Magicats Review: Magic Cats, or Magi Cats?
Transcript
Hey there everybody, I'm Mike Delisio.
And I am Joey Evans.
And today, that was very subdued. Today, he's coming with you subdued because we're talking about a game that is anything but subdued. This is Magic Cats.
Magic Cats. There's only one C, too, which I've
misspelled that many times.
Yeah, Magic Cats. It's Shouldn't the C have at least been capitalized to
You know, it's the whole camel cup. Maybe it's magi.
I didn't even think about that. Ma jackets.
It could No, no, it could be cats that are mages. Magi cat.
I got to change my number.
blown. I used to think this was a very stupid name. Now I think it's only possibly a very stupid name. Um, this is a game from Reiner Knizia and publisher Korea Board Games. It is a re-implementation of sorts of a very old Well, I say very old, but quite old game called Clash of the Gladiators, okay? Okay. And um, this takes the bones of that system, adds a couple of things, and I'll talk about that briefly when we come back. But first of all, why don't we go over to the table? I'm going to show them briefly how the game plays, and then we'll come back here, and we'll let you know what we think. To set up Magic Cats, you're going to take the four mat boards, and just in any orientation you like, you're going to place them out so that you have a rectangle game board, okay? And um, this is the standard side of the game boards. On the other side, you have another map type that's going to have more kind of advanced features. For your first game, they recommend that you play it on this side of the board. To finish the setup, you're going to take this magic display board, place it off to the side, and fill up the spots with the associated tokens, which are essentially powers that your fighter is going to have. Every player is going to choose a particular faction. This is the purple faction with acrylic standees. If you're playing in a two-to-three player game, you'd have all four. If you're playing in a four-player game, you would only
have three, but then every player would have their own associated pieces. The game is broken up into two parts. First, you have the preparation phase, and then you have the battle phase. In the preparation phase, you're going to be placing your fighters out into the arena and equipping them with these tokens. And that's just going to be done in clockwise order, starting from the first player. And the general idea here is that when you place one of your pieces, it has to be in an empty space. It cannot be where any other player is. And you can also not have another one of your pieces in the same vertical row or excuse me, vertical column or horizontal row unless it's blocked by a bookshelf. So, this would be not okay. This would be okay. Also, if another player is between you, then you'll be able to do that. So, if this had been the case, you could purple put another one there because the other player is in between them. That's really the restrictions there. Once you have at least one of your players out there, you can then, instead of bringing another one out, you can put a token onto one of the four slots on each of them. So, maybe after I play this, on my next turn come around, I'd go ahead and take this fireball and equip it by sliding it into one of the four slots there on my particular player. Once all of those are filled, then you would have to bring out
another one and you would fill that. This is going to continue until all of the players have all of their fighters on the field and they're all fully equipped with those magic tokens. Okay, so once the preparation phase is complete, it might look something like this. Every player has all of their pieces on the board and they've all been fully equipped with their magic tokens. At that play at that point, you go on to the battle phase, which is going to be the remainder of the game. In the battle phase, you're going to start with the starting player and on your turn, you're going to do uh two possible things. The first thing you can do is optional and that is move. So optionally, you can move one of your pieces and then the required portion is that you're going to battle. Every single turn in the battle phase, you're going to battle somebody. The way that the battle works is really determined by this magic display board. Things are going to trigger in the order of this board going from left to right. So these first two magic tokens are things that happen immediately. That's why they say immediately there. Um and so if you're equipped with either those, those things are going to happen right away. Then you've got something that will allow you to perhaps um remove a a particular power from somebody else, which is the distraction token. That would be the next thing that can happen. And then the next thing is going to happen is haste and this is going to be determining who rolls first in that particular battle. And so whichever wizard has more of that haste will roll first. If there's a tie, uh
then it's going to go to the attacker. And then you're determining what your dice pool is going to be. Each wizard, just on its own, is going to be rolling one of these dice as its base. Then depending upon the type of other tokens that they have and the type of attack it's going to be, whether it's melee or ranged, you are going to potentially be adding more dice. Uh you'll never roll more than six dice in a battle, but this is where you're going to be determining how much uh how many dice you're going to be rolling. Then the last few things here are things that could be either one-time use like the blizzard here where you're going to roll all six dice, but it's a one-time use and you remove it from your player piece after uh you've used it. Then you've got potential rerolls if you've got those uh that token. You've got the blocks that are going to be blocking uh particular types of damage. In this case, with the regular shield, you would block one blue. It's a little hard to see on the camera, but you've got uh blue single hits and red double hits on these dice.
A shield would block one of those, and then this power or greater shield would remove all of the damage done to you no matter whether it's red or blue, but again, this is a one-time use and you remove it. As you are rolling dice and doing damage to the other player, so let's say for example that um this player went first, and uh they are going to move optionally. They they can move. If they do, it's up to four spaces, and you can only do it uh in uh orthogonal uh positions. Let's say that this player moves here, and they're going to target them. They have a single haste. There's no haste on the red, so the attacker is clearly going to go first. Going from left to right, we see none of the immediate effects happened. It did have the haste. And now what we're looking at here is it's got a couple of options.
It's got this, which is the lightning, which in ranged would allow them to roll two extra dice. And so at this point, if they chose that, they'd have one for their base, and then two more because this is a ranged combat. However, they also have the blizzard. And if they chose to do the blizzard, they'd be rolling six dice. That works in ranged or melee, but it's a one-time use, and after they used it, they'd have to remove it from their uh stand here. So, maybe they decide they're going to do a lightning attack against this particular uh figure here. They would roll the three dice, and in this case, they did pretty terribly. They only got one single damage. There's no shield Oops, there was no shield there to block that. Um so, they would go ahead and take that damage. When you do damage, if it's one, you're going to place a damage marker on that particular unit. If it is damaged again, this would get removed, and then the um damaged player would choose one of these tokens to remove from their uh unit to give to the player that did that damage. So, perhaps they would remove this uh token and give it to the player that caused that second damage. That player will have this as kind of a trophy.
When the last blow is dealt to a unit, and it is now completely without tokens, that player would also get this piece as a kind of like a a trophy or a point, if you want to think about it that way, at the end of the game. The game is going to continue in this battle phase until only one faction is left on the board. At that point, the game will end, and players will count up how uh how many points they got by counting the enemy units they have in front of them, plus all of the magic tokens that they've collected from battle, and whichever player has the most points will win the game. That's about it. Let's head back, and we'll let you know what we think.
All right. So, just briefly, I'll talk uh about kind of how this differs from the original game Clash of the Gladiators. So, Clash of Gladiators came out Clash of the Gladiators came out I just made that into one word like Saturday Night Live. Saturday Night Live. Um
Clash of the Gladiators came out and it was immediately unlike almost anything else in my opinion that Reiner Knizia has designed who
Okay.
tends to design, you know, Euro games that, you know,
mechanic first.
Yeah, this was almost an Ameritrash type of a game where you're just chucking dice and you've got gladiators that are going against each other in an arena and if you get knocked out then you would take over an NPC animal that would try to take out the other ones.
Yeah.
Okay. Um it had a limited number of those player powers. What Magic Cats does and another game that came out I believe last year which is exactly like this with a different theme called Battle of Mecha Verse.
Okay. I did not know that.
not come out in wide release is that they've increased the the power. So, when I showed you those magical tokens in the overview most of those tokens did not exist in Clash of the Gladiators.
Okay.
Okay. And then they took out the kind of the NPC thing um which I think for this game works. So, those are the differences, right? It kept the dice chucking the kind of the craziness. So, um You've played a number of Reiner Knizia games. I've played a bunch.
Did this feel different to you than other Reiner Knizia games?
Oh, 100%. It's like you would not have known if they didn't put it on the box. You know, I was like, "Oh, it's a Knizia."
Mhm.
It's very and we played with people like, "This is a Knizia game." I'm like, "Oh, really?" Unlike anything you've you're you're imagining right now.
Yeah, I don't know if you would say if you like Knizia games you won't like this or vice versa.
I don't think so either.
It's just it's it's its own game but it's not like many of the other games that he has designed over the years. So, we said a dice chucking game. What one of the things I do like about this game is and this was in the original game too is is there's two distinct phases, right? You've got the preparation phase, and then you've got the battle phase. And I like both almost equally. It's really about the battle, but that preparation is so much fun, too, because you see what people are doing, and you're like, "Oh, man, that one's going to be a beast, right?" So, I like that.
You see them leaning like, "Oh, somebody's going for a lot of fireballs." You know, it's like or you get like all these rerolls, and you really I mean, that right there, first of all, it's very important to me. It's just huge. But you get to watch, and then you also pivot on your turn. You're like, "Okay, I'm going to have to kind of counter that." You know? So, and then you see those go. I think fireballs is one they have the most of, right?
Yes, that's correct.
So, you'll see some go. You're like, "Ah, I'm not going to be able to get in the hell I that that one." So, it's like, "Okay." And you kind of have to pivot a lot.
Yeah, you do. You start seeing ones that people are taking, and you get a little bit antsy. It's like, "Well, I didn't wasn't necessarily going to do one of those, but I'm going to do it now because it won't be there when I get back around to it." Yeah, so I like that aspect of it. Um but most of the game is about the battle, right? So, once every unit is out there, and it's fully loaded with those battle chips or whatever they're called, right? Then you're getting down into the battle. And one of the things that I think that is interesting is that there is literally no turtling involved.
No.
This is actually something I didn't mention in the overview. Um is that in that move phase, which is optional, if you are not within four spaces of another character, you're going to basically warp to get next to one of the other players. You never skip a battle. There will always be a battle. And I think in this game, that very much works.
I 100% think so. That's one of the things that makes this shine among different Coliseum or arena battles because a lot of time it's like strategic positioning, and you're like, "Just do something." Yeah. You know, this one you have to do something. And you have to move and attack. Even someone that you don't necessarily want to attack, you're like, "I'm going to have to go at you, you know? And it makes it make And also it makes this game short.
Yeah, it Yeah, and and and I think that it does not outstay its welcome. I think you know, if it went on much longer it would get a little tedious, right? But it's it's I think it's just about right the way that the the length works. Now, did you mention the components on this are just
No, but let's get into it. Let's talk about the production a little
I love the production on this. But again, I'm a huge fan of acrylics anyway. But the way they're used here, there's several things about this that I think stand out. And one the acrylics are gorgeous. You pull them out and the insert is great the way you pull them out that way. I also love anything arena battler I forgot the name of it Hoplo macus or one of those has where you can tell the hit points by the stack of chips, right? This one again has the same thing cuz you see how many are on each cat and you're like, all right. I could take that if I take the last one and him I get two trophies out of that. So I love that visual aspect of going after well, I don't want to say the weaker players, but you know, the ones you can actually
players.
You know what I mean. But it's just I love that visual aspect of hit points. And that again everything about this is great.
Yeah, that's good. That that's a good point. I This is by far in my opinion the best production of any iteration of this game has ever had. There were some little plastic components in the original Clash of the Gladiators, but certainly was not as as compelling looking. This is by far the best production and that I think helps. The negative that I have honestly is the theme. And it's not because I don't
like cats or it's not that I'm over cat games because you know, there there's still in comparison to like generic fantasy, there's a lot more of those than there are cat games. But the first iteration of the game, Gladiators fighting in an arena, that makes a lot of sense. The second one that I was talking about is you play as mechs fighting each other in a battle arena. Right. Magical cats I it feels a little cloying to me. It's It's cats are very popular. Let's make them magical. And And so to me that is probably the the the negative I would say for this is I don't really love the theme in this particular game.
Yeah, I can see that. But I I honestly don't think of the theme much. I just think I'm throwing fireballs at you.
Yeah, yeah. That's that's that's true. I did show you briefly in the overview there is a an alternate side of the board. So if you get kind of proficient with the game and you feel comfortable with kind of how all the things work, you can flip it over to the other side and it add some, you know, terrain type things to to deal with. Um the other thing I did want to mention is the the way that the kind of the the that board that you place all the tokens on also gives you a flow.
Yes.
and I think that's smart. It's actually it's necessary, right? Because you have a couple of things that can happen immediately, then you're figuring out how big your dice pool is, then you're figuring Well, first you're figuring out who's going to go first, then you're figuring out how big your dice pool, do you have any defense, things along those lines. So I think that works really well.
It's very important. There's there's so many I love the decisions on this on when you're taking hits.
Mhm.
Removing which one to remove. You're like, I got to remove the reroll because I just have to keep this powerful. Or my next one will be range, so I have to keep that. So I guess I'm getting rid of this.
Yeah.
You know, I love those type of decisions. Again, they're not they don't add time, but it is a tough decision you have to make.
Yeah. Um do we want to go to final thoughts?
I think I'm ready.
Yeah. All right. Uh I'll go ahead and start off. So this is a game that I already liked the original version of Clash of the Gladiators. I liked that it was something that felt different from my favorite designer. Um I think [clears throat] that the uh theme on this is my least favorite, but the production is my favorite.
So good.
Um and so I'm coming at a 7.5. That may seem a little bit low, but I honestly I that's a game I recommend. It's a game I like. It's a game that I will continue to play. I just feel like maybe it's one that is in a little bit more of a crowded space um amongst some of the games that I will play. Most of the right of Canisius games are kind of in that Euro. This is in kind of this arena battler and there's quite a few of those out there and so maybe it doesn't raise reach the highest level of that type of a game for me but it's certainly one that I enjoy. 7.5 is a good score just as a reminder. But yeah, the theme hurts a little bit but the production's great.
Wow, this is crazy. I'm coming in higher than Mike on a Canisius game. I'm on 8.5.
Wow, there you go.
Because I like this game. I love arena battlers. This one I have not heard the phrase curling before but I completely know what you're talking about. Arena battlers for me don't hit the table as much because it is almost like that meme with a stick do something. You know, it's like just fight. This forces you to fight. You have to get out there and fight and because it's shorter I was I don't know what it says 45 minutes or so it's 30 to 45. You have to go and get it but again I have to reward the production value of this. This is what I'm talking about. You take a game and you make it this. It is gorgeous. It's a point we played at the bash and people walk by and say what is this? It looks so good and it's so visually striking and the fact that everything's efficient on you can see the hit points everything. It's right there. I think this is well thought out. I have not played the first iterations. The theme is fine. Whatever but I see this as a battler. So I think this will be this will get a lot of play because it hits the table quickly and it's one of those that people can jump in and they're like got it. You know, so it's good.
Yeah, it's funny actually now that I think about it of this is more of a Joey game than a Mike game. It just happens to be with a designer that doesn't usually come with these types of games. So that actually makes a whole lot of sense.
Yeah.
All right folks, there you go. That is Magic Cats. Until the next time this is Mike Delisio
this is Joey Evans
reminding you to always
choose fireball.
fireball
fireball
100%
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.