there's not going to be a ton of these different ones you're trying to collect those throughout the game and you can only collect one of each type which will help you move the head in the caves here again where's my little person you're going to have a person that's going to start way over here and then start moving through as you collect those you'll get to move through you'll pick up different bonuses and it's it's pretty cool but it is a cave and I want to I want to stress that because this is the cave module scenario not a module sorry scenario comes with the most number of cards that can be added to the decks and that will will be shuffled into the top half of each deck every play this is to kind of bring in those new cave cards they are cave cards so there are absolutely there are really again really cool nice pieces of artwork here um but then you're you're in a cave so I I just want to make it clear you're going to see a lot more insects there are they're they're cool and I like them in the base game I like seeing there's like a a bright yellow neon spider and I'm like yeah

this is awesome and you'll you know in the caves you'll you'll spot these cool places and little you know there are there are neat places absolutely but it is a cave and just to be clear a lot of the ground cards are going to feature spiders I don't necessarily dislike spiders um but there are a fair amount of them in this one that could add it in and it also is you you know you you'll get some of the cards that look like they are oh I found this you know on my my walk they all have this the bat symbol in the bottom to kind of indicate caves you will also see some adorable ones I mean there's a good mix here but again just just going off of there you went into a cave there there's a lot of a lot of cave stuff it's not a meadow it's a cave and I don't know what I'm trying to say there but to except to the fact that it doesn't feel like I'm going I I don't know it it didn't quite resonate with me that I'm going into a cave and yes I'm seeing these these new cards and you know spiders and insects it's fine it's not the end of the world but cave paintings why am I seeing cave paintings what is what is happening on my hike and you know what is the significance of that I don't know uh and I think that to back up a minute I think that is one of the other things that I

found with the scenarios is that they are interesting puzzles absolutely they add new rules they change up the mechanics they focus in on these on these elements of play but for me it felt very mechanical to say that um it they it didn't really tie into the theme of the original Meadow game I didn't feel like I was going on these hikes aside from the weather cards I will say that weather scenario at the start absolutely loved it I loved having that little bit of extra hey it was sunny when I went over here or it was stormy that was great but everything else felt like I was chasing after icons or I was trying to time it when I did this one thing and it wasn't like you know it wasn't enjoyable to see I didn't see this tree it was more like great I got points it wasn't it it just didn't it did not resonate with me and I will say I suppose I'm just not in the target audience because I do see how this could be very fun um but I am I would be concerned about how this plays because another thing that I didn't mention and I should it's clearly stated in the rule book this is not compatible with Downstream you can't use Downstream with this so if you enjoy that River element and those decisions you can't use it with the adventure book I don't know if there's going to be a

wai use it in the future maybe maybe not but as it is right now the adventure Book Adventure book yes the adventure book this one is only compatible with the base game so who is this for and who would look at this you know and who would enjoy this because again just because I didn't does not mean that it is not a great choice for you if you have just the meow Bas game and are looking for a way to challenge yourself to make it a little more difficult to focus in on different kind of rules and really changing it up and really trying to solve these unique sorts of puzzles I think the adventure book would be excellent um the alternative though is Downstream and I think that is where that's where I think it might be a little trickier to recommend if you have Meadow plus Downstream already getting the adventure book I don't know I was is able to fit Downstream in the base game box so I just have this is this is it this is on my shelf like this everything fits in there um it's great if you get the adventure book possibly if you cut down the insert took it out completely in the base game box you might be able to fit everything in there doubtful though so you're going to have another box and it does it really is are you going to play Meadow or are you going to play

The Adventure book one of these scenarios another concern that I have is how often you would want to keep playing through these they change the rules up yes but you're sort of you play through maybe 1 through six you might find your favorites and then maybe you're like I like this one or I like that one but I don't know if I enjoyed these this much would I keep playing it like would I keep playing that weather scenario to keep getting the weather cards every time maybe um but there is that additional level of I need to track this there's extra setup who knows I think this could definitely work for the right type of player if you want to solve puzzles if these scenarios sounded cool if you were like no what are you talking about Jessica this this is amazing and if you see some of these things and you're like that is exactly what I want to do with Meadow then get it absolutely that sounds like it would be a good choice I will just say I am looking forward to returning to playing Meadow plus Downstream together I thought that was a little complex you know adding on that River and that that huge board and there's a lot of stuff going on there but now that I've played the adventure book I'm actually looking forward to getting back to that and just enjoying the core elements of the game that kind of delighted me from the start and that I don't want to get away from so in in a way this was definitely very helpful for

me to experience this to try it out I think solo games and board games as a hobby in general we're always learning about our preferences and what we like what we don't like and kind of learning from that I still am excited that I went to my game store and was like here's a new game well an expansion but here's a new thing and I'm so excited let me get it to the table and I did so I'm happy about that and I'm happy that I got to at least try it out and I had fun there were moments of fun absolutely I just did not click for me and that is fine it may very well work for you so that again is Meadow the adventure book as always thanks so much for watching and hopefully you get some fun solo games to your table soon thanks so much for watching and take care bye

Progress saved