71 Ways to Become a Better Game Designer
Transcript
all right so you want to be a better game designer but how do you do that like what are some actionable steps you can take to design great games that people love actually what are 71 actionable steps you can take let's talk about it number one know your why why are you making this game why do you think it needs to exist why should it be brought to Market is that is that something you want to do do you want to publish this game and create a product or is this something just for fun just an enjoyable artistic exercise for you to play or you and your family you and your friends you and your dog whatever but why does this game need to come out of you and if it's going to be something you want to turn into a product that's going to create some different choices some different things you have to figure out versus a game that you're designing just for fun just for something to do maybe something to relieve stress I used to do that a lot of of just designing games to kind of get away from all the craziness of the world and there's really no wrong answer it just depends on what you want to do and so determining that pretty early on can be very very helpful in the game design process number two find the fun what is the best part of your game what are the main things that really create that enjoyable experience for players the way I look at it I'm not trying to create a game I'm trying to create a fun engine that players put time in and it bounces around the engine and they get fun out on the other side and that's super helpful when I'm figuring out okay do I want to add this or cut this or what mechanism and theme all those choices really come down to what creates the
best most fun experience and so figuring that out as early as you can but you know it doesn't matter if it comes middle or late as well but then leaning into what are the funnest best parts of this game and then let's get rid of all the other stuff number three focus more on the player experience than the theme or the mechanisms a lot of times people get so bogged down with being very specific about okay I want to have this mechanic this mechanism the way the game works or I need this very specific theme or thematic idea and then they miss the overall experience that they're actually trying to create for the players so for instance if you're trying to make a game about Cthulhu right do you want the players to feel like they're slowly going insane and they're just trying to solve a mystery before going crazy or do you want them to feel powerful and they're running around shooting Cthulhu in the face with a shotgun because those are two very different experiences and then the Thematic ideas the the game mechanisms everything that comes off of that is going to be very different and so focusing early on especially but then kind of figuring it out through play testing which we'll talk more about in a minute how does this all come together for a cohesive experience and the sooner you figure that out the sooner you kind of understand that if you have that idea going in it makes game design so much easier but how do you want players to feel and then add all the other cool stuff after that number four begin with the end in mind how do you win what creates the end state of the game what brings the game to an ultimate end are you wanting the players to feel powerful or you wanting them to feel smart or better than their friends because they
were able to understand the combos of the game and the way the engine was being built but what ends the game and how the players accomplish whatever ultimate goal there is you don't necessarily have to know this at the beginning but the sooner that you know it the easier everything else gets because now everything you do can point to the end game and can kind of push play players motivate them in different ways to get to that end game that somebody wins or everybody loses depending on what kind of game you're creating but figure that out as early as you can what's the end how do people win number five explain the game to somebody in two minutes or less and if you can't it's probably too complicated it's probably not something that people are really going to resonate with because if people don't understand they typically don't buy it they typically don't want to spend their time or energy or effort on it and so what is your game what's it about think of it as a pitch or like the hook that draws people in and if you're going to create a game that goes to Kickstarter or is on a store shelf somewhere you gotta do it quick and preferably in like one sentence maybe two you know use the visuals whatever that you're going to use for marketing but you got to be able to explain it quickly draw people in for them to go oh that sounds like something I want to play I want to buy I want to check out and if you can't cut some things out or at least figure out a better way to say it number six less is more a lot of times new designers think oh I've got a problem I should solve it by adding more I should add more rules I should have add more complications more things going on but actually the opposite is typically true what can you take away what rules can you get rid of what entire systems are just really not that
fun or not that necessary for the game cut them out less is more the more stuff you have in the game the more rules you have the thicker the rule book is the less likely people are to buy it now this isn't always the case there are plenty of Euro games out there that take three hours to play Twilight Imperium takes eight hours to play and people love it but those are the exceptions to the rule and please don't ever think you're going to be the outlier it's probably not going to happen and so what can you cut out of your game what can you do to make it more succinct fewer rules fewer edge cases just cut things out less is more number seven kind of follows up with number six and don't add too many new things to a game design for example Dominion Dominion is a deck builder that's all it is there's no board there's no pieces there's nothing else going on all you do is build a deck because at the time that had never really been done before at least not in that way and so it was very new people had to get used to it get you know figure it out now you can have a deck builder with a million other things going on and there are pretty plenty of examples of that but if you're going to create a game that's kind of new and people aren't really sure about it the mechanism is an interesting one it hasn't really been done before that's enough that's that's plenty for players to figure out so don't keep adding adding adding again less is more but don't add too many new things at the same time or just don't keep stacking up complication because again it's just a lot for players to understand a lot of rules to learn so yeah keep it simple again number eight learn from every bad design you are going to make some really
terrible games you're gonna have some really bad ideas it's just part of the process every game designer goes through it don't feel bad don't feel like oh I'm not any good at this even though you're probably not yet you know honestly you develop taste long before you develop skill in other words you know what is good long before you can create anything good and that's the same with everyone no matter who you are no matter what art form you're into you have to start the process as a beginner that's not any good and eventually over time you get better the trick is just don't stop don't quit just keep going and make sure you learn from every mistake every bad idea every bad design and make sure you take the good out of those bad ideas and kind of put them on the shelf and come back to them later I can't tell you how many times I've been working on a game run into a problem and realized oh I figured out the answer to this a year ago in that game that was trash but I can take that one idea out of that bad game applied to this new game and all of a sudden I've got something interesting number nine reuse what works one thing you'll you'll notice about really good game designers designers with lots of games on the market a lot of times they'll kind of have a similarity they'll use a very similar mechanism or they'll use a different way to look at the same mechanism and it may makes sense they've gotten really good at that thing and then they just have new ideas about ways to turn it to different angles and try it in different ways and so you can do the same thing if if you're really good at designing building games then make deck building games like don't feel like you have to prove something or you have to do something else just for whatever reason to show
that you're an actual legit games who cares it doesn't matter reuse what works learn from other people their game designs reuse things that they they use what are the games that you enjoy what are those mechanisms and themes and all the ideas for the player experience how can you reuse that put your own spin on it look at it from a different angle and create something new there are no new ideas really that's truly Picasso said I know a good idea when I steal one basically right that there's new light no new ideas you just kind of borrow from other people and create new ways to look at things number 10 get out of the echo chamber what that means is don't just listen to people who know you and like you and are friends with you your mom your dog again get out and find other people to play your game with to play their game to play other published games you know complete strangers people you're not really in the same wavelength with in life like different kinds of people learn from them they're going to have different ideas they're going to have different mindsets different reasons why they play games they're going to experience your experience differently and that's super helpful super super important and so make sure you're not just kind of bogged down listening to people who are only going to tell you good things and are actually going to go hey this sucks and give you some ideas about why find those people find people that will tell you the truth constructively in a loving way obviously not not someone that's just going to be mean to you because they're insecure but someone that actually cares enough to go hey I don't think this is very good let's let's maybe try something else but it's super helpful to find those people
and then just surround yourself with people that tell you the truth number 11 get involved with a game design Community don't try to just do this on your own in isolation there are some amazing online online communities where you can find like-minded people people who are also designing games who can offer advice and give you ideas and then you can help them as well I know a lot of people are afraid that someone's going to steal their idea that they're going to go make a million dollars off of your hard work in all of your effort but it doesn't really happen especially in the board game Space people are pretty open and honest about things and that's actually for the best and just always remember the old saying if you want to go fast go alone if you want to go far go together right find other people that can help you that you can bring on board that you can help them everybody wins when you're involved with their community and let me recommend the board game Design Lab Facebook Community it's the best game Design Group on the internet tons and tons of people it's encouraging it's it's just an amazing group of folks that will help you design great games that people love number 12 go to game design conventions and meetups there are a ton of conventions called unpub and there's Proto Spiel and there's all sorts of local meetups there's lots of places where you can get out of your house take your game with you sit down with other designers and other people that are there to play test designs that aren't done yet everybody knows that going in so you can have some pretty good feedback they're not expecting this to be a fully polished fully you know ready to go published game but it oh you learn so many amazing
things not only by having people play test and check out your game but by you being in the atmosphere networking with people and then playing and play testing their games it's going to give you ideas you're going to be able to help them vice versa go find a convention a meet-up if you don't have any in in your area start one get online meetups and you know different websites where you can create those things get the word out Post online go into forums and say hey this is where I live anybody want to get together let's get some lunch let's get some coffee let's play test each other's games let's get better trust me you'll become a much better game designer because of it number 13 don't get mad if you have an ugly baby everybody's got ugly babies when it comes to heart some people have a good babies when it comes to babies but hopefully that's not true but anyway uh your game is going to have ugly Parts it's gonna have things that don't belong that need to be cut out and when people let you know that don't get mad about it say thank you it's a wonderful thing to find out it's like finding out you know part of you has cancer and then the surgeon's like hey you got cancer we should cut it out hopefully you don't get mad at the surgeon in that moment and if you do there's probably some other issues going on and so again kind of let go of the insecurity let go of this as a child this is not your child okay this is not your identity this is something that you have created that you want other people to play and enjoy and so part of that process of making it the best it can be is to hear criticism and to get feedback that's negative and to look at things go this is kind of bad and either put it on the shelf or is there a way to make it better fix it cut things out maybe change some things around and make it
the experience that you really and truly want it to be and when you get that negative feedback just remember chew the meat spit out the bones you know take in the good and the bad and kind of figure out what makes the most sense and then go from there number 14 and along those same lines don't get upset don't begrudge Publishers who reject your game if your goal is to get the game published in and out on the market and you submit it to different Publishers and they send it back and say hey it's not what we're looking for or sometimes they'll even give you feedback and say hey this is why it's got these issues this is what we notice we're not looking for this theme or this idea or this experience right now don't get upset don't write an angry email don't write an email that even like tries to defend your game like oh well you played it wrong and this that and the other if they did maybe send that in and go ahead well actually you know here's the feedback you gave me but I feel like maybe you played it wrong maybe the rule set I sent in what it wasn't as clear maybe we can have a quick conversation but I can't tell you how many times I've had people send me messages and talk to me in real life as a publisher and doesn't do them any favors right it doesn't make me go oh I really want to work with this person who's yelling at me and so remember you're not only selling a game you're and a lot of ways selling yourself and so don't say things don't send messages that are angry or super defensive or like hey you didn't do it right if you want to maybe reach out to that publisher again because maybe this game isn't right for them but the next one is and so don't mess things up now because it's going to mess things up in the future so again reach out to Publishers for sure submit your games to be published but when they send
criticism they send feedback or they reject you just say thanks for checking it out I'll talk to you again later number 15 along those same lines seek to understand if someone is giving you feedback if they're giving you criticism don't get defensive don't get upset I've heard one game designer actually he beats this by anytime he sits down with a play with a group of play testers he'll say hey a friend of mine designed this game and he asked me if I would help him get it play tested and so we're gonna sit down we're gonna play it if you have any feedback any criticisms any ideas then just let me know and I'll relay it to my friend because now people feel more open they feel like they can be a little more honest about the game and their experience and the flaws and things that they're seeing or playing and they don't feel like they're hurting anybody's feelings because to their knowledge the designer is not at the table and so that can be a little dangerous so be aware of that like make sure you have the security and the self-confidence to do that first of all but second of all maybe that's not an idea you can try to get the best feedback out of your players but just seek to understand again don't get defensive don't get super upset just hear what people have to say listen to it use what's good discard the rest and go from there number 16 realize that perception is reality when players ultimately open your game and your box and they sit down to play it you're probably not going to be there to explain what you were trying to do and so you have to understand that and so when you're play testing when things are going on and people are having a certain experience don't tell them they're wrong because they're probably not and it's
going to be way worse if the game ever does come out in a published form and so realize that when you're when you're playing your game designing your game whatever the perception is that's the truth whether it's actually correct based on what you are attempting to do what you're trying to do it's really about the perception so design and change things accordingly number 17 don't talk bad about other people in the industry unless it's super warranted now if there's some really bad behavior someone's doing something saying something that's legitimately just wrong and needs to be called out and people need to be held accountable by all means go for it but in general try not to create drama with people especially if it's just based on like their political beliefs unfortunately a lot of people in various Industries have been captured by their ideology and so if you follow them on Twitter or Facebook anything like that you're going to see a lot of stuff that they post that maybe you completely disagree with but especially if it has nothing to do with what you're actually connected by like if it's if it has nothing to do with game design or the publishing industry or anything like that if it's something about human rights in One Direction or the other like you have to really weigh out like is it worth engaging with this person that you vehemently disagree with because ultimately maybe that undercuts you later on right so if you have a big disagreement with someone you get online and you you have to make sure they know how wrong they are and they're going to return the favor and they're going to do everything they can to make sure you know how wrong you are what do you gain I mean you've wasted a lot of time you waste a lot of energy you're not going to change their mind and if they happen to be a gatekeeper which a lot of these like really ideologically based people sometimes are then maybe you're ending
up keeping yourself out of something not because of anything in the industry not because of your design skills or because of your game being good or not but because you disagree on some other thing and so just be aware of that like is it worth it to engage with people for things not game design game publishing related my answer is probably not so let things go let people believe different things and and you know if you get to know them in real life have that conversation one-on-one over lunch one day doing it online on the internet might actually mess you up more than it helps number 18 know your customer Avatar so if you want to get your game published if it's going to be for a specific group of people a certain demographic whether it's families or solo Gamers whatever it is know who that person is that you're aiming at and what I like to do is actually write it down write down Steve and Steve is 32 years old and he's got three kids and he only has 30 minutes a week to play a solo game and so and this is kind of experience he wants like it's so helpful so beneficial in designing the game overall when you can look at your customer as a real person and then design with that person in mind it makes a lot of choices easier it gives you a decision filter and a lot of ways that every time you have a new idea new choice or a new decision for the design you can filter it through that person through that demographic through that Avatar and then make a choice based on that it makes things so much easier know who your game is for and why number 19 build an email list I know social media is is flashier I know there's even a
video and all the things you can do with social media but there's still nothing better marketing wise than an email list even if you want to get your game published by someone else you're going to pitch it to a publisher and they're going to do all the manufacturing and the marketing all that even still if you can build up an email list around your game around you as a designer or anything that's going to help so much later on when you're actually trying to sell your game it also will help you get the game published like if you go to a publisher and you say hey I've got this game idea here's how it works and then you also say I've got a thousand people on an email list that are interested in this game that want to buy it whenever it becomes available that makes you a much better person to to bring on to publish your game that makes you much more marketable because the publisher realizes hey we're starting with a thousand people we're starting ahead we're not starting from scratch starting at zero we're already ahead of the game and so anything you can do to bring people in to an email list maybe it's a bi-weekly or a monthly newsletter where you just kind of send out updates hey here's the game here's some pictures of the Prototype Get on Board Game Geek start some Forum strings about that you know posting about the game getting people interested getting them excited you can't go wrong and that way when the game does come to Market when it goes to Kickstarter when it becomes available you've already got people that want to buy it whether you're doing it yourself or pitching it to a publisher build an email list number 20 is a follow-up of that make sure you communicate regularly with the people interested in your game maybe you've got a Facebook group that you've built or maybe it's a board game geek Forum newsletter whatever it is make sure you're sending out regular
posts don't send out one and then wait six months and then give an update now if you haven't done anything in six months you kind of took a Hiatus from the design hey it happens but typically you want to work on things regularly and then update people regularly so it brings in more people the hype goes up a little bit but you have to manage the hype you're not trying to be like hey this is the greatest game since Monopoly you're not trying to do that you're just trying to post progress and that makes people feel involved they feel like they're part of it they got to see the behind the scenes inside look before everybody else kind of makes them feel good feel better more likely to back the game on Kickstarter but anyway communicate regularly whether you're like in the board game Design Lab Facebook group and just saying hey guys here's some progress check out the latest uh prototype of my game you'll have people comments oh that's really cool but again it gets interest it also might help people see it and then offer some feedback or something like that so anyway be regular with your Communication number 21 get better at public speaking now you're probably not going to have to get up in front of thousands of people because of your game design although if you do it's pretty cool because it probably means you did something amazing that a lot of people want to hear about but in general the skill set of public speaking is not ever going to do you wrong especially when it comes to sitting down maybe at a convey in your meeting with a publisher you're giving them a pitch for your game you got to be able to sit there and talk and carry on that conversation carry on that pitch in a way that makes them go hey this person's a pro this is something we really want to work with or if you're demoing your game and you've got three or four players there at the table you need to be concise you need to say things again without going um um like this and so get better at public
speaking whatever that looks like take an online class go to a local community college and just see if you can take a class there but whatever it takes get better at public speaking you're never going to go wrong with that and it'll give you more confidence it'll give you more security more self-esteem to do all these other things better as well number 22 Go Pro what does it look like for you to be a professional even if you're not making any money even if game design is literally nothing but putting you in the red right now and you're spending money but you're not bringing anything in still what does it look like to be a professional if you were doing this full time if you're doing this as a pro how would you organize your time how would you organize your schedule and your life like what kind of sacrifices would you be making because if you're serious about this and you actually want to do this in a way that brings in money later that you're getting Games published and you're out there on the market that people can buy as products go ahead and start acting like that like what would a professional do how would they act do that now and the more you do it the more you'll become and so GoPro what does that look like for you and your life and go ahead and start doing it now number 23 give more to the game design Community than you take in other words be a ladder Builder not just a ladder climber there are very few things in life that I I know to be true more than this the more you give the more you receive the more you take the more you lose it's just is what it is it doesn't necessarily make sense if you write it down on paper but that just it's just a way of life and so how can you help other others how can you build them up encourage them give them ideas and
feedback because when you do that they want to reciprocate they naturally want to help you now don't do this selfishly and you make the transaction I'm gonna help you and then you're gonna help me that's not what this is about do it out of generosity do it out of kindness do what I love for the the game design Community the game design skill set you know as an art form as craft and I promise you the more you do it the more you help others the more it's going to come back to help you be a ladder Builder not just a ladder climber number 24 follows up on that play other people's prototypes right maybe you send them your prototype and they send theirs and then you you play it and you get some feedback and you send it back that works really really well go to some conventions reach out to people and just say hey I've got some time blocked off I've got my schedule kind of figured out I'm gonna go pro I'm going to do this in a way that actually I set certain days and certain times for different things and play testing is one of those things I do on a weekly or bi-weekly basis and reach out to people and say hey can I play test your game one it's going to create a ton of Goodwill they're going to want to reciprocate but two you're going to learn a ton just by playing other people's unfinished games and see the problems that they're they're going through and the solutions they're trying to figure out the ideas and give them feedback it's such an incredible process so play other people's prototypes number 25 play other people's published games don't fall into the Trap of only playing prototypes if only play testing your game and not actually going out into the market and buying games or going to conventions and playing games that are really good they're polished they're complete that have their graphic design
finished and the user experience all those different things you're going to learn so much play as many games as you can it's kind of like free throws you want to get better shooting free throws you got to shoot free throws over and over again if you want to get better at designing games and go to design games but also play a ton of games to figure out how to do it well so make sure you're playing other people's published games number 26 watch other people playing great games go to game night go to Convention get you something to drink get you some popcorn and just watch just tell people hey I'm gonna set this one out I'm just gonna watch y'all play I'll get in on the next one and then watch The Experience don't just watch the game and see who's gonna win or lose it watch them as they play watch the people who it's not their turn what are they doing during down time what are they doing what other people are figuring out their turns what are the things that are going on the Dynamics what's the overall experience take some notes figure it out and go okay this is the game here's the kind of experience it's going for here's what I'm noticing in the players as they play it and then how can I apply that to my own game design in the in the games that I'm trying to create you'll learn a lot I promise it's like watching film with a sport you know you just learn a lot you see all the little details that you normally Miss if you're only watching the game to see who scores and see who wins or loses watch people play in the game what's going on take notes number 27 read what designers have to say there are so many amazing blogs and so many things on Board Game Geek where you can get behind the scenes and you can read a designer's thought process their design journals the kind of you know talking about along the way along their journey of going from nothing from
scratch all the way to finished published game learn from it it's it's such a rare thing most Industries don't do this they don't say hey here's the idea and here's how I changed it and here's what did work and here's what didn't work and here's all the ways that I came up with Solutions and ideas and not take advantage of that there are so many amazing places cardboard Edison is a great place it's just a resource for you know as blogs and different things come out you can go there you know once every few days and see is there anything new once a week and go okay what are the new blogs what are the new discussions and conversations being had around game design read those things learn from it again if you want to be really good at this don't try to do it on your own don't just try to figure everything out for yourself take some time put in the effort learn from other people's experience through Reading what they have to say there's also a ton of amazing books on the market as well read everything you can get as good as you possibly can the more you can learn from other people and their failures the better you'll be I mean failure is the best teacher by far but it doesn't have to be your failure only that you learn from learn from other people's experiences as well number 28 along those same lines listen to what designers have to say there are so many amazing podcasts on the internet where you can just listen to conversations and interviews from game designers and Publishers and people in marketing and accounting and all the different aspects of gaming game design listen to those podcasts the board game Design Lab podcast got over 300 episodes where I covered as many topics as I could possibly come up with I talked to some of the best Minds the best designers in
the industry go listen to as much as you can go and find the topics that you're interested in find the the topics that are about games that your work working on or things you've never even thought about listen to what people have to say I promise you'll get some amazing ideas you'll come up with ways to overcome the obstacles that you're facing to fix the broken problems the broken things in your game just sit down listen again maybe you're cutting the grass and listening maybe you're doing some kind of mundane task or maybe it's your morning ritual but whatever figure out times that you can listen to what people have to say you'll get a lot from it number 29 listen to Gamers problems with published games that's why it's so valuable to be part of various Facebook communities or Board Game Geek forums different things where people are complaining and sometimes it gets a little petty and it gets a little too negative and it's just like oh my gosh get over it but you can learn from a lot of those things there's people post about issues they have with a game maybe it's graphic design maybe it's the game lasts too long maybe the player count said five players but this should really be played with three whatever it is though listen to what they're saying about those games that are already on the market that someone has already said hey this is good enough to bring to the market as a product charge people money for it it already you know made a hundred thousand or a million dollars on Kickstarter but what are people's problems what are their criticisms of those things that are already out there and how can you internalize it and figure out ways to make your own games your own game designs better based on the criticisms of other published games number 30 never let an idea get forgotten remember that your brain is much better at having ideas than storing
ideas so always have some methods some apps some notebook something that you can write things down or take notes on your phone whatever it is that way when ideas come in that you organize them in some way that you can come back to them later I am the worst about saying hey if it's a good idea it'll come back that's not true and I can't tell you how many things I have lost to the just sands of time and just the recesses of the dark places in my brain and hopefully they come back but there's no guarantee on that so now I make sure anytime I have an idea I wake up middle of night or I'm in the shower or something like that I have a way to organize things to write things down and then we'll see what happens sometimes I'll lot of times they're not very good and they're not worth actually coming back to you but sometimes have an idea that actually turns into something special so make sure you've got a way to write down ideas and then keep them collected keep them organized number 31 watch game reviews it's not possible to play all the games that are coming out on the market today I mean I think around 700 it came out at Gen Con alone last year you're never going to be able to get to the mall but you can watch game reviews and see the new trends see how other game designers are approaching various ideas and mechanisms and themes and learn from it again it's kind of like watching film on other teams and figuring out what they do really well and then how can you do that also and so yeah get get online get on YouTube and just find game reviews watch game reviews of games that you're really interested in games that like are similar to what you're trying to create watch game reviews for things that you have no interest in at all because again you can learn from all of it watch game reviews number 32 design with production
cost in mind board games can be expensive right there are plenty of hundred dollar games on the market the question is should you be designing one of those games at the moment if you don't have a body of work if you don't have a portfolio of games if you haven't built up an audience it's going to be a bit of a hard sale to go to a publisher and say hey here's my 100 game it's got a ton of Miniatures and custom Dice and boards and cards that's a hard sell if you haven't built up something for them to go yes this is worth that investment and so it might be much better for you to design a game that's a 20 price point a card game but maybe some dice maybe some cubes and just kind of build up your experience build up something to say to a publisher hey here are the games I've created here's what's worked here's the audience I built up here's the people that are a fan of me and my games it's a much easier sell so again just design with price point in mind and production cost also if you're designing even if you are a well-known designer a 200 game is a very hard sell even in the deluxified kickstarter you know world uh that's still it's a lot of money for people to pay and so just be aware of that how many Miniatures do you really need how many custom dice how many custom components in general can you get away with just using generic regular d6s or something like that or do you really have to have that custom piece is it is it something that really makes the game better or could you do something easier and cheaper so anyway design with the production cost in mind number 33 don't think too much about the production cost don't get so caught up in okay this many cards is going to be this much and dicer
this many pennies and this many cubes is this many you know it's 15 cents and versus 17 cents it can get really easy to get bogged down and worrying too much about it so again just kind of go into the general idea of okay this is a thirty dollar game it's a family style game takes 40 minutes to play it's for you know kids and their parents to play they're probably not going to spend 75 dollars right so I need to really think through the production costs but don't over think it don't get bogged down because a lot of times it just becomes procrastination as opposed to actually doing something that matters so don't overthink production number 34 meet people get out there and network whether it's at conventions or just online in different communities or through forms and things like that become someone that people know right and you don't have to be in there every moment of every day and comment on everything but just be around be someone that shows up and offers feedback someone who you know comments and provides encouragement provides ideas someone who posts and asks for feedback right be someone that others know as someone that is enjoyable to talk to it's really just that simple because when you when you sit down to pitch a game to a publisher if you're someone they've already interacted with or someone that they've just kind of seen that you're you know someone in the community in some way it can be pretty helpful it's a lot of times who you know and who knows you it's just the way of the world number 35 along the same networking idea go to conventions meet people build fans build an audience for your games even if you're just in the open play area and you've got a little thing set up and you can play test your
game or if you're going to the play testing rooms times conventions will have specific areas to sign up and bring your prototypes to and people come in it's a great place to meet designers great place to meet Publishers and gamers in general but go to conventions have fun see other products that are coming out see how they're marketed see how they're sold just go enjoy buy some games have have fun again this is a fun industry to be a part of go out there and enjoy it to the fullest number 36 learn how to demo a game go to conventions and watch how really good designers and Publishers demo their games take some notes right what are the things that they really focus on what are the things that they make sure to put at the beginning of you know teaching how to play the game the middle the end what are some things that they leave out for various reasons and then maybe bring up as the game gets going you don't necessarily have to teach every single rule before a game starts sometimes you do but not always right and so what are they doing and then how can you grow and become better at demoing your own games and you know get some experience try to demo publish the games that you really enjoy right go and have fun on teaching other people how to play them grow in that because when you sit down with the publisher to pitch your game and you have to kind of demo it to them teach them the rules teach them and show them what makes it fun what makes it worth publishing this is a wonderful skill set to have because the better their experience is going into the game like before it starts the better experience they're going to have as they actually play it and makes you more likely to get your game published so learn how to demo a game do it over and over again get good at it number 37
also at conventions volunteer to work in Publishers booths this is a great way to network and get to know people in the industry to help them out as you work the booth and you're helping out with selling games or demoing games or whatever else you know the setup the takedown I can't tell you how many times Publishers are in the last minute right before convention starts like hey I need somebody else to come help because somebody got sick or they had to drop out and it's a great way to just kind of be involved in the industry build relationships that maybe turn into things down the road where they say hey don't you have a game you're a Gamers aren't you working on something you know same me a cell sheet send me a prototype and maybe that turns into and actually you know actually publishing your game but also typically you get a free badge for the convention you know and you have to work a certain number of hours and then you get to just experience a convention you know as much as you want after that a lot of times they'll pay for a plane ticket and travel and food so it's kind of a good deal overall and again it just kind of immerses you more and more into the industry builds your relationships build your network it's a good thing to do working uh Publishers boost at conventions number 38 take one bite at a time I realize this is a list of 71 things you can do to grow and get better as a game designer but don't let it overwhelm you don't let game design in general be overwhelming because I know it can be a lot of times there's so much going on there's so much to think about there's so many different angles you have to be aware of but just take one bite at a time just try to get better at one thing today what does that look like to get one percent better as opposed to trying to make these giant leaps and all I'm 40 but just get one percent better today work on one thing
eventually you'll grow your skill set your skill set will get bigger and better and you'll be able to work on multiple things you can kind of keep a lot more on your mind at the same time but especially early on what's one thing I can do today and a lot of times also it turns into procrastination it turns into just being kind of overwhelmed so it's a daunting experience to design a game especially a big game a midi game with a lot going on and so a lot of times you're just like ah I'll do it tomorrow and it's always saying I'll do it tomorrow but what's one thing you can do today what can you work on right now to push the game design forward don't let it overwhelm you you're gonna be fine number 39 borrow from other games there are no new ideas right very very rarely does something come along that's just like brand new wow this never existed before and even then it's usually just a different way of doing something that was already established realize that we are all standing on the shoulders of giants and so it's okay to borrow from other other games and other ideas and you know you want to give it your own spin you don't want to just like take their idea and put a new theme on it that's meh don't do that but like take their idea and then what what can you say about it how can you add a different idea to it how can you turn it on its head how can you look at it from the opposite angle and then go from there but but don't feel like you're stealing you're just borrowing and the good news is that person that you're borrowing from borrowed from a lot of other people as well it's just part of it so borrow from other games it's already established you already know it works it's already on the market it sells how can you do it in a cool way or
a different way or just something that's more interesting number 40 is focus which stands for follow one course until successful a lot of times as designers we have shiny object syndrome that we're constantly looking at the new shiny idea and we have a million things going on and we never finish any of them because anytime it gets to a point where something is not as enjoyable you're not getting the same dopamine hit or something like that it's like ah I'll move on to the next thing and then before you know it you've just got a graveyard of ideas and nothing really to actually show for it and there's nothing necessarily wrong with that if you want to design games just for fun just to relieve stress just as an interesting how hobby by all means do whatever you want that's fine but if you want to bring games to Market if you actually want to be a pro game designer that has Games published then you need to focus you need to figure out okay what can I do today to move this one project forward and then do that over and over again until it's done it's just a better way to do it to avoid shiny object syndrome and constantly jumping from one thing to the next Focus number 41 or don't focus it really comes down to your own personal style your own personal skill set personally what I do is I usually have two to three sometimes four usually around three games that I'm working on at the same time and I'm kind of bouncing around I've got an idea for this one let's work on that I just finished the prototype for this one let's play test it I just kind of bounce back and forth as I have ideas as I get some energy about one get a little juice flowing about one I'll work on it for a little bit bounce to the next until it gets to a place where it's like almost done it's like 70 75 done then I get
laser focused let's finish this one let's see what it looks like to bring it to Market and then I'll come back to these other ones when when I have time or when you know when there's something going on that I just need to take a break but I get laser focused once a game is like ready to go across the finish line and that's what works for me you'll figure out what works for you you'll come up with your own system your own schedule and then just kind of lean into that find out what's best for you and how you operate that actually gets games finished actually gets you know things to completion but then just do that maybe it's laser focusing only one thing at a time maybe it's three things probably not ten things I think there is a certain maximum that 90 of people have that's like okay if I go beyond this I'm never getting anything done but you might be able to work on multiple at the same time and get them all across the Finish Line it's just whatever works best for you but the main thing is you got to figure out what works best for you and that takes time but then when you when you're there when you figure it out lean into it do that over and over and over again number 42 know when to walk away know when to put the game on a shelf and also know when to just put it in the trash and not come back to it at all maybe bring up some ideas that worked and bring those back later but maybe the game just doesn't need to exist maybe it doesn't have a place in the market or at least not right now or something I ran into a lot early on in my game design journey is I would run into a problem that I just didn't have the skill set yet to overcome I just didn't have the ability to figure it out to fix it and so I would put things on the shelf and then years later I've come back to designs and go okay this was a cool idea and now I've learned I've grown I actually understand how to solve the problems I was running into and then
it actually becomes a game that becomes a product and gets on the market and so it can be hard to know when that's why also it's really good to have other people around you that will tell you the truth and go you know this is just not that fun and maybe you can change it maybe you can add some things or take some things away that actually increases the fun that we're having you know maybe the game works it works as a game that's not enjoyable to play but again that's why it's good to have people there to tell you the truth but just get to a point where you let things go and again this isn't your identity it's not who you are putting that game on the shelf or the trash doesn't mean that you're on the Shelf it doesn't mean that you are trash it just means something you create it didn't work out and that's that's life that's art so know when to walk away know when to leave things alone number 43 Kill Your Darlings that's something that it's very popular to say in writing when you you have to cut out conversations or paragraphs or entire chapters even though you love them even though it's great it doesn't actually move the story along where it doesn't actually create any interesting tension or any character development it's just there because you like it as the the author same thing in game design so many games have mechanisms and have systems and things like that just don't need to be there they don't actually make the game more fun sometimes they actually make the game Less Fun which you definitely want to cut those out but there's a lot of things in game design that are just there and they work they're fine it's part of the game it's a certain phase of play it's a certain number of rounds whatever it is but does it really need to be there or is it only there because you put a lot of time effort maybe money into it and now you're you're feeling like oh I don't want to cut that because I put so much into it but if it makes the game better
get rid of it right again this is not who you are this is something you're making and if you really want to create something great it's okay to let things go even if you put a lot of time and effort and energy or money into it if it makes the product makes the game better and more fun kill those things that take away from that number 44 just ship the thing and what that means is you got to get to a place where you're done the game design itself is technically can never be done there's always something to tweak there's always another number to change another card to add or take away or another way you can mess with the dice system and make it 12 instead of 11 you can do that endlessly but you got to get to a point where you're done and it's okay to be done and yeah there might still be some things that need to be worked on whatever but finish you got to finish things I've talked to so many amazing designers and I ask them how do you how do you know when the game is done and quite a few have told me when the game is at the manufacturer like when the deadline hits and the publisher says hey we need it by this date to get this thing out in time for Christmas or in time for Gen Con River and that's how you know when it's done is when when you don't have a choice right so maybe that's something you need to do is set a deadline and go okay I get to this day I'm done obviously if something pops up you're like oh shoot that's broken we really need to fix that or change the rules or you know add or take away it was obviously always context involved but you got to get to a point where you're like hey done enough is done enough good enough is good enough and put it out the door again another reason to have other people around you to go hey this is good it's done this is fun this is the game you're trying to make this is the
experience you're going for stop worrying about 11 versus 12 on the dice ratios doesn't matter just ship the thing number 45 Niche down a game for everyone is really a game for no one and so you really want to to figure out who is this game for and how do I laser focus on that with the way it's played the mechanisms the theme the experience all that kind of stuff just get real specific right you would much rather have people that love your game and people that hate your game versus just people that you know everyone's like this game's okay meh right it's better to have highs and lows as opposed to a whole bunch of just in the middle uh oh it's fine right and so what does it look like for you to do that with your game how can you Niche down and really focus on a specific group of Gamers a certain group of people not trying to appeal to everybody because you're going to be forgotten in about 30 seconds number 46 don't worry about the art right now when you're play testing and you need a prototype you obviously want to have something on the card something on the board so that players can look at and go okay I understand this is what's going on to give them an idea to give them kind of the feeling that you're going to have later on when the game is finished and published and you know all the art is finalized but a lot of times as a designer you can get so bogged down and going online going on Google Images and trying to find the perfect clip art the perfect illustration to put on that card and then you waste a ton of time and it feels like progress it feels like you're doing something that matters that's important but you're not because if you spent 30 seconds and went and just found an icon and used that as the
illustration versus three hours finding the perfect illustration that you can't use anyway because it's copyrighted you've wasted a lot of time in that three hour process that you could have been doing something that really did matter and the danger is you feel like progress is being made but it's kind of like being stuck in the mud right and your tires are spinning at a hundred miles an hour but you're not going anywhere so don't worry too much about art and all the different things just again do good enough do what you can to get the point across and then let that let that stand for itself number 47 quit trying to figure out the perfect title right A lot of times we spend so much time trying to find that perfect little pun that perfect little set of words that's going to have people giving us money as soon as they see it without even knowing what the game is actually but a lot of times titles are better found than created what I mean by that is they they come out of the game design process in general the playing process where you go oh this would be a better title and so don't overthink it Untitled game number seven is totally fine to play tests and prototype and figure things out don't waste too much time overthinking it don't try to figure out the perfect title sometimes you actually have a title before the game design process begins actually I've seen designers that had an idea for a title and then everything came after that that definitely happens but again don't procrastinate by trying to find perfect just go with what works for now and if you find a better way to do it you find a better title later change it out but just design play test Prototype all the things that actually move the game forward as opposed to just wasting time
trying to figure out a good pun number 48 quit asking for price quotes and this is when you go to manufacturers websites and you fill out all the details and you submit you know their survey their online form for how much would this game cost if I print it myself a lot of people think okay let me just start a business and go to Kickstarter and do it all myself without actually thinking through all that goes into that and then they'll do it when their games like 50 done and so it's gonna change and so unless your game is like 90 95 done and you're really pretty sure that you're going to do this yourself as opposed to pitching it to a publisher stop wasting time again so many things I'm talking about right now are just ways that it's really just procrastination it looks like planning it looks like figuring something out that matters but it's really just wasting time that could be much better spent actually working on your game number 49 speaking of time schedule your design time specific days specific times again act like this is your job right don't just wait for motivation don't just wait for inspiration to strike that's what amateurs do they just sit around and wait hopefully though something's gonna happen they're going to have some ideas randomly no professionals they show up to work whether they feel like it or not so maybe it's Tuesday night you know nine o'clock P.M after the kids are in bed you can you can go work on game design from 9 to 10 30. maybe it looks like waking up early in the morning maybe it looks like you know going to lunch in a quiet place and not going with other people but going you know by yourself you can work on a game and prototype and play test things I don't
know what it looks like for you but you schedule it and you stick to the schedule as much as you can just like you would for anything else that matters anything else that's important to you you show up to your job at 8 30 in the morning because that's when you're supposed to be there so why not treat game design or something you really want to take seriously in the same way number 50 work on your game every day now that doesn't mean you have to have these three hour design sessions every day or anything like that but do something that pushes your game forward if you want to get good at something do it every day right you build a habit you get into the habit of it being something that you're always working on and even if it's just something small even if it's just like cutting out a few cards today you've got 10 extra minutes to do some proofreading of your rule book and you're just going to proofread you know the first two pages or something like that but anything is better than nothing it's kind of like exercise right even if you get up and just walk a quarter of a mile right and it takes you five minutes to do it well you're doing laps around everybody sitting on the couch and so just do something just do anything because the truth is scientifically speaking motivation comes after you begin not before right typically not all the time but typically you get going and objects in motion stays in motion right so what does it look like to just get into motion and so set that bar low right maybe it just means working on game design for five minutes every day right that's your goal five minutes doesn't have to be any more than that that's just the you know setting the bar as low as you possibly can because most of the time when you hit the five minute
Mark you'd be like ah I Can Do 10. I Can Do 30. I can do an hour but you got to get in to motion so what can you do every day that kind of sets the bar low that then you get going I knew a guy that uh he really wanted to get in shape and so he's like okay I'm gonna start swimming he had that knees he didn't want to lift weights as I'm going to start swimming but his goal on a daily basis was just to get into the pool it wasn't to swim a bunch of laps it wasn't to swim for 30 minutes or an hour it was literally just get in the pool and if he gets in the pool that he's checked the Box he's hit his goal for the day if he's sick if he doesn't feel like it if he needs something going on at work super busy he can get right back out of the pool and go do it he's accomplished his goal for the day but he's like you know I'm in the pool I can do a lap they do a laugh and say I can do a few more and he do a few more and eventually he got into super great shape he lost a ton of weight gained a bunch of muscle looks great now but his goal was just get into the pool so what does it look like for you to just work on something anything that gets the ball rolling gets you into motion and do it every day number 51 keep a design notebook and this is more than just like having a place to write down ideas and you know an app on your phone or something like that this is something that is very organized very structured I've used the bullet Journal method in the past that works really well but a place where you can kind of keep everything in one place that you can come back to six months later you know when you kind of put a game on the Shelf you come back to it like okay here's all my ideas but also make sure you're writing down the problems not just the solutions because one thing I found is sometimes I have potentially I'll write down the answer to the issue
of the game and then I'll I'll you know take a few weeks off and come back and I'll try that solution and realize oh this this is not fun this is not any good but what was the actual problem what was actually wrong with the game so make sure you're writing up problems not just the answers and not just the ways to overcome those challenges what are the actual challenges and then have you know organized ideas under it the solutions to it but anyway just having a place where you can keep all your thoughts write down your mission statement for the game write down the demographics like okay this is a game for two to four players uh ages 14 to 25 you know whatever the the specifics of the game are it just makes it so much easier and you can have a nice notebook that kind of you know looks good on the shelf and kind of makes you feel like you're somebody anyway have a design notebook number 52 fix one thing at a time a lot of times early on in the design your game has a lot of problems and the issue is you try to fix them all at once and then you play the next version of the game and it still has some issues but you're not actually sure which of the solutions made it better and which of them made it worse and so think scientifically right when you're doing a scientific experiment you don't want to have a whole bunch of different things going on because then you don't actually know what's creating the changes right and so if you have multiple problems just fix one right try to fix one and okay we're going to change from Dice to hours and this one next play test and see what that does okay that did this all right in this next play test we're going to change this other thing okay that did this number but anyway just do one thing at a time that way you can easily much more
easily pinpoint what's actually wrong and what's actually going to fix the the issues as opposed to shotgun blasting a whole bunch of ideas and going yeah but which one of these is actually making the game more fun fix one thing at a time number 53 learn how to make an awesome sale sheet if you want to get your game published you're probably going to need a sell sheet most Publishers will ask for a sale sheet now all that is is a one-page document typically a PDF that you're emailing that gives your the overview of your game right and it's not just big walls of text it's a handful of you know sentences overview player count components list but then it's also a lot of pictures showing the game in action and let the publisher kind of see it on the table and go oh okay I understand I get it I see what's going on here and it's really its main job is to get you a follow-up email to get you a pitch meeting or get you a meeting at a convention or something like that but it's just a sheet that looks good right it's worth the money to hire a graphic designer if you're not any good at this stuff I'm like I'm no good so I will go find gravity designers and pay them 50 bucks 100 bucks you know whatever it is for their time and get them to create a compelling good looking sell sheet that then I send out it makes me look more professional makes me look a lot more like I know what I am doing and so that hopefully leads to the publisher thinking the same thing and wanting to actually take a look at my game number 54 sell yourself it's not just your game it's not just the the design that you're pitching you're also pitching you because I can speak from personal experience as a publisher I've met lots of people that you know even if they had
a great game I don't know that I would want to work with them for the long you know it takes a year or two years for a game to come to Market I'm gonna invest two years of meetings and conversations and emails back and forth with somebody that you know maybe we just aren't in good Rhythm we're not you know lined up value-wise or lined up for all sorts of reasons it's like no thanks so you're remember you're selling yourself as much as you're selling a game design uh are you with the kind of person that takes feedback well takes criticism well that is easy to work with do you respond to emails timely or or just do I wait two weeks to hear back from you because if I wait two weeks I'm probably not going to want to work with you even if it's like the next Ticket to Ride it's like it might not be worth it for my own mental health to deal with that and so just remember as you're selling your game you're also selling yourself number 55 don't expect anyone else to care about your game remember this is your baby this is the thing you've put a bunch of time and effort energy and maybe money into but not anybody else like no one else has to care and that's okay it's your job as the designer to create a compelling product a compelling game that gets them interested that the hook that the pitch that you say it to them and they see it online and go oh tell me more right don't expect them to care at all it doesn't matter that you've been working on a game for 10 years who cares does I don't care if you've been working on it for 10 minutes is it fun is it compelling does it draw me in to to play a game that I want to play or not right but don't put an expectation on other people just design the best game you can put it out there into the world and if
it's right if you're actually aiming it at the right people you've done a good job then they're going to be drawing in but don't go online and post comments and throw a little pity party for yourself be like oh no one cares that doesn't matter that's just the nature of anything creative any kind of artwork is that if some people are going to Care some people aren't oh well it's your job to get as many people that you're aiming at to care as possible through your pitch through the design they're just making a great amazing product for them to enjoy number 56 along those same lines don't just Spam forums don't just go online and post about your game and expect everyone to go oh here to take my money you know every now and then I haven't but typically If You're just showing up as a nobody as kind of a random person and saying hey hey guys how are you I'm new here here's my name please buy it or please give me feedback like who who are you right so it's much much better get involved with these communities help other people you know offer feedback comments different things like that and then be like hey I've got a game that I'm working on is anybody interested in it can I get some feedback on this would you mind reading my rule book hey here's my Kickstarter campaign but I mean it takes a long time if you just show up and spam the link to your game or link to your email list or something like that you're probably going to get zero you're probably gonna get nobody interested in it because you're only for yourself you're only here to sell something and a lot of times that just doesn't go over very well so it's much better to become involved and then post you know ideas help other people and then post about yourself post about the projects that you're working on that way people don't
just see it as you being like a sleazy used car salesman or you're just trying to spam they'll see you as an actual contributor to the community and then they'll be much more inclined to hear what you have to say number 57 don't even consider Kickstarter unless you really truly want to start a business because that's what it is I know it's easy to go online and you go on Kickstarter or game found or some of these other crowdfunding sites and you see that someone made a million dollars and like that could be me probably not but again don't Bank on being the outlier it's probably not going to happen so kind of manage your expectations going in but just understand it's starting a business and there's tax stuff to figure out and there's all sorts of things to do as far as you're starting an LLC and understanding all the marketing and doing all the project management and hiring the artists and the graphic designers and figuring out the shipping and the logistics the freight the manufacturer there's a million things to be aware of and the truth is most kickstarters don't actually make money so just because they have a million dollars that come in through the crowdfunding campaign it doesn't mean they made a million dollars a lot of campaigns even if they make a ton of money don't actually make anything a lot of people go into the red they sometimes go bankrupt even after a very what looks like successful campaign so understand it's a business it's starting a business it's doing all the things that go along with business so just be aware of that don't get caught up in all the flashy numbers and the million dollar you know dollar signs number 58 don't consider Kickstarter unless you're fairly certain that your game will actually fund and this goes into the game design process
because Kickstarter is a very specific Community it's a group of people looking for very specific types of games or certain games that do really well certain games that don't do very very well at all and so what kind of games are you designing and is it for the kickstarter Market also all the things that go along with designing the game that a lot of things have already talked about building an email list getting involved in different communities all sorts of things that build into this much bigger idea of crowdfunding make sure you're doing all of those things it's not just hey I've got an idea I throw it up on Kickstarter I make a bunch of money and then I'm off to the races it just doesn't work that way and so make sure you're doing all the things from a game design perspective and just a networking perspective that actually ensure that you're going to fill in or at least be close to it before you even consider running a campaign number 59 don't ask people to do things for free I can't tell you how many times I've seen people post online that hey I don't have any money to pay you as an artist or you as a graphic designer but it'd be really good if you're a portfolio and so it's good for your portfolio and it'll be good for me and my business and my crowdfunding campaign I'm going to be making money off of but it's good it's good for you to do it for free that's garbage it's complete another garbage now I know it can be a little discouraging sometimes as a game designer to Think Through how much time how many hours you put into something and then you calculate that and realize that hey I made like 42 cents an hour working on this game just don't just don't do it just don't worry about that calculation but don't ask people to do things for free now maybe you want to trade a service you want to trade something hey Will somebody proofread my
rulebook and then I'll proofread yours you kind of have that as something but if it's something that's going to help you make money then you should be paying people for that service right and just realize that you get what you pay for typically which leads right into number 60 don't be a cheapskate just like you shouldn't be trying to get things done for free and assuming that other people are going to want to to help them in some way um pay people pay people what they're worth art is expensive graphic design is expensive a lot of things that go into creating a product that goes to the marketplace is expensive and so again if you're going to design games that you ultimately want to publish yourself be thinking through the cost right if you're going to design a deck building game that has 200 different kinds of cards unique cards that require 200 pieces of art that's very expensive and think through the the business side of that as you're working on the game in general also if you're going to pitch the game it's something the publisher I assure you is going to be thinking about wow that's a lot of art I don't want to take on this project because it's going to be way more expensive to produce it and I don't know if we're going to be able to actually make money off of it and in the marketplace as it is right now it's just things to be thinking about as a game designer but again you get what you pay for if people help you in some way pay them in some way if you have play testers helping out you know even if you're just paying them with with pizza and then Coke you know that's that's fine put their name in the rulebook there's all sorts of things you can do to pay people for various things that aren't necessarily money but ultimately a lot of times for most of these Services you want to pay people real money because it's valuable if it's
worth it to you to do that it should be worth it to you to actually pay people for what they're helping you out with number 61 fail fast what I mean by that is get the game to the table as quickly as possible figure out what's broken what doesn't work what's really fun well it's not fun at all because the faster you do that the faster you can iterate the faster you can create the next version of the game to make it better A lot of times designs will float around in our heads for a long time or write down all these notes we'll plan out the entire game start to finish in our notebook and then eventually you know six months later you get it to the table and you go oh this game is trash and I don't think it can recover let me work on something else and so you just wasted a whole bunch of time and mental processes on something that wasn't even worth it and so the faster you can get an idea out even if it's just pushing around some note cards and some dice just a very basic simple version of the game it's more than than just writing down all the ideas and notes the truth is a lot of times the game in your head is perfect it's going to be the next big thing it's an amazing game how could anyone not want to buy this game but then when you get it out on the actual table it's got a lot of issues got a lot of problems right but then you can fix them that's the thing you can't edit what doesn't exist right so you get it out there as quickly as possible and then you can fix it as quickly as possible number 62 play test nothing will make you a better game designer than play testing play testing your game over and over and over again in all sorts of different ways and all sorts of different all sorts of different angles just play test play test play test you will learn so much more from doing this
but it's an action action right it's an active thing and it's not just playing your game that's another thing that a lot of times new designers don't understand you're not just sitting out to play the game this is actually much more scientific than that you're going in with a hypothesis you're thinking through okay what are some questions that I have that I'm trying to get answered right is the battle system taking too long or is the economy in the game too tight does there need to be more money in the economy whatever it is but you're going into the play test with something you're trying to figure out you're not just playing it to see who wins or who loses but play testing is the number one thing to improve you as a game designer number 63 play test without saying a word now this is often called Blind play testing but I much prefer the phrase unguided play testing I think that makes a lot more sense also there's less confusion with that one time I had someone send me an email and they said so blind play testing is that where you give people the game and then you close your eyes and you just listen to them play and that you get some good feedback there it's like no that's that's not what that means it means you give people the game and then you just step back and you just watch right you don't say a word when they make a mistake when they misinterpret a rule when they misread something or they play the game poorly or wrongly you just take notes and you don't say a word about it right so play testing and just kind of Let It Go start to finish right hand them the Box let them teach themselves the rules and things like that and that's another thing I really just love to do is play testing only the rule book you hand someone the rule book they've never seen it before never read it don't know anything about the game and then they teach me how to play and I
don't say a word when they miss you know read something or whatever I'm just taking notes the whole time and I do that with people who are really experienced Gamers and I do that with people who know how to play Uno and Connect Four right and I just kind of see the stumbling blocks and the issues and maybe they get something you know out of line they went from number one down to number four because I didn't you know number things in a way that was visually that made sense the graphic design maybe is a little bit off or something like that but you learn so much by play testing and just watching number 64 play test early and often this goes right along with the whole fail fast right fail as quickly as you can the sooner you can get an idea in front of other people and get their ideas get their feedback on it see how they play the game see how they interact with the experience the sooner you can actually make the game better I know it can be scary and I know going in you're like this is hot garbage why would anyone want to play it and that's a that's a really good point right and so the thing is you don't have to play a full game a lot of times early on I'll go into a play testing session and I'll say hey guys we're just gonna play the first two rounds or we're just gonna play for 20 minutes and I'm just going to get some ideas and we'll kind of get some feedback after we're done but we're not going to play the full 90 minute version because a lot of times play tests they last a long time you're trying to create a game that lasts 45 minutes but the original version of the game lasts three hours because you haven't honed it in yet you haven't cut out all the things need to be cut and so make sure you're cutting your make sure you're shutting things down when they need to be right and give play testers the option to ask them every now and then hey does anybody want to quit are you kind of done are you feeling like you want to go do
something else and if they say yes that's totally fine like give them that opportunity right let them know before you start hey if you're done playing Just raise your hand like hey I'm kind of done this is not fun anymore and shut the place that's Place us down you don't have to finish you probably have all you need right to uh to go back to the drawing board and figure some things out so anyway play test early play test often but don't feel like you have to run full play tests especially early on you don't number 65 listen to your play testers they took the time out to play your game you should take some time out to listen to what they have to say now sometimes they'll say things that are maybe overly critical overly negative and maybe they say things without without being particularly kind or gracious don't fall into that trap don't let it turn into an argument where you're just Defending Your Game and you're you know I've seen so many play tests unfortunately devolve into just heated arguments and debates and it's like what are we what are we doing like just thank people for playing uh and just kind of listen to what they have to say weigh it you know figure out is this really good feedback good ideas good advice maybe maybe not but just take your notes go back to the design process figure it out from there don't again don't act like someone's attacking you as a person and you as in your identity there's just maybe pretty critical of something that you've created that you're trying to make better anyway so again thank them for their time and that actually might make them want to play test the game again and play testers are hard to find so try to keep them around as much as you can number 66 don't listen to play testers and what I mean by that is it's usually context right
one thing I've found is that play testers are usually really good at being able to verbalize the problem but pretty terrible at being able to come up with the solution so for example they might say hey I felt like I just didn't have enough money or I didn't have enough actions to be able to do what I wanted to do and that's okay it's a good problem to write right down do I need to change the action economy the money economy in the game and give players more options or more opportunities for combos or something like that but then when they start coming up with ideas on how to fix it usually those are pretty bad every now and then a play tester typically a game designer that's play testing we'll come up with something like oh that's a really good solution but again first like I said earlier write down the problem don't just write down Solutions but just realize most solutions are coming from a place of a gamer not typically a game designer and so a lot of their ideas are really them trying to make the game more theirs then and it might not be your vision right they might be trying to create the experience that they really want and it might not be the experience that you're trying to put out into the world and so don't feel like you have to listen to everything again to the meat spit out the bones sometimes they have really good feedback sometimes they don't and that's okay that's part of the play testing process number 67 play test with different groups and different people one trap you can run into is play testing the game over and over and over again with the same people because then they become Masters they become really really good at the game and that might skew what you need to be doing from a design side of things right and one thing I learned is you know I had a game I was play testing as a solo game play
testing a lot by myself and with other another person that was really we got really good at the game and so it's to a point where we were winning like 75 80 of the time which is way higher than I wanted it to be I wanted players to win somewhere around 35 40 percent of the time and so I was like oh we're winning like 80 let me make the game a lot harder and then I did that and then I put it in front of people who had never played the game had no Mastery of it at all and they got smoked they got decimated every time they played it because they didn't know all the ins and outs and the nuances of the game and so I was like oh I have made the game way too hard because I know all the other side of things they don't so I had to ratchet it back down and kind of make it much much easier so again you can run into that so play test the game with different kinds of people I can go to conventions go to game stores go to meetups whatever and play the game with people who really like this kind of game play test the game with folks that aren't really into it you know all their feedback matters because at game night typically you're not going to have a bunch of people that all love the same kinds of games they're gonna like different ideas different themes and genres and play times and things like that but if they want to play together you're going to have a situation where you have one person who's really excited they just bought the game they can't wait to get it to the table and then there's another person at game night who's not really into it but they'll play it because other people want to whatever but you want both of those people to have as good of an experience as you can and it really helps if you play tested the game with both those kinds of people to really create something for for a lot of people at game night not trying to create a game for everybody but at least a game that these people can love and these people over here can at least tolerate well
enough to play it with the people who love it so anyway play test with lots of different people number 68 play test with people who don't know you I know your mom and your second cousin think you've created the best game ever made but maybe their opinions are a little bit biased maybe they're a little bit less likely to tell you the full-on truth and so it's really helpful to find people who don't know you whether it's conventions or at a game store or something like that that you can play the game and they'll just tell you the truth and they're not worried about seeing you at Thanksgiving or the next morning at The Breakfast Table so again play test with people who you've never met before or even if you only have like a passing knowledge of them or if you know five people online that you've interacted with maybe a little bit here and there that you can send your game they send yours and you play test each other's games you send feedback but you don't know each other you're not going to see each other at the office the next day or anything like that super valuable number 69 use a play test feedback form I'll put the form that I use in the description below but you want something that you can kind of track data and it doesn't have to be super specific a lot of times you're taking your own notes and writing down specific ideas but you want something at the end of the game or even if middle you can have different phases when you offer people you know feedback form that they can kind of write down something give you you know highs and lows and have a numbering system that's kind of simple to understand as far as like what you're trying to accomplish with a game length and the game depth and complexity and things like that but just something where you can track and then you can compile that data and see where your game is is it kind of right in the the middle as far as what you're what you're aiming at or have you gone too and far this way or too far that way super helpful to have a feedback form number
70 film the play test sessions if you can it's so valuable to be able to go back and watch the film because you can typically only focus on one thing at a time so if you're watching one person as they're playing you know and you're kind of taking notes on their experience but then there's you know other people at the table that you can't see and so if you've got it filmed you can go back after the game and and watch what happened watch what was going on and you'll notice other things you can kind of speed it up put in 2x speed or something like that to kind of you know get a a faster version of it but it's super helpful just be able to go in and kind of watch different things see different things that you're not going to be able to see at the table in the first time you're playing it and number 71 play test did I mention play test play test over and over and over again different angles different ways play test your game play test other people's game play test as much as you possibly can again nothing will make you better as a game designer nothing will improve your skills as a game designer more than play testing so just do it as much as you possibly can alright that is my list of 71 ways you can become a better game designer but I'm sure I've missed one or two or a thousand other ones and so in the comments below let me know your best advice what are some things that I left out what are some ways that game designers can get better at the art at the craft of game design that we can all grow and you know create great games that people love because I think ultimately that's what we're all trying to accomplish just create things that are fun that people enjoy spending time with again thanks for checking out the
videos thanks for stopping by and I look forward to seeing you again real soon