Talking Birds in the Wingspan European expansion and Q&A - The Mill
Transcript
hello and welcome to the mill I am your host dusty crane it feels like it's been a while since I've been in front of this camera with you guys but I mean it hasn't really been that long I did have a video last week it's just earlier but I'm glad to be back hope you're glad to see the the mill pop back up in your feed one of the questions this week I kind of I took some questions from the the wingspan Facebook group and also also have been asked several times like what are you maybe the top five most powerful birds in the expansion or something like that and so I thought I'd take a little crack at it and get some answers and see what I came up with so when I was looking over and I was looking over the birds I remember the fact that you know Elizabeth kind of has a equation or something some kind of mathematical breakdown that like you know that birds are kind of worth a certain range of points or something or if if it's gonna have a star type nest then maybe it has less eggs or it's worth less victory points like some kind of balancing act to make sure that there's not any like you know just crazy bird that's like you know you pay one and it's worth you know fifteen points or something and and you know that you know something it's not way out of sorts so what I kind of looked for is not necessarily hey this bird is worth eight points cool that's that's just a one shot right there what I find most interesting is
the birds that are low value points because it typically means that you can work them into your engine or something and that's how they're going to benefit you the most so in looking through the expansion I decided to look at the birds that were zero cost in one cost because or one victory point and zero victory point net cost forget I saw that but because I figured that the victory points are going to come in another way that's maybe more interesting so the European expansion has three birds that are have zero victory points just you know out the gate that's the black red start the lesser white throw in the long-tailed tit I'm gonna try and behave myself okay I pray so the the dog doesn't believe me if you just heard her sigh you probably heard my wife sigh - I'm sure the both of them anyway so the black Redstart is a just a single habitat bird it is three food star nest four eggs the power is choose a habitat with no eggs and lay one egg on each bird in its habitat what I kind of like about this one is that you know obviously you need to plan ahead to use this bird that you would want no eggs and that habitat and then you can tension a add up to five with that one which you can kind of see then where where those victory points are coming from is you get to add you know eggs to all those birds the lesser white throat that's a - habitat bird - food so it's lower cost it's a single
nest type it's a bowl egg and you choose a habitat with no eggs only one egg on each bird and habitat so the same power is the other one the long-tailed tit is a one habitat bird it's a star net - or star nest into food and that's one of the new type that you place sideways to cover up two spots in your habitat and you pay the lower of the egg cost where I find those to be particularly interesting is in this one it's a it's a forest or woodland habitat type of bird in so that in that in the habitat you're actually gaining food so I can see as maybe early on that if you were able to get that bird early that you could go ahead and immediately jump to getting more food from the feeder would be a potential benefit there so those were the the 3-0 victory point Birds they're also seven one victory point birds and and I'm not going to go through all the titles and the habitats that they go into but I kind of looked at their powers and there was a couple of the brown powers that were a custom is seeing one of them is draw - bird cards and tuck one and keep on so that and that one is actually the into winds gull and that's draw Bird cards that's typically in the food lane so that's another one of those if you can get a ninja and you can get multiple actions out of a single row where you're you know doing something
you don't typically do so if you're in the food row and you're able to lay out eggs or you're in you know the egg row and you're able to draw bird cards you know some way to maximize those actions is what I'm looking for there and you're seeing that with that with that gull there that draw two bird cards you can go ahead and tuck one and keep one the dunnock which is this is one of those new teal power is the end of round powers you choose one other player and for each action cube and they're grass lands you lay one egg on this bird now what I liked about this was you know people talk a lot about that egg spamming strategy and if you do find yourself in a situation this bird would you know not necessarily stop them from doing that cuz they're gonna get their points but you're also gonna benefit from that so maybe that takes some of the sting away I know some people are like you've just spam and eggs and last rounds which you know bother some people this way maybe a bothers you less if you're gaining a benefit from it to the dunnock gives you that the Eurasian magpie that's another one of those teal powers where you choose one of their player for their it's the same thing as the XP the last one you know if they've you know taking actions in that grasslands you're benefiting from that too the Griffon vulture is one where it doesn't cost any food whatsoever to put it out there but you choose any one player even yourself and then you can cache food on top of it for each predator bird that you or that other player has in in place so another one of those situations where you're actually
looking to someone else and what they've done it and that's really kind of like what one of the focuses of this expansion is you can definitely see the intention on you know some people consider a negative connotation I heard people say this is just multiplayer solitaire or whatever this definitely seems like some emphasis was placed on no let's go ahead and pay more attention to what other people are doing there's more direct interaction to in terms of some of these birds allow you to you know if someone has a worm take a worm and then they can draw food from the bird feeder I saw some people upset about this too or are concerned about this too because maybe you're you know gathering food because you want to play this bird and then someone takes a food type I can understand that concern Elizabeth's found in playtesting that because they were also able to grab a food from the bird feeder maybe maybe you pivot and so instead of playing this bird they had that that worm cost or whatever now you're gonna go ahead and oh there's a berry there that's actually something that I that I wanted but it wasn't in the feed or you know there wasn't I didn't have an opportunity to grab it and now I can take it it's not gonna cost me a turn to get it and now I can play this bird you know in my final action cube or whatever so there is that focus on you know what other people are doing and what they have on their mat and so that's that's one of the things I like about this expansion a couple more of those those single victory point
Birds is one of them is draw two bird cards all other players get one now this is a bird that is in the wetlands this is Savi's Warbler so you are typically already getting bird cards in the wetlands but this is just there are several different birds that actually give you more of what you normally get out of that area so like if you play a bird in The Woodlands or in the forest there that you are getting extra food or and maybe an extra food type of a certain type so you see that in this expansion to I don't necessarily know how interesting they are but I kind of captioned it as sort of interesting stats um for all of the talk we heard or maybe we in people talking just drew attention to this but we noticed hey there's this new bird type you can lay it sideways for that having attention drawn to it it's really not prevalent in the expansion too much I mentioned there's only four birds that you can actually play sideways and the whole expansion there there's two in the forest one in the grasslands and one in the wetlands so you're not gonna you know bump into these every single game there's only five new pink power birds there's 21 of the new teal end-of-round power Birds and let's see here Oh in three of those which I find kind of interesting three of those are actually birds that allow them to count as double toward the end around goals if
they apply so if let's say you have an end round goal that says you know how many eggs on a certain bird type and this bird has you know two eggs on it well toward the end around goal goals if it's just birds with eggs then instead of counting as one bird it counts as two birds and so I found that was kind of a way to be a little bit sneaky if people aren't paying really close attention to your mat and they're not paying really close attention to your bird powers you know they might gloss right over there and be like okay well he's got two birds with with eggs you know and then you're like oh hey guess what I actually I don't you know they thought they were tied but you jumped out ahead so there's a little way to be sneaky so those are my sort of interesting facts I also did do some questions my dog is snoring really loud so if you can hear that I apologize but I did it like I mentioned asked some questions on the wingspan Facebook page so I'm just gonna go ahead and get to those Pete asked will I send him my copy now Pete instructed me to answer this with yes however I am going answer with no because I am really enjoying this and I would like to continue enjoying this sorry Pete David asked how expanded does it feel the end around goals sound cool but they won't pop up with a lot of frequency same with the sideway birds it's true that you won't see a lot of the sideway sideways birds and how expanded does it feel now this is actually a good
question because at first as I was I was looking through the cards and I was kind of trying to wrap my mind around the expansion I felt like some of it kind of felt saying me saying Z and yeah there's the end around goals which are new but like it kind of felt like you're getting the same powers and when I first got the expansion I decided I'm gonna play with just the expansion I wanted to experience the new bird cards and new powers and what I found in playing just the expansion just solo or in two-player was alone the expansion it doesn't feel same Z at all it feels it just feels like something is missing like it feels like the the only conclusion I can draw is like it felt like it was meant to be with the base card set which makes sense with it being an expansion but it doesn't feel like this was meant to stand alone it felt like it was meant to to expand upon you know the base game which I know experience all that stuff sounds funny but you know a lot of people are are thinking I'm gonna get this game and I want to play this as a standalone because you know I'm a European you know game player and I want to see all these birds and I think for a game or two that's a really fun way to learn the new birds and to learn the new powers but I do think at the end of it at the end of the game you do kind of go oh you know I
was I was really I've grown accustomed to using this particular you know if I get this bird or this type of bird in my hand then it plays really well in the grasslands or if you know you just get kind of kind of accustomed to the birds that you are familiar with seeing and so it just felt different like the powers that they that are on the cards may at first glance appear same Z but they don't feel that way at all and so does it feel expanded I I do think once you mix them all together it does and it's true that because there are so many more of the base card or the base cards that it feels like you're not bumping into those European cards super frequently I mean I don't know what the actual if it's you know one in three cards or whatever that that ratio is I didn't figure it out but I do feel like when they do come up in your normal game they're they're kind of they kind of are a welcome a welcome addition they feel like it's it's exciting to get those new mechanics and play with the existing set in consideration so I do think that this is you're going to go huh you know I don't think I see the European see a European cards as much in this game that we played but when they do come up they feel like they're exciting to get into the rotation Tim asks are there any
birds that have more than nine points and yeah the other are the house sparrow itself is worth six victory points it holds five eggs and at the end of the round you can discard up to five grain to tuck a card from the deck behind it potentially so if you were to get this bird right off the gate and you have to have five grain every single time the end of the round was up potentially that card alone is or Lizzie I figured it out here the is worth 31 points just for that one bird if you were able to take advantage every single round to the full capacity of the birds starting right from the first round now there's another bird in the in the collection that is is similar it holds it starts with five victory points it holds two eggs but this one you can discard any food type it's not just the grain and this one's a potential up to 27 victory points so getting back to that question of what I think is the most powerful bird in the expansion I'm probably going to go with that Eurasian collared dove because what I like about this bird in particular is it's an end-around goal like you can literally be sitting at the end of the at the end of the game and maybe you have a ton of extra food and you don't want to maybe get rid of all the food because that's the tiebreaker is you no amount of food you have leftover but you might be able to go ahead and I'm gonna trade you know these five in for five extra victory
points that might be you know what sets you over the edge so it doesn't seem like much but when you take into account that you can trade in any food type at the end of every round if you were to give this in the first round I think that's a pretty pretty nice benefit there so that one's about up to a potential at 27 in terms of just you know I guess the boring stat of just the point the bird is worth this many points it holds as many eggs the great tit is worth for victory points and holds six eggs so that right there is a total of 10 so you don't necessarily have to do any kind of a gameplay magic to get those numbers up above 9 Malcolm asks do the Ravens still seem as powerful yeah yeah I'd say so and not in a bad way if anything because there's more cards they're gonna come up less but I really think that the strategies that you had in for the first wingspan still apply to the expansion with the possible exception of the fact that you know now people can take advantage of your expanding strategy or you know if let's see here if what was I think you know it's going to come up less frequently but also there are yeah like I said people that are able to benefit though there's also a finally caught that train there the end of round goals the new ones that come with the
game the inter on goal tiles that there are some of them that are you know your benefit or what you're competing for is no eggs and so at the beginning of the game maybe that's easier to come by then you know birds with no eggs toward the end of the game you might have to decide or find yourself in a position where you have to go are the points that I would gain here in the final round worth it or you know am I going to go ahead and take these eggs and I take the victory points from that and and have less so that is one thing to consider there I don't think anything takes away from the power of those birds Malcolm ox also asks what's your favorite thing about EE and that I really I really do think that my favorite thing about the European expansion aside from the great new powers is it's hard there's for some reason the end-around gold tiles I've always found that those n around gold tiles I may be one of those people that gets distracted by that maybe I focus too much on it but because that is the way play the game having a new thing to focus on having all these new gold tile and around gold tiles to focus on has really kind of changed you know maybe what I'm going for from round to round Joshua asks what's new for automo and the answer is they get a couple of new gold cards that's something and they're there only for the automa which is kind of neat one of them is birds that are worth three or four points the
automa can keep up to two of them the other one is birds their goal is birds that are worth five six or seven victory points now thankfully they only keep one of those but it is a having these goals for the automa is a nice change at first I was like wow these are really powerful and then when I got to thinking about it that the alternative is you know they're getting a face down card which is probably worth for victory points anyway if you're playing on normal mode so it's it's not a huge shift but those are those are nice goal cards that's a nice change and then it's not really a change for the automa of the automa does also get a couple of new scoring cards which just you know for each goal reach round tells you you know where they currently stand for that goal so these new end-of-round powers are birds in one row filled columns birds with tucked cards white or no powers birds with greater than four victory points food in your personal supply bird cards in hand birds with no eggs brown powers or food costs of played birds and so you know it's funny like just adding a few and around gold cards it does feel like a very different game a wingspan at least it did for me Joshua asks what bird would you put on the cover if you won the charity auction that's actually a good opportunity for me to mention that so
admire every year does a charity auction and it goes up in November Jamie will announce who those me goes to contra content creators that he likes and in asks them what cause would they like to donate to and he usually has a product that he auctions off last year I think it was the full set of the metal mechs and I don't remember what it was the the year before but in any case this year it's wild it is a it's a copy of wingspan which obviously most of us probably have but it's a custom cover you get to choose the birds that are on the cover and are on the outside edges of the box so that is super cool to keep with Joshua's question the what bird would you put on the cover and that is a hard one I know you're you're thinking he's gonna say a pretty bird and I understand why you'd say that because that seems to be my answer to what what's your favorite bird I know it's one of the pretty ones I think I was kind of drawn between a couple in and it shouldn't be any surprise that they are pretty birds but I really there's and and I meant to grab the card and so I could say it but there's one it's a very deep blue it's not a blue bird but it's it's really pretty I like that one I also really really like the the Kingfisher that's in the the new
expansion but the bald eagle was my dad's favorite bird there's been bald eagles around my house you know drawings or paintings or sculptures that my dad had bought statues so I kind of think that if I did win the auction I think it would probably I think I'd go with the sentimental choice and I think I'd go with bald eagle but I would have pretty birds all around inside of the box I promise you that let's see the final question Josh asks is what birds would have to leave the game if you know if affected by brexit no birds birds do not acknowledge or adhere to the laws of man so every bird is staying that's that's just all there is to it and that is all there is to this week's episode of the middle that went longer than I was expecting but I just I've I've really enjoyed the European expansion I enjoyed talking about it you may have seen there's a PDF out there that shows every bird and the expansion that's powers what birds I'll go ahead and toss them in the show notes to what birds are you most excited to play with now that then she just come out or maybe which power or which type that has been announced it looks the most fun to you I look forward to hearing from you and we will talk to you again next week take care of yourself
and take care of each other thanks for watching bye