Skip to main content
Loading video...

Shugendo - Board Game Review - Yokai Do Better

Transcript 22:26

Mike Hanland said I had to go that I had to get cleaned up.

Hi everyone. I'm the broken mele. Win or lose, I'm going to be honest with you. And I'm going to take a break from the uh mass plays of Kingdom Come Deliverance I've got on the table here. I guess trust me, I will get a solo review done for you at some point for that, but it's just going to take a while to get through all the games. Let's take a look at some smaller games though that I've been grabbing at Essen. One of which is Shugendo from Devier Games. This is a co-design actually. Alessandro Cuno. I'm not sure how that's pronounced, but also Simone Lucani, who I swear is not actually designing anything by himself anymore. He's just constantly co-designing. But I went into this actually not knowing that you know it's only recently that that has come to light for me. This is a light game only an hour from Dier and this is meant to have mechanics similar to another game I like called Living Forest where basically you have a deck of cards and you flip a card one at a time and you carry on until you either bust or you wish to stick. And it's basically based on not revealing too many symbols on the card before you bust so that you can do two actions rather than just one. This one's got a kind of sort of Japanesey Yo-kai theme to it. Um, but other than that, the only thing I've heard about it was that people were playing it and saying that this was a pretty sweet game. So, uh, okay. You know, if this could be a quicker version of Living Forest that gives me the same kind of feel, then I'm all for it. But, you know, Deio games are more hit and miss for me. You know, they they usually come out with something that's decent or something that's fairly meh or bland.

And they haven't really come out with anything that's like a belter for me. I've got cities on my shelf downstairs, but even that is probably the best game they've done. And it's not exactly, you know, like blowing my mind. It's just okay. This is a night nice, you know, simple gateway game for new players. That's about a seven out of 10 that I'm happy to keep on the shelf, you know. So, you know, I'm hoping that one day they will come out with something that absolutely blows me away. Could this be THE ONE? [crying and screaming]

SO, in Shagendo, obviously the name of the game is victory points, but there's three main ways that you're kind of doing it. You have a track which you can level up in order to score points just by cards you play during a game. You've also got a map that you can build up which can get you points for building clusters of buildings. Kind of think like almost Terrammystica style type game. And you've also got points that you can earn from leveling up in power level for these different card decks that you can access during the game. One of those is going to be the endgame trigger. And what you focus on is entirely up to you. But players have a starter deck of cards and there'll be more cards laid out with these free piles. So you've got these yellow ones here which are kind of the basic level and then you've got the purple ones which are the the highest level and red pinky which are kind of in the middle and you can access these different cards as the game goes on. But what you do is everybody simultaneously will shuffle their um will have a deck of cards and they'll flip one and put it down and they'll decide whether they want to stick or carry on. They're looking closely at not only what symbols they give you for the actions, but also what effects at the bottom they give you for recruiting other cards and more importantly the Yo-kai spirit symbols because if you get seven or more of those, you bust. So, I got two here for now. I flip another one, I got a third.

Okay, I'll carry on. I got five. Right. So, if I carry on, I could bust. I'll carry on. Three. I just busted. So, by getting more than seven seven or more of these yo-yo spirits, when it comes to the next part of the round, you have a phase where you gather resources and do an action, and you have a phase where you recruit more cards. If you're fine, you get to do both of those. If you bust, you have to choose one or the other. So, in this case, I'd have to decide which is more important out of recruiting cards or gathering resources. Once you, let's assume you have not busted. Let's say I stuck a little bit earlier. You have symbols for books, compasses, and hammers. And these resources are trapped on your board and each one and then you are allowed to do one action in relation to those. So compasses let you put these tiles out on your map and they basically build outwards, cover spaces, get you little bonuses. You can use the hammers to build little buildings. You have a bunch of them on your board along here and basically you just remove them off here.

They get more points as you go along. but you place them on top of said tiles and if you build them in certain like clusters you can get another like points tile for them which is what they call a prefecture. I know that's a Japanesey term for something, but I mean, at the end of the day, I just call them settlements. But you've also got the third one, books, which is this one, where normally you can only access this deck of cards, which are kind of like the they're better than your starter cards, but they're a little weaker. But if you spend the books, you can develop further and you're able to access more powerful cards for your deck. But the trick with these cards is that when you do recruit a new one from one of these stacks, it doesn't just go into your deck like a normal deck builder would. Instead, it replaces one of the cards you play during the turn. So, one of these three cards is what I had. If I decide I want to recruit this, I've got to scrap one of these and replace it.

That's probably going to be a good exchange, but it means that you are limited in which cards that you can replace, and you don't just simply get the new card to use. But these new cards are more powerful. or they give you more symbols or they give you more victory points or they give you more effects on the bottom. Whether it's more cash for buying more cards or victory points for certain conditions like in this case like uh you get money for having free farms. You might get just a flat number of victory points. You might get victory points based on having a set of buildings, you know, that kind of thing. And basically players just rinse and repeat this cycle throughout the game until one of the free endgame triggers is met. you get to the top level of development 15 VP or you create three of those settlements prefectures I mentioned earlier and basically first person to do that triggers the end of the game and then count up the points

that's easy

everything does come in a small box so at least it's easy to store but I mean components wise are okay it's pretty cheap for the most part you know the boards are fine but the card and the cards are okay card stock but the tokens and little things you get for the buildings they're just like little thin pieces of cardboard I'm not a fan these map tiles at all. I mean, they're they're pretty thin. Yes, they've only got to go on your player board, but the the what makes it a little bit more annoying is the artwork for this game. The artwork is fine. I mean, I'm not a fan of this style, but it works for like the board game cover. You've got this like Yo-kai spirit on the tree overlooking the Japanese family. You know, that's pretty cool. But the rest of the aesthetics of the game are kind of just a little bit muted or bland, I think, if I'm honest. You know, this one, the boards are okay, but everything's kind of all the same bluey color at this. You know, there's very little that stands out. The card artwork is fine. You know, I don't mind the cards. I think the cards are probably the best aspect, but the other parts of it, I mean, your player board, for example, with the map, the tiles themselves are not particularly great looking. I mean, one's supposed to be desert, one's supposed to be forest, one's supposed to be mountain. And I mean, they just How do you draw your squiggly lines is basically how they differentiate them really. But on your map, it's actually hard to tell them apart. I mean, the desert's easy enough cuz it's bright yellow. But the forest is meant to be green, the mountains meant to be, you know, blue effectively, or like in this case, it's meant to be more purple than that. But on your board, one is dark green, and the other one's a muted green. So there's like two separate greens fighting for contention

here. And you know, in the wrong light, or even if you just look at the squiggly lines on, you know, they kind of do look similar. You know, I've not had a time when somebody's gone, "Oh, I thought that was a forest. That was a mountain." But it's just like it just looks a little bit on the ugly side. I mean, even the recent Cascadia Alpine Lakes that I reviewed, you know, I thought the tiles looked slightly better in that one even. And you know, that one had baby vomit green as one of the colors in it. So, it's not a massive looker on the table. It's not going to draw too much attention, but it's okay. You know, it's not the most expensive game in the world, but yeah, I've seen better component quality in other games.

Overall, I would rate it a C plus. Okay. Not great.

The whole push your luck mechanic is one that does irk a few people. There are people I have played this game with who don't like this aspect of, you know, push your luck where you end up busting and you don't get to do as much on the turn. In Living Forest, that's also a problem. But it tends to be mitigated quite well in that one. But even then, it's a it's not the shortest game in the world, and you have to accept that you're playing a game with an element of push your luck. Mystic Veil has the same sort of thing where you push your luck with flipping the cards and then that determines how much manner you get and stuff. So, these games are not going to appeal to everybody. I mean, I don't mind the mechanic too much, but it can it does carry its own negative. And all those other games, Living Forest and Mystic Veil, have this same negative, which is that you, you know, if you push your luck and you're just unlucky, then it sucks. You know, it sucks only doing one of the two actions in this game. And this game does not go on for that long, even though it feels like it goes on for that long, but you know, more on that in a minute. But, you know, losing actions, losing entire phases, it doesn't feel good for the player and it does hold you back quite a lot. I mean, if somebody gets lucky with their cards and never busts, they'll win flat flat out.

They're just going to win because they've done more in the game than you have. So, it it does feel like it's a tempo hit that hurts. And sometimes you were just unfortunate. I mean, I'm on like, you know, I'm on four Yo-kai spirits. That's not too bad. I mean, as long as I don't draw one of the two threes in my entire deck. Oh, look, there's the three. You know, it's it the even when the odds are in your favor, it can still screw you up. And it's like it's just a bit of a pain. But, you know, it adds a little bit of tension and it does make you make, you know, conscious decisions of like, oh, do I do I keep going? I don't know. Is that enough money to work with? I could do with another symbol. Really could. Give it a go. Come on. It will be fine. Oh, few. We're good. You know, you do get a little bit of that as the game goes on. That is a nice feeling, you know, a feeling of tension as you go through. Upgrading the cards is pretty cool. I mean, there's not a lot of variety in these, unfortunately. Most of them pretty much do the same sort of thing. I mean, you've got a flat VP, you've got something for free farms, and something for mountains. And that's pretty much what the bottom row sort of tends to do for a lot of their cards. You know, the middle ones, you know, a bit of extra cash, uh, VP for certain building types.

you know, that's mainly what these ones are as well, but mostly like the bigger buildings. And then you've got, you know, these ones up here, which want you to build the really good buildings, but mostly they just give you a crap ton of money or a decent amount of points. But even then, the effects on them kind of rinse repeat throughout the decks. You know, you've got, you know, points for free farms here, you've got points for a couple of buildings here, you've got points for buildings here. It's not like one deck has fundamentally different cards. They're just slightly better than the one before. It's not even that much of a a crazy upgrade. I mean, they're an upgrade in terms of victory points. That's why you kind of want them. But, you know, just because your deck has a couple of pinks as opposed to a bunch of yellows, your deck doesn't feel that much more powerful as a result. It's very they're very incremental upgrades, these cards. They're not like, "Wow, this card is so much better than this one." It's like, it's a little bit of on top. Um, the comboastic potential of this is a little limited. I mean, you can, you know, create a nice little engine with your deck, you know, if you're focusing on a particular uh building type or going down one particular strategy, but it's very difficult to specialize in this game unless the right cards come out of the decks. And this game, for some bizarre reason, does not have a cycling mechanism. So, if the cards come out and they they aren't what you want, you know, let's say a bunch of pinks come out and all they care about is the pink buildings and you haven't done that this game. You know, you're concentrating on the farms and that and maybe you're not getting a lot of the hammers. You're focusing more on developing these decks and all the cards seem to just want you to focus on that particular building.

Well, you don't have enough time in the game to pivot to one of those things in order to make the engine work. But then also, you have no way to scrap the cards. there's nothing that says a player can do this and cycle through a deck or there's no all the cards scrap you know before we do another round or anything. So suddenly it's like the decks get very stagnant with what cards are there and that is a problem because it just means that somebody going down a particular route could just be shafted by the cards that come out and that's a random element they can't control and it's a bit of a negative. I mean how hard could it be to just shove in a cycling mechanism? just say that to all the cards scrap every round. In fact, I would put that in as a house rule. At the end of a round, kill all the cards in all those piles, put them underneath the deck, and deal out new ones. It's not that hard to absorb what the cards do, even though some people do seem to have a problem APing in this game with choosing of the cards. And that isn't helped by the fact that, you know, when you've got uh the t um you've got simultaneous play for the first couple of phases, which is good. which is nice that you do have that aspect, but then you do have the turn order of choosing the cards and you get some people, particularly with the lower cards where there's five of them on offer like I could replace that one with that one, but there's that one there. Could replace that one.

Jesus, it's like there's a lot of potential AP from some players because you're not usually playing this with gamers. if you're playing this with lighter gamers and lighter gamers are going to find the choices available just something that they can't think very quickly on. I mentioned about the game length not being too long. It's not the longest game in the world. It says 60 minutes on the box, but I think when you got four players, you're looking more closer to 90 really. The problem is that the game technically isn't long, but it feels it. You know, you're rinse and repeating this cycle ad nauseium. you know, the the turn the rounds don't take too long, but you know, you're doing it multiple times and it just seems like I don't know, you you're playing through and you when you get to that 60-minute mark, you're kind of done and it starts out staying its welcome. But the way that the turn sequence is done where the first bit is entirely simultaneous, then the whole gather resources and do an action is simultaneous, but then the next bit is turn order. the game kind of is a little bit on the clunky side, you know, because you're only as fast as your slowest player and because you've got to wait for somebody to do the turn order in there. You do get people sort of skipping ahead or, you know, like, oh, I'm at the uh point where I can choose cards now. Oh, we still waiting for somebody to do their gather resources bit. All right. Okay. We're there now. And and it it's like and as soon as somebody's already finished picking their card, somebody's like, "Well, you know what? I might as well get started on the uh you know uh push your luck part of it." And it's like, well, that last person hasn't taken the card yet. You know, we're not technically starting. And it you do find that some people just get a little bit

lost in terms of, oh, okay, which stage are we at? Or like, are we waiting for this one guy? It's it's not the smoothest play in the world, despite the fact it's only a fairly short and what is meant to be a simple game. But I think the main problem I have with this game is that it is just fundamentally quite bland. There's not a lot of yay moments. There's not a lot of a cool, that was that moment. And it's like, no, it's just you just cycle through the cards, get another one every now and again. It doesn't feel like a big upgrade, so it doesn't make you go, "Oo, yeah, I love that card." You you're just leveling up these tracks, and then you spend them to do the actions. And what are the actions? I mean, one of them is literally just take a token and access a deck. That's it. That's all the develop action is. You spend it, you take a victory point token, and that's it.

Whippy. Not exactly a big deal, but then you've got this map here. And you know, one of the actions is just to put a tile down. Okay, I'll put a forest here. Put a desert here and cover up this. Okay, I'll put a mountain there. Maybe that's two less points at the end of the game. I'll put a thing here that gives me a book. Okay, fine. There you go. And you know, it's not that interesting either. And the buildings, it's Terrammystica. It's the idea that you're going to place these buildings on your map in such a way that you create six stars worth of buildings in a cluster. You then have to put a tile on top of the buildings, which is very fiddly, very cluttered because it just it just makes your board look like a mess. And if you've created it via like a nice simple, oh yeah, just free things there, and you put the tile on it, it's relatively neat. But if you've got a cluster that's like a big snake and then you put the thing on top, it's like if you're doing a lot of these things, it just makes your board look like a fiddly mess. and all you got to do is nudge the board and suddenly it all goes flying. So, it's, you know, just not it's not a pretty sight. But, as I say, the actions just don't feel interesting. I mean, Living Forest at least gives you more comboastic potential. It has a much better aesthetic. The cards do feel more powerful, you know, and with the expansion, it even adds more options with Living Forest. Plus, you've got that really interesting, you know, like end game trigger system where it's a case of right where you can pull someone back so the game doesn't end that much faster. here. You don't interact with anybody at all. I mean, I don't affect your deck. Uh, I don't affect what you're doing on the points track. I don't affect your map. The interaction

is non-existent. Literally, only the only thing that gets in the way of other players is you took a card that I might have wanted. That is it. That is it. No other player interaction is in this game. So, why the hell am I including four players in this game when I might as well just play it with only two? And there's no solo mode, so you don't even get that luxury. You know, normally Deb already usually put a solo mode in these games. here. There isn't one. It's just literally two to four players and that's it. Okay, fine. Um the but yeah, you just don't feel and or Mystic Veil the other one. I mean, Mystic Veil, you get to do the classic like, you know, combos with the cards. You get to slide those um cards into the was it the transparent sleeves that it has. You create these amazing cards that you can play. So, it's great when you flip one of those over and then you got all the other magic effects. I mean, yes, they are heavier games, but they so much more happens with what you're doing with this mechanic here. You're going through this mechanic which is already going to irk some people. It's already pretty bad if you bust in this because as much as you are rinse and repeating this cycle, falling behind means that it's very difficult to catch up. You know, there's no catch-up mechanisms in this. Even the track, it's got bonuses for if you get high enough on the track. And basically, if you get high enough, you get a bonus, which means you're doing even better.

So, it's rich getting richer. There's no, "Well, I fell behind, but it's okay. I'll catch up eventually." No, only if the person in front busts about five times, but it's not going to happen, you know? So, if they've got really good cards or if they just pay it safe, they're not really going to have that much of a problem. So, it's it just doesn't it it's weird. It it technically functions, but it's just not exciting. And that's the problem. It's got a fairly easy to follow rule book. It's got a, you know, okayish aesthetics. I think the aesthetics could be better as well as the component quality. The rules themselves are not complicated and it is a smooth system, but it's just not, as I say, it's not exciting. That's its biggest flaw. And I think this one will just be forgettable. You know, people have mentioned, oh, you know, I quite liked it and that, but this is not going to be like anybody's top 10 of the year.

No way. There's no there's nothing there's not enough in it. You know, if you think this is one of your top 10 of the year, then go play Living Forest or Mystic Veil because they're better games with this mechanic. This one is just a very generic victory point system with a mechanic that we've seen done at least two or three times already, done better two or three times already. And what you're left with is just a kind of a a bit of nothing. you know, not a bad game by any means, and I would play it every now and again, but I would be wanting to cap the player count at two because I mean, a third and a fourth just adds more time unnecessarily. There's no solo mode, so there's no incentive there. And it's, as I say, even just explaining the theme, I can't even do that to players because honestly, the theme doesn't matter in this. You know, we've had living forest with nature spirits, we've had mystic veil with magic users, and now we've got this one with Yo-kai spirits. You can plug any theme you like onto this sort of game and it will still do the same thing. So, the whole thing about Yo-kai spirits and stuff doesn't even mean anything. I mean, you've got a whole page worth of fluff here um to talk about it, but at the end of the day, it's like, you know, here's the blurb here. You will guide your family's farmstead beyond the familiar edges of the land. As your settlement grows, more people will gather under your banner.

You will cultivate the land, build new communities, and shape the future. But beware, your expansion may unsettle the spirits who still linger in the wild places. That is a very fluffy way of explaining that you basically just flip a card, get some get some resources and make victory points. I mean, it's, you know, that that sounds way more epic than what this game actually delivers. So, overall, it's okay at best. You know, it's just not it's not a bad game. It's not a bad design. It's just not bringing anything new to the genre. It's not a particularly big looker. It drags it drags out when you have too many players and it only goes from two to four. Anyway, it's just like I say, I I've played it and now I just don't feel like I would care if I played it again really. I'm giving this one a five out of 10. It's average. An average game.

It's it it's all right. Every now and again I would play it maybe once, you know, in a blue moon, but I would be thinking I'd rather play the other examples of this. I wouldn't want to own it. I wouldn't suggest it as like, oh yeah, I fancy playing this one. It just and much like a few of the other games from Deree games, it just feels like a bit of nothing. There are a lot of games from Dvir that just come and go that nobody plays anymore. You know, everyone talks about White Castle. Personally, I mean, I like it, okay, but even I've got bored with that one. You know, that one's already um like dropped from a seven to probably a six out of 10 for me. And Cities Downstairs is a seven. But yeah, none of their games have been like builters. cuz I want them to make a builter that I can go this is fantastic, you know, they should run with this one. But a lot of their games just fall into obscurity and I think this one will be forgotten before we even hit 2027.

And how come we still remember him? Remember who? I don't remember.

So that's it for me on this episode of the Broken People. If you like to see them, please thumb up on YouTube and thumb up on boarding geek when it goes live on the page. Check out the rest of my content. I've done a lot of SM games now. They're going to be filtered through for the next few months, just constantly playing those Essen games and getting them reviewed. And the only way that I'm able to do that is because the Patreons have helped support this channel. This is not a review copy. I've had to buy it through personal funds. And the Patreon is what keeps this channel going to be able to get a lot of these games from Essen and give them a shot. So, you know, five out of 10. Nothing major, but at the end of the day, remember, it's only a game. And I'll see you on the next broken video. Take care.

Progress saved