Dune Bloodlines & Splitting the Baby - An in-depth Review
Transcript
let me tell you my favorite Parable it's the tale of direwolf and its two favorite Creations it goes something like this dir wolf was a fortunate game company for it had created two of the brightest Works known to gamer ilk Dune Imperium and dune Imperium Uprising siblings almost twins these games brought great success and the people rejoiced but direwolf ever Restless sought to improve their Creations to make them stronger and so they set forth to craft an expansion Bloodlines yet in their hubris direwolf crafted Bloodlines for only Dune Imperium and the people cried out what of Uprising have you forsaken it like Netflix forsook mind Hunter for many deemed Uprising the superior the greater of the two and now they felt abandoned so direwolf hearing their cries returned to the forge and reshaped Bloodlines to serve Uprising alone but low people Jered once more what of classic Dune Imperium is it to be put down like an elderly chihuahua in Pala of care for these many thousands have only ever known the classic version and so once more direwolf toiled this
time Bloodlines would serve both classic and Uprising and at last when the people beheld their voices Rose louder still but not in Praise but scorn for they scowled now it serves both but perfectly serves neither and thus direwolf in striving to please all found itself pleasing no no one so please join me as we unravel Dune Imperium Bloodlines an ambitious expansion burdened by sky high expectations and doomed to the
cruestv expansions think rise of X rather than the smaller immortality inside you'll find four major additions the sardaar a new type of unit that can be acquired and upgraded and recruited throughout a game the return of TecTiles the ones found in Rise of x. Tech module is back you can add it into fresh up Uprising or mix it in directly with x's tech tiles from before nine new Leaders with varying levels of complexity ambitiousness and trickiness additional supplementary material and content things like new Imperium Deck cards Intrigue cards CH contracts and new conflict cards each of these is fairly sizable so let's dive in a bit deeper and see what they bring to the table Sardar the Sardar are the flashiest addition to Bloodlines and the only truly new gameplay system these little buddies bring the franchise's total unit types to four standard troops sandworms dreadnots and now sardaar so what makes them stand out well their gimmick is that they are upgradable through their Commander skills whenever you acquire a Sardar Warrior you can pick between four different skills shaping their powerups
to suit your strategy now the neat thing is Commander skills stack if you acquire another sardaar you pick another skill and all of the previous skills still apply so even if you only have one sardaar in a conflict all of your unlocked Commander skills kick in it's like building a sardaar sandwich you pick your toppings you pick your meat and by the end of it they're Hefty little boys it's a clever way to improve your combat potential and also your reveal turns with a touch of customization of course these new Elite Warriors come at a cost sard a car costs two Solaria to acquire from a space and then two more salari for each future starter car you recruit from your supply it makes sense thematically since they're essentially a hired Elite group of Warriors but let's be real you're basically subscribing to their life service model I think the idea is that for most players once you get your high counil and swordmaster Solari isn't very impactful so in order to create a new Solari sink the starter car can provide a fun way to improve your combat while also providing a new decision Point throughout a game overall I rather enjoy this mechanic they feel finely tuned and well crafted plus it's very hard to go both for sandworms and sardaar so in a way they play an
antagonistic role to anyone who goes for a sandw warm strategy this adds a nice layer of strategic depth into conflicts likewise their Commander skills add a sense of progression um that is different from the usual deck building and you can feel like you're actively training them with new skills of all of the new additions in Bloodlines the sarda car carve out a good gameplay Niche that is different enough from the other unit types for example those dreadnots and sandworms just don't expect them to show show up for free the tech module all right now we come to the tech module a mini expansion within an expansion before you get too giddy though let me be upfront this is mostly a retread of the tech module from rise ofix for those unfamiliar tech tiles are essentially permanent Buffs and active abilities you can gain when you purchase them from the ixian embassy with spice they range from Nifty little tricks like letting you look at the top card of your deck to more powerful effects like permanently reducing the cost of all spaces that require spice and Solari in Uprising these tiles integrate with the new ixi and Embassy board it allows purchases when players drop an agent at a green space in classic Dune Imperium though these tactiles just get jumbled
in with the rest of them from Rise of X I like TecTiles they add variety and some additional asymmetry throughout each game the cost benefit feels fair and they offer interesting ways to shape your game plan but and I might catch some heat for this TecTiles feel conceptually stale the tectile system itself feels constrained because it needs to work for both Dune Imperium classic and dune Imperium Uprising both games get a slice but neither gets the full pie and if you already have rise of X and Uprising you could have already Incorporated those TecTiles um so it's not exactly a a fresh pie I will admit these new TecTiles are more interesting on average than the ones from Rise ofx and I do enjoy this mechanic overall but it does feel a bit slapped together the whole purchase when you visit green spaces feels uninspired and not a clever or thrilling mechanic sure it's functional but compared to rise of X that introduced entirely new spaces this implementation feels a bit tacked on rather than Innovative so yeah they're here again do you do I like them yes are they fun absolutely but I can't help but wonder how far this design element could have gone and could have been pushed if it was free from the bounds of dual compatibility new
leaders right out of the gate Bloodlines brings in nine new leaders some are long- awaited fan favorites like leot KES chy Duncan Idaho Reverend mother MIM but they also toss in some Oddities like the steersman and Kota of X I'm not a pro when it comes to balance and I do think the meta is still too fresh to really judge accurately but I think these might be some of the funnest leaders in the game standouts include esmar who introduced produces a new space which really revamps the entire spice economy of a game or perer who gets an entire deck of unique entry cards which he draws from each round leot KES is a great addition to counter the muad dominance from the base of Uprising and provides a clever way to use those sandw War spaces without focusing on combat the most Innovative of the bunch is the steersman who plays with a deck of navigation cards which allows them to set a course each time they reach two influence with a faction they activate their next navigation card it grants a huge amount of flexibility and some of the crazy one-off abilities if the steersmen can pull it off the trade-off no signat ring or start in water which can be a major hindrance and takes some creative play to get through those starting rounds that said not all leaders are super compellent
Duncan Idaho for instance might have a neat gimmick of deploying his agent to combat but in practice he feels surprisingly Bland then there is chni who has a neat concept of being a master tactician but in practice she's kind of underwhelming direwolf seems determined on pushing her gameplay around constantly retreating but it just doesn't feel very satis fine as a whole though these leaders are some of the most well-designed and offer some of the funnest leaders in the entire franchise it's a good mix of mechanics all pushed in a new way even if some are less interesting than others new supplemental content Bloodlines comes with a healthy dose of new cards and cardboard chits 32 Imperium cards 18 entry cards two new conflict cards and eight contract tokens the card quality is overall solid especially when combining with the base Uprising deck there's a good variety of the new command reveal cards and it's a nice mechanism since it encourages more deck building with a greater emphasis on persuasion the biggest disappointment I had is the lack of cards with the new Mechanics for example there is literally only one card that uses the new Deep Cover spy mechanic as well there's only one pair of identical cards for the entire Tech module in a weird way way there is also very little interaction
between multiple mechanics within cards it's like each mechanic is doing its own thing completely unaware of the others it's not the biggest deal breaker but it is a bit strange that these mechanics feel bubbled off from one another sure there's exceptions such as these two Chom cards and spies but in general mechanics do feel isolated still the card quality as a whole feels appropriately balanced and offers enough meat to justify its addition to the uprising deck the intrigues are also pretty decent the three new endgame intrigues can either be a fun twist or endlessly frustrating depending on how much you enjoy surprises the other intrigues melt perfectly well with Uprising and feel appropriately complex for a expansion deck the additional conflict cards are both wild so it adds a bit more opportunity to make pairs in your uprising combats they also inject some Solari into the game so not a bad addition for the pace of the game itself and this additional salari is the perfect sync for the sarda car likewise the contracts for the Cho module are super easy just to add on there's not much of a fuss I really wouldn't say there's much to discuss here but it's good to know that they add some more variety to a mechanic that I already rather enjoy so yeah it's all solid but not really groundbreaking not pushing
the design of Uprising okay so that's all the content it's Hefty and it definitely adds a lot when it's all laid out that said I have a few critiques my biggest critique and my biggest issue with Bloodlines and Uprising is that the mechanics feel isolated all of these mechanics are in their own little bubble and don't get me wrong they're good mechanics even very good but there is this weird sensation of interacting with unique self-contained modules instead of a more holistic design where the mechanics kind of blend together in creative ways there's no card in the Imperium deck that combines tactiles and spies for example or Sardar and spies everything is its own little module neatly separated from the others the tactiles themselves do partially alleviate this as they do interact with spies and Sardar and even the shield wall but again it's never two mechanics linked together on the same Tech tile it's kind of frustrating once you notice it because you start to feel like these designers could go all out and just go hard on making these mechanics feel more interconnected and kind of lock together in interesting ways but they can't because Bloodlines needs to work with classic dun Imperium as well and that dual compatibility limits how much of the content and how many of these mechanics can mesh together and what I mean by this is that you can't have a card that involves spies and sard AAR
because that card won't be able to be compatible with the base game and the sad thing is Bloodlines already feels kind of bad in the base game as we'll talk about shortly so any more interaction with the mechanics and Uprising only further hurts Bloodlines with classic Dune Imperium I think once you realize that once you add on Bloodlines with Uprising it's really just all optional modular content you kind of get it stuck in your brain TecTiles are their own thing the Sardar are their own thing spies from Uprising are their own thing the Chom contracts it's their own thing there just isn't a lot of overlap and interaction between these mechanics which is kind of sad and you know I don't have a magic crystal ball nor can I enter a spice TR and predict if more interconnected mechanics would make the game better but it just feels like there's so much untapped potential in merging some of these excellent mechanics in a creative way and it's been two full games and three major expansions and the modules are starting to make me feel like all of the mechanics are quarantined that said Uprising is still excellent and it was my favorite game in 2023 Bloodlines absolutely adds content that I enjoy and both the Sardar and TecTiles add more decision space into an already complete
experience so don't get me wrong it's still great it just feels like some of the content is safe and kind of boring for reasons it doesn't need to be so yeah maybe it felt a little unsatisfying opening the box and just finding out that there's only one truly new game system in the sard of car not worth it for classic Imperium all right let's shift gears and talk about blood blood lines and classic Dune Imperium and I'll be honest if you only own the original game don't bother with Bloodlines it's janky incomplete and really adds the least Improvement out of all of your potential options let me break it down for you 6 out of 18 entry cards are removed 12 out of 32 Imperium cards three out of nine leader cards both conflict cards all eight CH contracts two out of 14 Sardar skills six out of 18 TecTiles are all removed that's 39 out of 101 or 38.6% of the content that is completely incompatible with classic Dune Imperium which is just not great value when you think of this as a full-sized expansion sure the rest of the content works but it doesn't work good enough to justify its existence or even the effort to make it compatible with classic Dune Imperium for example take the card possible Futures this is the Premier most powerful most expensive card in Bloodlines from a power level
perspective it works pretty well in Uprising it feels about on par with the other eight cost cards but compare it to the original Chom directorship or the quizat hatak and you'll quickly realize its power level just ain't there it works but it doesn't have that same balanced philosophy as a full experience Bloodlines works with Dune Imperium but there is a jankiness to all of it in the same way of trying to incorporate rise of I and immortality to Uprising the expansions just weren't made to address problems in Uprising likewise Bloodlines doesn't really address any issues or the concerns of the base Dune Imperium so here's my opinion if you own only classic Dune Imperium and you're even more content both rise ofix and immortality are better expansions than Bloodlines and will offer a higher quality experience if you have both of those already or want to jump into a better game entirely then just get uprisen as a standalone game bottom line is there is no situation where getting Bloodlines with the classic Dune emperium makes sense unless you absolutely hate Uprising ratings and concl I usion so as you probably gathered by now I feel like Bloodlines is a bit of a split the baby situation it just doesn't feel perfectly crafted
for either classic Dune Imperium or the newer Uprising it's like 3/4 Uprising focused and a quarter for classic Dune Imperium I would say for Uprising the game just feels a little stifled and not as genius as the last few expansions and Uprising itself the mechanics feel isolated and modular like they're quarantined from one another this might be a result of design needed to satisfy two different games or it just might be a design philosophy that doesn't really allow for mechanics to interact with one another both ways it just feels strange and while the content is solid I wouldn't call it transformative in fact you could play Uprising with Bloodlines and completely ignore the sardaar and the tactiles they really do exist in isolation in other words an entire game can be played with ever even bothering with these two game systems you can straight out ignore them this is in contrast to both rise of I and immortality where I modified key board spaces and immortality adjusted your starting deck to force you interacting with these mechanics in Bloodlines there's no mechanism except your own interest to interact with these new addition and to adjust your gameplay which just adds on to that disjointed feeling of it all on the other hand for classic Dune Imperium the implementation just feels
incomplete the game automatically removes 30% of all the content in the box and while the Sardar and new tactiles work fine they don't really feel like they add a meaningful Improvement relative to those other two expansions that already exist or you could just buy uprising itself for this reason I just can't recommend sticking with classic Dune Imperium and getting Bloodlines if you're looking for a better experience you're better off getting any other expansion or just going straight for Uprising so all said and done how do I rate it all let's do it this way for Uprising the star car get 9 out of 10 the TecTiles get 7 out of 10 the new leaders get a 9.5 out of 10 and the new supplementary content get 7.5 out of 10 which gives it a total of 8.25 out of 10 for Uprising for classic Dune Imperium though let's break it down the Sardar get 8 out of 10 the TecTiles get a 6 out of 10 the new leaders also get a 6 out of 10 and the supplementary content gets a 5 out of 10 which gives it a total of 6.25 out of 10 for its implementation with classic Dune Imperium so yeah that's my take on Bloodlines I think think that the expansion is good for Uprising but doesn't really reach that Brilliance that I would have expected from direwolf for classic Dune Imperium it's a it's a pass and look there's only two
possibilities during the design process of Bloodlines either one they decided to make game design concessions to allow some of the content to work with classic Dune Imperium in which case you're intentionally limiting Your Design space to accommodate two two different games and just create an okay product or two you've made no design concessions to accommodate the classic Dune Imperium in which case why in the world would you advertise that this is an expansion for classic Dune Imperium as well if you already know it's not going to be a good fit it just doesn't bode well for the future of the franchise from playing Bloodlines I think option one was chosen because of the modular nature of the tactiles and the sardaar they don't inherently rely on any design space from Uprising so they're easy gameplay systems to slide into classic emperium without much of a fuss but I was never in the meetings with direwolf so I don't really know what the logic was overall I think that the team at direwolf needs to stop trying to accommodate two different games in their design I'm confident that in a year or so another expansion will be released and if it's another attempt to appease two separate game designs I might even be more J I don't really understand it to be honest don't most people who buy these expansions already have Uprising did people really want more to tack onto the base game of Dune Imperium when I and
immortality already add more than enough I'd rather that direwolf just make the best experience possible instead of trying to satisfy two different games that have subtle but key design changes that really modify the experience anyways One Last Thing Before You Go someone I know has been working on a sticker set for Uprising and Bloodlines mles they're heavily inspired from jodor rosi's Dune but they wanted to know if there was any interest in these meeple designs or if the design is too jarring for the more realistic and grounded characters in dude Imperium uh would love to hear what you think of these designs and these meeple stickers so please leave a comment and bye