Skip to main content
Loading video...

Gloomhaven: Buttons and Bugs Review — Size Don't Matter?

Transcript 22:06

this big game this small game but Sia don't matter right right right seair took this box and made it into this wow this can actually fit in your hand buttons and bugs is based off of the Gloom Haven Mass of Dungeon Crawler experience and goodness me the condensing is real and it's only for single player and I beat the campaign before we go on this is a review copy from sethair and Shelfs side is pretty buddy buddy with sethair but more specifically our Gloom Haven expert and no that is not me who has lost some weight I on the contrary am not the hardcore Haven fan who beat every single big Haven Board Game who dedicated half a year to our Frost Haven review I've only beat jaw of lion in a group and was part of the play testing team for frost Haven huh you know what it's actually more fitting that I'm doing the review of this game instead of Daniel because this is for the time constrained crowd the scenarios are only 20 minutes it just streamlines so many parts of Gloom Haven including obviously the components also this spoiler-free review figures that you at least are somewhat familiar with Gloom Haven so if you're new to that check out our full comprehensive review over there what is buttons and bugs BNB for short BNB is a standalone experience based off of the Gloom Haven combat system only single player and has up to 20 scenarios to beat you can play each one individually but we're viewing this as per one completed campaign the idea is that your dude got shrunk down to the size of a a mere button hence

buttons and bugs but yeah it's mostly just more of an excuse to fight things with the Gloom Haven is combat system so for the combat the main difference between it and Gloom Haven is that you always start with four cards in your hand but look at this they're double-sided so once you play the aide you get that bside back in your hand next turn bside when played gets discarded the second big change is that you now roll a D6 with three different symbols to determine all the randomness it first determines Initiative for Monsters then when you or monsters attack you will roll the die see the modifier for the row then move this white Cube down and it eventually resets back to the top lastly no more line of sight rules I mean maps are tiny anyways in terms of progressing through the campaign it does have leveling up throughout scenarios as they get harder and you can upgrade your classes cards get a better attack modifier card and you'll see more items one last thing Buns of bugs is not made by Daddy Isaac shis the great Godfather of Haven rather it's by another design team so that'll be interesting as we get into the pros first is a number one appeal how freaking small this box is like look at look at how small this is again it's small it's small it is small it does a good job of being small too setup takes 2 to 3 minutes if you're familiar with the game with streamline components everywhere there's double Sid inness cards without interrupting the flow of things are feeling Jank doesn't feel forced with the Monster cards or these level up cards flavor Texs and items being on the back of scenarios totally works Health dials are also double-sided with all the streamlining if you lose a scenario and need to restart nope no problem just move around some cubes set

these Health back to full and just rearrange on the map that's it it takes about 15 to 30 seconds you don't have to rearrange decks of cards or move around extraneous components like in Gloom Haven there's not even the element board from Gloom Haven to worry about either elements are now a onetime use if you see it on a card played that round you can probably use the element and the game still comes with minis for each class granted they're small okay let's zoom in yeah they're small but they still look distinct as for art there's new Splash art for the classes and the Maps actually reflect the fact that you're shrunk down real cute seeing buttons and maybe daggers as huge things on the map but usually you're trkking through fruit peels uh yeah just trash on the ground okay gameplay Pros time the first is how buttons and bugs is able to condense so much of the Gloom Haven combat moments into a 20-minute package compare that to Gloom Haven where it's very easy to find yourself spending one to one and a half hours to complete a scenario with two people first you got the double-sided combat cards where them being double-sided is is an intuitive way to plan out future turns and thinking when you would play the different b-sides and maybe combine it with as sides while they're not necessarily always better than their back the bides open up a new realm of possibility on turns and they got different initiatives too you got a Bonus small feeling of progression of starting with all A's then eventually getting to see some B's and yes looking at all these be's in your hand is essentially four new cards as opposed to Four A's also having only four cards means that you're just going to exhaust faster meaning that you have to be very efficient with every single turn there's no more leeway to discard cards or

frequently rest cuz you only got four cards you actually in total have only nine actions Max with using the A's and B's to their fullest this puts a very predictable cap on how long the game will be and you just cannot sit around and wait it's non-stop action go go go you can really see this franticness in the maps they're extremely tight now with plenty of Hazards around there's no separate rooms and or really places to hide so you're constantly on your feet to survive spawn and Bam you're immediately probably in range to attack after a simple move and those monsters can move and immediately attack you going back to the cards the new A's and B's for the Glo Haven classes means that there's Merit to just picking this up to see how it handles your favorite class asymmetry is still as strong as always with the same types of feelings cckar is big hard guy who uses obstacles to his Advantage spell Weaver has ways to get cards back from discard or lost pile and the Bruiser which I used is about pushing and pulling enemies and strengthening himself for big attacks now of course we got to talk about the dice rolling for modifiers that really condenses the if fire system instead of a deck progressing it's just the white Cube going down and you can still plan for those turns of strengthening yourself to avoid the Miss or secure the 2X or you can take a breather because next round you know that your attack is going to do at least plus zero next Pro is the campaign progression and it's shrunk down unique way sure as you progress through the campaign the scenarios will get harder meaning that they're higher levels so that means you get to bring better cards and you get to equip more items but you also get a nice new attack modifier card not deck not stickers it's just a card so you slap that on and you're ready to go there's

also no pen and paper in this game to track anything it's just cards another cool Streamlight progression is how they handled items where now you get two items included into your choosing pool for every completed or past scenario this gives you a big option select for more puzzling as you get deeper in the campaign as you look back at all your previous scenarios and mix and match what equips to use with what instance also without spoiling anything the complexity of the monsters ramps up well there's monsters that will deal with spawning different elements or different conditions you know just just kind of like Gloom Haven but condensed there's also multiple boss fights that encourages you to think differently I I can't really spoil it too much but I'm just going to say that the game is definitely not just fighting normal monsters there's thrown in bosses that really make you uh read their monster card very carefully and then look at your A's and B's and go like huh maybe I need to play a different a pair than before maybe I'll combine this a with this B in a new way to deal with this son of a gun oh and then these upgraded attacking modifiers for your hero really do give more cool moments later in the campaign there's like getting to choose additional targets or healing yourself in the nick of time the last game playay pro is actually the replayability here and it's incredible I get that you might not want to replay the campaign after beating it once but the scenarios can be approached Standalone so just pick a character you never tried one out of six and Bam you have a condensed Gloom Haven combat remember six different classes with roughly 20 scenarios to pick from so go to town just note that some scenarios are class specific specific on it's almost like we're back to the normal Gloom Haven in rule book

Shenanigans okay here's the thing this current rule book is fine when you read through it it's totally okay it's just too minimal there's just not enough content in here it's just a quick start to get you started on scenario one and then it just says well go here and scan the QR code for the full rules I totally understand the need to have the rules be smaller to fit in this box but if I'm spending most of my gameplay scrambling through the online rules which are hilariously on GitHub could the included physical rules be at least a little bit bigger like a couple Pages the physical rules don't have a component breakdown which is weird and it also doesn't explain how to switch difficulties which could literally just be a diagram showing to grab this new monster attack thing trust me this will be important later the physical rules also don't have this flying icon on a couple of the monsters which isn't explained on the icon reference as well or how about the symbol for items rotating to the side that's not on the player reference so if you're not going to make the rule book bigger at least give one to two more player reference cards I doubt adding two more cards to this box wouldn't fit right explain what to do when playing on scenarios which level isn't one and how items work it's hilarious how many people online have to remind others to properly change out some cards for level two scenarios because the rule book barely mentions it this actually gets into how I was unintentionally sucked into the massive Gloom Haven online community as I kept looking up rules exceptions I haven't found this fan-made printout rule book for buns and bugs I'm genuine impressed that there's so much fan-made material out there like this monster movement explainer but come on

this is from the fans not from the game itself and also there's not that much specifically buttons and bugs discussion out there as of yet anyways essentially learning buttons and bugs is going to be totally fine if you're very very comfortable with the Gloom Haven you just read this quick start and then search up a couple things on the GitHub if you've only played a couple hours of Gloom Haven maybe even more severe if someone else taught you the rules and helped you run scenarios well getting through the entire butons of bugs campaign is going to be a lot of research detours now for component cons first are these two Health dials the green and blue these don't really look that different right just make the green one more bright like its Cube remember there's no standies like normal Gloom Haven actually speaking of this abstraction it can be tricky to remember what color Cube corresponds to what monster at times specifically when the original spawn Place gets covered up when there's three plus types of enemies even crazier are when some are spawning mid scenario again can't show on screen because spoilers but monsters do get different from each other and always using colored cubes can get confusing so then maybe just have color markers you can put on the monster board as well the last component con is how the scenario cards tend to really fold up I've used them in different environments and they just have seemingly a mind of their own the non-f flat surface means that cubes and minis don't always stay put while playing it's not unusable by any means but I wouldn't be surprised if you always want to play with paper weights gameplay cons time and the first one is how it's possible for Monster activation to get weird with this dice rolling variant to determining their activ ation see in Gloom Haven you'd flip a monster activation card from a deck then once that runs out you'd Shuffle the deck so

by default you're never going to see the same action more than twice in a row in buttons and bugs you just roll a die and see what happens and with the onethird chance of each symbol happening it's possible to repeat the same ability more than Gloom Haven it is entirely possible that you see the same action done four times out of five activations or three times in a row a more specific non-spoiler example is monsters managing to heal three times in a row this is generally awful because you don't have the hard stamina in the tightness of BNB so yeah three major heels in a row can be gained now these monster activation roles really aren't that big of a deal you just have to set your expectations correctly if you've come from normal Gloom Haven you just have to be okay with scooping some scenarios when rolls don't go your way but that's also not that big of a deal because it's so easy to reset up the game a quick con I can think of but didn't personally use is that if you see the same monster activation three times in a row you just roll the die speaking of scooping some scenarios let's get to the next gameplay con where the difficulty feels weirdly labeled now as a reminder I played as the Bruiser which is a low complexity class and I'm not new to Gloom Haven by any means and then with this combo I actually struggled on standard difficulty I mean maybe the Bruiser is just a weak class as I've read online maybe Bruiser being weak or not buttons of bugs is just inherently Tighter and harder and only skilled for single player as opposed to Gloom Haven let's talk about the standard difficulty and how it's fun fine until you hit the dreaded scenario 5 this one exists in a weird spot where you don't have the best items and only one level two card and it

throws three really strong enemies at you one of which has few responses for what I'd imagine for most early game kits to have it's far from impossible especially if you picked up right items for your class however I didn't have such knowledge during my initial playthrough and I tried 15 times before reasoning that the perfect die rolls on almost every round were not worth spending a couple more hours in to just get so then I changed difficulty to the dreaded very easy and you know what happened it was like playing John's The Lion now the game was easy it wasn't very easy it was just easy eventually I normalized to easy and that felt very appropriate I beat the game by completing scenarios between the first two to four times with scenarios after five being slightly easier than it then ending the game by being almost as hard as 5 hard game doesn't mean bad hard game doesn't mean a con but I have to bring it up as a con in this game game because buns and bugs present itself as a 20 minute Dungeon Crawler so then it doesn't make sense for someone to be dropping 3 to 5 hours on a single scenario to beat it plus buttons and bugs isn't like frost Haven where something bad happens if you lose nope buttons and bugs is so streamlined that you literally just restart and nothing else happens which can definitely add to the feeling of straight grind after a while remember that Buns of bugs was made by different designers Joe and Nikki it's not Daddy Isaac no longer is this Gloom Haven box tuned to Daddy Isaac's preferences is but to someone else's if you're familiar with Gloom Haven combat and think you're so good maybe buttons and bugs will surprise you I don't remember the last time I seen this in a game where standard difficulty

is actually hard difficulty and easy difficulty is more like standard difficulty and then going back to the rules this minimal rule book it should have made it more obvious that you can just reduce difficulty by just switching out a card that's that's all you have to say scoring now it's time for a recommended score where we try to critically evaluate all the after mentioned pros and cons of the game with the caveat of whether or not this is a good idea in the first place and B&B is bringing this huge Dungeon Crawler Behemoth that is Frost Haven or Gloom Haven and condensing it down to this to be played Solo in 20 minutes sounds like a fantastic idea to me remember it can fit in your hand and so this is going to get a recommender score of8 out of 10 it is great with all the Haven products out there sure this game isn't really doing anything remarkable except for two things one being extremely accessible and two just having amazing value for the price it does both these things so well it's $20 that it just shoots up in our recommendations it is one of the best bang for buck games we've ever reviewed where the systems that you play the game for dozen maybe two dozen hours if you really like the classes where every single turn means so much I mean come on it's six classes 20 scenarios play the scenarios by themselves granted this has an unfair Advantage by just piggybacking off of Gloom Haven established classes and some of the systems but that means if you never wanted to Chan out the money initially now you get kind of close to that combat experience at a fraction of the price although it definitely doesn't feel as much of a Dungeon Crawler but that's okay buttons of bugs is even easier to set up than jaws of the line and how

small it is but yep it's only for a single player and so if you have anything but that definitely start with jaws of the line but if you are just solo you get Jaws of the line for the deeper World building playing scenarios two-headed and controlling two classes at a time and then the fact that you're opening hands won't always be just four cards where the initial card decisions and buttons and bugs is definitely reduced from normal Gloom Haven you cannot beat the sheer speed of buttons and bugs we joked here at shelide that if you're good at Gloom Haven combat you could probably finish half the campaign of this in the time it takes to set up and store Frost Haven properly maybe some speedrunners out there will test my theory on this so again it doesn't have all the fancy stuff that might keep you invested in the bigger Haven games like branching story pass puzzle books secret objectives more ways to spec your character and that's also what keeps the game so short Fally enough the B&B storyline still kind of feels like Gloom Haven and that stuff just happens and you're long for the ride with buttons and bugs around you as you're shrunk down in size and you mostly just kill things whoopee even with Kill All Enemies not being strictly every Mission here a lot of them are very similar to that Mantra and now you have your B- sided cards to worry about as you have to win the game in nine solo turns the game is so tight I'm not actually sure how much you'll be long resting too I think I only did it once throughout my campaign sure to complete the campaign you're probably going to have to play with your laptop or phone next to you for the rules but other than that the cons are really not that big of a deal if you know that the combat system is something like with four cards in hand I've already read people online trying to house rule this to work with two

players just because the package works so well with them and potentially this is also because of how much tighter and demanding getting through a scenario by yourself in buttons and bugs is just how I actually completed this small story about becoming big again haha this might be the Gloom Haven that you will actually see the end and you don't have to invest in entire room to keep buns and bugs set up we are now reaping the rewards of sephir getting their cash INF Fusion from these big expensive games and for a combat system already as tight and as Nuance as Gloom Haven condensing into four cards totally still works may this be a Haven for those who want accessibility and value in their single player games it's not just for gloom Haven fans my personal score for buttons and bugs after completing the campaign with the Bruiser is going to be a out of 10 I have an above average time with it above average time uh yeah this actually went exactly how I thought it was going to go uh so throughout the years I've come to the realization that I don't really like strictly Co-op long games if I'm going to be in a room with a bunch of my buddies for hours and hours I want it to feel like I'm competing in some way it can be in teams too I just don't want to feel like we're going against the rules or a robot together where board game robots just aren't as compelling as video game robots if the cop is is going to be long I'd want it to be a highly thematic experience to get sucked in like a story of manes of Madness or some detective game so in the past couple years this upcoming euro is Dungeon Crawlers like Gloom Haven where the

puzzling in combat is the Highlight just didn't do it for me after the novelty War off after the four session of spending 3 to four hours going into two rooms I just kept thinking of how many other epic games I could have been playing for that time 30 minutes per player my freaking butt that jaws of the line campaign just felt like a chore but maybe this is only because I played Gloom Haven at four players I've played with four players having so many empty feeling turns as you just slowly move forward on the map after waiting 5 minutes from when you flipped your two combat cards or the right play is to Long rest so you literally don't do anything for 10 minutes or how components feel like Overkill and FID Galore and I'd want way more things automated and uh don't get me started on the whole oh are you going very fast or are you going very slow or slower than last round banter thing I just at some point I just didn't want to do that anymore okay so now with all that backyard out of the way buttons of bugs pretty much solved all my core gameplay issues with Gloom Haven it's one solo on a very tight board so I don't feel like I have to wait just most of the time so I'm always doing something and action is always happening number two the game is actually time efficient now I can actually get what I wanted this type of puzzling experience that doesn't take more than an hour for gameplay where you're realistically just jumping around a room over and over again 20 minutes feels perfect for me these points number one and two culminate in point number three where it feels like every action really matters a lot more I just enjoy that increased feeling tension of the timer being short with only nine actions and so the clock is ticking about you using your A's and B's very carefully oh yeah some things that caught me off

guard was actually how satisfying the flipping from A to B was every scenario and how enjoyable was to get better at the game as I went through the scenarios I actually felt like I was becoming one with the Bruiser with the Gloom Haven isms of strengthening when the time was right and timing initiatives perfectly to guarantee attacks I actually think the score would have been a 7 out of 10 if not for me getting a little less six sided through the end of the campaign I feel like the narrative that is the way the story was presented just didn't do much for me it really felt like empty flavor text with an NPC I didn't care about I mean I understand that this box is being played for its combat mostly but I do wish there would have been more interacting with story elements on each map to make it feel like some more realistic world I got shrunk into monsters often felt like they just randomly appeared and after a while the new one stop being so interesting to me oh also screw the scenarios where monsters just keep spawning on the map and this wouldn't be as bad if you didn't have to keep setting up these Health dials that do get a teeny bit fiddly after a while just just a teeny bit the Gloom hav and fiddlin does catch up to me eventually oh then speaking of fiddlin once there's three plus monster types rolling this again and again every round can get a little bit repetitive also just like Jaws the line the class progression just didn't cut it near the end of the campaign where after I got my second upgrade card the excitement really cooled down on that end and while getting more items was cool it didn't change the game as much as early game where it felt like a fresh new world lastly the art and Gloom Haven just still doesn't do anything for me but that's just me but even with this style I keep thinking if there could be some more arts on the cards you look at all

the time or the items that would help with immersion buttons and bugs does this hex based card puzzling thing well for me in that it's just a nice relaxer at the end of the day it's not like Gloom Haven or Frost Haven where it at minimum takes an entire night to play one scenario far from a transformational experience it's still satisfying nonetheless and it makes me like Gloom Haven combat just a little bit more so hooray thanks for watching this video shout out to teair for providing this copy to us and again we never compromise our scores from sponsored content also thank you to all our patrons making videos like this possible over here yeah this was uh this took a little bit longer than I thought to review but Daniel told me I should get it going glad to get out for you guys I think that's the review yeah thank you to our mtic cardboard over here all you guys over here okay all right see you guys later bye-bye let me know what camp campaign game you want us to um cover next yeah okay yeah

Progress saved