Skip to main content
Loading video...

What are Carolyn Fern's Strengths and Weaknesses? (Arkham Horror: The Card Game)

Transcript 18:41

Hello everybody and welcome to strengths and weaknesses. We are here nearing the end of the first season. I hope you've been enjoying this. I also find it fun to watch which investigators get more views than other investigators in this series. Turns out you guys freaking love Zoey Samaras. Her video did freaking great. So let's roll another Zoey Samaras like investigator. If we get someone that we already rolled before, we are going to reroll. That's the rule of this. So let's see who we're going to be talking about today.

Okay, Zoey. Not so fast. You already had your time in the sun. I'm sorry, Zoey. Not again. That's kind of crazy, two weeks in a row. Nice try, Zoey. Carolyn Fern, okay. Okay, Carolyn Fern. 3 4 2 2 As a reaction, after one of your card effects heals horror from an investigator or ally asset, the healed card's controller gains one resource. Elder sign effect plus one, you may heal one horror from an investigator or ally asset at your location. Deck size is 30. Deck building guardian 0 to 3, neutral 0 to 5, cards that heal horror level 0 to 5, up to 15 other seeker and or mystic cards 0 to 1.

We are going to also quickly look at her signatures. So we have hypnotic therapy. Exhausted as an action, test book two. If you succeed, heal one horror from an investigator at your location. Then that investigator may draw one card. As a reaction, after one of your other card effects heals horror from an investigator, exhaust hypnotic therapy. That effect heals one additional horror. [snorts] Additionally, we also got rational thought, which is not really a weakness and something that should be celebrated, but unfortunately in the world of Arkham Horror, having rational thought doesn't really cut it. This is a revelation, but rational thought is a plane your threat area with four horror on it. If horror is on a horror on rational thought may be healed as if it were on Carolyn Fern.

If there is no horror on rational thought, discard it. You cannot heal horror from cards other than rational thought. You cannot gain resources from Carolyn Fern's ability. So, this is essentially going to eat four of your heals and not give you the resource bonus that is associated with it. So, I'm going to actually just be real with all of you here for a second cuz I'm actually I'm having a hard time thinking about weaknesses for Carolyn Fern. Because I don't think Carolyn Fern is essentially like a a busted investigator. Like I wouldn't even say she's like super amazing, but she does a really good job of like just functioning well without not necessarily being um not necessarily being too great or like too bad. She is just very good. So, we're going to have to take some time on this one. This one like buckle up. I'm just saying this might be a longer one.

But I know what her two strengths are, right? And I think that is this this should be pretty pretty easy. Phenomenal uh team so support for the team and herself. Um so, the ability to just heal horror on people is really nice. But you really only want to be healing horror if you're getting some sort of effect in addition to that horror, right? Like healing horror we often say here at PBG, like healing is basically just like not losing as opposed to winning, right? And you generally want to win over not lose, right?

[clears throat]

So, uh healing horror is just a way to not necessarily get ahead of the game. It's just kind of there doing its thing. But, Carolyn takes that idea and says, "What if we got some resources out of it, right?" And it's not limited, so whenever anytime I'm doing healing, if I'm doing burst healing, it works really well as as an addition. Being able to just deal out a bunch of cash, which I think is really, really nice to just have. It's like the horror healing is good, but it's the fact that you're just kind of giving resources to your teammates or alternatively just to yourself with Carolyn Fern is what makes it so good. Like, the ability looks like I'm a healing investigator, but what it really is is saying is like, "I'm going to round out your economy, so you're able to get ahead." And then what you do is now you look at anytime you take horror from whether it be from your own effect or alternatively an effect from like the mythos phase or an enemy, you're going to look at that a little bit differently, which I think is very, very powerful.

Uh another strength for her is uh incredibly open deck building. Uh probably the most open. Less like I mean like I think there's there's definitely arguments that um uh like Charlie and uh Lola and uh the first one for strengths and weaknesses, Suzy, is like um really good for um Sorry. [clears throat] Like with the most open deck building, and I think that's fair. Like, I think that this is like probably the most open like do I have brackets to put in here for class, not floor.

For class cuz neutrals aren't a class, right? It's one of those things where uh I'll read her deck building again. Guardian 0 to 3, neutral 0 to 5, cards that heal horror 0 to 5, up to 15 other seeker or mystic cards level 0 to 1. It's very much like uh she's kind of a tri-class investigator. And Vincent Lee is very similar. I'm glad that they kind of mirry uh mirrored uh Vincent and Carolyn so well because I think it works really well because of that. But like you're basically half of your deck is mystic seeker. So you're kind of like guardian 0 to 3, but the cards that heal can be a lot of things as well. It can go into even rogue. It can go into survivor, right? She is kind of just like a a multi-class investigator. She's kind of like neutral asterisk. And it makes it so that there's a lot of cool builds that you can do with her. Um and I think that that is very nice.

She's a great investigator for those things, and she's also a surprisingly competent clue-er. Um and there's some people in chat talking about like how the stat line I mean like the six dam like the six health is interesting. She gets an extra stat point, too, man. Like that's kind of crazy. I think it's cuz her ability is so dependent on like support that they wanted to give her a bit more. But the reality is a lot of excuse [clears throat] me a lot of the cards that heal horror also end up um also healing damage, right? A lot of the good ones also do that.

Like there are some exceptions, but and you just give her Peter Sylvester, and then she's also just like fine. She has plus one health sanity and minus one on the stat line. That makes sense. Uh, but again, I don't think I I don't think that's a Carolyn weakness. What is a weakness for Carolyn?

I was going to say like less control over your ability. But there's like a lot of ways in mystic to take horror.

Like she can play that new uh soul link card or whatever it is, the the triple wild pip that takes a horror. She could put it on Peter Sylvester and then gain a resource. That seems so good. Getting caught up in healing instead of progressing the game. Actually, Holly Helicopter, I think that's a great weakness. Um, I think it is more pilot error, but I think that is a good point. Uh, can get a little lost in the healing sauce. That's what we'll say. I think that that is uh Is she actually good in two player? Yeah, she is. She is. She's a great cluever.

Enemies are hard for her, no weapons, no evasion. I don't think, but she's I don't think she's designed to fight enemies. So, I think that's okay. I It might That might I mean, it might be It might be, but she also could just like take toe to toe and just kill a small enemy, which is pretty good. Um, yeah, [clears throat] actually, I think that's potentially I'm going to do as well. I'm Corona. I think that's a good one. Um, can get a little lost in the healing sauce. So, that's a very weird thing to say. You're like, "What the hell does that even mean?"

So, what I mean by this is that um you It is kind of like up to learning the investigator and like figuring out the right numbers. She can be hard to approach the deck building because it is so open and you could find yourself for example, taking too many cards that heal and not enough cards that like deal you horror or allow you to take horror. So there could be situations where you are playing the game and you have no horror marked on you and you're looking at a handful of healing cards and you need to just make sure that you're finding that balance. So I guess what I'm going to put is like um like So I'm just going to say like I want to just So we're going to we're going to get rid of lost in the healing sauce and deck building Carolyn can be hard to refine. We're going to go with that. I think that's kind of a better thing that we got here, right?

Uh it's it's one of those things where um she can like because the deck building so open you need to find the right balance of cards that heal horror, cards that advance the game and cards that um like take horror. Like I think you need to find that good balance, right? Um and I think that that can be a really big thing to kind of figure out. So if you're just going to dive into Carolyn, uh it can be hard to like really figure out what that balance is for what you need to do because you do need to be able to do things. You can't just like look at you can't just like look at just horror healing. It's you need to do more and especially in two players finding that balance is even tougher. It is super easy to play like she's a fantastic cluever. She has she is like I know there's some people's like uh there's um there's questions about how do you like like you do just take her as a full cluever? Yeah, she's half seeker, right?

She's half seeker, give her two magnifying glasses and a Dr. Milan Christopher and she's investigating at seven, right? Give her the card draw to find it, it's no problem. And again, this is where it becomes that the deck building can be very hard to refine, to find that balance between ability and um ability and the uh the do something. And I do think that she did get good cards from the Carolyn set, right? Anything that can heal horror from that new Carolyn set she can now take advantage of. And also the cards that deal horror are also very nice with her as well. So, I think that she has uh a very hard balance when it comes to um figuring out the figuring out how to um make the perfect deck. It can be very tough for that.

Huh.

[sighs]

Okay. The other weakness. What is Carolyn's other weakness? The weakness is certainly annoying. You don't like seeing that. We can't talk about her old signatures because there those are kind of tough. We It's actually funny. She is with Vincent and we had both Vincent and Carolyn for this. She's better than Vincent, right? Yeah, I think she is better than Vincent. I think Vincent has more decks, but I think that Carolyn is stronger than Vincent. Um I was going to say like I mean it's potentially this. I think I'm going to go with but uh on Corona said in chat. I think it is the weakness to go here. Um Again, this kind of comes down to the deck building. There's so much for this, but like it's it's like again, finding that balance.

But I think it's I think I'm going to change this. I'm going to I'm going to go like No, but this is still also the deck building can be hard to refine. Oh, man. So, it's like the idea of you don't want to you can fall into a trap. Uh I'm going to just put this can fall into an economy trap.

Uh no, I think that's still I'll explain what that is for the people watching. This is a hard one to come up with a weakness because again, she is just so like balanced. Um so the economy trap is like the idea of I'm I can produce resources with my ability. I'm going to have be able to pay for all my cards. But what if you don't find the cards that heal and you find all the cards that do the thing, right? But I think that kind of falls more into the refining one here.

[snorts]

More setup time required, but I think that's also pretty common, but that is probably the one I'm thinking of the most. I just want to even be like I I think we're going to kind of go with like a like in addition, like uh with that. So, deck-building can be hard to refine and uh can provide tricky board states to to assess and move through. Uh again, I think that I'm trying to get like what I think is like specific weaknesses. I don't want to just be like she's Guardian and she has low health, right? I don't want to like just spit that out. So, I'm going to go with can provide tricky board states to assess and move through.

And this is kind of on the um the deck-building can be hard to refine but in action. And I think this is also kind of um kind of what Corona was saying, which is like take some time to get started. So, what I mean by tricky board states to assess and move through, let's just say for example, let's compare this to like Daisy Walker, right? Daisy Walker, you put a tome into play, you activate the tome, right? Um and like that's your game. And then when that tome's activated, you investigate and move, right? But Carolyn, it's like, do I heal here? Do I grab clues here? Do I play this card? Do I set up my board? Do I have to figure all this? Do I follow this person? Do I heal you? Do I heal you? Do I heal myself? Do I even heal this turn, right? So, yeah.

Uh what Brainy and chat said this much more elegantly than I did, which is higher complexity or skill baseline for players to build and pilot. I think that to me, they're kind of the same thing and they're kind of a mirror of each other, but I do think that weak the weak biggest weakness that Carolyn has is that new players will bring her and then will find that she is hard to build and then when they bring this deck because it was hard to build, they'll find it hard to play. I think like when you have experience with Carolyn Fern or understanding the tempo and flow of Arkham, she's a very, very powerful investigator, can do a lot of things very well, but I think it does take some time to get there. This is a consequence of her incredibly open deck building cuz as I mentioned, she is kind of a tri-class investigator, but not really.

And then that can be very hard to balance because while she is a phenomenal support, you have to also be pushing the game forward even as a support. You can't just heal horror and expect the team to win as a three-player or four-player game. You want to still actually be impacting the board. And also as I mentioned, don't get economy locked, don't assume that her ability is going to help you out and round out your economy because if you draw your deck awkwardly, that's a good way to fall behind. Carolyn Fern is a fantastic investigator and I'm very glad to see her on this. I think that she's an interesting mirror to um Vincent Lee. Again, I think Vincent Lee is more open and a bit more interesting with the deck building that provides, but I think Carolyn is just generally stronger because resources are very good. Everyone wants resources. Thanks for watching, everybody. That was another strengths and weaknesses. We only have a few more left until this is done. So, thanks for watching, everybody. Have a good one. And as always, a GG's.

Progress saved