Dark Souls - The Board Game: Discussion
Transcript
you
viewer discretion is advised it will welcome to the discussion for Dark Souls the board game now like I said I have played this with three with cat iing and Luke all of which have been in most of my videos yang is obviously the agent Lucas guy with the sweet braided ponytail and the bear gang hat is yeah my girlfriend um so I'm going to tell you what they said after I talk about what I think um I have mixed feelings about the game I'm honestly not sure where to start so I guess I will answer the question is this dark souls the video game in board game for me no no not not at all this is literally a getting like in it is the only thing that this in the board or in the video game have in common is that it's hard and just forgoing the theme obviously is that it's hard obviously the the boss fights didn't make didn't look at but you could see there were times in the fight where you saw me I had to use my SS five other words even if they hit me with one damage to damage I would have died and that's pretty much how this game works so no this like has this is not anything like the the video game and and here's why the biggest reason how they seem to
compensate for the number of players la is based off of sparks I mentioned that a little bit you didn't really get to see it cuz I didn't do anything rindy but oh that's another thing you have to grind but in the in this game they have a spark dial which basically means how many times you can go back and rest and that is probably the biggest disconnect that I have with this because I'm not a huge friend in the video games I like the world I love the lore but hard for the sake of being hard doesn't do it for me having to go out and find the story doesn't do it for me but I understand why people would like it now anyway that's part dial if you have four people you only can rest twice and I actually I think technically yeah you can only rest or lose twice because how are the players lose the game is that if they die or rest at the bonfire when there are zero sparks remaining so whenever you go about how you gain your souls is that four players actually two three or four players you start out with zero Souls every games of the bonfire title and four other tiles and if you win in each style isn't encounter and this is just one card it stays the same each time so every time you rest that encounter garden just flipped over for some reason but then you flip back over monsters go exactly where they go and
and you redo the whole thing and that's why I didn't want to show that because I was boring as hell to watch it's boring it'll do in the board or in the video game uh so after you beat a tile you get two souls per player so in a four player game you get eight souls per tile if you do all four tiles you're going to get a thirty-two souls and that's one of 32 Souls per person that's thirty two souls / the party so you have to look at what is you get which you can get which you go which you have to willingly go back to the bonfire and rest which knocks that spark down so now if you have to in the four player game you only now have one time if you guys lose it goes down so you can go there and spend souls to look for treasure which you may find treasure it's possible that every tile could have a treasure chest which gives you two things that go in your inventory so you can go there look at your souls look at what you have in your inventory and be like okay we're going to upgrade you you and you to this level spend these souls so you can wear these weapons so it's possible that people could one person could get jacked up to hold everything all everyone else was weak very much possible that everyone could get a little bit of something here's the problem with that whenever you you have to willingly go back and and and rest that takes one some of your time down whenever everything kind of no these
dice okay okay I make it to the dice on the site I should just say no I actually like these dice the probability of you actually doing relatively well on your attacks and your your defensive like that it is pretty high like the black guy has only won this it is possible to with that everything has resistance so at least you do get a hit it's sometimes the enemy defense is higher so I really like that I really like they didn't make this game hard just because the dice like oh the black guy only has one hit and the orange side just doesn't hit like some [ __ ] like that like if you're rolling to two of their orange dice you're gonna you're gonna you could roll with eight damage plus any upgrades and [ __ ] so so having that disconnect of the spark having to go back and willingly rest which knocks it down which means oh [ __ ] we can't do this all the time that kind of the kind of ruins of the game and it's very boring to actually play to reset it because if the reset everything up and so at least in the video game whenever you rest if you just you be rested in you go you little open it you go and eat and slaughter bone or if you're on task people here you can't do that you cannot run from an encounter so you have to you have to fight and you have to fight even if you have everything you want to know to really go fight the boss so really go fight the mini-boss you have to trudge through each unexplored tile I mean if you if you have beaten them then you can just run right past them but it's like
just the setup and takedown doesn't compensate for that and I think there's a house rule I'm wondering if it if it breaks for game and Luke has mentioned this was that what happens if you take away the spark dial ever like you're the players can't get rid of that again they can grind as much as they want to make sure that they're ready to fight fight the bosses over the mini-boss and he said well in because your treasure chest don't reset so you're going to get what you get out of those and then you can pay a soul to draw a card from the treasure deck and he's like well if that was the case and you can literally just hop back and forth and and there's no consequences to whatever you do and so you could literally slide them through the treasure deck until you get exactly what you want and then probably makes the mains also minibox too easy I'm like okay that's fair that's fair so my idea is that you only lose a spark and it's like I said and four player game you get two chances technically three I think if you have a zero you get to go again but if you can't rest and if you die you lose I can't remember so I'm like okay so what if you only knock the spark down whenever excuse me whenever you lose now if you willingly go back well I guess that's pretty much the same well no because you can still have a chance of losing so any you understand my problem
with the fact it's like okay so it's it bothers me a lot I won't hate it but it bothers me because on top of you have to you only have to round to willingly rest and or die and then you have to knock it down and you have to go out and retrieve your soul so then you can't really go back collect your soul then go back and rest I mean I guess it's balance but I mean it's not balanced in the way that I like it because if you if you lessen the people then you don't get as many souls per encounter but you also don't have as many people to upgrade but with the spark and everything all souls and everything hinges on the randomness of the treasure day and here's the cool thing that in my unboxing the treasure deck is it everything is different and that is fantastic I think that's amazing the fact that every single card is different does something different and and I mean sometimes you can draw something at the beginning of the and I could already wield this and that's great the way it works with upgrades and all that that's fantastic but it can screw you or benefit you think it's like a magic thing to think of it like manna you could only ever draw cards that you don't have enough souls to wield so you can never ever upgrade and that's a possibility and it's like okay what the [ __ ] are we doing this for now Granick sorry
you you can upgrade some people like the chances of you drawing only hearts that you don't have enough soul to get anything it slims done because you can kill the scrubs with your basic weapons it's gonna be a little bit harder but it is possible we did it and I played this I play the split myself I played it controlling two people and I play this for it not done with three I imagine it's the same but so it's like okay so it's impossible really that no one could get anything but if you're playing with four people it doesn't hurt the fact that okay we only have items that only the herald can use because there are specific items that only each class can use and if they are that's kind of cool kind of you know personalize them a little bit there's a way more comment so I think okay well we got like you could draw all Harold's is they are able to pump our stuff in this without needs everyone else shitty and whenever it comes down to it you lose an encounter when one person dies on the 4 player game if one person dies you all start over and that makes no sense in here's why and a typical encounter yes you saw in the boss though is no different it went every enemy then one player every enemy than one player every enemies than one player every enemies is one player and that is extremely unbalanced that makes me feel like descent when all the heroes got to go and then the boss got to go for one massive turn and he just
need to muse way better or the overlord that is so unfair because if one person dies like there's like the program like enemies are all programmed to act a certain way so someone's the aggro and they all attack the aggro person then that person could easily die and you're like well I'm glad we didn't upgrade them or anything like that it's ridiculous like and I can't think of a way to make that part any better like it can't go threat threat level of the enemy because it's like okay well it went highest the lowest threat then you just start targeting the one with the weakest threat so the other game at Tech next okay let's kill them it makes no sense to me like I really I don't know how they thought like about the way to make this game hard did you saw with these two with ornstein and smough you saw with them they both went and then oh well okay then I had the first player marker so nice going first okay they both go and in the word goods and I understand that you're supposed to maneuver yourself around so they can't hit you well with the way these knows is that it doesn't work like that you you can't most people don't have a lot of range so they're going to have to be up close which means if they're attacking the nearest person it's going to be a person in their same space and honestly every person should have been like what like this like I love the fact that the
bosses have that the nodes or the areas because then it's like oh [ __ ] let's maneuver around them and attack and while these weak you can't do that with the scrub they will always hit you almost over to you yes you can dodge and you get out of the way or they'll push you and then they'll get out of the way but it's like not a lot of people can dodge and the only person I can dodge is the assassin these doesn't actually at one point was rolling three of a dot so your chances of you know invading are way higher and that's what the assassin was meant to do that was fun but the fact that they all get to go and then only one it's like it's like fine they all just go and target some people then we all get to go or something like that and that's why I feel it actually this game is with less people like I actually played this by myself just one person because I'm in a one player game you started out with sixteen souls so maybe a way to balance the stupid spark is okay with two people is 14 Souls with three people it's you know eight Souls and with four people it's for something like that to where you start out with a little bit of something and and it makes a little bit easier to level up like you're just entertain 'pl I like I said I grind it and I did everything and just showed you the mini bosses fight well I got extremely lucky with Mike with my treasure drawers
because obviously I'm gonna have the cards in for these I had enough to level them up and I drew their cards you know for treasure chests and then paying for it and level them up to where I was able to get great items which probably made it seem like the gargoyle and orange in its long word were easy which I mean I hardly ever took damaged so it's like it is the game balanced I don't think so and maybe that's the point like the debate or the video game isn't balanced but as you level up over and over and over and you grind over and over and over and over it becomes more and more in your favor um but I mean you have saw like I said I was like you can get really good dog rolls I was getting really good titles I was taking some damage but it's like I don't know I don't know I don't hate this game I don't like the spark and I don't like the encounter the fact that each enemy gets to go in and one of us goes because then I mean it does bring a different element of strategy because you guys think of who has the threat marker and or hear you closest so you you mean I mean it's all open knowledge you can look at like the scrubs and how they're going to attack so you can plan accordingly just stay back and they're going to move and maybe we didn't do that maybe we didn't do that well enough so we can be like oh these Oh Lord they're all going to move well we did pretty well we did it with the range people or the people that were
like okay well we're going to move and then that means that these guys are going to come after him and he doesn't have any damage or stamina so that's fine so we did it well enough and it made it a little bit better also the fact to each encounter if you survive you completely clean your stamina health part which I gotta say I actually really love that mechanic I think it brings a huge element of strategy duh if you haven't really get to see it you guys pretty much only saw the night in the warrior pictures but each you only have ten slots for your stamina cubes and your damage cubes if those if that bar so there's only ten if that ever gets filled up you die so you really have to think of okay how badly do I'm going to attack this person and exert myself to possibly most likely dish out more damage which could kill them and then you won't attack me or there I want to play it safe and like and wait for a more opportune moment to attack and then if you take some damage okay because we're there is a time where we were like okay this person is going to hate you even both likely will do damage so you should dodge and we're like no you can't dodge because then that makes it even more difficult like it makes me even more risky because the dodging all or nothing if you succeed the dumbest you don't take any damage if you fail you take all the damage at least when you try to defend you can you get some of it but a
dodge also cups of stamina so if you're really close if you're imitating if you could survive taking three damage like if you're like okay three damage and I I'd be fine so you're like okay well we're really close some are trying dodge it well now that reduces how much damage you could take by tip to one or two two by one to two because you've now added a stamina now you heal staminate each turn you loose Kemeny turn with your items that do a little bit more you there are healing spells you can do the herald has their ability allows I wanted to stamina at some time because damage almost always stays it's your stamina that goes back and forth so at the end of each encounter you you lose all of it um and and I think I actually I think that's really awesome that bar is is really cool so it kind of makes the all enemies go then one person goes a little bit better but in the sense of a board game having everyone wait for their turn longer than they really should it's actually really boring which brings me to my next point grinding is one of the reasons why I hate the video game the video game like I don't like to grind I don't think that's fun like it's a chore like deck building and constructing a deck for game to display it that's a chore to me grinding is a
chore just you have to grind to be good it's not any level of skill it's just how much time do you have and it's like finding the same enemies over and over and over they do the same thing over and over and over all to get to the really really exciting and fun boss battles now whenever we were playing in a four player game we didn't get to the boss we didn't get his boss we didn't get to the mini boss of the main boss because they were pretty much tapped out because all we did for the grind and they didn't want to do it they didn't feel it so I was like fine i'ma do this by myself and then I'll play the whole game and to show them you know the boss fights and I exploded I completely understand like the boss fights or whatever one wants is game for good everyone wants a game to fight Hortensius long everyone's game to fight the dancers of boreal valley no one or I guess there's the tightenin demon which is the mini boss and there's the wing night which is a mini boss as more mini bosses in here the only made busts are these two and the dancer of the board of Ally everyone wants to play this game not to [ __ ] grind it's to fight these guys but unfortunately to fight these guys and have a chance of being pissed off because you suck because of some imbalance it does let's not that's not fun Experion so the the souls are weird gathering Souls you have to grind that you can't grind enough because of the spark value which is why I think that in
one player game you start with 16 souls 16 Souls and you get 5 sparks which I found was actually more than enough granite you only get two souls / per encounter so you're only getting mech bates old but it's only you that is actually going to be upgrading so that's way more like that that's that the ratio is way better okay so there was that there was oh there's a sloth I like them I really like the fact that Armour can have as many upgrade well it kind of I don't know if this is a the video game at all weapon can only hold or can hold you know zero to two upgrades and they go under it see it's very it's very nice it's organized very well but swords or dent weapons can only hold upgrades and they can't be removed armor kits can remove their upgrades don't know why they thought that I don't know if that's a that's the video game or what but I don't know but I really like the board I like the leveling system whenever you can level up and and yeah I mean every every person has their own ability that you can only use once you have to see me use the Warriors which I think was a good opportunity time to use it you get one rear old another thing
because I know this wasn't the case you only get I mean and I get it I get it it's supposed to be a mini scaled-down version of the game um but if you're going to make it as hard to get souls in it's hard to rest and so like that I mean I get that you kind of get an ember or in every slot and that's the flask at the end of each encounter if you survive so maybe I guess that's how a mute complaint that you only get one at this loss but I guess I guess should you compare this to the video game know like theme is really all there is that you can compare this to the video game and a lot of people are going to be expecting this to mimic the video game and I think that that's a bad idea in it because that's going to ruin it for a lot of people because no it's not the beginning it's not as smooth it's not as fluid it's fun because because of setup time to fight omein a mini-boss you guys saw me it was one board you have you have the whole thing set up you have to remove all that it gets technical you can put the board on top of it the rules say that remove it and place the mini the mini boss board here and then you pylons and you have to set everything back up really really like that's that's so monotonous to actually do and then the main boss is the mini box on the main boss tile and so yeah that's that now what do I say oh the rules the rulebook is weird and by
weird I mean it's it's like it goes over weird way of explaining things like it's kind of it's broken up into sections it doesn't inherently say what around is or what a spark is pretty much what it's called it just kind of starts explaining random things so you have your game components and then you go to straight and just set up all right cool then it starts explaining the tiles and nodes and then characters like I'd love it if this have a poet does it just have a table of contents but yeah it's like typical comes then it goes to equipment then the bonfire tile and what you can do there and then encounter set up and then encounters and then combat and then character activations an enemy activation and boss encounters and just like there were a lot of times roads like I'm pretty sure I read that but I cannot find it it's very weird it's not a fluid rule book now that the back is actually very very helpful to show you what all the icons mean enemy movement this makes sense the the rules kind of don't I was sitting here like what how the bosses were and then you know the boss encounters but it's like just text and I'm like okay so where where what's that mean there were a lot of times didn't like answer questions that we had like for example that small go from sorry to 45 if you don't damage him if Ornstein dies or the other way around Ornstein gains 10 health if Smok dies so
it's like okay does that mean they get 10 extra health like on top of what they normally would have so should smog has had 45 and says 30 or like I said well if he was at 10 and then sports being died then did he go up to 25 it's like I I don't know it doesn't explain something that the rules tell you how to play in a very disorganized way and then it's going to leave it at that they don't really answer any questions on how this pushing acts are work if I jump in do I choose which one like it's just pushing you didn't all you guys kind of got to see it but each note should hold three people or three models except awesome so if you have three scrubs and I jump in do I choose which one moves out it goes goes back same same way back um I know it doesn't really explain it and if it does it doesn't explain it in like a clear way so the rule book is not terrible I have had worse rule books it would not make my top 10 worst rule books let me say that but it's not the best there are conditions I should say I'm just seeing that because I saw it now they're a fortune to bleed poison Frostbite staggered and but none that seem really worth it to me because there were some items like a coke tree I think Dilton no damage believe me game please he calls new stamina and bleed when them all of that has a blade token suffers damage that suffers two additional
damage and then it goes away the bleep token goes away so it's like what's up worth it now I will say it was very fun for each of the four characters too we build ourselves a different way to nine is built to be a tank he just sits there and you saw him take me the mole - no damage the warrior was meant to dish out a lot of damage which he did and take some take a little bit in return the herald is meant to heal and have all of ranged attacks and the assassin cook sorry the assassin is meant to dodge and get to the weak spots or to get to maneuver around the board and so you can build them that way but there's no sorcerer there's no none of those but I think there's a lot of stretch goals now what do I think of the bosses in the mini boss encounters from not just doing the grinding which I did again but just by just doing the grinding when I first played it - pretty much focusing on the the bosses obviously the boss fights are way better I actually think it's a very very smart way to do boss encounters I really like the fact that each boss and many boss has their own deck of cards that you shuffle and the main bosses seem to have just enough like they have five cards that the main bosses seem to have life I think they had five cards but you removed one so it's going to be a little bit different you shovel is before they start and then it stayed like a static
deck you flip it over it's going to do these same five cards in the same order every single time until they die or until you die and I think that's brilliant I think that's very tactical to sit here and be like okay because I knew you saw it that I was like okay the next one is going to be that jumping [ __ ] move or was it the electric bonds I draw I think that's the strongest move it's going to hit everywhere around him I need to kill him before that happens because I don't think my warrior will survive that attack and so I think that's really really cool I like the fact my favorite part about it is that but right after is the arc it took a little bit to get used to I wasn't sure because some of them some of the cards actually requires them to turn 90 degrees as well but at first that's well that's the only way I something moved so I thought they were just at the entire time pocket the entire time just like oh I only make one way but I did find out they are on that whoever they're targeting before they move they turn and they move towards them and so I think it's really cool I had a lot of fun doing The Gargoyle I had a lot of fun fighting the orange and smog by far as in the video game the boss fights are the best part about this game now I'm trying to think of anything else the game does seem very complicated
whenever you first break it out say oh my god was always one of these all these icons but then like everyone caught on it was I mean very much okay you call it he moves forward once and he pushes or it pushes that he moves forward and then he's moving towards the person that is closest it makes sense the art thing was kind of hard to get used to it like so to be hit those people is the item y'see week behind it with the tail end so it doesn't it doesn't inherently say what's the front what's the back which is annoying unless it's in a diagram that I missed which I don't think is the case it's not it is I mean if you're looking at it it's like okay yes on him that's the front that's what's behind them is the back the how is it on the card stuff like that so that's what the robot fails to answer um and let's see other dolls would [ __ ] I I kind of like them in my unboxing I'm going to explain here you they put the numbers like they're not they didn't put them like all on the edge towards red but basically you can't really see it but it's like 23 is here than 24 is here and then it goes like that it goes no bigs eye pattern down the dial but it doesn't leave enough space for each number to be its own number so it's like whenever you are reading it it shows like I can see 21 20 19 but 21 and 19 are cut off so I'm like I guess it's
like that's just [ __ ] like make enough room on your damn dials to to make it make it eligible or legible in a game that's based heavily on dye rules everything is based on the rules I actually had a lot of fun I was like there were times where I was like [ __ ] die rolls but it was a Arcadia quest there wasn't time stories like it was very rarely that I was like damn but there are times where you make wrists and you're like and it pays off like it didn't hear where I was like I need to dodge otherwise he'll die and I did that successfully dodge and I was ditching out a lot of damage so he can plan well or get lucky enough in your treasure deck to get enough for your people then you'll have a fun time okay now what is my scale on a scale of 1 to 10 for this game honestly I'm probably going to have to give it a 6 out of 10 and the reason why is because like this game has about as much as I like out of it and as much as I don't like out of it so originally I'd be a 5 Luke gave the 5 he's like I there's things in years I'd really like missing here that I really hate his complaints with it were the spark and the turn order and the fact that the rule book didn't explain a whole lot pretty much the same problems of I have eating cat were pretty much the same cat
gives a 4 she don't like the fact that there was inherently hard just for the sake of being hard and yang gave the 5 for the same reasons he didn't like the fact that it is grinding a nice boring imma give it a little bit I give it a little bit higher because it I'm going to keep it and I did have a lot of fun fighting and fighting these bosses and it does give me a sense of wanting more which I will be getting in October all the stretch goals for this game will be coming on October and there's a [ __ ] ton of them they're adding summons like people that you can summon to aid you in fighting they're adding a with a column and containment okay I can't think of it but like I just had it I just this is they have a god damn it the people who can come in and fight you the visitors I guess god damn I'm so mad invaders they add their enemy betas honestly tell you everything I'm getting for Kickstarter backers were getting a cleric a Pyromancer a thief a mercenary a sorcerer and a deprived sort character expansion it's adding the pursuer sir alone silver Knight Lancers and the ball Mahler's adding treasure chest iPhones or minis barrel minis grave so many than bonfire minions of the dial
the iron keep expansion adding the smelter demon iron plus soldiers alone Sword knife alone knife captain mimics elf [ __ ] mini crystal lizards and a Lobo Knights an arbor set expansion adventurers that goldynhan Black said Black Knight set dark set like iron sets of a favor Katarina said Crimson set guard set or Guardian set and have a bowl set invaders expansion so I think these are people who actually makes their these invaders off of paladin Leroy yes armor agenda Oliver the collector fencer Sharon Meldrum the assassins both Melinda the butcher xanthus King Jeremiah and maneater Mildred Oh Kirk Knight of the thorns summon extension the cell for loop towards the hushed which Beatrice sword master saber series of the sums roam a on of care Kieran said words of Katharina and ruined alphys oh in the Luca Luigi love Meera and since we got everything we got still there about storia so that like that's a lot of [ __ ] that I'm getting for I think a $90 pledge or some like that so the base game isn't enough I don't think it's enough so that's life at six all that stuff summons there's more more main bosses all armors all this stuff could potentially bump it up to a seven or eight only if I'm
playing by myself I would give this actually probably a four or five probably a four as is a five with all that stuff with more people I had way more fun playing this by myself being able to upgrade even even controlling more people but I actually really liked playing as one character in grinding like it is in the base game and it adds some ins you can play this as a solo game and then get summons like you can in the video game I think that's way better with four people grinding it's not fun you're doing the same thing over and over for few hours it says 90 120 minutes by yourself I can see that more people he'll know so that's a [ __ ] lie so seven or eight with all the stuff solo as of right now it's a six like quarantines motor fun but you have to get lucky in your cards otherwise like what's the point so so that's it that's all that's all I got like this game I guess I'm sure that or I guess I should answer is it balanced inherently yes if the treasure deck wasn't so random then then I'd say it's a little bit more balanced but overall I think I did well but I got lucky and draws and and you get more sparks to try and get some [ __ ] so yes I think I got lucky
now I would I need to say this I really do need to say that's like I don't hate this game I do like it I would not really recommend it to anyone even if I played artful chains no it's not for you like you're going to hate it as if you're a huge fan because if no this is like the game that's true for the casual gamer know for a little hardcore gamer maybe um but all the stuff I'm getting I'm still really excited for I know I need to say this the dice tower did a review over this game and I happened to wash the dice tower I like them a lot I've never met them I spoke to Tom through BoardGameGeek and let the answer my question is very helpful so I have nothing but respect for those guys but don't take their review to heart because they have one never played the video game so they can't draw that frame of reference of what this game was suppose was aiming to be yes it's hard and it needs to be hard because the video game is [ __ ] hard and too they have these weird notions on like and everyone has their tastes like polluted I totally understand that but I don't believe you should review a game solely on your personal tastes if you know you're not going to like it don't review it and trash on it the whole time because the they were like I don't like dark games so this game is complete gathered [ __ ] like like I knew
they weren't going to like and they still review that anyway because it's like look yeah you're not going to like it so I mean if you if you agree with them then you'll probably you're not gonna like this game but if you are looking at mechanics and theme and all of it together not just one thing all of it together then that's how you should review a game so so I just I just have to say that um other than that yeah that's that's all I got that's all I can think of I feel like I've talked way too much but I think I've covered everything so six out of ten with all the stuff the most likely be high seven maybe eight maybe negative ten well probably doing no runs a review for all those expansions when I finally get them but other than that I hope you enjoy if you've played this game let me know what you think of it in the comments below or if you agree or disagree with what I said I let me know also in comes below I will debate not argue but other than that a lot comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thanks for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you want to poreless you can go ahead and click that link to go to my patreon account you have any suggestions you can go ahead and click the link in the show notes below because of my BoardGameGeek list other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of datas for you