Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is Warhammer Still the MOST GRIMDARK?

Transcript 12:10

in this video I'll tell you about three things that are becoming more Grim dark than Warhammer if you've been in the miniature wargaming hobby for a while and especially if you've played some Warhammer then you've probably heard the term Grim dark thrown around Grim dark is by definition a genre of fiction especially fantasy fiction side note here fantasy is in contrast to say like historical fiction right so by saying fantasy here they mean sci-fi you know and fantasy and cyber Punk and all the stuff in between uh characterized by disturbing violent or Bleak subject matter and a dystopian setting according to Wikipedia the term was inspired by the tagline for Warhammer 40,000 in the Grim darkness of the far future there is only War Adam Roberts a British sci-fi and fantasy novelist describes it more as fiction where nobody is Honorable and might is right and he also believes that Grim dark storytelling is designed to convey the sense that our own world is a kind of cynical disillusioned ultraviolent place all this completely tracks with the creation of Warhammer 40,000 in the UK of the 1980s from what I understand it was a rough time over there and it spawned the idea of grim dark fiction and art that we know today but as with many inventions it's

outgrowing and surpassing its inventor though Warhammer 40,000 in 2025 is still mostly Grim dark in story and lore and that kind of stuff especially the nobody is Honorable and you know might is right parts it's surprisingly clean and parade ready when compared to most other things that we consider Grim dark today as far as the visuals of the models even like way back in the old days of the 19 1980s the models that GW would show off were you know pretty clean and frequently bright colors one could say neither Grim nor dark especially today the box art images that the Warhammer Studio produces are surgically clean you could eat off the paint jobs of every model that you see even chaos models speaking of chaos I would say that nurgle models are the closest to what we generally think of these days when we think of grim dark but still they're very different from what we see when we search the word grim dark on Instagram for example in 2025 I'd argue that Grim dark starts where Warhammer left off and has taken it into a really interesting Direction now I'm going to talk about three things here that I think are surpassing perhaps evolving is a nicer word uh the Grim dark that was you've probably heard of them but perhaps not but there are three different newer interpretations of grim dark that I feel really brings something to the table uh

two of them are wargaming related but one is a video game that really struck me as being a perfect distillation of where Grim dark is going these days and it's not a Warhammer video game of which I've played many first is the new miniature Skirmish game called trench Crusade which you've probably heard of at this point there's been a lot of videos about it and its massively successful Kickstarter at the end of 2024 including even a video by me Pia it's an alternate history game where the Crusades of the 11th and 12th centuries just never ended a portal to Hell had opened in Jerusalem uh due to a bunch of things that happened and whatnot and you know then Crusades Crusades Crusades and now it's 1914 and the war has raged this entire time the forces of Hell versus the forces of the church you'll notice I didn't say the forces of good the lore and setting is the epitome of grim dark the war has been raging for 800 plus years and it doesn't look like there'll be any chance of it stopping anytime soon like I said there isn't really a cut and dried like good guys versus bad guys narrative either the the forces of hell are certainly bad you know but the trench pilgrims and even the principality of new Antioch aren't exactly good either they're definitely playing defense right trying to protect Earth from the heretic forces coming through the portal and all that but they're doing it in some morally odd way ways let's just say look up the metac Christ program if you want to find out

more but it's not just the story and the way it handles religious themes that's Ultra Grim dark it's also the visuals from what I understand trench Crusade was a visual idea before it was a game Mike franina a concept artist on a bunch of the Diablo video games from blizzard started making illustrations and messing around building the world in his head it wasn't until later that other folks like Thomas pan a designer of morheim another very Grim dark title got involved and brought the game to where it is today and the visuals range from some Darkly beautiful images to downright brutal ones but more of them lean towards the latter than the former it is a brutal time for all sides of the conflict constant War for the last 800 plus years has brought about some technologies far ahead of where you know we were in the real 1914 but this centuries long conflict has also ruined the Earth in many different ways and mere survival is the best case scenario of many people born to this time to be a pilgrim in trench Crusade is to die there's simply a lot more blood in the imagery of trench Crusade When comparing it to today's Warhammer also many more severed hands as well um I suspect that Warhammer can't go as Grim dark these days in comparison to trench Crusade for example because they're such a big corporate intellectual ual property shareholders probably aren't very much

into the level of exposed viscera that some of these visuals portray so trench Crusade can go really hard on the visuals and the sculpts and really bring the new levels of grim dark as I mentioned earlier though Warhammer brought about the concept of grim dark the box art paint jobs of Warhammer models have never really seemed particularly Grim or grimy you know or dark to me especially these days the paint jobs are clean and perfect in most situations but if you see what Instagram creators and viewers consider Grim dark you'll see a very different visual language on display and one of my favorite purveyors of the Grim dark aesthetic are the folks over at Grim dark compendium Grim dark compendium is a YouTube channel that's mostly all tutorials about how to paint in the Grim dark style and when they say Grim dark they mean it dark oil washing and enamel washes added texture and physical grit on the models distressing the surface of the model all that kind of stuff the figures from Grim dark compendium really look proper Grim dark when I think of the term these days their channel is full of tutorials about how to paint in the Grim dark style and I'd say it's far more adherent to the term than Warhammer paint jobs are these days what's interesting is that most of the models that grimart compendium Paints in their tutorials are Warhammer models models they just end up looking very different at the end of those tutorials in

comparison to the box art on the Warhammer website the overall look is dim and grimy and in many cases desaturated very little in the way of like bright colors there's no bright blues or yellows and in many cases disturbing visuals and filth that can be kind of unsettling to look at in my mind this is what Grim dark is supposed to look like and Grim dark compendium has taken even further than just tutorials last year they released their own line of enamel washes called villain Inc it's a range of colors with names like goon's Grime and decay of death and ior of the Damned all darker colors of enamel wash designed to be applied to your kind of bass painted models and then left to dry for 15 or 20 minutes or whatever and then wiped away basically painting as a reductive process you're putting it on and then taking away like in the highlights but keeping all the little crevices and grungy areas and stuff like really nice and dark and whatnot this allows you to leave behind as much or as little Grim dark on your model as you'd want I really enjoy working with enamel washes it gives a much more interesting and gritty look to my Miniatures lastly there's a video game I came across recently I learned about it on YouTube and the visuals and the play style really intrigued me especially because of how extremely grim dark it is it's called Forever winter which is a very Grim dark title of course and it's a

unique type of extraction shooter that I haven't seen before there's a massive sci-fi war going on between two ultra powerful forces and you as the player are not on either side you're a scavenger just a weak human hiding in the cracks between and trying to survive everything in the world of forever winter is ruined nothing is clean or shiny it's like kind of a post-apocalyptic world except that no one told the soldiers and the giant mechs and the drones so they just keep fighting after the Apocalypse in many situations the two main forces pretty much just straight up ignore you if they come across you on the battlefield because you're not a threat and they've got bigger problems than you however if you cause too much trouble trying to scaven for clean water and food and stuff like that and maybe you you know shoot a little bit at a couple of drones or whatever they will then decide that you're now a threat and they'll take appropriate action this game fits true Grim dark so well the visuals are spoton with the destroyed Landscapes and grim and gritty color pallet and the Monstrous troops and war machines but also in the story as well there's no good guys and your entire winning strategy is to try and gather the castoff things that you need for survival and get out of the level extract if you will alive you're not there to win the war or save the world like in most Shooters you're there to try and gather a few things to prolong

your wretched life a little bit longer and not get blown up in the process Grim dark might be something that Games Workshop invented or at least inspired but nowadays Warhammer isn't the Pinnacle of grim dark if anything I'd say that Warhammer becomes a bit less Grim dark every year now aays there's a lot of games and settings and novels and comics and Painters that are far more grimo dark so if you're interested in checking out what Grim dark is I'd tell you to start with the stuff that I talked about in this video and see where it takes you from there do you think that Warhammer is still the peak of grim Darkness do you want to see even more Grim dark content or is grim dark starting to go kind of over the line for you maybe it should be called something else now I don't know let us all know what you think down in the comments below and while you're down there in the Grim dark comments some Grim dark deprecation of the like button would brighten my day and help out the channel and if you want to see more videos every single Friday hit the Subscribe button down there as well it's free thanks for watching he

Progress saved