Skip to main content
Loading video...

Fromage – For Sharp Cheese & Shaper Gameplay

Transcript 17:07

I've never seen that done before I couldn't have even imagined how it's going to be done and I think that from here on out there will be imitators of this game because it works so well verage is a simultaneous worker placement game where all players have access to only one of four quadrants of a giant cheese wheel and simultaneously they're placing their time workers into a spot to either collect resources or make cheese when everyone has made their choices the wheel rotates giving players access to a new sector of the wheel I mentioned these workers being timed what I mean by that is the more powerful the action is the longer the worker is going to sit on the cheese wheel before you can retrieve it the actions have one of three levels of strength and this is indicated by the direction that the worker is facing when it is placed the big idea is you will know when it's time to retrieve your workers because at the beginning of your turn you will retrieve every worker who is currently facing you so what are these actions well in each sector of the board there are always two types of actions either making cheese or taking resources each turn a player can only make one piece of cheese and claim resources one time so in other words a player is is always going to be placing

at most two workers on their sector of the cheese wheel making cheese varies greatly in each sector so we'll talk about that first no particular order because the board is modular after all one action is the festival in the festival uh a worker can be placed in order to claim a tent at the festival and the objective here is to place cheese adjacent to others in a group because at the end of the game you're going to scoring points based on the largest group of tents that you have at the festival the ferie gives you both a benefit and ingame scoring for the endgame scoring you get different points based on the number of different shelves your workers are placed on and the bonuses are different ways of getting resources so the highest tier of reward will give you two different resources the second tier down is going to give you one resource and then the Third tier is just going to let you trade one resource for another resource or on the right side of the ferie there are three tiers giving you three different points three two or one point the city section of the board is all based on area majorities so you're placing cheese in order to claim a certain region and at the end of the game all of the regions are evaluated and in each one the player with the majority of cheese or influence gets the points for those regions unless there's a tie in which case the players share a set number of points that

differs based on player count the beastro is quite unique uh because in the beastro you're scoring for cheese pairings your what what players are trying to do is put two pieces of cheese on the same table if you can accomplish getting two pieces of cheese on the same table then the value of all of those plates increases so the more cheese pairings you have the higher the points you'll earn for each plate at the end of the game the second type of action is taking resources and there are four types of resources one for each sector the First Resource is fruit and fruit is required in order to claim specialized places on the board for cheese based on the icon you can either move that fruit over to the fruited cheese section or the jam section and at the end of the game those two sections fruited cheese and jam get multiplied together to give you points the next resource is livestock and whereas on your turn you can normally only make one piece of cheese in each in the sector that you're on uh livestock enables you to add an extra cheese to the board it is a free action to make cheese but in order to pay for it instead of paying with a worker you're paying with the livestock resources that you've collected and the more valuable the cheese is the more livestock are required order cards can be retrieved and they will give you victory points at the end of the game for making cheese of a specified type

and the way that this works out is just very simple thresholds the more orders you fulfill the more points you get and then finally structures are resources that you can collect and later pay in order to add a benefit or upgrade to your player board at the beginning of the game every player is going to have a different player board with uh different but balanced structures to give them benefits during the course of the game but they can only unlock these if they pay if they pay with the structures that they collect then in the advanced version of the game you can add in additional structures which players can draft at the beginning of game play so that they can kind of customize their player abilities I'll also point out that some structures give you a new space where you can place workers so even though you can normally only place two workers on your turn with structures sometimes you can place up to three players continue placing workers into each sector and making cheese until one player has has made 15 pieces of cheese at which point the game is immediately over and game end all sectors are scored and players earn points for their their fruit and their structures if any of the structures they've constructed give them victory points and their completed orders this is a phenomenal game it is so welld designed in fact on on my channel I once posted 18 most popular and influential board games and one of

the challenges in that video is trying to predict the next game that's going to be so groundbreaking and this has that type of quality in its design and I'm going to tell you why and I'm even going to tell try to tell you why you still might not like it cuz I always try to put that in there as well but gosh I am a fan of this game it was hard for me to figure out how to start explaining what I like about this game because everything is just so well integrated but I'm going to try to break it into three parts beginning with the game is very easy to teach if a game is very easy to teach it's important because it means that with any group it becomes a candidate for taking out you're not you're not going like oh I don't know I want to play this game but it takes half an hour to teach it I don't really know if we have time for that this one you can teach quick so you're going to be playing it more often and I mean you've just heard me explain the rules but what's cool is when you're actually teaching this game the components themselves lend themselves to the teach which is why I give the game such a high uh score for the components here these are really phenomenal because everything just makes more sense because the components are so welld designed everything from the rotating board to the shape of the cheese spaces and what they're pointing in once you point out that there are three types of worker actions facing in

different directions and the reason they face different directions is because it tells you which worker to pick up once the board rotates you're picking up the worker that faces you this light goes off and everyone goes oh oh I get it and then pretty soon people are examining the spaces and they're going oh oh wait oh this makes sense because the more valuable the spaces are the longer the workers there they can see it it stands out it pops out at them without having to be told that's the best that's the best thing a component could ever do number two is simultaneous play now I have always been excited about games that are engaging while playing simultaneously because they keep people in the action but often times these are either some form of like a rolling right or flip and right Style game or a tile placing game I think it's it's almost too easy to make a simultaneous action game where people are placing playing a card or a tile or doing some sort of roll and right to do a simultaneous worker placement I've never seen that done before I couldn't have even imagined how it's going to be done and I think that from here on out there will be imitators of this game because it works so well but I don't think an imitator is ever going to accomplish the intuitive the intuitive rotation of this

cheese wheel it fits the theme it fits the function the rotation and the the sector that becomes available to you as the wheel rotates is excellent for it's extremely conducive to worker placement and it gives people something that they e easily visualize and the action keeps the game moving number three is the game strategic depth and this is really important to me because I love games that are thinky I love problem solving and if I if I could that's all I would ever play I would always play complex deeply strategic games but I can't get away with that because not everyone's always in the mood for games that are as as thinky as what I like and what's cool about this one is that even while this is very thinky it's still accessible and it's not intimidating so I can get my wife to play this game I'm not going to play on Mars with her which you know that would scratch a particular itch for me but the rule set gets in the way there are all these things that interfere with my objective which is how can I get more of my friends into the games that I want to play this one does does that work for me because the game is attractive it's easy to learn and once people learn the game the strategy is apparent to them and they can have fun they can get into the strategy that I really enjoy and in that

way I kind of feel like I'm sharing more of what I love about this hobby but it takes a special kind of game to make strategy accessible and that's what this game accomplishes so I like this because it scratches an itch for me without I I don't have to compromise and like play an an easier game that I'm not so much in the mood for just to appease more casual gamers I can invite them into the games that I really love so that's what I love about the game I think this is an essential game I think everyone should own this game because it's so excellent but I'll tell you what there are some things that I will caution you about because I I imagine not everyone in the entire world is going to love this game so let me tell you what I would think is the problem with it even though I have no problem with it so number one the game is 15 pieces of cheese that is very fast normally I think it's good when a game ends while it's still fun this one I think this is the first time I've ever identified a game where I say no this game ends too soon I wish the game was longer there's a weird conflict there because I don't it doesn't need more strategic depth I don't need more more problem thinking it's just that 40 minutes and the game's over and you're just going huh I was having so much fun and then you could keep playing over and over again I suppose but I so often when I want to play a heavy game I expect the

night to take two and a half three hours and I'm I'm accustomed to that to accomplish that in 40 minutes you're just going like huh it's over huh that was really quick it's it's a little too quick it almost it's not light it's I don't think it's a light game I think it's a really great game with a lot that you can think about but it's so just it starts and it ends and so the only really way that you can either you can work this into your game night is either you're going to keep playing the game over and over again which I don't know I mean it's been a while since I've just played a game over and over again I haven't played this one over and over again in the same night uh normally what I'll do is I'll just pair it with more games like you pair cheese you it's a game pairing night we're going to play this and we're going to play that um but yes it it almost it has this like it feels lighter than it is because it's so short the other thing I had to work at this in order to put a finger on it and I think I figured out what it is there's very little luck in this game right the only luck in the game is drawing those order cards because sometimes you can draw draw an order card that's very easy for you to produce and plays into your strategy well and sometimes you can draw an order card that doesn't work out so well you don't have the opportunity to play that cheese in a way that synergizes with the rest of your strategy other than that there is no other luck uh you have I guess you

have the draft if you're drafting structures at the beginning of the game well then maybe you could draw like a better a better structure than some other one of your opponents I guess but that's very minor most of this game is pure strategy you're looking at what your opponents can do and yet here's the thing there are so many configurations because you can change the order of the venues on the change wheel you can change the order of the resources as well you can pair each venue with a different resource and that's going to change the game while that's happen happening you can also change what you're doing with your re Source strategy uh you know what structures are you building are you going to be emphasizing livestock how are you using your structures in order to uh you know synergize with your fruit and your your LIF there's a lot going on there my point is it feels like there are just absolutely countless ways to approach this game now here's here's where this could be a bad thing if you don't see what's going on if you don't understand how things are related it almost feels like luck it almost feels like there are elements in this game that that are broken almost because I played this game and I've had like Killer games I'm like oh my gosh I'm so good at this game and then I try to do the same thing that's

the mistake I try to do the same thing and I get wrecked and I'm like oh my gosh what I what I did this time didn't work at all and as I was new at the game I didn't realize it's not because the strategy didn't work because it was a bad strategy it's because the game had changed the order was different the structures were different the resources were M aligned differently you can't just do the same thing every single time if you don't realize that you're going to think that sometimes the game is wacky or out of Balan but if you realize that the setup of the game can seriously influence your strategy then you can take ownership of it and you can strategize for it you can actually really really get excited about it if you don't put in that effort you might just be like oh I don't know I you know I I played the game and it was so broken and this guy did one thing he just totally took off and crushed us and I think the game is unbalanced like you could do that maybe it's just because I I I am saying I think it takes more work to understand the game because it's not luck it's not luck um so those are those are really only two things I would see that are wrong with it but I love it I think it's a fantastic game definitely one of my favorites in the last year and as I reflect on it further maybe I'll be publishing a a uh best games of all time list or something and we'll see where it places in that um for as thanks for

watching this video byebye

Progress saved